Dareka no Manazashi

Shinkai shows once again why he is a master at tugging the heartstrings, specifically in conveying the space between human connection. In just 7 minutes we get a sense of the all to relatable distance between father and daughter, as well as the quiet desperation of the daily grind of a working adult living alone, who has become disconnected from the joys of family and youth. In just 7 minutes we understand how things got to the place, through gorgeous character design and limited animation we are taken on this heartfelt journey of adulthood.

I think there’s an instinct to describe this short film (and ... most of Shinkai’s work) as sappy or melodramatic, but it’s so connected to something genuine that many of us experience that I don’t think it’s a fair description, even if I understand where that instinct is coming from.

Dareka no Manazashi was a really touching short, definitely said what it needed to in the 6 minutes it had.

Story: 6/10
It focuses on Aya and the relationship with her family. Who grew apart as she got older and moved out. She slowly begins to realise how much she misses her family, mostly her father. It is a beautiful and very meaningful piece, showing that you need to do something before it's too late.

Art: 10/10
Once again, Shinkai has outdone himself with the beautiful animation and backgrounds. Everything about this piece is beautifully illustrated.

Sound: 8/10
Very pretty music that fits very well with the piece.
...
Character: 6/10
Due to there not being enough time, the characters cannot be expressed that well. But for what there is, it is beautiful. You really start to feel for Aya as the short goes on, hoping that she will rekindle with her family eventually.

Enjoyment: 6/10
There was not much to go on with this 6 minute short, but it was very enjoyable for what there was. Very beautiful and amazing message that touched me deeply. Made me think of my own family.

Overall: 7/10
It is a very powerful short, definitely recommend if you have a spare 6 minutes of your day.

Dareka no Manazashi (DnM for short) is a short film directed by Makoto Shinkai - if you're an anime fan in any capacity, you're probably familiar with some of the titles he's directed, such as Byousoku 5 Centimeter and the more recent Kimi no Na wa. His films are often described as bittersweet and sentimental, and this is also the case with DnM. However, the short length and consequential underdevelopent of the many plot points the film presents left me feeling underwhelmed - like this was something that had the potential to be emotionally touching, if given more time.

DnM is visually stunning, featuring vibrant colors, ... attractive character designs and skilled use of lighting to match the story's emotional shifts. However, the "near future" setting adds nothing to the overall story - it could have just as easily taken place in the present.

The voice actors portrayed their characters with conviction and heart. The music was soft piano for the bulk of the film and a piano ballad at the end, which fit the mood of the story well. All aspects of sound featured in DnM were pleasing but nothing spectacular.

The story of DnM centers around Aya Okamura and the evolution of her relationship with her family, and many focal points of this relationship are shown, past and present, ups and downs. The common thread between these plot points is that very little time is spent on any of them, preventing the viewer from establishing much of a meaningful connection with the plot or the characters portrayed in the story. Speaking of the characters, they've got a surprising amount of personality for the short time they're shown, but because we don't get to see that much of them it's hard to find yourself caring about their lives, day-to-day troubles, or relationships with one another. The themes of the story, in addition, are underexplored due to the film's brevity and quick switches from scene to scene.

I do have one gripe about a potential "plothole", which is strange for a film that isn't even seven minutes long - it has no impact on the events of the story, but left me slightly puzzled. Near the end of the film, it's heavily implied that the narrator is one of the characters from the story. However, this narrator describes events as if they were there from before their character was actually introduced in the story, which raises questions. Whether this was an oversight or just Shinkai taking creative liberties with the narration, I found it a bit odd.

Overall, DnM is a good example of an adequate film that could have been much better given more time to grow and develop. There's a lot here with potential that is never met, which is a shame, but the framework for a more solid film is present.