Forum Settings
Forums

Why are most of the webcomic/webtoons aren't listed here ?

New
Nov 5, 2020 11:18 AM
#1
Offline
Nov 2020
4
I see big ones like Tower of God and God of High School but barely anything else ?

Viral hit, Omniscient Reader Viewpoint, Hardcore Leveling Warrior, Hero Waltz,Gamer, Eleceed, GOSU ?

I understand that this site lists mainly Japanese materials but it does have some Korean comics like Solo Leveling too. I'm new to this website, don't kill me
RedditERalpine2Nov 5, 2020 11:29 AM
Nov 5, 2020 11:32 AM
#2
Manga Moderator
Offline
Feb 2017
2402
First of all, welcome to MAL! And don't worry, I won't kill you ;)

For a webcomic/webtoon be eligible to be on MAL, it must be published physically by a reputable publishing company.

For example, Omniscient Reader Viewpoint is only published digitally. Therefore, it is not eligible (yet) to be included in the database.

You can learn more about the eligibility of manga/manhwa/manhua here.

Hope this helps!
Nov 5, 2020 11:39 AM
#3
Offline
Nov 2020
4
Phloup said:
First of all, welcome to MAL! And don't worry, I won't kill you ;)

For a webcomic/webtoon be eligible to be on MAL, it must be published physically by a reputable publishing company.

For example, Omniscient Reader Viewpoint is only published digitally. Therefore, it is not eligible (yet) to be included in the database.

You can learn more about the eligibility of manga/manhwa/manhua here.

Hope this helps!
I'll make sure to read that, since it's very long so I'll take my time, but if only those stuffs are here who have been physically published, does that real mean every single thing or there are some exceptions
Nov 5, 2020 11:58 AM
#4
Manga Moderator
Offline
Feb 2017
2402
RedditERalpine2 said:
I'll make sure to read that, since it's very long so I'll take my time, but if only those stuffs are here who have been physically published, does that real mean every single thing or there are some exceptions


I have only been a manga moderator for a few months, so I'm unsure whether there are exceptions or not. However, as far as I'm aware, all Korean and Chinese webtoons have to be published physically to be included in the database.

The only exception to this rule are Japanese manga/one-shots published digitally by a reputable publishing company. If they are published on a publisher's site, then they are eligible to be included in the database. For example, everything on Shounen Jump+ and ComicWalker is eligible (or should be eligible), as these are official sites owned by reputable publishing companies, with these owned by Shueisha and Kadokawa, respectively.

By the way, for the Manga Database Guidelines, the only point that discusses manga eligibility is point I. So if you only want to know about that, you don't have to go read the entire guidelines.
Nov 5, 2020 7:39 PM
#5
Offline
Nov 2020
4
Phloup said:
RedditERalpine2 said:
I'll make sure to read that, since it's very long so I'll take my time, but if only those stuffs are here who have been physically published, does that real mean every single thing or there are some exceptions


I have only been a manga moderator for a few months, so I'm unsure whether there are exceptions or not. However, as far as I'm aware, all Korean and Chinese webtoons have to be published physically to be included in the database.

The only exception to this rule are Japanese manga/one-shots published digitally by a reputable publishing company. If they are published on a publisher's site, then they are eligible to be included in the database. For example, everything on Shounen Jump+ and ComicWalker is eligible (or should be eligible), as these are official sites owned by reputable publishing companies, with these owned by Shueisha and Kadokawa, respectively.

By the way, for the Manga Database Guidelines, the only point that discusses manga eligibility is point I. So if you only want to know about that, you don't have to go read the entire guidelines.
okay, thanks for the response

More topics from this board

Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Modifications/Duplicates Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Aarana - Jan 4, 2009

8294 by Walrsu »»
2 hours ago

» Add "Sakura no Machi" by Sugaru Miaki

kizumi91 - Today

2 by kizumi91 »»
Today, 6:36 AM

» How to add missing manga magazine to the database

Lalako - Oct 6

2 by Lalako »»
Yesterday, 7:57 AM

» Is there a reason BIBLIOMANIA is not in the manga DB?

Leosmileyface - Feb 10, 2021

34 by EurekaLover »»
Oct 5, 7:57 PM

» Add Sanctify by GODSSTATION

rtim - Oct 5

0 by rtim »»
Oct 5, 7:11 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login