Report Credulous's Profile

R.I.P

You are one weird mofo you know that. Scrabbled brain. Interesting.

I want to make one thing clear. I agree with the majority of your opinions, but some of your negative ones I feel did not properly analyze what made said anime so good to others.

The most notable criticism you did was with Clannad, which I know does get negative reviews a lot, but unlike the other reviews, your phrasing made it seem like it had nothing else going for it. If you don't take it very seriously, Clannad did have pretty nice humor and I am really surprised you left out how good its animation is, especially during the Illusionary World sequences and the soundtrack is great, even if it is ripped from the game. That aside, I can fully agree with you and say that the game is the way to go, since there's a lot more exposition in it, even if the supernatural stuff still feels a bit strange, it works a lot better when the characters have a lot more time with you, rather than speedrunning it the way the anime did. Even Nagisa's arc in After Story was rushed a bit, despite being dedicated to her, on top of the main series already having her onscreen a lot. Sometimes, the more serious moments could feel rushed in the anime in a bad way, if not coming out of nowhere.

But, I do agree with you on just about every other review. To Heart 2 was pretty trash. My rating is higher than yours, but as you can see, I analyze a lot of other aspects beyond just the story of an anime, which is why I have pretty forgivable ratings for the most part. But, I am not afraid to go low if the anime really did try to annoy me. Combat Butler is not overall amazing, but I can't deny it had an amazing first episode with great comedic timing, writing and even animation in some areas. The episode with the highest budget was definitely the sequence with Yukiji refusing to let Hayate into the school, where her "fighting style" had a lot of unique frames and detail, even though the fight itself never happened because she inadvertently walked around him. Green Green is complete garbage.

I like your criticism on more of the mainstream stuff. It's nice to read these opinions, that is if they are legitimately fair and not just criticism for the sake of it. Keep up the good writing and I look forward to reading more of your stuff is what I would say, but you appear to have lost interest in anime, or at least stopped updating your list.

Listen, I don't like Sengoku Basara either but saying "giving a character the title devil king of sixth heaven is bad!" is funny because that's not only an actual existing name, derived from beliefs in ancient India which held that there are six heavens between Earth and the Brahma heaven, it was also the title of the actual Oda Nobunaga

>In most cases what I give 5/6 you give 9/10. My 8's are like your 12's and my only 10 would be a 20 for you.

>Elfen Lied a 9
2/10

''People who don't get this anime are too smart''

Please enlighten me, what is there to get?

Please die.

men svara då din lilla mört !

Loved your clannad review, when I wrote my review I gave it a worse score but happy to see someone see this as generic trash.

You fooled me good with your Tokimeki Memorail review.

Pippi :)

You don't have to watch the first series to enjoy the second series, but certain bits in the sequel will make more sense if you do.

We live on, but we are a rarity. The real world claims most every fan in time.

Excess is always tricky to tackle because everyone's threshold differs. With Saikano, it was simply a matter that my threshold for inconsolable sadness was reached. Reflecting on your comments, it may have been at the time I originally watched the series that when I reached my threshold, I may have felt desensitized and indifferent to the varying degrees of despair leading up to the ultimate end as an involuntary defense mechanism. It's hard to find the series anymore since it is out of print (when I watched it, I rented it from the library in 2007 and that copy was destroyed when the library flooded the next year) but if I ever get the chance to revisit it, I will to see if my opinion has changed. Thanks for the comment :)

Thanks to your list, I've found more interesting anime to watch :D
Again, thanks.