MyAnimeList.net

Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

Recommendations
MyAnimeList.net Forum »» Club Discussion »» BL Obsession »» Recommendations

Must be a Club Member to Reply
Pages (7) [1] 2 3 » ... Last »
#1
01-05-10, 6:07 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 4350
Intro
All of us probably find it a problem when you cant find anything to read or watch.
Or you find a great yaoi manga and you want something similar?
But with all the yaoi out there, it's nearly impossible to find something that will actually suite your taste.

Thus... we have opened up a new topic dedicated on helping all the members with this problem!

All you have to do is:

Tell us what you want: Comedy, romance, smut, rape, historical... well anything that would tell us the genre of the yaoi you like
What yaoi's did you like of this similarity: It would help us a lot if you could tell us some of the titles that you really liked and what you want similar to. Example: I want a manga like Dog Style because of its...
What you don't want: If you don't like guys to look like girls, or you don't want rape, or something similar to those; write it here
Preferred length: It could be a one-shot or a 3 volume manga, your choice
Status: Finished, Ongoing, or I don't care
Other: You can add something specific here, something you want to add what wasn't said yet

When you add your request, all the staff members will try their hardest to help in finding the yaoi you really want or ones you might like.

ALL THE MEMBERS CAN GIVE THERE RECOMMENDATIONS!!!
That's always welcome ^-^
All the members that have something to recommend are welcome to do so, the more recommendations a person gets, the more chances that we will help them ^-^

If you don't like the ones we recommend, you can always ask for more recommendations, add the manga's you didn't like and tell us WHY you didn't like it. This will help us in the future to find more titles to your liking.

Please recommend in this format:

For who:
Recommendations:
  • Haru Wo Daiteita - Publishing - 14 volumes (75 chapters) - how it suits their preferences
  • Dog Style - Finished - 3 volumes (30 chapters) - how it suits their preferences
  • etc.


    User Preferences



    I really hope that this topic will help members on finding more yaoi's that they like ^-^
  • Modified by yaoiisgood, 10-10-12, 9:50 PM
     
    #2
    01-05-10, 6:32 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Feb 2008
    Posts: 1167
    *Sorry Linslet for editing your post, it's to make more room*

    Recommendations (so far...)

    Modified by yaoiisgood, 10-11-12, 1:44 AM
     
    #3
    01-05-10, 8:17 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Dec 2008
    Posts: 4350
    Original Post:


    Recommendations (cont...)

    For who: Ranoom


    For who: Shinino


    For who: poliyoyo


    For who: d_w_


    For who: xBlackRosex


    For who: XNezushiX
    Modified by yaoiisgood, 10-10-12, 9:51 PM
     
    #4
    01-05-10, 8:43 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Oct 2009
    Posts: 1684
    Tell as what you want: I really like when the 2 guys are just normal guys, not one super girly and one manly one. not good :(
    What yaois did you like of this similarity: Junjou Romantica is the epitome of my style
    What you dont want: dont want rape or forced sex. or shota. uh uh, not for triseke
    Preferd length: it doesnt really bother me. i like one shots when they are done well, but also as long as possible is good!
    Status: Dont realy care
     
    #5
    01-05-10, 9:05 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Dec 2009
    Posts: 255
    Tell us what you want: I really like a shounen-ai/yaoi story that involve two men who are basically straight, but end up falling in love with each other. <3 :)
    What yaois did you like of this similarity: So far, SEVEN DAYS is the best series ever! Even though it's only 2 volumes, I never get bored to reread it. The plot is awesome.
    What you don't want: I don't like muscle-man. x( Too girlish is also a no-no. =.=' Normal school boys are the best. :)
    Preferred length: About two or three volumes, maybe. But if the story is very good, even about ten volumes are fine.
    Status: Anything is fine. As long as the plot is good and the story flows nicely so I won't be bored.
    Other: I really think about the style of the art so much before reading a manga or watch an anime. For example, when I first saw the cover of SEVEN DAYS, I kind of fell in love at the first sight. xD It has a perfect art and story. :)

    Thank you very much~! <3 ^^
     
    #6
    01-05-10, 4:58 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Apr 2008
    Posts: 1977
    For who: Pupsia
    Recommendations:
  • Double Call - Publishing - 9 volumes (unknown chapters) - no girly guys, longer than a one-shot, and no rape (so far).
  • ZE - Publishing - 8 volumes (unknown chapters) - no girly guys (from what I can tell)
  • Yume no Kodomo - Publishing - 6 volumes (unknown chapters) - no girly buys, longer than a one-shot, and no rape (of what I know of) - BEWARE, OLD looking art (but very nice story).
  • Brother x Brother - Publishing - 4 volumes (unknown chapters) - no girly guys, relatively long (volume-wise), no rape, and B-E-A-UTIFUL art and story (if you don't mind slight incest)!

    I'm not sure what you meant by smut... so if you find any in the above, my apologies. Also, I'll probably edit this post with more recommendations for you on later days!
  •  
    #7
    01-09-10, 8:31 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Sep 2008
    Posts: 868
    For Who: Triseke
    Rocommendations:
    ~ Sekaiichi Hatsukoi - Ongoing- (unknown Chapters and Volumes) - It is the same author as Junjou Romantica and none of what u dont want is there.

    I will add more for u once i remeber the title of the other ones, lol
     
    #8
    01-10-10, 9:27 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Jul 2009
    Posts: 241
    Tell as what you want: 2 guys falling in love. maybe one more manly than the other, but not a girly guy as the other man. romance, comedy, pos smut
    What yaois did you like of this similarity: Junjou Romantica, Petto Oshigotochuu, i also like Crimson Spell
    What you dont want: not rape. or shota.or girly men
    Preferd length: either, but longer the better =)
    Status: Dont mind
     
    #9
    01-10-10, 4:37 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Sep 2008
    Posts: 868
    For who: Rachel3
    Rocommendations:
    ~ Keep Out- Ongoing ( 1 volume and 6 chapters) It has really good art and a good story with a twist
    and as far as i read, there where no rape or anything u dont like.

    ~Innocent Bird- finished ( 3 volumes, wiht 14 chapters) Kinda like crimson spell, with magic,demons and and good art.
     
    01-10-10, 7:22 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Apr 2008
    Posts: 1977
    For who: asinankurus
    Recommendations:
  • Non-Non - Finished (1 volume 2 chapters) - both main characters are straight but end up falling for each other - neither characters are muscle-y or girly - they are school boys - the length of the series is short (hope you don't mind) - and the art is very unique but nothing fantastical.
  • Ore ni Koi Shite Dousunda - Ongoing (1 volume 4 chapters out so far) - both main characters are straight but end up falling for each other - neither characters are muscle-y or girly although the uke does have the pale skin and blushes sometimes look - the length of the series is known - and the art is AMAZING (in my opinion) and this is one of my FAVORITE yaoi manga's of all time (but, all of Yoneda, Kou's works are amazing!) - hopefully you don't mind slight incest. -^_^-

  • Freefall Romance - Complete (1 volume 6 chapters) - both main characters start out straight - they are both manly men (not TOO manly and no girly guys) - the art is really nice (in my opinion), but all of Fujiyama Hyouta's works are amazing (check em' out)!

    I may add more to this post later!
    Hope you enjoy! Tell me what you don't like or like about em'! ^_^
  • Modified by yaoiisgood, 02-02-10, 7:10 AM
     
    01-11-10, 1:28 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Dec 2009
    Posts: 255
    @inuyashashotty:
    Thank you very much~! :D
    Yeah, it's really hard to find yaoi manga which starts with two straight guys. =.='
    It's great that you've found two mangas of such type. Thank you! xD
    I'll read them soon. And after that I'll edit this post and add my opinion about those manga. :)

    EDIT:
    • Non-non
      I really like it! It makes my heart thumps when reading it. :D
      They're normal school boys who were straight at first but ended up falling for each other.
      Hm, their relationship seems to progress too fast. They made out right after asking each others' feelings. But it's OK, since the manga contains only two chapters. ^^
      The art is good. I like this kind of art, it's simple and not too neat. :)
      Neat and fancy art hurts my eyes. @.@
      Overall, it gets 8/10 from me. ^^
    • Ore ni Koi Shite Dousunda
      I kind of didn't feel like reading it at first. Since the seme seems too arrogant or such. But I like it how STRAIGHT he is at first. He even tried to kiss one of his male friend to make sure that he's straight. lol
      But he ended up have a special feeling for the uke. :)
      And I like it that even the uke couldn't believe that he likes a guy. He was so sure that he's straight.
      The art is good, and the story is developed nicely.
      I can't wait to read the next chapter! I hope it will be coming out soon! :D

    Thanks a lot for the recommendation, inuyashashotty~! <3 :D
    Modified by asinankurus, 01-12-10, 5:41 AM
     
    01-11-10, 9:32 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Jul 2009
    Posts: 241
    to: Rukia_23

    thankyou for your suggestions =) i've actually already started Keep Out =) lol and i like it. i'll have a look at the other one. thanks again =)
     
    01-15-10, 5:44 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Apr 2008
    Posts: 1977
    asinankurus said:
    @inuyashashotty:
    Thank you very much~! :D
    Yeah, it's really hard to find yaoi manga which starts with two straight guys. =.='
    It's great that you've found two mangas of such type. Thank you! xD
    I'll read them soon. And after that I'll edit this post and add my opinion about those manga. :)

    EDIT:
    • Non-non
      I really like it! It makes my heart thumps when reading it. :D
      They're normal school boys who were straight at first but ended up falling for each other.
      Hm, their relationship seems to progress too fast. They made out right after asking each others' feelings. But it's OK, since the manga contains only two chapters. ^^
      The art is good. I like this kind of art, it's simple and not too neat. :)
      Neat and fancy art hurts my eyes. @.@
      Overall, it gets 8/10 from me. ^^
    • Ore ni Koi Shite Dousunda
      I kind of didn't feel like reading it at first. Since the seme seems too arrogant or such. But I like it how STRAIGHT he is at first. He even tried to kiss one of his male friend to make sure that he's straight. lol
      But he ended up have a special feeling for the uke. :)
      And I like it that even the uke couldn't believe that he likes a guy. He was so sure that he's straight.
      The art is good, and the story is developed nicely.
      I can't wait to read the next chapter! I hope it will be coming out soon! :D

    Thanks a lot for the recommendation, inuyashashotty~! <3 :D


    Your welcome!!! I'm so glad you liked them! Now, I also have more of an idea for what you are looking for so I'll keep my eyes open for those types of manga's now! <3
     
    01-18-10, 2:51 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Sep 2008
    Posts: 868
    rachel3 said:
    to: Rukia_23

    thankyou for your suggestions =) i've actually already started Keep Out =) lol and i like it. i'll have a look at the other one. thanks again =)


    U are welcome Rachel ^^ and i will deffinitely telll u more if i remeber the other titles that i have for ur requests . I am so glad u like them ^^
     
    01-23-10, 7:07 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Jul 2009
    Posts: 224
    Tell as what you want: Would prefer comedy/ school / light-hearted kind of storyline but something touching/drama/tragic is fine too~
    What yaoi's did you like of this similarity: something along the line of Junjou Romantica / Seven Days / Otona Keikenchi / Totally Captivated / Dog Style / Only the Ring Finger Knows / etc, Uh... it's so broad D: gomen!
    What you don't want: Probably No S&M @_@
    Preferred length: At least 1 Vol (1 vol consisting of 1 shots are fine!)
    Status: Completed preferred, but if you have a really nice ongoing one with regular update, then it's fine too 8D
    Other: Great Art & Bishies are the best! >D

    Thanks in advance! <3
    Modified by ayakabun, 02-25-10, 8:28 AM
     
    02-01-10, 7:36 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Mar 2009
    Posts: 68
    Tell as what you want: I wanna find some with the school theme.. a little comedy...maybe the uke pushing the seme away and giving in at the same time. If you find others with maybe the business theme with beautiful art that would be wonderful too.
    What yaois did you like of this similarity: Junjou Romantica, Love is Like a Hurricane, hero heel, Koiha Ina Mono Mouna Mono
    What you dont want: muscle men, girly boys...just normal...(i like if uke looks like kid/brat and seme like the the mature and responsible type...i do mean LOOK)
    Preferd length: well....at least 4-5 chapters long.
    Status: i perfer completed...but if its ongoing still recommend it i could put it in my plan to read list and start on it later
    other: i would like if you could find a manga with beautiful art like the mangas: Kooru Shakunetsu, Koiha Ina Mono Mouna Mono, yellow. (I do like the force sex/rape) and HOT guys!
     
    02-02-10, 11:33 AM

    Offline
    Joined: Feb 2009
    Posts: 152
    For who: cr6zym0nkeyiz
    Recommendation:
    Tyrant falls in love (5 Volumes -ongoing) It´s set in university and its also deals with an Uke who alway pushes his seme back. It´s very hilariouse and the Artwork is great, too.

    Kimitachi otoko no ko (1 Volume) A very funny school story with great Artwork and Hot guys in it!

    For the buisness thing:
    Hisho to Yajuu (1 Volume) great story and great Artwork. Definetly one of the best Yaois dealing with that Boss/secretery topic.

    And here is one for the force sex/rape category:
    Saihate no kimi e ( 1 Volume)
    Yeah it has force sex in it, but I liked this story very much. It´s dramatic, thou. But the guys and the whole story are HOT! xD

    Hope I could help you. Tell me how you liked the manga. I´ll tell you more if some good things will popp up in my mind.
    Modified by sayurichama, 02-02-10, 11:37 AM


     
    02-02-10, 12:11 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Nov 2009
    Posts: 213
    Tell as what you want: I like one of the guys to be cute, or the two to be manly
    What yaois did you like of this similarity: Junjou Romantica
    What you dont want: I hate if one of the guys is too girly, and don't like rape
    Preferd length: short ones but I don't hate long once eather
    Status: Dont realy care :)
     
    02-02-10, 12:31 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Feb 2009
    Posts: 152
    For who: GHmimi
    Recomendation: Bukiyou na Silent (3 Volumes-ongoing-) The story is set in school. I think you will love it, because it´s really a totally CUTE story. The caracters (especially the seme) are manly, but somehow totally cute (especially the uke).


     
    02-02-10, 5:46 PM

    Offline
    Joined: Mar 2009
    Posts: 68
    sayurichama said:
    For who: cr6zym0nkeyiz
    Recommendation:
    Tyrant falls in love (5 Volumes -ongoing) It´s set in university and its also deals with an Uke who alway pushes his seme back. It´s very hilariouse and the Artwork is great, too.

    Kimitachi otoko no ko (1 Volume) A very funny school story with great Artwork and Hot guys in it!

    For the buisness thing:
    Hisho to Yajuu (1 Volume) great story and great Artwork. Definetly one of the best Yaois dealing with that Boss/secretery topic.

    And here is one for the force sex/rape category:
    Saihate no kimi e ( 1 Volume)
    Yeah it has force sex in it, but I liked this story very much. It´s dramatic, thou. But the guys and the whole story are HOT! xD

    Hope I could help you. Tell me how you liked the manga. I´ll tell you more if some good things will popp up in my mind.


    ive seen Kimitachi otoko no ko, but the other look great. let me knoe if u think of anymore and ill also let u knoe how i liked the ones u recommended. XD
     
    Top
    Pages (7) [1] 2 3 » ... Last »
    FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices