Ever Green

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

This is a case of a manga that had potential but needed more time to be fleshed out, it seems that this got axed because by the second half of the story it was rushing to the end with a lot of moments that needed more build-up to be impactful, however, while the ending wasn't great, I think this is overall a fun read especially since it's a short read with only 23 chapters, it has good moments and good art with good shot composition and I think that makes it worth reading even if the ending isn't great, but at least it's not outright ... awful or anything.
If you wanted something like Toradora or Golden Time this might've been like them if it had more time in the oven, but for what it is now you're not gonna find it here, but you might like what you read.

I really like the story and I would give it a 8 In general. Why? I saw many negative comment about this manga but personally I think this manga deserve better than that.This manga is really underrated, I came here because I really love Yuyuko Takemiya story (Toradora!, Golden time...).

It is true, the ending is not what we expected, the ending is not very clear. They were hiding their relationship but for what reason?
1. Because they are brother and sister so it would be very awkward if people know brother and sister were couple?
2. Because they are still couple, they still love each ... other but they doesn't want people to know about it since they are brother or sister?

The ending wasn't clear enough to let us know the truth but that's very nice of it. Some people prefer this ending and some people prefer the other. The 1. is very realistic, the 2. is a happy ending so it depends the taste of readers.

What's a bit unfortunate is the story is a bit too short, I would wish to have more detail about them both and there's some small thing a bit confusing, the part where Niki ( with a mask) kill Niki (kid) in Hotaka's dream. Really not sure what's he trying to tell us.

In conclusion, I really love the idea of the story, I love the way it ended, the art is great but it was a bit too short and some part was a bit hard to understand

While I think I did overall enjoy this and think it tackled it's major themes presented, I think the ending was seriously rushed. I feel like when the big reveal happens, Niki turns 180. Then turns another 180 when the MC rescues her from the cabin. It's like Niki didn't have time to properly develop into her own character if that makes sense. The way she acted was understandable but I feel like we needed a deeper dive into her head. Also, I feel like the ending is extremely rushed. Yes, it gets its point across but it would be nice to have the two ... MCs learn to live with reveal after the fact. We get very little dialogue between the two after they both find out the big reveal. I can't give it anything over a 7 because of that of that and think I am probably overrating it then even. It's a fine and quick read but seriously rushed