The Irregular at Magic High School (light novel)
VaroOP said: -Mahesvara said: The engagement is more of a plot device if anything and its been intoduced way to early in the story for it to be an actual endgame senario. If they do end up together, I'll bet it won't be from Maya's plan. Anyways, before any of this can happen, Tatsuya needs the ability to be able to fall in love, which is something he still lacks. I am now used to being pessimistic about my own OTP. That way you don't feel much disappointed when the story doesn't turn out the way you wanted it to. Still, knowing that Kouichi wants Mayumi to marry Tatsuya is definitely interesting considering the past Kouichi and Maya have. Gotta binge read ! xD Well Kouichi wants Mayumi and Tatsuya to get together, because he wants to weaken the Yotsuba with either bringing Tatsuya to his side or giving Mayumi to the yotsuba, which will give him some influence within the clan. So unfortunately Mayumi's feeling for Tatsuya are being taken advantage of like how Miyuki's feelings are by Maya. |
My Queens  |
| I spit on the floor each time Miyuki says "Onii-sama" . |
 |
True_Ancestor said: I spit on the floor each time Miyuki says "Onii-sama" . I guess your house is flooded with your spit then. xD |
VaroOP said: True_Ancestor said: I spit on the floor each time Miyuki says "Onii-sama" . I guess your house is flooded with your spit then. xD I had to call the plumber when I finished it . |
|
| @Mahesvara I read Miyuki's monologue in volume 11 which said that she doesn't want any other male to touch her other than Tatsuya. I have a very nasty side to myself so now I am all for someone coming and forcefully marrying Miyuki. It could be Ichijou or some drunk fool on the street. I just wanna see Miyuki get "touched" by someone who ain't Tatsuya. Please O holy author, go down the NTR route!!! ( This is the first time that I actually want a story to go in the NTR direction.) |
Not every ship, Mayumi has her moment with Tatsuya in vol 18, but i would say every girl except Mayumi doesn't stand a chance now. But isn't it obvious to readers that Mahouka shipping is only the game between Mayumi and Miyuki since the beginning? Satou Tsutomu, author of this novel, also specifically mentioned that both Mayumi and Miyuki will have a happy ending, he did not even care to say anything about the any other girl (poor girls XD). |
sidomeApr 12, 2016 8:01 AM
sidome said: Not every ship, Mayumi has her moment with Tatsuya in vol 18, but i would say every girl except Mayumi doesn't stand a chance now. But isn't it obvious to readers that Mahouka shipping is only the game between Mayumi and Miyuki since the beginning? Satou Tsutomu, author of this novel, also specifically mentioned that both Mayumi and Miyuki will have a happy ending, he did not even care to say anything about the any other girl (poor girls XD). Honoka seems to always be in the equation though and she's not giving up, so its really those three. Everyone else has either thrown in the white flag(Erika), its impossible for them(Lina being stuck in the USNA), or haven't even tried anything(Ayako). I always thought there could be a chance that he could end up with two of them at least, one be his wife and the other a mistress or maybe even two mistresses. Having a mistress or two is not all that rare in magic families in mahouka, as there have been multiple mentions of it with Erika's father, the shiba siblings father, and even Maya offered it to the one candidate for the head because he wanted to marry his guardian. If excepted by all parties, it could work out and give the characters the happy ending that Satou foretold. |
My Queens |
| Though isn't the biggest hurdle in shipping Tatsuya with anyone his sister Miyuki, so would it be possible to see the writer make it where the will actually end up Miyuki being shipped with Masaki? I know that it seems like Miyuki has some sort of different feelings towards Masaki then what she does with most other males, I think this happening first in more likely then Tatsuya shipping with anyone else My opinion |
| Why not all? This is not a joke. With the power of our lord Tatsuya, he can make any harem possible. |
 |
HandsomeMan said: I honestly hope it would be Tatsuya x Miyuki or no one at all for him, e.g. dies at the end of the series or something. Why? Because this is a fictional universe and there's no reason why we shouldn't have a bit of bro x sis taboo. All the shipping is ridiculous in the first place considering that anime/manga is not real. But anyway the siblings have just way too big of a bond to have it shatter by other parties. Since it's fantasy let me fantasize more like this lol. Or they don't need to end up with anyone and just stay together without getting intimate lol. Exactly what I think! *Highfive!* hohohoho Tatsuya x Miyuki forever! |
-Mahesvara said: VaroOP said: The engagement is more of a plot device if anything and its been intoduced way to early in the story for it to be an actual endgame senario. If they do end up together, I'll bet it won't be from Maya's plan.Looking good but with Maya and Miyuki both going for Tatsuya X Miyuki, I don't think Mayumi stands a chance anymore. I hate feeling disappointed and that is why I will read the rest believing that Tatsuya X Mayumi will never happen. Anyways, before any of this can happen, Tatsuya needs the ability to be able to fall in love, which is something he still lacks. I may be rezzing an older quote, but in regards to Tatsuya's ability to experience feelings for females other than his sister, there are examples of unrecognized feelings back as far as Vol 3. Vol 3 P150: At this moment, Tatsuya thought her smile was a radiant as the sun. This must have been a hallucination... (upon observing Mayumi's natural smile) This example is not a purely physical reaction on Tatsuya's part, as the author has, on occasion, highlighted the fact that Tatsuya is able to separate himeslf from physical arousal in order to disarm it. Given that he has no familiarity with what emotional attraction might actually feel like, this may be an example of his experiencing feelings for Mayumi, but brushing them off as a heat induced hallucination due to his inability to identify the feeling for what it is. |
Sparteh said: VaroOP said: Woah! Tatsuya and Miyuki engaged ? What became of Mayumi ? Tatsuya actually agreed to marry Miyuki in the future ? xO XO . Personally I believe that romance in the story was once very well described as "shipper's tragedy" Therefore, me personally this endless intrigue on a possible incest, starts a little annoying. |
RobertBobertNov 23, 2016 6:12 AM
 |
Urgalicious said: ... please, what's the status on this ship, has it sunk? ;-; It depends on whether the author will support "desire" of fans to the end, or continue to speculate on his incest moe. Although, of course, the situation in Mahouka is not so hot how in ReZero, where the "main" heroine is so boring that Miyuki compared with her just divinely prescribed character. |
RobertBobertNov 23, 2016 6:38 AM
|
| tatsuya x mayumi ? hell no!! that did be the most forced and disappointing ending ever.. |
xavion296 said: tatsuya x mayumi ? hell no!! that did be the most forced and disappointing ending ever.. The most forced? Lol, Maya and Miyuki laugh at you after the 16th volume. |
|
RobertBobert said: laugh? at what exactly?The most forced? Lol, Maya and Miyuki laugh at you after the 16th volume. |
xavion296 said: RobertBobert said: laugh? at what exactly?The most forced? Lol, Maya and Miyuki laugh at you after the 16th volume. His engagement with Miyuki is the most artificial attempt to bring together the official couple that I've seen lately, lol |
|
RobertBobert said: His engagement with Miyuki is the most artificial attempt to bring together the official couple that I've seen lately, lol Artificial but still a fact. And how exactly was that supposed invalidate what i wrote ? |
xavion296 said: RobertBobert said: His engagement with Miyuki is the most artificial attempt to bring together the official couple that I've seen lately, lol Artificial but still a fact. And how exactly was that supposed invalidate what i wrote ? You are contradicting yourself. First, you complain that the pair Tatsuya x Mayumi would be artificial, but after that, you write that you are not experiencing problems with artificial Tatsuya x Miyuki. This is hypocrisy. As for the rest, I do not see any reason to believe Tatsuya x Mayumi artificial. Do you have any arguments to support your point of view? |
RobertBobertFeb 15, 2017 7:37 AM
|
RobertBobert said: You are contradicting yourself. First, you complain that the pair Tatsuya x Mayumi would be artificial, but after that, you write that you are not experiencing problems with artificial Tatsuya x Miyuki. This is hypocrisy. As for the rest, I do not see any reason to believe Tatsuya x Mayumi artificial. Do you have any arguments to support your point of view? All I'm saying is an ending with Tatsuya and Mayumi ending up together will come out as forced 'cause we haven't seen any major romantic development between the two over the course of 21 volumes of ln unlike Tatsuya and Miyuki. If in case the incest is out of question I would rather support Honoka who has even gone as far as confessing to Tatsuya multiple times. |
xavion296Feb 15, 2017 8:42 AM
xavion296 said: RobertBobert said: You are contradicting yourself. First, you complain that the pair Tatsuya x Mayumi would be artificial, but after that, you write that you are not experiencing problems with artificial Tatsuya x Miyuki. This is hypocrisy. As for the rest, I do not see any reason to believe Tatsuya x Mayumi artificial. Do you have any arguments to support your point of view? All i'm saying is an ending with Tatsuya and Mayumi ending up together will come out as forced 'cause we haven't seen any major romantic development between the two over the course of 21 volumes of ln unlike Tatsuya and Miyuki. If in case the incest is out of question i would rather support Honoka who has even gone as far as confessing to Tatsuya multiple times. Lol, Tatsuya x Miyuki no less forced, because he does not love her as a woman, while most of "development of their romantic relationship" is the result of the addition of an artificial romantic subtext in any scene with their participation. Of course, Tatsuya x Miyuki is the most obvious result of the series, but at the moment Tatsuya does not have a romantic relationship with any of the girls. The rest is only a self-deception of people who look at everything through the Shipping Goggles. |
RobertBobertFeb 15, 2017 8:54 AM
|
| @RobertBobert and what the hell do you mean by artificial anyway? They are human not some freakin' robot! (previously when i wrote 'artificial' i meant the genetic modification, not Miyuki's feelings for her brother) |
xavion296Feb 15, 2017 9:28 AM
xavion296 said: @RobertBobert and what the hell do you mean by artificial anyways? They are human not some freakin' robot! (previously when i wrote 'artificial' i meant the genetic modification, not Miyuki's feelings for her brother) Well, sorry, English is not my native language, it is sometimes difficult to find the right synonym, lol In general, if not for Miyuki currently in Mahouka there would be no romance at all. As a result, if Miyuki was not deeply in love with Tatsuya and could respond to the feelings of the other guy, this pairing would have already died. |
|
| i have long forgotten about this series, but suddenly i have an urge to get updates and become so upset to know that tatsuya and miyuki got engaged, i really hope tatsuya ended up with mayumi or lina :( |
| If you just did nothing because you thought it wouldn't help, then you'd end up doing less than nothing; for nothing would change and nothing would end. (Kira Yamato - Gundam Seed Phase 34: Seen & Unseen) |
NovaMagic said: Wait so does tatsuya end up with his sister??? I was reading the wiki and saw "Fiancée" I've seen the anime and read some of the manga(translations are so slow) If they end up together then I'm done with the series.... Right now I wouldn't call it set in stone, since we have to take Tatsuya's own feelings into consideration and the fact that the whole engagement thing was set-up at the series half-way point, makes it less likely to be an actual endgame plot point. For Tatsuya, to be able to have a proper romantic relationship with anyone, he somehow must regain the emotion/urge to fall in love with someone, which is currently impossible at this point, but there was a point where it was mentioned that a parasites psyche could help lead to the origin of emotions , so the possibility could exist somewhere down the road. Part of me still hopes Mayumi or Lina will pull it out at the end, but alas its only hope at this point, since the odds are heavily in Miyuki's favor. At the end of the day, I'll be satisfied with who ever Tatsuya chooses as long he has the emotional capacity to truly choose for himself. |
My Queens |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei Volume 32 DiscussionSyureria - Oct 12, 2020 |
19 |
by StarZone1
»»
Aug 2, 2023 9:52 AM |
|
Poll: » Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei Volume 24 DiscussionZaphkiel_El_Rem - Sep 21, 2018 |
2 |
by StarZone1
»»
Jul 22, 2023 10:22 PM |
|
» English translationsdadroo - Jan 26, 2023 |
2 |
by dadroo
»»
Jan 26, 2023 2:36 AM |
|
» [spoiler] Shiba Tatsuya & MiyukiSyureria - Aug 25, 2020 |
16 |
by zensh
»»
Jul 11, 2022 10:52 AM |
|
» Mahouka Koukou no Retoussei Volume 16 Discussion/Spoilers *major spoilers*Lolcats1997 - Jul 13, 2015 |
17 |
by zensh
»»
Jul 11, 2022 10:50 AM |