So a little biography. I'm the former president of the Anime Club at NCSU. Been watching anime since early 2000, but been picking it up a lot recently. I try to be objective with my scores, and I'll admit when I'm being completely bias on a certain topic.
How I rate animu:
10 - Masterpiece, you'd be crazy to not watch
9 - Amazing, would highly recommend, only a couple flaws making it
8 - Pretty darn good, would recommend
7 - Above average, was enjoyable but not amazing. Watch if you
have the time
6 - Just okay.
5 or lower - Just no.