The way they cut content is smart as heck(mostly). Spoilers for the 3 episodes so far

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

yea they

Mattinator95 said:

Bababazooka69 said:

no the producers kodansha decides the episode count also the schedule like by what time the season will be released

Wouldn't the TV channel also have a say in it as they are the ones that air it

yea they do

Dec 21, 2020 9:59 AM

#16

RealMTL

Offline

Dec 2013

1294

Thank you, as an anime only dude this really helps. Once this is finished I might end up reading the Manga at some point.

Dec 21, 2020 10:00 AM

#17

derpinat0rz

Offline

Aug 2015

113

all i see is cope kek

Dec 21, 2020 10:26 AM

#18

Offline

Mar 2018

808

All the little things you said that are irrelevant to the plot do add character and acts as a breathing room.

But also all the major story related content that was cut confuses people who are anime only. It also leads to avoidable speculation as to make sense of the events. If the manga weren't there then I can't imagine you saying the same things.

Admit it. This episode was rushed. Even ep 2 was but this is much worse. Yiu are just making up excuses for Mappa. I get you. I get how you feel but sometimes you just gotta acknowledge bad things when you see it.

Dec 21, 2020 10:29 AM

#19

Offline

Mar 2018

808

derpinat0rz said:
all i see is cope kek

Lol ikr. I do be like that sometimes so I should know.

Dec 21, 2020 10:43 AM

#20

HyperL

Offline

May 2016

3008

Imagine being this eager to diminish others opinions.

You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it.

Dec 21, 2020 10:54 AM

#21

Hiro4ka11

Offline

May 2019

584

ahmed9talha said:
hat is mappa fault they adapted more than 3 chapters in one episode!! and the strange thing about isyama who said it was great ep!!

Actually they still adapted 2 chapter/episode.
reiner struggle scene was in previous chapter buy it swapped with warrior meeting scene. so eps 3 will be solid flashback episode.

please note that the manga itself since basement reveal scene has very heavy dialogue scene. a lots.

Dec 21, 2020 9:57 PM

#22

Moceus

Offline

Jul 2019

50

Alpha_Druid said:
All the little things you said that are irrelevant to the plot do add character and acts as a breathing room.

But also all the major story related content that was cut confuses people who are anime only. It also leads to avoidable speculation as to make sense of the events. If the manga weren't there then I can't imagine you saying the same things.

Admit it. This episode was rushed. Even ep 2 was but this is much worse. Yiu are just making up excuses for Mappa. I get you. I get how you feel but sometimes you just gotta acknowledge bad things when you see it.

Uh, no. I am an anime only and I was never a fan of Mappa so I am certainly not defending them. If any, I am having criticism for both the pacing of the anime and the manga, just the anime made fewer faults than the manga so far but then again, we can disagree.

Dec 21, 2020 10:05 PM

#23

MegaStride

Offline

Feb 2017

6006

_MushiRock11_ said:
A little bummed that they cut the reason as to why Annie’s missing from the Shiganshina assault in particular and some of the scenes not getting enough time to breath. But it was still a pretty good episode, honestly.

With that said though, I’m concerned with the pacing in the upcoming episodes. This part of the story is a mostly about the buildup, answers and world building which basically means that the pacing has to be a little on the slow side and not the rushed end.

When I first saw the episode (anime-only) I just thought that Reiner and Bertholdt proceeded the mission without Annie (her being knocked unconscious with Reiner's choke hold). I kind of thought of it like Annie was dead-set on returning home, but Reiner proceeded anyway, so when she woke up the work had already been done and she had to just go along with the plan.

I've read that one little part though so it makes more sense. However, I don't think my idea of what might've happened was such a bad idea, especially since in many scenes it shows how Annie wants to return home ASAP.

MegaStrideDec 21, 2020 10:10 PM

Dec 21, 2020 10:27 PM

#24

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Moceus said:

Alpha_Druid said:
All the little things you said that are irrelevant to the plot do add character and acts as a breathing room.

But also all the major story related content that was cut confuses people who are anime only. It also leads to avoidable speculation as to make sense of the events. If the manga weren't there then I can't imagine you saying the same things.

Admit it. This episode was rushed. Even ep 2 was but this is much worse. Yiu are just making up excuses for Mappa. I get you. I get how you feel but sometimes you just gotta acknowledge bad things when you see it.

Uh, no. I am an anime only and I was never a fan of Mappa so I am certainly not defending them. If any, I am having criticism for both the pacing of the anime and the manga, just the anime made fewer faults than the manga so far but then again, we can disagree.

>"I'm an anime only"
>"Anime made fewer faults than the manga"

>"Criticizing Mappa"
>Brings up excuses to defend it

Bruh. Your actions speak louder than words.

Dec 21, 2020 10:30 PM

#25

Boku no Anime List Boku no Manga List Boku no Profile Page

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Alpha_Druid said:

Moceus said:

Uh, no. I am an anime only and I was never a fan of Mappa so I am certainly not defending them. If any, I am having criticism for both the pacing of the anime and the manga, just the anime made fewer faults than the manga so far but then again, we can disagree.

>"I'm an anime only"
>"Anime made fewer faults than the manga"

>"Criticizing Mappa"
>Brings up excuses to defend it

Bruh. Your actions speak louder than words.

Either ways just from a stand alone episode if we don't consider the manga its close to perfect but its a shame it wasn't able to achieve it

Dec 21, 2020 10:34 PM

#26

_MushiRock11_

長鳥真 / ナガトリマコト

Offline

Jun 2017

8199

BlakexEkalb said:
When I first saw the episode (anime-only) I just thought that Reiner and Bertholdt proceeded the mission without Annie (her being knocked unconscious with Reiner's choke hold). I kind of thought of it like Annie was dead-set on returning home, but Reiner proceeded anyway, so when she woke up the work had already been done and she had to just go along with the plan.

Yeah, makes sense. My kid brother, who is currently an anime-only too, felt the same and it saddened me since that doesn’t quite add up. You can’t knock some out out for a day like that xD.

I've read that one little part though so it makes more sense. However, I don't think my idea of what might've happened was such a bad idea, especially since in many scenes it shows how Annie wants to return home ASAP.

Sure it adds up to this line of thought but it doesn’t explain a few other things such as how they managed to get away from the titans and consequently amass all the titans near the walls. And these really make the story more complete and satisfying, especially for people who’ll try to rewatch season 1 later on I imagine.

Also, the whole Annie - Kenny scene felt a little random too. I don’t think it’s easy for anime-onlies to pick that up easily. Feel free to ask if that isn’t clear by the way, I doubt the anime will come back to this.

@BlakexEkalb Right, lol.

_MushiRock11_Dec 22, 2020 2:26 AM

#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni

Dec 21, 2020 10:36 PM

#27

Offline

Mar 2018

808

Harsha1314 said:

Alpha_Druid said:

>"I'm an anime only"
>"Anime made fewer faults than the manga"

>"Criticizing Mappa"
>Brings up excuses to defend it

Bruh. Your actions speak louder than words.

Either ways just from a stand alone episode if we don't consider the manga its close to perfect but its a shame it wasn't able to achieve it

Harsha1314 said:

Alpha_Druid said:

>"I'm an anime only"
>"Anime made fewer faults than the manga"

>"Criticizing Mappa"
>Brings up excuses to defend it

Bruh. Your actions speak louder than words.

Either ways just from a stand alone episode if we don't consider the manga its close to perfect but its a shame it wasn't able to achieve it

The anime doesn't exist in a vacuum even if it did, it'd still have the same problems. Problems like confusion and no breathing room. Manga is infinitely better in this regard.

Dec 21, 2020 10:38 PM

#28

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Alpha_Druid said:

Harsha1314 said:

Either ways just from a stand alone episode if we don't consider the manga its close to perfect but its a shame it wasn't able to achieve it

Harsha1314 said:

Either ways just from a stand alone episode if we don't consider the manga its close to perfect but its a shame it wasn't able to achieve it

The anime doesn't exist in a vacuum even if it did, it'd still have the same problems. Problems like confusion and no breathing room. Manga is infinitely better in this regard.

yes it is like i had to rewatch uprising twice to understand everything that was going on and join the dots. this season in and itself feels like its more binge worthy than a weekly installlment. manga allows u to stop reading or re read to reflect on stuff it can never be the same with the anime and especially this episode aside from covering Reiner's struggle wasn't able to completely capture the atmosphere the Warriors were living in. Sure many anime onlies won't be as bothered because of execution but as someone who knows the story in advance itll be tough to completely relish the episode. also annie and kenny scene caused a lot of confusion id say wait for eng dub to actually understand the scene in one watch

Harsha1314Dec 21, 2020 10:42 PM

Dec 21, 2020 10:38 PM

#29

Offline

Mar 2018

808

I finally understood when people said, "the manga was better". Now I know how they felt T-T

Dec 21, 2020 11:00 PM

#30

Reiner_undieable

Offline

May 2017

538

I saw countless anime onlies confused about alot of things like what happened to annie after reiner choked her, did she accept to continue? What is that random scene of kenny and annie, how did she escape him? Why did she stalk him?and alot of misunderstandings, even saw people hate reiner more after this ep instead of loving him because they didn't show his suffering all they showed is how he failed his mission misrebly.

Dec 21, 2020 11:25 PM

#31

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 21, 2020 11:41 PM

#32

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Dec 21, 2020 11:45 PM

#33

Moceus

Offline

Jul 2019

50

Alpha_Druid said:

Moceus said:

Uh, no. I am an anime only and I was never a fan of Mappa so I am certainly not defending them. If any, I am having criticism for both the pacing of the anime and the manga, just the anime made fewer faults than the manga so far but then again, we can disagree.

>"I'm an anime only"
>"Anime made fewer faults than the manga"

>"Criticizing Mappa"
>Brings up excuses to defend it

Bruh. Your actions speak louder than words.

I checked only the chapters adpated so far because people on both sides wine non-stop and yes, in terms of story telling so far, the manga makes way more mistakes, like why need so many recaps? All the episodes are far from perfect, but cutting content overall is not the main issue, in fact it is doing much more good than harm(still doesn't justify the harms, though).

And yes, there are obvious pacing issues but I disagree with the idea of fixing it by adding the filler scenes and instead, cut out the OP and ED, keep the important scenes(Annie's fatigue), restructure them(Annie perspective transition is confusing) and extend the calmer scenes like Reiner's departure and Bert sleeping position dialogue. But that's not the point, this post is more of an appreciation for all the efforts went into the storyboarding so far, while not perfect but still great and somehow people just keep blowing it up.

MoceusDec 21, 2020 11:48 PM

Dec 21, 2020 11:45 PM

#34

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

Arin-sanDec 22, 2020 12:04 AM

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 21, 2020 11:48 PM

#35

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Dec 21, 2020 11:49 PM

#36

SparkleDuck

Offline

Mar 2012

618

derpinat0rz said:
all i see is cope kek

what's there to cope with if you like it lmao

Dec 21, 2020 11:51 PM

#37

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? My post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

Arin-sanDec 22, 2020 12:04 AM

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 21, 2020 11:54 PM

#38

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

Dec 21, 2020 11:56 PM

#39

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

Arin-sanDec 21, 2020 11:59 PM

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 21, 2020 11:58 PM

#40

ghkbftuvut

Offline

Jul 2019

1

i am genuinely upset that they cut out the part where pieck is crawling on the floor
this is injustice and i wont stand for it

shaking and crying and shitting and pissing rn

- The

Dec 21, 2020 11:59 PM

#41

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

Dec 22, 2020 12:01 AM

#42

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 22, 2020 12:01 AM

#43

yaruka

Offline

Feb 2019

996

honestly flashbacks would have been fine. I didn't have the time to go back and refresh myself about the previous sesasons.

Dec 22, 2020 12:02 AM

#44

MegaStride

Offline

Feb 2017

6006

_MushiRock11_ said:

BlakexEkalb said:
When I first saw the episode (anime-only) I just thought that Reiner and Bertholdt proceeded the mission without Annie (her being knocked unconscious with Reiner's choke hold). I kind of thought of it like Annie was dead-set on returning home, but Reiner proceeded anyway, so when she woke up the work had already been done and she had to just go along with the plan.

Yeah, makes sense. My kid brother, who is currently an anime-only too, felt the same and it saddened me since that doesn’t quite add up. You can’t knock some out out for a day like that xD.

I've read that one little part though so it makes more sense. However, I don't think my idea of what might've happened was such a bad idea, especially since in many scenes it shows how Annie wants to return home ASAP.

Sure it adds up to this line of thought but it doesn’t explain a few other things such as how they managed to get away from the titans and consequently amass all the titans near the walls. And these really make the story more complete and satisfying, especially for people who’ll try to rewatch season 1 later on I imagine.

Also, the whole Annie - Kenny scene felt a little random too. I don’t think it’s easy for anime-onlies to pick that up easily. Feel free to ask if that isn’t clear by the way, I doubt the anime will come back to this.

Yeah ik that but I was using anime logic lol

Dec 22, 2020 12:03 AM

#45

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

many people made out nearly the same conclusion thats why u were attacked so much. u shouldve made it seem like reading the manga is a good thing as well, but the way u put it it felt like you were totally degrading the adaptation, not just s4 but the prev seasons as well

Dec 22, 2020 12:36 AM

#46

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

also to be a little more sarcastic after being rude, i expected a fall in ratings and people running around criticising this adaptation well that didn't happen when i wanted it to.... even if it did its not half as much as for ep2

Dec 22, 2020 12:39 AM

#47

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

also to be a little more sarcastic after being rude, i expected a fall in ratings and people running around criticising this adaptation well that didn't happen when i wanted it to.... even if it did its not half as much as for ep2

I never wanted this season to drop in ratings, because the past few eps might've been bad, but it was bad when compared to Attack on Titan standards, it's still one of the greatest anime ever and better than most anime, it still deserves it's current score, but compared to AoT standards, it's not that great.

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 22, 2020 1:47 AM

#48

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

also to be a little more sarcastic after being rude, i expected a fall in ratings and people running around criticising this adaptation well that didn't happen when i wanted it to.... even if it did its not half as much as for ep2

I never wanted this season to drop in ratings, because the past few eps might've been bad, but it was bad when compared to Attack on Titan standards, it's still one of the greatest anime ever and better than most anime, it still deserves it's current score, but compared to AoT standards, it's not that great.

hmm.... the thing is i feel the anime can never really beat the manga story wise or even pacing wise, but what it can surpass is the impact, so we have to see what will actually happen with the next few episodes, if ep 5,6,7 are bad I will have to drop the anime, even so i still feel it will blow up, since there are many anime onlies who are liking it so far and given the story itself being this good, but for AoT standards this episode surely doesn't hold as well as prev 2, mostly because of the fast pacing relatively and what the first 2 episodes were able to cover and present direction wise from the manga and what this episode wasn't able to for the manga readers. because if we go just story and execution wise this episode is definitely better than previous 2 episodes given I'm just seeing so much praise for this ep from many anime onlies not only in MAL but twitter and Youtube comment sections........ also because the anime onlies don't know the extra scenes, and hence they'd still be happy with it, just because everything the STORY presented this episode relative to the other 2 episodes. and certainly this episode enhanced the feel of scenes like Marcel getting Eaten, Porco beating the shit out of Reiner, his breakdown, Annie's fight with Reiner, and Reiner and Eren scene before Reiner tried to commit suicide and even that scene looked really good. the best part of the episode however is the Mr. Krueger and Falco's little talk and Mr. Krueger's speech which was so good and had more impact than in the manga overall. So I'd really say each media has its own ups and downs and sometimes knowing things in advance can spoil the affect, for example not you but my friends who read this part of the story long while ago felt the impact of ep3 because they didn't revise it, but even now when they did they felt mostly there are more additional dialogue and scenes but the overall impact for them remained the same. So aiming at anime onlies alone, i think this adaptation is fantastic but pleasing the manga readers completely will still be tough, and seems ep 2 pleased most of em a lot more but for this ep when it didn't there isn't that big of an uproar I feel........
-> " but for AoT standards this episode surely doesn't hold as well as prev 2" from a manga reader stand point because its still pretty much AoT standards for anime onlies considering ep3,4 of s3 pt1 and ep7 of s3 pt2
-> however i feel for people who read the manga in advance surely won't feel the same impact as when they did,.i.e., if they read the part recently (example myself)

Harsha1314Dec 22, 2020 2:04 AM

Dec 22, 2020 1:54 AM

#49

Offline

Jun 2020

1407

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:

Harsha1314 said:

Arin-san said:
And here comes the MAPPA fanboys to whiteknight MAPPA. Such shitheads. I also agree that this episode was hella rushed, and thank god I gave up in ep 2 and started reading the manga, I actually understood ep 3 better thanks to the manga.

I also made a thread about how the anime was rushed and had a lot of cut content, MAPPA fanboys took over my thread and started their assault.

"B-but uprising had cut content too!!!" Oh fucking shut up please.

shut up your arguement for episode 2 was still not relevant. but ep3 messed up bad

Yeah you need to shut up MAPPA fanboy, what do you mean my argument wasn't relevant? I exactly said this in my OP how the later eps was gonna be rushed as well, this is why I told people to read the manga, but disgusting MAPPA fanboys like you hijacked the thread and started saying "oMGGg yOu gAvE uP tOo eArLy" and now look what happened to episode 3. And now you pretend to be a saint? Yeah you better stop talking to me.

im not fanboying cause i barely know mappa. this episode wasn't as great but not even half as bad as u made it up to be. but even now your arguements to drop the anime for manga based on ep 2 is shit.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

Oh my god. Your reading skills is so lacklustre that I cannot even comprehend it. Did I ever tell anyone to drop the anime? You nimrod, my post wasn't telling people to drop the anime, it was about how anime onlies should start reading the manga to understand the anime better. Yeah you can't read shit. That's why you need to shut up.

>"I barely know MAPPA"
>continues to whiteknight MAPPA

im not whiteknighting mappa im whiteknighting the adaptation. and u did say to drop the anime in that thread

"and u did say to drop the anime in that thread" So now YOU will tell me what MY thread meant? It's not my fault you can't read for shit.

its not even my problem when u can't elaborate shit

I can say the same thing, it's not my fault you can't read shit properly, when other people did read it properly and you didn't.

also to be a little more sarcastic after being rude, i expected a fall in ratings and people running around criticising this adaptation well that didn't happen when i wanted it to.... even if it did its not half as much as for ep2

I never wanted this season to drop in ratings, because the past few eps might've been bad, but it was bad when compared to Attack on Titan standards, it's still one of the greatest anime ever and better than most anime, it still deserves it's current score, but compared to AoT standards, it's not that great.

hmm.... the thing is i feel the anime can never really beat the manga story wise or even pacing wise, but what it can surpass is the impact, so we have to see what will actually happen with the next few episodes, if ep 5,6,7 are bad I will have to drop the anime, even so i still feel it will blow up, since there are many anime onlies who are liking it so far and given the story itself being this good, but for AoT standards this episode surely doesn't hold as well as prev 2

One thing is for sure, when the Rumbling arc gets animated, the anime will blow up pretty good, I'm not even kidding. I haven't started the rumbing arc in manga yet but I'm so hyped for it, I might not start the rumbling arc because I still have faith that MAPPA won't mess up the best arc, if they do, then we'll see what to do with MAPPA, but I think MAPPA is smart enough to not mess it up. I just wanna see the rumbling arc get animated so badly, and I'm sure there are people like me who'd love to see the rumbling arc get animated, that's why there is a chance that the anime might still blow up.

I said keep your hands on the table

Dec 22, 2020 2:08 AM

#50