| Finally decided to create this after six episodes. It's been bugging me for a while now, but I've been wondering how many people actually prefer Shiina to Aoyama. Shiina is cute in her own regard, but somehow her character just fails to stand up compared to Aoyama, who is hard-working, straightforward and has to struggle with family issues. Having slightly tsundere tendencies also makes her more attractive in my opinion. So, what do you guys think? |
| 'I met many people. We were separated. And then reunited. This tune contains all those feelings.' - Nanaka Yatsushiro, Myself;Yourself, Episode 13  |
| I think Aoyama's annoying and I hope she moves out of Sakurasou soon. Mashiro all the way... <3 |
| I like them both, but if I were to choose, I'd say Aoyama :D Shiina would probably win this poll anyway~ |
| Aoyama yo. |
 |
| Shiina, and it's not even close. I usually love tsunderes, but Aoyama is a thoroughly irritating, pointless character who will likely become even worse as the story progresses, since she'll inevitably try her hardest to interfere with the main relationship. All of which is the reason she's the worst of the introduced characters by far. |
 |
Lelouch22 said: Shiina, and it's not even close. Pretty much this, Aoyama became more likable after this little arc of hers but its still easily Shiina. |
 |
| I like both of them but I prefer Aoyama over Shiina. Why? First thing is that She deserves to be on Sorata's side more than Shiina imo. She works so hard just to compensate her expenditures throughout the school year and puts so much hard work on what she's doing (Shiina also does hers but i can't see so much efforts compared to Aoyama) I know that she's a bit annoying but after this latest episode, she's more likable. Secondly, practically speaking, She's not gonna be a pain in ass like Shiina who doesn't even know how to take care of herself/ lacks common sense (Well, no offense to all Shiina fans/shippers but i think that's the truth if we'll put it practically) Shiina's gonna win anyway so why even bother on making up this thread?. lol We can already even see the numbers of people who prefer Shiina over Aoyama and can judge who's the winner..... It's gonna be Main x Main anyway so what's the point of this thread? |
| why the poll ? maybe cause tsundere vs. kuudere is always intersting ? ^^ |
 "Smiles aren't made, they're shown."- Belldandy (A!MG) |
| Like them both. I like girls with Kansai-ben...and Nananmi had great development last ep, so she's become really likable. BUT...Mashiro wins for me...and I'm sure she'll be developed to be even more lovable later. |
 |
| Definitely Mashiro. Not so fond of Aoyama from the very beginning. |
| I love aoyama more than Mashiro, |
 |
| They are both endearing in their own ways, but Mashiro is the main driving force behind a lot of what happens so I would vote for her only for this reason. |
 |
| I hate Aoyama and love Shiina, so it's an obvious decision. |
 |
| I voted Aoyama, Shiina may be pretty and have a nice voice actor but she is also weird and overly obsessed with drawing manga. Aoyama isn't perfect, she's shown to be really annoying when it comes to her being so stubborn but I'm sure her cute side will be revealed further like it was beginning to be last episode :3 |
| If you did this after episode 5, it probably would've been 80% Shiina, and 20% aoyama. For me, I'd prefer Shiina, but I love 'em both ^_^ |
| I have to say I really liked both of the characters, but in the end, I obviously like Shiina more. I have nothing negative to say about Aoyama tho, because she has few flaws, the only thing against her is that Shiina is just herself and I can't deny how alluring it is to meh |
 |
| I dont get the poll, obviously Misaki is the best. The rest dont even come close to her. |
AlexGK said: I dont get the poll, obviously Misaki is the best. The rest dont even come close to her. You shouldn't state such things as fact, but lets say you are just stating your opinion like anyone else, your comment is still pointless, Misaki doesn't like Sorata, when comparing Shiina to Aoyama that topic mostly comes up, its a romantic comedy after all, most dislike Aoyama for the simple reason that she gets in the way of Shiina who pending some out of nowhere reversal will end up winning Sorata in the end. |
|
| I like both but I like shiina more |
| Either one works for me, but I prefer Mashiro way more. |
 |
| Mashiro. Mashiro change Sorata greatly and positively. Nanami does not have such influence on Sorata. But Nanami is needed in Sakurasou for the Normal People VS Genius plot. |
 ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ |
| I like them both, but Mashiro. I find Aoyama to be very annoying. |
 |
| At the moment it's Shiina for me cause well Aoyama is just annoying atm |
  |
| Shiina! I don't like her very much too, but she's way better than Aoyama. |
InfiniteDestiny said: AlexGK said: I dont get the poll, obviously Misaki is the best. The rest dont even come close to her. You shouldn't state such things as fact, but lets say you are just stating your opinion like anyone else, your comment is still pointless, Misaki doesn't like Sorata, when comparing Shiina to Aoyama that topic mostly comes up, its a romantic comedy after all, most dislike Aoyama for the simple reason that she gets in the way of Shiina who pending some out of nowhere reversal will end up winning Sorata in the end. Ehm, not that I dont get it, but would u tell me where did the OP state that the poll had anything to do with Sorata? My opinion was half joke half serious actually. Joke cose, though obvious, it isnt stated that we have to choose who we ship as the main pair. The serious half is actually my real opinion on who is the most intresting girl in the show. Seriously, I had a gf similar to Misaki and the worst thing is I was too stupid and could not keep her... Nuff said. As for the poll - why does NOONE consider that Shiina walking naked and acting all seductive (albeit not on purpose) is also gettin in the way of Aoyama? Is that fair? Cose, you know, when you are a teenage boy such things tend to make you lose what little brains you have :D Aoyama on the other hand is being stupid for not being true to her feelings. "Love is not a spectator sport". So I voted Shiina. At least shes acting sincere. |
AlexGKNov 18, 2012 9:22 AM
| I support Nanamin~ :3 |
AlexGK said: InfiniteDestiny said: AlexGK said: I dont get the poll, obviously Misaki is the best. The rest dont even come close to her. You shouldn't state such things as fact, but lets say you are just stating your opinion like anyone else, your comment is still pointless, Misaki doesn't like Sorata, when comparing Shiina to Aoyama that topic mostly comes up, its a romantic comedy after all, most dislike Aoyama for the simple reason that she gets in the way of Shiina who pending some out of nowhere reversal will end up winning Sorata in the end. Ehm, not that I dont get it, but would u tell me where did the OP state that the poll had anything to do with Sorata? My opinion was half joke half serious actually. Joke cose, though obvious, it isnt stated that we have to choose who we ship as the main pair. The serious half is actually my real opinion on who is the most intresting girl in the show. Seriously, I had a gf similar to Misaki and the worst thing is I was too stupid and could not keep her... Nuff said. As for the poll - why does NOONE consider that Shiina walking naked and acting all seductive (albeit not on purpose) is also gettin in the way of Aoyama? Is that fair? Cose, you know, when you are a teenage boy such things tend to make you lose what little brains you have :D Aoyama on the other hand is being stupid for not being true to her feelings. "Love is not a spectator sport". So I voted Shiina. At least shes acting sincere. I'm pretty much the same, I love Misaki she is just so full of energy and it's so endearing. I'd have voted for her too if she was on the poll lol. However with the two choices I have to pick Mashiro even though I am a stickler for Tsunderes normally, she just kind of does it for me =P |
 |
| Aoyama doesn't stand a chance in hell. The whole setup is for her to be the contrasting "normal girl" to Shiina's "eccentric" personality. The whole design of the series is for Aoyama to be the "odd one out". |
| I love them both. Shiina is just so freaking cute and lovable. The perfect waifu material in this anime. Aoyama is pretty cool too and I love her story and how ambitious she is. With this said, I vote for Shiina. |
| The hardworking tsundere or the quiet genius? Conclusion: Shiina. |
| http://myanimelist.net/animelist/LuckyMango http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/LuckyMango Feel free to comment on my profile for anime recommendations. Ill try my best to help! Remember don't message me. Comment! |
| Shina because she's a blonde/beauty/amazingly talented, BUT! and a big 'BUT', she's way too autistic but if it's not permanent then comprise can be done! However, Aoyoma is a hard worker, very dedicated and adorable, so... close call. |
    |
| Mashiro. I just tired of tsundere osananajimi type. But Aoyama deserves some + as real hardworker |
 |
| The walking fanservice. Much love for her. |
| I'm leaning towards Aoyama. |
| Although I like Shiina, I prefer Aoyama. |
 |
| So far, I like Mashiro better. However, Aoyoma does occasionally shine in some of her moments imo. |
 |
| Mashiro makes me laugh a lot more than Aoyama does, so my vote easily goes to her. |
 |
gamerguy50 said: Yea pretty much though both can indeed have their alluring moments hahaI have to say I really liked both of the characters, but in the end, I obviously like Shiina more. I have nothing negative to say about Aoyama tho, because she has few flaws, the only thing against her is that Shiina is just herself and I can't deny how alluring it is to meh |
Nachtwandler_21 said: Yeah, pretty much. The combative tsundere (Aoyama) has been done to death, whereas the idiot savant (Shiina) is comparatively fresh. (Of course, Aoyama doesn't start the series as a tsundere, which is mildly interesting in itself.) Furthermore, Shiina's relationship with Sorata at this point is nuanced in a way that Aoyama's is not, and that works to Shiina's favor, in my opinion. Shiina is intriguing; Aoyama is not. Therefore, advantage: Shiina.Mashiro. I just tired of tsundere osananajimi type. I think that part of the problem I have with Aoyama is that she is the only character (other than the teacher) who from the get-go seemed destined to be one-dimensional. Something about the nice girl who is always trying her best and has an unrequited crush on the male lead sets off alarm bells. (Heck, if you call her "plucky" and say that Sorata is thought to be unattainable, she is the spitting image of a painfully generic shoujo heroine.) Turning her into a generic combative tsundere once her romantic turf is stolen does not help her to gain character depth. (Spoiler is for episodes 5-6.) Ultimately, I'm hoping Aoyama is blessed with some enhanced characterization and develops a less straightforward/predictable relationship with Sorata. I am irrationally fond of her character and would like to see her win, but only if she earns it. By which I mean: earns the screen time that would be devoted to her in that case. By being more interesting. |
ZetaAspectNov 20, 2012 12:53 AM
 Graph provided to verify that I am a CERTIFIED pretentious jerk. |
| Misaki is the best haha anyway, I like them both but i prefer Aoyama because I like her annoying character XD |
     |
| WOW. I never expected the poll to be this way. A bit shocked on what's happening 'cause almost everyone is in favor of Shiina beating Aoyama's count. Almost everyone is like even saying that "she's a nuisance in the show" but hey, it's 56 to 86. 30 more and she'll beat Shiina. WOHOOO! I'm glad that Nanami's catching up to Shiina. Glad that there's still viewers fawning over Aoyama's beauty and personality. I go for Aoyoma > Shiina :D |
| Mashiro by a large margin. I will gladly take care and look after her. I find Aoyama annoying more than anything. |
| Aoyama. Shiina doesn't blush! |
-MgZ_ said: Aoyama. Shiina doesn't blush! lol XD |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Best GirlShizuna - Mar 23, 2022 |
29 |
by Mochi_i
»»
Mar 31, 10:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )tsubasalover - Mar 25, 2013 |
639 |
by JoaoPedru
»»
Mar 25, 12:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo Episode 22 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 11, 2013 |
227 |
by JoaoPedru
»»
Mar 24, 11:43 PM |
|
Poll: » Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Dec 24, 2012 |
319 |
by Fadhil01dx
»»
Feb 24, 4:09 PM |
|
Poll: » Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Nov 12, 2012 |
213 |
by Liddo-kun
»»
Feb 9, 3:56 AM |