Ufotable would&#039;ve been a better choice

Offline

Apr 2018

403

Blackkatsu001 said:
"Something less than perfect is an insult to AoT" lol
Aot isn't profitable or popular in japan as before. Even Season 3 Parts 1 & 2 weren't able to restore AOT to its former glory.

S3P2 is literally what built up the hype for S4 to reach near S1 levels of community hype.

Manga readers are the icing on the cake for this

Jan 18, 2021 3:50 AM

#55

Intouch

Offline

May 2015

8

I am so disappointed with the work of the current studio. I expected a drop in quality but this is carnage.
It's an insult to the fans. I still have trouble recovering from this last episode.

Jan 18, 2021 3:52 AM

#56

Offline

Apr 2018

403

Dimmadeezy said:
Not to mention the production committee wanted this season finished at the same time as the manga, so the schedule was 8 months compared to the literal YEARS that WIT studio had to animate the first 3 seasons.

False. WIT started S2 production a year before it aired. And that was WIT's best schedule.

MAPPA had slightly over a year for this season

Jan 18, 2021 3:53 AM

#57

https://streamable.com/fsoleb

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Omertaskaya said:
People are sooo exaggerate Ufotable. They did a good anime and people are treat the studio like god of animation or something.

The only memorable anime that Ufotable made is Fate Zero and Demon Slayer. That's it.

And I can assure you making Demon Slayer and Attack on Titan is not the same fucking thing. Not even close.

I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation.

"I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation."

Are you seriously saying this when they made the Demon Slayer anime? Compare the manga scenes to anime and then say that again.

Jan 18, 2021 3:58 AM

#58

Sad7727

Offline

Aug 2020

509

PrasantGrG said:

Dimmadeezy said:
Not to mention the production committee wanted this season finished at the same time as the manga, so the schedule was 8 months compared to the literal YEARS that WIT studio had to animate the first 3 seasons.

False. WIT started S2 production a year before it aired. And that was WIT's best schedule.

MAPPA had slightly over a year for this season

but didn't u know bro,there's 1 or 2 more titans now its impossible to animate!! please understand and thank mappa by buying these newest blurays for 250$ a piece (bonus 2D levi frame included)

Jan 18, 2021 3:59 AM

#59

Offline

Mar 2018

808

PrasantGrG said:

Dimmadeezy said:
Not to mention the production committee wanted this season finished at the same time as the manga, so the schedule was 8 months compared to the literal YEARS that WIT studio had to animate the first 3 seasons.

False. WIT started S2 production a year before it aired. And that was WIT's best schedule.

MAPPA had slightly over a year for this season

If what you're saying is true then seriously Mappa has no excuse now. They are just incompetent.

Jan 18, 2021 4:02 AM

#60

Offline

Apr 2018

403

Alpha_Druid said:

"I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation."

Are you seriously saying this when they made the Demon Slayer anime? Compare the manga scenes to anime and then say that again.

Ufotable would be a great studio but idk about their style though. Only Bones or Madhouse at their very peaks would be able to pull it off perfectly I guess.

WIT with a good schedule is still something we've never truly seen and considering how well they did despite the horrible schedule I'll always believe they'd still have been the best choice as long as the Production Committee weren't clowns.

Jan 18, 2021 4:06 AM

#61

Offline

Feb 2020

447

Snow_dropindo99 said:

Mathi786 said:

Why would anyone decline this offer I mean if you do this thing right you are making a fanbase which would give you a free pass for at least a decade

I'ts simple Because they know AOT fanbase is toxic.

Nah that's not an excuse, if you don't know than don't bother to comment

Jan 18, 2021 4:09 AM

#62

Offline

Feb 2018

833

Next thread please

Bones would've been a better choice
Kyoani would've been a better choice
Cloverworks would've been a better choice
Madhouse would've been a better choice
Ig production would've been a better choice

*insert any studio name* would've been a better choice

Please, we all knew that wit is better, but they didnt continue aot, fck wit
Why nobody blaming wit for that?

Jan 18, 2021 4:10 AM

#63

Offline

Feb 2018

833

PrasantGrG said:

Dimmadeezy said:
Not to mention the production committee wanted this season finished at the same time as the manga, so the schedule was 8 months compared to the literal YEARS that WIT studio had to animate the first 3 seasons.

False. WIT started S2 production a year before it aired. And that was WIT's best schedule.

MAPPA had slightly over a year for this season

So fck wit bcs they didnt continue aot

Jan 18, 2021 4:11 AM

#64

Snow_dropindo99

Offline

Oct 2020

848

Mathi786 said:

Snow_dropindo99 said:

I'ts simple Because they know AOT fanbase is toxic.

Nah that's not an excuse, if you don't know than don't bother to comment

LOL that's my excuse dude
If you don't agree, it's up to you and not to change the fact that this fanbase is toxic.

And you also have no right to stop me from giving my opinion.

Jan 18, 2021 4:12 AM

#65

Offline

Feb 2018

833

ReegrezSNK said:

sAgE9 said:

sorry i meant fate/zero. compare it with any anime that was aired in 2011. also kmy was not a 3 hr movie but a full 26 eps series. honestly i dont think any studios are near ufotable at this moment, witt studio maybe

And you have 25 episodes of KNY and one fate movie in whole year versus 25 episodes of JJK, 16 episodes of AOT, 12 episodes of Dorohedoro and 13 episodes of GOH, if instead of this all Mappa would produce just one series like Ufotable they maybe could have even better quality.

They will choose jjk for sure bcs aot has toxic fandom

Jan 18, 2021 4:13 AM

#66

Offline

Feb 2020

447

PrasantGrG said:

Alpha_Druid said:

"I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation."

Are you seriously saying this when they made the Demon Slayer anime? Compare the manga scenes to anime and then say that again.

Ufotable would be a great studio but idk about their style though. Only Bones or Madhouse at their very peaks would be able to pull it off perfectly I guess.

WIT with a good schedule is still something we've never truly seen and considering how well they did despite the horrible schedule I'll always believe they'd still have been the best choice as long as the Production Committee weren't clowns.

So you are saying wit also had a bad schedule,
Damn it now mappa has no excuse
EXCUTE THEM!!!

ok just kidding but this is just bad

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 AM

#67

iamJericho7

Offline

Apr 2020

45

i say u should stop watching Attack on titan
cause it will animate till episode 16 don't like it?
plz die

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 AM

#68

Offline

Apr 2018

403

firstawahono said:

So fck wit bcs they didnt continue aot

WIT wasn't getting shit from AoT apart from recognition. Production IG took the profits as they were in the committee whilst WIT were rung out dry

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 AM

#69

Offline

Feb 2020

447

firstawahono said:
Next thread please

Bones would've been a better choice
Kyoani would've been a better choice
Cloverworks would've been a better choice
Madhouse would've been a better choice
Ig production would've been a better choice

*insert any studio name* would've been a better choice

Please, we all knew that wit is better, but they didnt continue aot, fck wit
Why nobody blaming wit for that?

Ok so you r gonna blame someone who didn't do anything vs someone who massacred a masterpiece

Props to you buddy

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 AM

#70

Karnox001

Offline

Jan 2019

801

Ufotable had HF3, the KnY movie and the opening of Tsukihime remake. I'm sure they wanted to do it, but their were already very busy. Also their style might not fit perfectly but who knows.

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 AM

#71

Offline

Feb 2018

833

Alpha_Druid said:

Omertaskaya said:
People are sooo exaggerate Ufotable. They did a good anime and people are treat the studio like god of animation or something.

The only memorable anime that Ufotable made is Fate Zero and Demon Slayer. That's it.

And I can assure you making Demon Slayer and Attack on Titan is not the same fucking thing. Not even close.

I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation.

"I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation."

Are you seriously saying this when they made the Demon Slayer anime? Compare the manga scenes to anime and then say that again.

Yeah yeah ufotable is the best, part 2 will be animated by ufotable studio haha LOL

Jan 18, 2021 4:17 AM

#72

Offline

Feb 2018

833

Mathi786 said:

firstawahono said:
Next thread please

Bones would've been a better choice
Kyoani would've been a better choice
Cloverworks would've been a better choice
Madhouse would've been a better choice
Ig production would've been a better choice

*insert any studio name* would've been a better choice

Please, we all knew that wit is better, but they didnt continue aot, fck wit
Why nobody blaming wit for that?

Ok so you r gonna blame someone who didn't do anything vs someone who massacred a masterpiece

Props to you buddy

Haha yeah i will do that, and still get higher rating than wit aot

Jan 18, 2021 4:17 AM

#73

Offline

Feb 2020

447

Snow_dropindo99 said:

Mathi786 said:

Nah that's not an excuse, if you don't know than don't bother to comment

LOL that's my excuse dude
If you don't agree, it's up to you and not to change the fact that this fanbase is toxic.

And you also have no right to stop me from giving my opinion.

I got it,
U just like emitting this nonrsens nonesence while having no point at all
Good to know

Jan 18, 2021 4:17 AM

#74

Diamond_Sel

Offline

Dec 2019

156

when it was announced that a new studio was taking over I thought ufotable would be the best choice due to their work with mixing 2D animation with 3D but I never saw it as a viable studio change because of the fact they have their hands full with fate and demon slayer, however I think MAPPA are doing a great job with the horrific schedule they were given, and honestly these discussions are just kinda pointless, we have what we were given and it's not like what we have been given is bad, far from it.

Diamond_SelJan 18, 2021 4:20 AM

Jan 18, 2021 4:18 AM

#75

Omertaskaya

Offline

Oct 2018

172

Alpha_Druid said:

Omertaskaya said:
People are sooo exaggerate Ufotable. They did a good anime and people are treat the studio like god of animation or something.

The only memorable anime that Ufotable made is Fate Zero and Demon Slayer. That's it.

And I can assure you making Demon Slayer and Attack on Titan is not the same fucking thing. Not even close.

I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation.

"I doubt Ufotable would have make a good adaptation."

Are you seriously saying this when they made the Demon Slayer anime? Compare the manga scenes to anime and then say that again.

Read my post again. I didn't say people are exaggerate Demon Slayer. I'm saying people are exaggerate Ufotable. Sure, Demon Slayer is great but it takes more than one anime to make a studio the best. In your logic, if J.C Staff would make a good Berserk adaptation, that makes the J.C Staff the best studio ever, automatically ? No.

And I repeat, making Attack on Titan and Demon Slayer IS NOT the same thing. Making Attack on Titan is WAYYYY more hard than Demon Slayer. You can understand why just by look at it both.

Making great adaptation of Demon Slayer doesn't mean they can make a great adaptation of Attack on Titan too. People don't understand that.

OmertaskayaJan 18, 2021 4:24 AM

Jan 18, 2021 4:19 AM

#76

Offline

Feb 2020

447

firstawahono said:

Mathi786 said:

Ok so you r gonna blame someone who didn't do anything vs someone who massacred a masterpiece

Props to you buddy

Haha yeah i will do that, and still get higher rating than wit aot

I gave to 10/10,
Bcz it's not about the rating it's about the content,
They shouldn't have done half assed job on the best anime of the decade or perhaps all times

Jan 18, 2021 4:20 AM

#77

Offline

Feb 2020

447

iamJericho7 said:
i say u should stop watching Attack on titan
cause it will animate till episode 16 don't like it?
plz die

Ok fine

M going to die bye bye

Jan 18, 2021 4:20 AM

#78

MajinSage

Offline

Dec 2018

559

The Amount of Shit Threads have Increased Rapidly Since AOT Came out.

Jan 18, 2021 4:22 AM

#79

Andigowho

Offline

Aug 2020

110

Its not about choice. Almost every big studio wes asked and everyone denied besides MAPPA so please stop wirh this dumb forums and do a hoogle search before you write something dumb

Jan 18, 2021 4:24 AM

#80

Offline

Feb 2018

833

MajinSage said:
The Amount of Shit Threads have Increased Rapidly Since AOT Came out.

Also the rating, getting higher every week LOL

Ironic

Jan 18, 2021 4:31 AM

#81

Kraftwerk0

Offline

Dec 2015

60

PrasantGrG said:

Dimmadeezy said:
Not to mention the production committee wanted this season finished at the same time as the manga, so the schedule was 8 months compared to the literal YEARS that WIT studio had to animate the first 3 seasons.

False. WIT started S2 production a year before it aired. And that was WIT's best schedule.

MAPPA had slightly over a year for this season

Please do research before you say stuff like this, you're gonna encourage people to start harassing anime staff on Twitter again.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2dgso4/attack_on_titan_season_2_is_in_preproduction/
A Google search shows that AoT S2 was in pre-production as early as August 2015 for an April 2017 release. Though there was not enough content to animate a full season at this time, they still had the currently released chapters to adapt.

Jan 18, 2021 4:31 AM

#82

-Aincrad-

Offline

Oct 2018

1688

No actually, ufotable's animation style wouldn't fit SnK at all.

Jan 18, 2021 4:35 AM

#83

Krugerman

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

btw what did u think of the ep? and the Cg titans?

its good for me but i still wish this season is Full 3DCG like the thread i made about it since its weird to see switching from 2D and 3D constantly

If MAPPA made AOT s4 with full dorohedoro lvl CG will u be happy with it?

Jan 18, 2021 4:37 AM

#84

deg

lagom

Offline

Jan 2009

107369

Krugerman said:

deg said:

its good for me but i still wish this season is Full 3DCG like the thread i made about it since its weird to see switching from 2D and 3D constantly

If MAPPA made AOT s4 with full dorohedoro lvl CG will u be happy with it?

i have not watch Dorohedoro but my problem with Attack on Titan Final Season is the overall visuals do not blend well with the constant switching between 2D and 3D unlike my favorite anime movie Promare

still its good enough no hate for me considering i know the production schedule is that bad anyway so this is the best that they can do with that problem

Jan 18, 2021 4:40 AM

#85

Offline

Apr 2018

403

Kraftwerk0 said:

Please do research before you say stuff like this, you're gonna encourage people to start harassing anime staff on Twitter again.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2dgso4/attack_on_titan_season_2_is_in_preproduction/
A Google search shows that AoT S2 was in pre-production as early as August 2015 for an April 2017 release. Though there was not enough content to animate a full season at this time, they still had the currently released chapters to adapt.

I literally said production for a reason. Pre production is completely different

https://blog.sakugabooru.com/2017/06/19/attack-on-titan-season-2-production-notes-12-and-final-impressions/

This article mentions active production beginning in late 2016. Though I've heard it might've been middle of 2016

We don't have much info on MAPPA's pre production but it was likely mid 2019 and production began late 2019 according to leaks

Jan 18, 2021 4:43 AM

#86

levi_ackerman_1

Offline

Dec 2020

28

i reach to a point where any 2D studio will do better

Jan 18, 2021 4:45 AM

#87

Offline

Feb 2020

447

firstawahono said:

MajinSage said:
The Amount of Shit Threads have Increased Rapidly Since AOT Came out.

Also the rating, getting higher every week LOL

Ironic

I gave it 10 so.......

Jan 18, 2021 4:47 AM

#88

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Panoskara said:
Its not about choice. Almost every big studio wes asked and everyone denied besides MAPPA so please stop wirh this dumb forums and do a hoogle search before you write something dumb

Because they had stuff to do and the schedule sucked. Mappa also had stuff to do but they took it anyway. Don't kid yourself into thinking that Mappa execs took this because they're passionate about the show, no, they took it because of money. Mappa isn't a saint here. Heck, the are even in the production committee. They're part of the problem not the victims. But go on and feed their greedy asses with more money lol.

Jan 18, 2021 4:48 AM

#89

Offline

Mar 2018

808

deg said:

Krugerman said:

If MAPPA made AOT s4 with full dorohedoro lvl CG will u be happy with it?

i have not watch Dorohedoro but my problem with Attack on Titan Final Season is the overall visuals do not blend well with the constant switching between 2D and 3D unlike my favorite anime movie Promare

still its good enough no hate for me considering i know the production schedule is that bad anyway so this is the best that they can do with that problem

Promare was a forgettable movie but I didn't even knew they used CGI. Kinda opposite of AoT.

Jan 18, 2021 4:50 AM

#90

ErwinDanchou

Offline

Dec 2020

151

Nah man David Production should have made the Final season so Mikasa-chan was a bit more manly

Shinzou Sasageyo!!!

Jan 18, 2021 4:51 AM

#91

Snow_dropindo99

Offline

Oct 2020

848

Mathi786 said:

Snow_dropindo99 said:

LOL that's my excuse dude
If you don't agree, it's up to you and not to change the fact that this fanbase is toxic.

And you also have no right to stop me from giving my opinion.

I got it,
U just like emitting this nonrsens nonesence while having no point at all
Good to know

Nonesense okay it looks like you just don't agree with my opinion, but I think the main reason no other studio was interested in taking it was because the fanbase was toxic.

I don't care if you think my opinion is nonsense. I'm not forcing you to agree either XD

Snow_dropindo99Jan 18, 2021 4:58 AM

Jan 18, 2021 4:54 AM

#92

Rdxrchi

Offline

Sep 2019

102

If jujutsu and aot didnt share the same studio, you all would probably beg for mappa to animate aot

Jan 18, 2021 4:55 AM

#93

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Snow_dropindo99 said:

Mathi786 said:

I got it,
U just like emitting this nonrsens nonesence while having no point at all
Good to know

Nonesense okay it looks like you just don't agree with my opinion, but I think the main reason no other studio was interested in taking it was because the fanbase was toxic.

I don't care if you think my opinion is nonsense. I'm not forcing you to agree either XD

No kiddo. It's because the production schedule is shit and they already have other projects. You think they care of a bunch of whiny ass neckbeards on the internet in the Far West? Stupid kid.

Jan 18, 2021 4:56 AM

#94

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Rdxrchi said:
If jujutsu and aot didnt share the same studio, you all would probably beg for mappa to animate aot

Too bad your fantasy didn't come true. Deal with it. Mappa is trash.

Jan 18, 2021 5:08 AM

#95

Snow_dropindo99

Offline

Oct 2020

848

Alpha_Druid said:

Snow_dropindo99 said:

Nonesense okay it looks like you just don't agree with my opinion, but I think the main reason no other studio was interested in taking it was because the fanbase was toxic.

I don't care if you think my opinion is nonsense. I'm not forcing you to agree either XD

No kiddo. It's because the production schedule is shit and they already have other projects. You think they care of a bunch of whiny ass neckbeards on the internet in the Far West? Stupid kid.

Well that's your opinion I also have my own opinion. learn to mature kid to respect differences of opinion.

Btw Are you offended because I said this fandom is toxic??

Jan 18, 2021 5:08 AM

#96

devmk0

Offline

Dec 2019

53

Mathi786 said:

Rhhdaiw said:
Guys he said choice
He really said choice
I can't stop laughing
You really think there was a choice
MAPPA was the only studio that wanted to take this shit
There was not any other choice
Also ufotable is busy with counting the income of Demon Slayer movie

Why would anyone decline this offer I mean if you do this thing right you are making a fanbase which would give you a free pass for at least a decade

Mainly because of time: Ufotable was busy with Kny movie, heavens feel movie,
And the production committee (I.G production,Kadokawa) wanted to finish aot as soon as possible before the hype dies down, aot is no longer profitable in Japan and Blu-ray sales are no where near season 1 or kny so there's no point in making a rushed adaptation and getting a bad name. If Mappa didn't take the 4th season, either it would have been given to a smaller studio which would wreck the adaptation like berserk, or we have to wait for maybe another year which the production committee would not allow and the season would have berserk like animation.

Jan 18, 2021 5:16 AM

#97

Hymynamesezra

Offline

Dec 2020

1

No one wanted to do Aot

Jan 18, 2021 5:18 AM

#98

SASSAGEYObihs

Offline

Dec 2019

48

I don't like shototable shit

Jan 18, 2021 5:21 AM

#99