10 - 10 - Flaws are so unnoticeable or so minuscule that they can easily be ignored or unseen, AND I love it so much that the flaws are irrelevant to me.
9 - Great emotional resonance with me but had flaws I cannot ignore or didn't leave me with much in terms of narrative/themes/food for thought; OR I can appreciate it as excellent from a critical standpoint but didn't have as strong an emotional resonance with it.
8 - Stands out from a critical standpoint but barely had an impact on me personally OR resonated with me emotionally but not too strongly/ made me happy but certainly wasn't anything particularly amazing.
7 - I recognize it as good but didn't think much of it. Most likely the show or movie with this rating is just fun or entertaining and not much else OR it had a lot of things going for it in terms of plot, characters, writing, style, etc. but was weak in execution.
6 - Somewhat entertaining but definitely has unignorable problems/lacking in content in my eyes OR I hate certain aspects of it while some other aspects were definitely entertaining in a good way.
5 - Bland / Boring. Had no thoughts on it OR it had both good and bad elements that balanced out to give a mediocre experience.
4 - Has some good qualities to it but the bad qualities outweighed the good OR I strongly dislike it while acknowledging that it has good qualities to it.
It was bad in a way that particularly upset or offended me while not being that bad on an objective level; OR tolerably bad where I'm not getting much entertainment value since it isn't THAT bad but is obviously not good.
2 - I can just barely tolerate watching it, meaning it's quite bad with one or 2 elements that kept my investment whether it be curiosity to see where it goes, to see how bad it could be or investment in the continuation of a pre-existing property or investment in the concept or investment in it's notoriety/impact in the film/anime world, though I definitely do not enjoy watching it; OR it is funny bad, where it is so ridiculously bad that it gets an extra point for at least entertaining me/making me laugh.
1 - Unbearable to watch, meaning it actually offended/upset me without any objective quality about it that could redeem it in any way; OR it was completely uninteresting and boring while also being horrendously bad.
Hentai Rating Scale
N.B. The main selling point for the fappability of a hentai for me is all in the visual department (animation, art style and directing). Writing is a secondary source of enjoyment.
I refuse to give a hentai a 10 or a 9
8 - Really good animation and I genuinely enjoyed the plot, characters, dialogue or writing in some capacity ("some" being the operative word) OR the animation is exceptional enough to carry me through the whole thing and I don't care for the writing.
7 - Pretty good animation OR pretty good plot, characters, dialogue and/or writing with good enough animation
6 - Lacking in the animation department but good enough OR it was pretty good but made me somewhat uncomfortable
5 - Pretty unsatisfying fap or no fap at all due to plot and/or animation
4 - Probably did fap but genuinely thought it was gross in some way, usually due to the plot
3 - A little too pedo or rapey for my liking
2 - Probably shota or loli or heavily rape, BDSM or taboo centric, at least it has something else other than that to make it somewhat bareable to watch
yeah, of course sangatsu no lion which is one of the highest rated anime on mal is a trash show. Says the guy who liked guilty crown a show that literally self destruct by its ending
All Comments (2) Comments