Statistics
Anime History Last Anime Updates
Fate/stay night Movie: Heaven's Feel - II. Lost Butterfly
Jan 16, 2020 9:53 PM
Completed
1/1
· Scored
8
Fate/stay night Movie: Heaven's Feel - I. Presage Flower
Oct 28, 2018 11:18 PM
Completed
1/1
· Scored
8
All Comments (19) Comments
LOL
I had the exact favorites when i was just starting out with anime
To answer your question, I am familiar with visual novels. I have personally read steins gate and grisaia no kajitsu (albeit not completed), and have played ace attorney and both danganronpa games. I personally find the Steins gate anime phenomenal, and even though kajitsu as an anime was mediocre, it's sequels meikyuu and rakyuen were pretty great.
Thanks for taking the offer to analyse my drafts and story projects. I have created a thread highlighting these as well as other questions. (http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1494160). I look forward to your comments!
Anyways, I can kinda agree with your points. I have to mention though that while the anime is good, it really lacks the foundation that was set-up by the manga. Many scenes involving the relevance of major characters such as the Sensei and Airi were pretty much scrapped due to a lack of time ( episode 11 was guilty of this ). As a result, these specific characters lack the development to flesh them out entirely, so giving the impression that say the sensei was a stereotypical psychopath rather than one that is fueled by a lack of challenge in life, and Airi being a symbol to push Satoru forward.
Regarding Hinazuki's mother, I think it is really up to interpretation as to whether the grandmother was brought out of nowhere. I feel there were very subtle hints to imply that there was something leading up to that but whether it would have been better to make it more obvious? That would certainly be debatable. I do have to agree with you on the whole mystery component being not as strong, you brought up some really valid points. I feel its great they built up the whole "what was his motive for killing" to compensate for the lack of subtlety regarding who is the killer, but it would have been much better if the writer accomplished both. As for Satoru, I think it was implied that he DID want to find out and expose the killer but again, same issue as whether the hints were too subtle. The strongest selling point for this show for me is the cinematography, character interactions and perhaps just the fact it was a breath of fresh air from shonen/harem archtypes. Then again, I would have to wait until the series ends before making a full assessment.
Anyways, thanks for your reply and I look forward to your next reply. By the way, I have sent a friend request to you. I think it will be great for us to further discuss about anime writing in general. I personally am interning at a studio and I would like opinions on the story I am currently drafting.
In light of this, I want to know more about your opinions regarding the show as a whole. I for one think that while the mystery may not be its strongest selling point (killer reveal and such), the direction and cinematography is pretty up there when compared to many recent anime. I also feel that the characters are decently fleshed out and even the mystery process was handled quite well. Admittedly, I felt that the journey was actually better than the end. What are your thoughts?
If you've been told it's ok to do in the club that's one thing but going out of your way to advertise to random users is annoying as fuck.
Text has been fixed