Report Akagi-kun's Profile

Statistics

Anime Stats
Days: 165.6
Mean Score: 7.64
  • Total Entries941
  • Rewatched3
  • Episodes9,684
Anime History Last Anime Updates
ReLIFE: Kanketsu-hen
ReLIFE: Kanketsu-hen
Jul 11, 3:39 PM
Completed 4/4 · Scored 8
Ijiranaide, Nagatoro-san
Ijiranaide, Nagatoro-san
Jul 2, 6:23 PM
Plan to Watch · Scored -
Burn the Witch
Burn the Witch
Jun 28, 3:24 AM
Plan to Watch · Scored -
Manga Stats
Days: 100.9
Mean Score: 7.40
  • Total Entries279
  • Reread1
  • Chapters18,078
  • Volumes1,669
Manga History Last Manga Updates
Mairimashita! Iruma-kun
Mairimashita! Iruma-kun
Yesterday, 4:06 AM
Reading 166/? · Scored 9
Wind Breaker
Wind Breaker
Jul 14, 9:35 PM
Reading 205/? · Scored -
Tonari no Seki-kun
Tonari no Seki-kun
Jul 9, 4:41 AM
Reading 14/? · Scored -

Favorites

All Comments (525) Comments

Would you like to post a comment? Please login or sign up first!
Clubby Jul 8, 1:50 AM
And, you just dug your own grave. Your "review" isn't a "critical evaluation of the story", it's a critical evaluation of the ending. Try again.
Clubby Jul 8, 1:38 AM
This isn't what I think, it's based according to the rules here on MAL, and your "review" isn't one.
Clubby Jul 8, 1:24 AM
Let me go in depth as to why your review isn't a review.

First off, what is a review? A review is a work that presents a series by presenting it's story, characters and art with a touch of opinion, it is meant to reflect the person's thoughts on said series and it is supposed to give people who haven't read it enough information (without spoilers) to let them decide whether or not they will try the series.

Based off of that definition, yours fails immediately, starting with "The success of a work often depends on its finale."
You immediately go after the ending and how you thought it was bad, but guess what, there's alot of people that liked it. New readers didn't come to learn about the ending, but if the series is worth a read.
In your second paragraph you go on to say how your score has always been low for the series blah blah blah and the typical "I never intended on writing a review" but you did anyways, moving on. You then use the shitty MAL scoring system to justify your point on how the ending is supposedly "bad". For someone who's been on MAL for a good 8 years i'd think that you'd know how easy to manipulate these scores are and that they don't really mean anything, but oh well, let's continue.
Your third paragraph starts off with "I really used to love reading this story", before going on another rant about the ending with pretty big spoilers. Again, a review is supposed to talk about the ENTIRE story, and if there's gonna be spoilers, include a spoiler alert tag at the very top. So far, you've literally done nothing that can categorize this as a review, and it's only a rant.
The only thing that I can possibly say is a review in this is your two-liner on the art. I don't agree with what you said, but it's your opinion on the art, and that's more of what's expected in a review.

If by now you still don't get that your "review" is a glorified rant, I don't know what to do anymore.
Clubby Jul 7, 2:39 PM
just stopping by to say that your "review" of domekano isn't a review and moreso a glorified rant, and it's pretty garbage at that, you're lucky that the mods are incompetant, that's the only reason why it's still up.
katsuvn Jun 25, 12:35 AM
woetashi Jun 2, 9:33 AM
hey there! i was led here from a forum discussion you were in and i figured i'd write you a comment in passing since your name particularly stood out to me compared to the rest. may i interest you in becoming a mutual of mine? considering we have relatively identical tastes for giant robots i'd say it's a fair exchange. we get to speak our minds freely without feeling overly coy around one another.
Kurt_Irving May 24, 9:04 PM
Weecome back Akagi! and as you can see, I made it to the Warriors of Love saga. On the other hand, I hope the world will get better soon.
Kurt_Irving Mar 21, 11:46 PM
Hey Akagi! I'm doing fine, I just had a lot of work and sunshine. I also watched some recently added Ghibli movies on Netflix.
Eiseirei Jan 23, 3:55 AM
Спасибо за поздравление.)
Keulia Jan 8, 11:40 PM
Oh so right now it's not good? but how many first chapters do you recommend?
Could you also mention something you like about it, like, character development because of X thing or etc
Keulia Jan 8, 1:16 AM
Hello! i saw your post on the forum talking about unordinary. Im also a webtoon user so i've seen it there multiple times but i never read it. Do you recommend it? Why? What do you like about it? Please avoid spoilers : ) thanks!
Kurt_Irving Jan 1, 12:18 PM
Happy New Year to you too and I was just watching videos on ancient weapons.
Eiseirei Dec 31, 2019 2:58 PM
Happy New Year and Merry Orthodox Christmas!
Kurt_Irving Dec 25, 2019 4:15 PM
Merry Christmas Akagi!
VincentHarkonnen Dec 23, 2019 5:50 AM
Thank you for the wishes, mate! I'm doing okay, been through much worse :D Hopefully everything's A-okay on your end too :)

By the way, Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! :D