New
Oct 19, 2017 5:03 AM
#701
I an headed to work and I've had no internet there so I'll be posting a read list and my thoughts this evening (internet permitting). Unless we miraculously got internet on that side of the island I'll be back after work. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Oct 19, 2017 5:14 AM
#702
Gwendolly said: ??? Excuse for what exactly?AbuHumaid said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. Feel like youre looking for a perfect excuse now. You're the weird one here.... |
Oct 19, 2017 5:24 AM
#703
Gwendolly said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I didnt even have to vote, so why would I vote if it risked putting me in harms way? Am i missing anyone I like Abu for town here Also forgot Yurkin was in the gams as she's missing from the vote count. She could be scum unvote: This feels just like my defense of my actions in ouran mafia vote: @yurkin Why no vote on D1? Yes you missed me. Am I already dead to you? Abu is being shady af. He didnt appear the whole day yesterday, he whiteknighted RE, then turns up on EoD and blaming others for their actions even though he was willing to lynch RE himself. It's as if he already knew she would flip town. It's odd that no one is suspecting him while he's out there accusing the whole train being scum. Abu-logic= scum? 1. When and how did I whiteknight RE? 2. I was far from disappearing the whole phase, so your point is moot 3. How is it scummy to call out scummy actions? Don't you think I'll overlook your scummniess just because it was EoD. 4. Shinichi has already used that argument and I refuted it, if you actually read my posts, of course you wouldn't care enough to read though, scum |
Oct 19, 2017 5:26 AM
#704
@Gwendolly 5. When was all this suspicion of me at the EoD 1? Now I'm a scum all of a sudden huh? Any scum reads other than me? |
Oct 19, 2017 5:30 AM
#705
Gwendolly said: #653AbuHumaid said: Suzune-chan said: AbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. Dafuq? Can't believe youre even going there. #465 #474 What's all this then? Again, read the thread before commenting, you're just making yourself look more scummy |
Oct 19, 2017 5:37 AM
#706
Gwendolly said: whatever you say won't hide the fact that you were jumping around and wasn't even scum reading the one you voted (Astros) then changed your vote to RE with such a weak reason after I called out the train on Astros that there was definitely scum there, and even Labs and Shinichi followed along. Making it seem like you were in a hurry won't work on meAbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Anyone wanna go after Shinichi with me? I'd go after RE with her last three suspicious posts Notice how Gwen didn't even consider Shinichi's lynch AbuHumaid said: logic340 said: AbuHumaid said: can.you expand in hour you feel about all three? Gwen more than the other two.Suzune-chan said: I was against the Astros train too, then suggested Shinichi for the lynch but everyone preferred RE's lynch it's suspicious how everyone easily followed along especially Gwen, Labs and ShinichiAbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. -.- Left my vote for Astros because I wanted to go to bed and he had the most votes at that time. Yes, I said RE was suspicious after her entrance of not wanting to join but telling Astros to defend himself. Sorry not sorry. I dont regret my vote. |
Oct 19, 2017 5:39 AM
#707
Gwendolly said: Just trying to get him to clarify his claim so no, try again.AbuHumaid said: Labs said: Cool, RE, Gwendo and Shinuku-koon is where I wanted to hit and pull yesterday. Logic might've made this a really quick game and backs the fact I felt like a D2 claim would be a laugh. Ryuu still seems tpr more specifically killing or mafia leaned. I'm the other tpr and we have 2 Mafio, potential conversion and vote manipulation. I'll explain the rest when home, back to work for me Role fishing? |
Oct 19, 2017 5:40 AM
#708
Gwendolly said: Highest possibility, how would you know he wasn't killed by either mafia or TPR?AbuHumaid said: Thank God scum killed Soda tbh, I was suspicious of him How would you know Soda was killed by scum? |
Oct 19, 2017 5:42 AM
#709
I wasn't planning to post because of my headache, but Gwen really provoked with her BS. |
Oct 19, 2017 6:42 AM
#710
Vote count 2.1 AbuHumaid: Labs Logic340: Shinichi-kun > Yurkin > Unvote > Suzune-chan Laby: Ryuuseino Gwen : AbuHumaid Hosts should be notified by players if they notice a mistake in the count or links. Mod notes: Did this on phone, please tell me if I made a mistake. Gambette all! |
Oct 19, 2017 6:46 AM
#711
Labs said: @Shinichi-kun Can't quote shit well on phone, But I'll get to you about having bolded my breadcrumbing ..... seeing as you're making it out to have been by chance alone. I mean if I actually did do that, then it was by chance lol |
Oct 19, 2017 6:50 AM
#712
Labs said: Unless someone speaks up and clears the second kill, we can probably assume SK or small mafia with a one shot extra kill.... If so, was likely strong man too. Again if it was SK as tpr instead of an extra shot or vig, this should lower the chances of traitor passives and/conversion but eh, with a town leaned for and the roster size there has to be something to balance it out and it won't be 3 Mafio from the get go. I have a secondary active which I'll explain more on once home, but it adds 2 votes to a select player the following day phase in turn of the day ability not going through. Thus the reason there is a good chance scum can negate or straight up steal voting power for balancing reasons, also the possibility one or two at most town roles have zero weight as a whole or under set circumstances. I also passively pass as inno on alignment checks, but this shouldn't cancel out what logic claims to have used and my role card will flip town even though I'm TPR. The rest of the role is a mess, so I'll save that post till I get home. So a player of your chosen would auto matically have 2 votes at the start of the next day phase of the night you used it, if thats true then ya i can see vote stealing as a thing. I think this is rolemadness which means almost every role prob has some sort of significant use. The showing up as town is quite convienent i must say, I mean logically if you hadnt said that my vote would be on you right now. If i wasnt to trust that claim that would only mean Qoco role prob has lies in it to. |
Oct 19, 2017 6:51 AM
#713
Labs said: So my primary ability is actually stupidly strong in most sense and is pretty much a mix of hider and jailer and topped off with investigation properties ( though weak ) Santo Terra: I chose a player during the day phase. They are sent an invite to my personal realm. If they accept: Both the player and myself commute for the night. *Un-targetable by abilities, this include kills and everything else as far as I can tell. *They will however be role-blocked in a sense, as they are essentially no longer in play. *I Will also be informed of their role (flavour) Note that this does not reveal abilities or faction. *If I target Mafia I will die instead. If they decline: My second ability comes into effect and they will start the following day phase with 2 anonymous votes on them. I do not get to chose to activate this or not, it just happens in turn of being declined for the night. ^Probably to add some form of negative to such a stupid ability that favours town. Jesus holy christ almighty, that 1st effect. Anyways what do you gain from telling us this? |
Oct 19, 2017 6:52 AM
#714
Labs said: Shinichi-Kun said: Labs said: AbuHumaid said: Sodalicious_ said: Nice, same as you, the fact he's innocent child doesn't mean much in a bastard gameAbuHumaid said: alright let's get to business, since this is a bastard game, do you think Qoco is mafia? Not gonna say Qoco is mafia, but i'm also not gonna believe they're town That's my view You? @Qoco get on here and prove you're town Probably the wrong kind of bastard game/hosts tbh. Unless your role suggests otherwise already.... On a side note, wearing headphones all the time starts to hurt :'< Well its a closed setup so anything is possible but to take roles and mechanics youve only seen coming from 1 game and 1 specific host just seems like a way to throw fire onto Qc Behavior wise espically how hes been acting since knowing he was innocent child has shown that as of right now hes town. There has been no signs of fluster or hesitation which those 2 would be huge signs to being mafia or know you're caught in a lie. Dont wear headphones for so long Aight I found the post. Soooo what was with separating this and bolding it? That was bread-crumbing for my claim D2 tbh. Since I believe I saw at-least one person mention persona? within the sign-ups maybe in relation to the major arcana. My role card is the Hermit Due to there being few choices from persona for this card that are main characters I went with an obvious choice and well, being from the most recent addition to the series. Bish wears dem big fuck off headphones. ^Futaba ^Hermit What fucking hermit wears headphones lol, maybe in anime world sure but not in real life. Ive never played persona smh >_>, why did you try bread crumbing your role soe arly into the game? |
Oct 19, 2017 6:55 AM
#715
Labs said: Labs said: Ryuuseino said: If I were to state outright whether I wanted either mafia or town to win, would that get me killed? Soft TPR? or are you going for something else here? Quoting this to show what I was taking a stab at earlier. The whole suggestion of being either Neut and able to side with either or being forced to side with one or the other. ^Given that I alone knew my own role and that I am forced to win alone or alongside town, this allowed me to jump to the potential conclusion that Ryuu held the opposite end of TPR cards. Either neut/killing or specifically to aid Mafio only. If we look at it as a whole then prob the best case scenario, but let me keep catching up. |
Oct 19, 2017 6:59 AM
#716
Labs said: Shinichi-Kun said: Suzune-chan said: logic340 said: I don't doubt the result. I doubt the 100% accuracy of the result.Ryuuseino said: lynch me when I flip town know I was telling the truth. It said 4 evil players on the train.AbuHumaid said: logic340 said: Oh so you voted to lynch Astros for no reason then went MIA during phase change? HmmmAbuHumaid said: What reason did I give? I don't remember giving one? Like it or not that's where I voted. that's not a good reason to vote him... Does that mean there's 5 scum, unless logic was lying about how many mafia there were on the train. What if theirs a miller? No lie now that I see 4 evil results that possibility does cross my mind. If there is a miller, it's either hidden from said role card or it's too late and they can get lynched for it. I'm a reverse miller on the side.... so eh A hidden Miller i think would be fine, because if a person individially got checked and they saw that they showed up as scum reaction alone would prob clear their case. Labs said: This might come off as a little obnoxious but I'd prefer to get info out as fast as possible so I can get to the easier of my win conditions before getting necked out of paranoia. And so, here come the pingaz and yes Imma include those I suspect regardless: @AbuHumaid @Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco Assuming you're all wise enough to read up, feel free to submit something along these lines so I can default my ability usage into public hands. Use primary ability this day phase: Y/N Use primary ability to: Protect assumed town/Kill myself on assumed Mafia Invite user: Preferred user. Cheers. What do you want here i am confused? yurkin said: Labs said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: 3 mafia 1 killing (evil) tpr made evident by two deathslogic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: tpr would also be uninformed which could lend itself to looking townie..I also feel Abu I'd town here saved more linked inclined to think you may be scum over him.logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun.If you're town do you think Abu could be tpr? @AbuHumaid if you're town do you think shin could be tpr? If I may ask first, what brought upon the dicussion of TPR before scum? I think Abu is town for now, I want to look into gwenny right now. So you think there is 4 evil people and an unaligned tpr on top of that? Thoughts on 2 intial Mafia or total. Good TPR and Evil TPR? Seeing as I've spewed what I need to now. If there is evil tpr + 2maf as per you theory, then how do u explain logic's result of 4 evil on that train?? Suzune theory could be correct in a sense. Gwendolly said: Shinichi-Kun said: I wonder if the flavor indicates ability as well. Justice sounds like a vig or cop to me. Two deaths still happened tho. Hanged Man could sound like TPR? Thats what i was thinking too, hanged Man sounds like a role with a suicidal passive attached to it haha. |
Oct 19, 2017 7:00 AM
#717
Gwendolly said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I didnt even have to vote, so why would I vote if it risked putting me in harms way? Am i missing anyone I like Abu for town here Also forgot Yurkin was in the gams as she's missing from the vote count. She could be scum unvote: This feels just like my defense of my actions in ouran mafia vote: @yurkin Why no vote on D1? Yes you missed me. Am I already dead to you? Abu is being shady af. He didnt appear the whole day yesterday, he whiteknighted RE, then turns up on EoD and blaming others for their actions even though he was willing to lynch RE himself. It's as if he already knew she would flip town. It's odd that no one is suspecting him while he's out there accusing the whole train being scum. Abu-logic= scum? He led the vote train on RE, if you think that makes him scum then explain the intention behind that. |
Oct 19, 2017 7:02 AM
#718
Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Suzune-chan said: AbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. Dafuq? Can't believe youre even going there. #465 #474 What's all this then? Abu does have alot of contradictions ill admit, but overrall hes been very townlike so far don't you think? |
Oct 19, 2017 7:02 AM
#719
Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Labs said: Cool, RE, Gwendo and Shinuku-koon is where I wanted to hit and pull yesterday. Logic might've made this a really quick game and backs the fact I felt like a D2 claim would be a laugh. Ryuu still seems tpr more specifically killing or mafia leaned. I'm the other tpr and we have 2 Mafio, potential conversion and vote manipulation. I'll explain the rest when home, back to work for me Role fishing? -_- how is it role fishing if the player himself stated he was gonna give away the information |
Oct 19, 2017 7:05 AM
#720
3 things come to mind when i think of Ryu 1. Overrall hes picked up the game quite quickly and most of his actions scream town. 2.Hes scum and hes being coached by another player who has alot of experience because I think its bs that someones picking up this game so quickly. What do you think of the possibility of 2? 3.The post that laby quoted suggests the possibility of tpr, but even as a new player would you honestly hint your tpr if for a second you thought people would think you were harmful to town? |
Oct 19, 2017 7:09 AM
#721
Shinichi-Kun said: Not even a contradiction, I've already explained that shit.Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Suzune-chan said: I was against the Astros train too, then suggested Shinichi for the lynch but everyone preferred RE's lynch it's suspicious how everyone easily followed along especially Gwen, Labs and ShinichiAbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. Dafuq? Can't believe youre even going there. #465 #474 What's all this then? Abu does have alot of contradictions ill admit, but overrall hes been very townlike so far don't you think? btw @Shinichi-kun what do you think of Suzune, you two seem like you're getting along Shinichi + Suzune + Gwen scum team? |
Oct 19, 2017 7:14 AM
#722
I can see a Suzune/Ryuu team tbh |
Oct 19, 2017 7:18 AM
#723
You know what? Let's keep Shinichi and Labs for now, at least they're contributing to the game. Suzune, Ryuu and Gwen aren't even scum hunting at this point. Vote change: Suzune |
Oct 19, 2017 7:27 AM
#724
@Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Labs @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco reads lists, now, who's scum and who's town? |
Oct 19, 2017 8:08 AM
#725
AbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: without you that leaves labs, abu, suzune, new guyI didnt even have to vote, so why would I vote if it risked putting me in harms way? Am i missing anyone I like Abu for town here Also forgot Yurkin was in the gams as she's missing from the vote count. She could be scum unvote: This feels just like my defense of my actions in ouran mafia vote: @yurkin Why no vote on D1? Yes you missed me. Am I already dead to you? Abu is being shady af. He didnt appear the whole day yesterday, he whiteknighted RE, then turns up on EoD and blaming others for their actions even though he was willing to lynch RE himself. It's as if he already knew she would flip town. It's odd that no one is suspecting him while he's out there accusing the whole train being scum. Abu-logic= scum? 1. When and how did I whiteknight RE? 2. I was far from disappearing the whole phase, so your point is moot 3. How is it scummy to call out scummy actions? Don't you think I'll overlook your scummniess just because it was EoD. 4. Shinichi has already used that argument and I refuted it, if you actually read my posts, of course you wouldn't care enough to read though, scum 1What do you consider that post about RE then? 2. I agree with Abu here hes been extremely active i am proud of him. 3.Depends on alot of stuff like the person and the timing. 4.Also if you reply with the mindset that gwen is scum then your reads will be slightly biased. |
Oct 19, 2017 8:09 AM
#726
AbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: Highest possibility, how would you know he wasn't killed by either mafia or TPR?AbuHumaid said: Thank God scum killed Soda tbh, I was suspicious of him How would you know Soda was killed by scum? HE clearly wasn't because the flavor of astros death suggests he was the one killled by a night kill. |
Oct 19, 2017 8:11 AM
#727
AbuHumaid said: Shinichi-Kun said: Not even a contradiction, I've already explained that shit.Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Suzune-chan said: I was against the Astros train too, then suggested Shinichi for the lynch but everyone preferred RE's lynch it's suspicious how everyone easily followed along especially Gwen, Labs and ShinichiAbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. Dafuq? Can't believe youre even going there. #465 #474 What's all this then? Abu does have alot of contradictions ill admit, but overrall hes been very townlike so far don't you think? btw @Shinichi-kun what do you think of Suzune, you two seem like you're getting along Shinichi + Suzune + Gwen scum team? Can you stop putting me in every team you make it lol. I want suzune to explain her view on Laby some more, and I want others who havent explained their view to do so. With both laby and Logic claims, on top of the innocent child something bastard has to be going on here. All this information seems way to convinent. |
Oct 19, 2017 8:47 AM
#728
Labs said: Shinichi-Kun said: Labs said: AbuHumaid said: Sodalicious_ said: Nice, same as you, the fact he's innocent child doesn't mean much in a bastard gameAbuHumaid said: alright let's get to business, since this is a bastard game, do you think Qoco is mafia? Not gonna say Qoco is mafia, but i'm also not gonna believe they're town That's my view You? @Qoco get on here and prove you're town Probably the wrong kind of bastard game/hosts tbh. Unless your role suggests otherwise already.... On a side note, wearing headphones all the time starts to hurt :'< Well its a closed setup so anything is possible but to take roles and mechanics youve only seen coming from 1 game and 1 specific host just seems like a way to throw fire onto Qc Behavior wise espically how hes been acting since knowing he was innocent child has shown that as of right now hes town. There has been no signs of fluster or hesitation which those 2 would be huge signs to being mafia or know you're caught in a lie. Dont wear headphones for so long Aight I found the post. Soooo what was with separating this and bolding it? That was bread-crumbing for my claim D2 tbh. Since I believe I saw at-least one person mention persona? within the sign-ups maybe in relation to the major arcana. My role card is the Hermit Due to there being few choices from persona for this card that are main characters I went with an obvious choice and well, being from the most recent addition to the series. Bish wears dem big fuck off headphones. ^Futaba ^Hermit That can't be true, the abilities you said you had, don't fit the definition or characteristics of a hermit. Especially the ability to invite someone. |
Oct 19, 2017 8:52 AM
#729
Ryuuseino said: Labs said: Shinichi-Kun said: Labs said: AbuHumaid said: Sodalicious_ said: Nice, same as you, the fact he's innocent child doesn't mean much in a bastard gameAbuHumaid said: alright let's get to business, since this is a bastard game, do you think Qoco is mafia? Not gonna say Qoco is mafia, but i'm also not gonna believe they're town That's my view You? @Qoco get on here and prove you're town Probably the wrong kind of bastard game/hosts tbh. Unless your role suggests otherwise already.... On a side note, wearing headphones all the time starts to hurt :'< Well its a closed setup so anything is possible but to take roles and mechanics youve only seen coming from 1 game and 1 specific host just seems like a way to throw fire onto Qc Behavior wise espically how hes been acting since knowing he was innocent child has shown that as of right now hes town. There has been no signs of fluster or hesitation which those 2 would be huge signs to being mafia or know you're caught in a lie. Dont wear headphones for so long Aight I found the post. Soooo what was with separating this and bolding it? That was bread-crumbing for my claim D2 tbh. Since I believe I saw at-least one person mention persona? within the sign-ups maybe in relation to the major arcana. My role card is the Hermit Due to there being few choices from persona for this card that are main characters I went with an obvious choice and well, being from the most recent addition to the series. Bish wears dem big fuck off headphones. ^Futaba ^Hermit That can't be true, the abilities you said you had, don't fit the definition or characteristics of a hermit. Especially the ability to invite someone. I think I misunderstood what you meant. |
Oct 19, 2017 9:02 AM
#730
Labs said: Well this place is dead as usual when I'm around. I'll drop a vote for now and give the PC back to my bro and watch him play some Ronpies. Vote: Ryuu As I can kind of assume they're the biggest of the threats within the current pool, koz 2 kills a night, even if it's only on odd nights is a massive sway in mafias direction. Edit: Nvm... guna be watching some task master and idling here, probably around for another hour or so..... would prefer for actual interactions in this game, not just catch-up game. The assumption of me been tpr, I can understand, but to assume that I'm the biggest threat within the pool... I don't know what to say |
7720CountKillerOct 19, 2017 9:42 AM
Oct 19, 2017 9:06 AM
#731
Labs said: This might come off as a little obnoxious but I'd prefer to get info out as fast as possible so I can get to the easier of my win conditions before getting necked out of paranoia. And so, here come the pingaz and yes Imma include those I suspect regardless: @AbuHumaid @Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco Assuming you're all wise enough to read up, feel free to submit something along these lines so I can default my ability usage into public hands. Use primary ability this day phase: Y/N Use primary ability to: Protect assumed town/Kill myself on assumed Mafia Invite user: Preferred user. Cheers. If you were to use, I'd prefer Qoco, I've got zero impression on him, whether town or scum. Ofc, if you think you're in danger of dieing, don't do it. |
7720CountKillerOct 19, 2017 11:14 AM
Oct 19, 2017 9:19 AM
#732
yurkin said: Ryuuseino said: Atm I vote: re1031 Her previous posts looked most scumish to me, especially her adamant defense of her vote on suzume being RVS, along with the fact she didn't state so from the beginning. correcting typo Just saying but an earlier vote is likely to be rvs unless stated otherwise, and its p1 #18 in this case, i think there is no reason to see it as anything else beside rvs, ryuu. That sorta reasoning lines up with the reasons with which shinichi-kun and suzune-chan pushed re hmm. As stated before in post #636 i know that the reasons might be weak but the vote was the only reasonable one I had. correcting typo |
7720CountKillerOct 19, 2017 9:31 AM
Oct 19, 2017 9:36 AM
#733
The fact that both Soda and Astros died on the same night and were confirmed townie, doesn't that mean there are two mafia killers? Or was one killed by bastard game? |
Oct 19, 2017 9:39 AM
#734
Well read list. I have suzune as scum. Her reasons for pushing re were made up af. As with #216. And all the "not real rvs" which is purely speculation, more like scums pulling out of thin air reason to tunnel on someone. The funny thing is the post that defend astros. I think astros lynch was the prefered lynch so to have re as available lynch d2 but stuff happened. <- my thoughts only. I highly doubt all what suzune did d1 is possible to ever comes from town. XD shinichi-kun followed all that so hes suspect. I don't trust lamb much, well being tpr ok, but the rest meh. Logic have too little presence here... or i haven't noticed much of it~~ Abu is townish... or if you are scum are playing good game XD i count him as town as of now. Gwen, idk what to think about her. Have to reread her posts. Same with ryuu. Funny thing a claimed tpr is voting someone for being tpr potentially, is it just me or this is weird. edit:typo |
yurkinOct 19, 2017 9:43 AM
Oct 19, 2017 9:41 AM
#735
AbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: whatever you say won't hide the fact that you were jumping around and wasn't even scum reading the one you voted (Astros) then changed your vote to RE with such a weak reason after I called out the train on Astros that there was definitely scum there, and even Labs and Shinichi followed along. Making it seem like you were in a hurry won't work on meAbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Anyone wanna go after Shinichi with me? I'd go after RE with her last three suspicious posts Notice how Gwen didn't even consider Shinichi's lynch AbuHumaid said: logic340 said: I asked her why was it OK for her to lynch Astros, she said because she preferred to lynch an inactive over an active player not because she thinks he's scum and when she was willing to lynch RE with such a weak reason after I told everyone that we shouldn't lynch Astros I approved of her reasons easily waiting for her to call me out for it but she didn't, then when I confronted her Shinichi came and whiteknighted her. Shinichi is my top 1 suspectAbuHumaid said: can.you expand in hour you feel about all three? Gwen more than the other two.Suzune-chan said: I was against the Astros train too, then suggested Shinichi for the lynch but everyone preferred RE's lynch it's suspicious how everyone easily followed along especially Gwen, Labs and ShinichiAbuHumaid said: This is very true. I voiced my disapproval of the Astros train. Worked on my masters and came back and it was gone. I couldn't believe it.logic340 said: I called it before you even used your ability, that train was really werid, it formed really fast.Shinichi-Kun said: imagine my surprise?logic340 said: AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, Ryuuseino, Labs, Shinichi-kun, Gwendolly 4i believe that 4 of these 6 are scum this should be our lynch pool. Pretty much, i still question the fact of all the mafia being on the same train thats quite risky. -.- Left my vote for Astros because I wanted to go to bed and he had the most votes at that time. Yes, I said RE was suspicious after her entrance of not wanting to join but telling Astros to defend himself. Sorry not sorry. I dont regret my vote. By that reasoning aren't I the same than? excluding the calling out. |
Oct 19, 2017 9:50 AM
#737
Oct 19, 2017 10:29 AM
#738
Oct 19, 2017 11:02 AM
#739
Shinichi-Kun said: 3 things come to mind when i think of Ryu 1. Overrall hes picked up the game quite quickly and most of his actions scream town. 2.Hes scum and hes being coached by another player who has alot of experience because I think its bs that someones picking up this game so quickly. What do you think of the possibility of 2? 3.The post that laby quoted suggests the possibility of tpr, but even as a new player would you honestly hint your tpr if for a second you thought people would think you were harmful to town? I give up on trying to convince anyone that this is my first game, I'm always been doubted. As for the 2nd theory, I'm just going to throw this out there, no I haven't had any coaching, I learned most of the logic from spectating the host game. |
Oct 19, 2017 11:03 AM
#740
AbuHumaid said: I can see a Suzune/Ryuu team tbh Why? |
Oct 19, 2017 11:11 AM
#741
Shinichi-Kun said: AbuHumaid said: Gwendolly said: AbuHumaid said: Thank God scum killed Soda tbh, I was suspicious of him How would you know Soda was killed by scum? HE clearly wasn't because the flavor of astros death suggests he was the one killled by a night kill. What if one of the roles had the ability to kill supernaturally? that would effect the phrasing. I'm thinking Magician or Death, though Magician sounds townish. |
Oct 19, 2017 11:33 AM
#742
yurkin said: Ryuuseino may you explain a little bit more what you mean to say in #735 pls? I first voted Gwen as RVS, than Suzume as OMGUS, than unvoted once she dropped the vote, than voted you which you already know, than unvoted again to brainstorm for real vote, than finally settled on RE, the reasons are in post #475, by abu's logic I'm in the same boat as Gwen |
Oct 19, 2017 11:35 AM
#743
AbuHumaid said: @Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Labs @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco reads lists, now, who's scum and who's town? I could see you as scum tbh. I see you assuming the role of a leader. A Godfather trying to lead Town could be bad nudes. |
Oct 19, 2017 11:40 AM
#744
yurkin said: Well read list. I have suzune as scum. Her reasons for pushing re were made up af. As with #216. And all the "not real rvs" which is purely speculation, more like scums pulling out of thin air reason to tunnel on someone. The funny thing is the post that defend astros. I think astros lynch was the prefered lynch so to have re as available lynch d2 but stuff happened. <- my thoughts only. I highly doubt all what suzune did d1 is possible to ever comes from town. I have gut feelings with Suzune. More than half of the time they're right. Something about how she words things trips me up. |
Oct 19, 2017 11:41 AM
#745
How is that you always seem to make your votes so scummy lol |
Oct 19, 2017 11:46 AM
#747
yurkin said: Abu is townish... or if you are scum are playing good game XD i count him as town as of now. He seems quite aggressive to me. |
Oct 19, 2017 11:49 AM
#748
Qoco said: yurkin said: Abu is townish... or if you are scum are playing good game XD i count him as town as of now. He seems quite aggressive to me. And often he is too bossy and that annoys me a lot. So what if he is aggressive? |
Oct 19, 2017 11:54 AM
#749
yurkin said: Qoco said: yurkin said: Abu is townish... or if you are scum are playing good game XD i count him as town as of now. He seems quite aggressive to me. And often he is too bossy and that annoys me a lot. So what if he is aggressive? Qoco said: AbuHumaid said: @Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Labs @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco reads lists, now, who's scum and who's town? I could see you as scum tbh. I see you assuming the role of a leader. A Godfather trying to lead Town could be bad nudes. |
Oct 19, 2017 12:23 PM
#750
AbuHumaid said: @Shinichi-kun @yurkin @Labs @Gwendolly @logic340 @Ryuuseino @Suzune-chan @Qoco reads lists, now, who's scum and who's town? Shinichi: scumlean. Yurkin's read convinced me of this, and shin's interactions with you does feel scumish, but it's too early to throw down the hammer. Suzume: scumlean. Yurkin's read, but she hasn't gotten deeply involved in discussion (besides RE, so can't get any feels. Labs: tpr. I believe he's claim. Abu: townlean. Feel like you're sincerely scum hunting, but will withhold reservations in case its a trick. Yurkin: not sure. She hasn't participated much. Qoco: not sure. Same reason as yurkin. Logic: townlean. For his ability, if he was scum he wouldn't have it. On the other hand if he was scum, he would know how many mafia there is, and would have been lying about having that ability, along with how many mafia there were on the train. I think I just worked myself up into a case of WIFOM LOL As I'm sure you will notice, I'm mostly relying on feels, not really trusting logic to reliably determine who's who, more for reasoning why someone's not. |
7720CountKillerOct 19, 2017 12:29 PM
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2866 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:07 AM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8750 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1159 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3810 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 19, 2023 2:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] Truth or dare (ToD) 2.0 [Round 5] ( 1 2 )Lambtron - Mar 12, 2019 |
92 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 18, 2023 12:09 PM |