Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Pages (3) « 1 2 [3]
Jun 16, 7:31 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
There is no need to debate and wall of texts . The quality of the animation for season 3 will be the same as Fairy Tail: 100 Years Quest if not worse which means light years worse than season 1 animation and slightly better than season 2 .


I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Jun 19, 12:28 AM
Offline
May 2024
2
Reply to hi777
bro why are you so fixated on the animation one punch man is not known for it it's known for its comedy and it's characters if you want that good animation go watch demon slayer man I find the animation good idk what's wrong
@hi777 did you see s1? it's most definitely known for animation and fights
Jun 19, 2:05 AM

Offline
Nov 2019
4613
bring me some popcorn because watching the trailer for animation is a wild construct. Similar to watching video game trailers for graphics.
Jun 28, 10:48 AM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to ST63LTH
bring me some popcorn because watching the trailer for animation is a wild construct. Similar to watching video game trailers for graphics.
@ST63LTH don't get me wrong but one punch man was famous/reached wider audiences cause of the fights especially saitama v genos and saitama v boros. Sure the story is unique and quirky and pretty deep at some times but as far as i know or met people who watched the the show were mainly intrigued by the fights and hype. Season 2 leaned on a some pretty deep areas compared to the prequel by introducing the ideologies of various characters, which will keep on getting more deeper as the story progresses and i have seen a pretty decent steep by viewership as the season progressed and have seen people online and also met/know people irl stating/deeming the season as "boring", i asked them why their answer was pretty simple and obviously we all know what they will state
"animation was shit"
"story too long"
"they are dragging the hell out of that shit"
"where the FUCK is saitama?!"
ST63LTH said:
Similar to watching video game trailers for graphics

ngl thats a pretty bad take.
the way u put it is like saying "i shit because others pee"
animation and art style are two both different subject.
Even if u truly mean it that way even after reading the upper statement is like u saying "i wanna play/enjoy modern games on the highest settings possible with the shittiest rig one can come up", do you really wanna play/enjoy/watch a game that runs at 10fps?
i never mentioned the art style was shit, they did pretty well for most of the parts except genos.
Jun 28, 11:50 AM

Offline
Nov 2019
4613
Reply to monke_guy
@ST63LTH don't get me wrong but one punch man was famous/reached wider audiences cause of the fights especially saitama v genos and saitama v boros. Sure the story is unique and quirky and pretty deep at some times but as far as i know or met people who watched the the show were mainly intrigued by the fights and hype. Season 2 leaned on a some pretty deep areas compared to the prequel by introducing the ideologies of various characters, which will keep on getting more deeper as the story progresses and i have seen a pretty decent steep by viewership as the season progressed and have seen people online and also met/know people irl stating/deeming the season as "boring", i asked them why their answer was pretty simple and obviously we all know what they will state
"animation was shit"
"story too long"
"they are dragging the hell out of that shit"
"where the FUCK is saitama?!"
ST63LTH said:
Similar to watching video game trailers for graphics

ngl thats a pretty bad take.
the way u put it is like saying "i shit because others pee"
animation and art style are two both different subject.
Even if u truly mean it that way even after reading the upper statement is like u saying "i wanna play/enjoy modern games on the highest settings possible with the shittiest rig one can come up", do you really wanna play/enjoy/watch a game that runs at 10fps?
i never mentioned the art style was shit, they did pretty well for most of the parts except genos.
@monke_guy i ain't gonna read allat but all i surmised was A. Story > Art this season and B. Don't think you understood my point in that comparison.
A. OPM is known for animation because it's a gag comedy, ofc it's expected to be carried by its visuals. Who cares about story and char atp.
B. The reason why I use the gaming trailer analogy is because gameplay is like 10% of the trailer (especially with modern day releases) So it's like expectations vs reality

Jun 28, 9:56 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to ST63LTH
@monke_guy i ain't gonna read allat but all i surmised was A. Story > Art this season and B. Don't think you understood my point in that comparison.
A. OPM is known for animation because it's a gag comedy, ofc it's expected to be carried by its visuals. Who cares about story and char atp.
B. The reason why I use the gaming trailer analogy is because gameplay is like 10% of the trailer (especially with modern day releases) So it's like expectations vs reality

@ST63LTH
ST63LTH said:
B. Don't think you understood my point in that comparison.

please elaborate i still cant get your point😅
ST63LTH said:
A. OPM is known for animation because it's a gag comedy, ofc it's expected to be carried by its visuals. Who cares about story and char atp.

so you're agreeing with me that even if the story is great but the animation sucks opm will struggle in charts?
ST63LTH said:
B. The reason why I use the gaming trailer analogy is because gameplay is like 10% of the trailer (especially with modern day releases) So it's like expectations vs reality

i still do not understand where you are going with. Lets be honest for a sec and let us both agree that major game studios these days are just baiting players with their visual "spectacle" of a trailer. whereas anime still didn't reach that far that it needs to be baiting its viewers with a visual spectacle as most old men in their "high chairs" definitely would want all the money to themselves they prolly wouldn't spend more than a cent than the amount they are spending on the actual anime itself. as most trailers are just bunch of clips which are slightly better than the ones in the in the anime put together in a specific order giving us a basic glimpse of the story or what it has to offer.
monke_guyJun 28, 10:01 PM
Jun 28, 10:06 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to huntersushil
Have any one seen the new staff added to season 3
Especially the newly added staff

Staff
Series Composition: Tomohiro Suzuki (Sousou no Frieren)
Character Design: Chikashi Kubota (One Punch Man), Shinjirou Kuroda (Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road key animation) NEW, Ryousuke Shirokawa (Violet Evergarden key animation) NEW
Music: Makoto Miyazaki (Zom 100: Zombie ni Naru made ni Shitai 100 no Koto)
@huntersushil
holy shit the the post and pre-animation are stacked by some genuinely great artists, but what about the in animation team tho, who is the animation and key director?
is this official?
Jun 28, 10:17 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to Yubisoft
There is no need to debate and wall of texts . The quality of the animation for season 3 will be the same as Fairy Tail: 100 Years Quest if not worse which means light years worse than season 1 animation and slightly better than season 2 .

@Yubisoft did they already release a trailer for 100 year quest?
Jun 29, 12:43 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to monke_guy
@Yubisoft did they already release a trailer for 100 year quest?
@monke_guy The anime will air in a few days

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Jun 29, 12:49 AM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to Yubisoft
@monke_guy The anime will air in a few days
@Yubisoft just saw the trailer im not surprised the anime always looked like that
Jun 29, 8:13 PM
Offline
Jul 2023
22
Reply to monke_guy
@huntersushil
holy shit the the post and pre-animation are stacked by some genuinely great artists, but what about the in animation team tho, who is the animation and key director?
is this official?
@monke_guy animation in season 2 is not really the major problem TBH it's inconsistencies in art, color grading and sfx are the problem. Seems like S3 will likely fix art inconsistencies because of the aforementioned staff. Idk about color and sfx.
Jun 30, 2:21 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to monke_guy
@Yubisoft just saw the trailer im not surprised the anime always looked like that
@monke_guy That's not the point , the point is that S3 of OPM will 99% most likely look like the new season of Fairy Tail or at least has the same animation quality (don't confuse it with the art style quality) because If the OPM production committee wanted S3 to look better than the average shonen animation projects like Fairy Tail they wouldn't have chose a mid like J.C.Staff especially when good studios like David Production exist that also have experience with projects like OPM
YubisoftJun 30, 2:28 AM

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Jul 2, 1:05 AM

Offline
Dec 2016
294
Reply to Yubisoft
@monke_guy That's not the point , the point is that S3 of OPM will 99% most likely look like the new season of Fairy Tail or at least has the same animation quality (don't confuse it with the art style quality) because If the OPM production committee wanted S3 to look better than the average shonen animation projects like Fairy Tail they wouldn't have chose a mid like J.C.Staff especially when good studios like David Production exist that also have experience with projects like OPM
@Yubisoft OPM s3 trailer is way better than Fairy tail trailer in my opinion , it had way better art and animation looks much cleaner than S2.

I JUST HOPE THEY GIVE US BETTER SOUND EFFECTS CUZ MY GOD THAT WAS HORRIBLE IN S2
Jul 2, 1:10 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to DojimaNoRyu
@Yubisoft OPM s3 trailer is way better than Fairy tail trailer in my opinion , it had way better art and animation looks much cleaner than S2.

I JUST HOPE THEY GIVE US BETTER SOUND EFFECTS CUZ MY GOD THAT WAS HORRIBLE IN S2
DojimaNoRyu said:
it had way better art and animation looks much cleaner than S2.

I am not talking about art quality , I am talking about animation quality . Animation quality as you know is vital for battle shonen .

DojimaNoRyu said:
I JUST HOPE THEY GIVE US BETTER SOUND EFFECTS CUZ MY GOD THAT WAS HORRIBLE IN S

OMG yes , those CS GO sound effect from S2 must definitely be improved and the people who were responsible for the abomination must never work in the industry again...

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Jul 2, 2:05 AM

Offline
Dec 2016
294
Reply to Yubisoft
DojimaNoRyu said:
it had way better art and animation looks much cleaner than S2.

I am not talking about art quality , I am talking about animation quality . Animation quality as you know is vital for battle shonen .

DojimaNoRyu said:
I JUST HOPE THEY GIVE US BETTER SOUND EFFECTS CUZ MY GOD THAT WAS HORRIBLE IN S

OMG yes , those CS GO sound effect from S2 must definitely be improved and the people who were responsible for the abomination must never work in the industry again...
@Yubisoft I agree with u , animation is so important for battle series but from the trailer it was good, of course wasn't mind blowing but very good and u can understand what going on unlike s2
+
I saw some of FT action done by J.C staff from the first 3 episodes it was decent and I'm expecting OPM s3 to be much better , if s2 was 6 out of 10 interms of animation I hope they take their time and we get 8 this time😢
Jul 2, 8:04 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to DojimaNoRyu
@Yubisoft I agree with u , animation is so important for battle series but from the trailer it was good, of course wasn't mind blowing but very good and u can understand what going on unlike s2
+
I saw some of FT action done by J.C staff from the first 3 episodes it was decent and I'm expecting OPM s3 to be much better , if s2 was 6 out of 10 interms of animation I hope they take their time and we get 8 this time😢
@DojimaNoRyu
Yubisoft said:
OPM production committee wanted S3 to look better than the average shonen animation projects like Fairy Tail they wouldn't have chose a mid like J.C.Staff
once again man j.c staff isnt actually shit if they tried they could actually produce some decent shit. they just too lazy or too tight with whatever shit they pick

j.c. staff is like one of the "better" studios to spend your money on an action anime
Jul 2, 8:34 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
294
Reply to monke_guy
@DojimaNoRyu
Yubisoft said:
OPM production committee wanted S3 to look better than the average shonen animation projects like Fairy Tail they wouldn't have chose a mid like J.C.Staff
once again man j.c staff isnt actually shit if they tried they could actually produce some decent shit. they just too lazy or too tight with whatever shit they pick

j.c. staff is like one of the "better" studios to spend your money on an action anime
@monke_guy i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho😕
+
2 years since announcement of s3 so I hope they just take their time

Im anime only and for almost 10 years we only got 24 episodes total💀 ,OPM deserves better man
Jul 2, 9:17 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to DojimaNoRyu
@monke_guy i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho😕
+
2 years since announcement of s3 so I hope they just take their time

Im anime only and for almost 10 years we only got 24 episodes total💀 ,OPM deserves better man
yeah fr and they are already experienced with super hero animes
Jul 2, 10:07 PM

Online
Apr 2021
1273
Reply to DojimaNoRyu
@monke_guy i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho😕
+
2 years since announcement of s3 so I hope they just take their time

Im anime only and for almost 10 years we only got 24 episodes total💀 ,OPM deserves better man
DojimaNoRyu said:
i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho


Because really, they have no real reason to. Bones is not the type of studio to just take the work from someone else, and specially not the type that just goes for whatever popular series they can find first.
Yesterday, 12:19 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to monke_guy
@DojimaNoRyu
Yubisoft said:
OPM production committee wanted S3 to look better than the average shonen animation projects like Fairy Tail they wouldn't have chose a mid like J.C.Staff
once again man j.c staff isnt actually shit if they tried they could actually produce some decent shit. they just too lazy or too tight with whatever shit they pick

j.c. staff is like one of the "better" studios to spend your money on an action anime
monke_guy said:
j.c. staff is like one of the "better" studios to spend your money on an action anime

Seriously when was the last time they proved they were one of the better studios ? Personally I can't remember .

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Yesterday, 12:21 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to DojimaNoRyu
@monke_guy i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho😕
+
2 years since announcement of s3 so I hope they just take their time

Im anime only and for almost 10 years we only got 24 episodes total💀 ,OPM deserves better man
DojimaNoRyu said:
i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho

I personally will say , why not David Production ? They have proved themselves with both JoJo and fire force etc.

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Yesterday, 1:06 AM

Offline
Dec 2016
294
Reply to Yubisoft
DojimaNoRyu said:
i just don't know why Bones didn't pick OPM after Mob psycho

I personally will say , why not David Production ? They have proved themselves with both JoJo and fire force etc.
@Yubisoft personally this is the last chance, If we get 12 episodes with mid animation/art and horrible sound effects like s2 after 5 years of waiting I will read the manga I already got some of the volumes

I just hope they deliver something good 🤞
Yesterday, 3:58 AM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to Yubisoft
monke_guy said:
j.c. staff is like one of the "better" studios to spend your money on an action anime

Seriously when was the last time they proved they were one of the better studios ? Personally I can't remember .
@Yubisoft
Yubisoft said:
Personally I can't remember .
this quote is wild man.
heres a list of anime i found j.c. staff handling it pretty well
-Dungeon ni Deai wo Motomeru no wa Machigatteiru Darou ka
-Prison School
-Toaru Majutsu no IndexKono Subarashii Sekai ni Shukufuku wo! Movie: Kurenai Densetsu
-Toaru Kagaku no Railgun
-Edens Zero (i didnt watch the entire shit but i have seen some clips and the absolutely nailed those scenes)
-Saiki Kusuo no Ψ-nan (its not every where but when when its there we can clearly see j.c. staff going all out)
-Toradora! (a damn 2000s romance anime from j.c. has better animation than most modern isekais)
-Shokugeki no Souma (just watch it man if u want see some "detailed" animation)
-<span style="display: none;" class="js-title">Sentouin, Hakenshimasu!</span> (it has some good parts here and there.)
Yesterday, 4:17 AM

Offline
May 2021
1401
Reply to Yubisoft
There is no need to debate and wall of texts . The quality of the animation for season 3 will be the same as Fairy Tail: 100 Years Quest if not worse which means light years worse than season 1 animation and slightly better than season 2 .

@monke_guy We are talking about a shonen anime which has light years more intense scenes(read the manga, can't put a picture here to avoid spoilers for others) and require an unbelievable amount of more work than all the anime you mentioned and almost all the anime you mentioned are from 2015 with a few exception like Edens Zero . So in conclusion with the Edens Zero example we are back to this :
Yubisoft said:
The quality of the animation for season 3 will be the same as Fairy Tail: 100 Years Quest

Improvements in textures and sound effects and what they were like more than a decade ago doesn't prove anything . Other studios like feel. , ufotable , Bones , David Production , Madhouse, CloverWorks , Wit studio, Doga Kobo etc(and btw some studios I mentioned have much smaller manpower excluding the freelancers) continue to improve over the years and yet studios like J.C.Staff not only they don't improve but they make less and less impressive projects and at the same time they take more and more projects( take a look how many anime they will animate for 2024) which will decrease their animation quality even further . And for some reason even though their animation has become so disappointing(the significant drop in revenue for opm s2 also prove it ) and yet more and more are selecting them


But seriously did you just put Sentouin, Hakenshimasu! as an example of the studio's ''greatness'' ..... come on man
YubisoftYesterday, 5:07 AM

I'm level on MAL-Badges. View my badges.
Yesterday, 5:34 AM
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to Yubisoft
@monke_guy We are talking about a shonen anime which has light years more intense scenes(read the manga, can't put a picture here to avoid spoilers for others) and require an unbelievable amount of more work than all the anime you mentioned and almost all the anime you mentioned are from 2015 with a few exception like Edens Zero . So in conclusion with the Edens Zero example we are back to this :
Yubisoft said:
The quality of the animation for season 3 will be the same as Fairy Tail: 100 Years Quest

Improvements in textures and sound effects and what they were like more than a decade ago doesn't prove anything . Other studios like feel. , ufotable , Bones , David Production , Madhouse, CloverWorks , Wit studio, Doga Kobo etc(and btw some studios I mentioned have much smaller manpower excluding the freelancers) continue to improve over the years and yet studios like J.C.Staff not only they don't improve but they make less and less impressive projects and at the same time they take more and more projects( take a look how many anime they will animate for 2024) which will decrease their animation quality even further . And for some reason even though their animation has become so disappointing(the significant drop in revenue for opm s2 also prove it ) and yet more and more are selecting them


But seriously did you just put Sentouin, Hakenshimasu! as an example of the studio's ''greatness'' ..... come on man
@Yubisoft
after reading that i feel like u have taken my line to the heart. there is a reason i have put "" over better and did not capitalize it. what i mean is to some extent j.c. staff better than 100s of studios out there but not better than the main power house like mappa, ufotable, wit, or i.g. productions. atleast j.c. was selected over deen that is huge W itself man.
Yubisoft said:
( take a look how many anime they will animate for 2024)
i already mentioned that in this forum and how it will hugely affect opm's production quality, but the way you put it is a bit harsh and right on the face "there is no hope" typa shit.
Yubisoft said:
Sentouin, Hakenshimasu!
i never said it was great i clearly stated it has "good" parts "here" and "there" like a glimpse of decent animation type shit. but honestly i feel like this could be better than s2 due to the fact the tomohiro is series compositor and also because unlike last season this time aoki(the guy who animated most of the good fight scenes, which is like very little) is very much in deeply involved in this.
Yubisoft said:
read the manga, can't put a picture here to avoid spoilers for others
idk how they will construct the pacing but i dont think that season 3 will be already having some of the biggest fights unless it is 24 episodes or sumn
Yesterday, 5:44 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
5086
It seems like you have high expectations for One Punch Man 3, especially considering the quality of the manga artwork. It's understandable to feel disappointed if the trailer did not meet your standards. It's important to remember that animation production can be a complex process with various factors influencing the final product. Hopefully, the studio will take feedback into consideration and make improvements before the release of the season. In the meantime, it's good to appreciate the source material and the talented individuals involved in its creation.
This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.
Yesterday, 5:21 PM
Offline
Feb 2020
178
it looks better than season 1 or season 2
Yesterday, 5:22 PM
Offline
Feb 2020
178
people are going to make an example out of you
12 hours ago
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to ToleratedToast6
people are going to make an example out of you
@ToleratedToast6 ok...? 💀
7 hours ago
Offline
Oct 2020
194
Reply to Zarutaku
It seems like you have high expectations for One Punch Man 3, especially considering the quality of the manga artwork. It's understandable to feel disappointed if the trailer did not meet your standards. It's important to remember that animation production can be a complex process with various factors influencing the final product. Hopefully, the studio will take feedback into consideration and make improvements before the release of the season. In the meantime, it's good to appreciate the source material and the talented individuals involved in its creation.
@Zarutaku
Zarutaku said:
It's important to remember that animation production can be a complex process with various factors influencing the final product.
im criticizing not because because its bad im criticizing because they arent working like they used to. (u have to read thru a few posts above)
Zarutaku said:
the studio will take feedback into consideration and make improvements before the release of the season
hopefully.
btw i see u in almost all the forum posts and i thought its about time u popped in one of mine.
Pages (3) « 1 2 [3]

More topics from this board

» Hero Visual #4 Fubuki

OvergrownRover - Jun 6

29 by Yubisoft »»
Jul 2, 11:16 AM

» this episode was banger fr

Sanvyx - Jun 18

43 by fluffsus »»
Jun 23, 12:29 AM

» God-level animations?

Leon888 - Apr 18

22 by Tony_macaroni12 »»
Jun 19, 12:22 AM

» Butchered Adaptation, No Hope.

Okeanix - Feb 29

41 by Jokuc »»
May 24, 8:52 PM

» Season 3 Director

BLACKANGER - Feb 29

25 by todd2580 »»
May 21, 8:25 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login