bunny_lover said: intense drama grounded on unclear story-telling, as a result the whole thing falls apart (ie. it might be a great visual novel but this anime is terrible). It's not really that terrible and it's not the worst made by KyoAni. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Air is literally the first and only anime to break my heart. I can't say that it's my favorite anime or that it's not, because for me it's a totally different matter from anything else I've watched. But it's definitely the first(and only up to now) anime that made me care so much. That said, I can see why people love it. |
  |
| I love Air mostly for it's atmosphere and Yukito(he's got so much swag). Eh, I guess I can see why ppl may not like this anime. |
| Because it's a beautiful anime :) |
| I really, really enjoyed this anime. I'd go so far to say that I even loved it. The ending was confusing, not to mention some parts in the middle, and I think that that is what let it down for quite a lot of viewers. However, after looking more into it (reading up on some things, rewatching, etc.) I can finally say that I understand it perfectly. The only things that I felt were left to be desired was some clarification of what kind of relationship Kanna and Ryuuya had, as well as Misuzu and Yukito. I kind of understood that Kanna did love Yukito, but I'm unsure of his feelings for her (they seemed more obligatory) and it's kind of eating at me. Some better clarification of what was going on with all the curse and reincarnation business would have been brilliant. As I said, I did have to do a bit of researching after watching to finally understand it. Once I understood it I was able to accept and digest the whole plot, but again, I think it would have just been nicer to have it more obvious in the story. All in all, though, I really liked this anime. It was emotional, it was deep, it was simply lovely. First time anything has really tugged at my emotions like this. |
TrylleOct 19, 2014 12:56 AM
Meddigo said: Why do I love Air? Well, it was my first foray into the beautiful and stunning art done by Kyoto Animation. Even though it was made 4 years ago, nearly all of the currently airing series don't come even close to the detail on the backgrounds or the fluidity of the animation. Secondly, the music. "Tori no Uta" and "Farewell Song" (both sung by Lia) are superb opening and ending themes respectively, and each helps foster the right mood for opening an episode or ending one. The background music, particularly "Summer Lights", "Bug Walk", "If Dreams Come True" (also the vocal version of this at the end of the Air Movie is amazing), etc. Air TV has a first-rate soundtrack. Thirdly the story. Air TV doesn't lead its viewers by the hand so that they can follow everything that's happening and why it happens. I think that's why most people don't like Air. It's either that they simply don't understand what's going on or they just hate the character design. I'm currently rewatching the series (I'm at the end of the Summer Arc right now), and this time during the first arc ("Dreams"), I was able to pick up on so many more links to the story. Everything fits together nicely. Also, people say that the ending is sad, but I don't find it to be so. Air is my favorite Key anime adaptation. It has a much stronger story than Kanon in my opinion (which just features the girls and their past when Yuuichi lived there so many years ago), and while I loved Clannad (though moreso I loved After Story), the ending of After Story didn't quite sit right with me. So Air is tops for me. You're Just like me |
| most memorable. *waves* |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
When people hate on Air |
| I wanted to like Air, and being a Key anime I really thought I would, but I just didn't like it that much. It might be primarily because I had no emotional investment in any of the characters at all because their arcs were so rushed, but it's probably also down to how ugly it looks (yes, I get it was made in 2005, but my point still stands) and due to the whole crow thing. I mean, I get why he turned into a crow, but it just felt so stupid that it made it extremely hard to take things seriously afterwards. Even more so when turning into a crow led to a major recap of the events of the series. Although, what I think really killed this series for me was the fact that everything that happened felt like it was totally pointless in the grand scheme of things. After all, from what I remember, the whole point was to end the curse so that Misuzu would no longer have to suffer and to ensure that no one in the future suffered. Instead, Misuzu died without the curse ever being broken, so it would inevitably be passed on to someone else and the whole cycle would start again. When I realised that, it annoyed me so much because it meant that everything that happened was essentially pointless and that everything would just happen again but with different people. Perhaps that was meant to be the point. Either way, I didn't like that at all. Overall, it's certainly not the worst anime I've ever seen but it isn't as good as some people make it out to be (IMO) and it certainly doesn't hold a candle to the other Key anime adaptations (even Little Busters, despite so many people being butthurt about it as an adaptation when it really wasn't so bad). |
AtavisticJun 13, 2015 1:02 PM
| I didn't care much for it. There are better anime to watch than this mediocre torture. I can see there was a lot of potential underneath Misuzu and Yukito's characters but they weren't fully executed. But it's not the worst anime I've ever seen, his downright annoying after the first three episodes. I think that's why the series ended at 13 episodes because maybe people were unsatisfied with it. Too bad the MC died... Oh, well. I'm not that into her anyway.... |
| Numbuh 3, you've got to get off the couch, you cannot sit in that tree house, girl you like Rainbow Monkeys so grab your little shit and then swing! Hand tracks be tracking me to different doorways. In a maze, and I don't know what to do. Guaranteed though, Ima find the emeralds. |
| Because people have to breath. Air (anime) is much more complex than it seems to be. |
| AIR was the second anime I've ever watched in my entire life. I didn't know ANYTHING about it, when I started. But from the op on, when I saw Misuzu in the sunflower field and the wind caressing her hair, I was hooked. It all looked so beautiful and the music was incredibly emotional! And the when the tragedy unfolded I was moved so deep inside, I didn't even know my heart had such depths. I undoubtedly fell for Misuzu. And even after watching dozens of shows telling sad stories, I still think AIR tells the most tragic one. When thinking about Kanna's fate, not being able to go to the festival, because people were searching for her, not being allowed to even touch her very mother, not succeeding with her juggling in front of her dying mother, not being able to see the ocean, she always wanted to go to, dying on her very first flight, dreaming of the death of Ryuuya, the man she was in love with... being reborn again and again and again, destined to live alone and die an early death, and her dreams ever unfulfilled, and after 1000 years, 1000 summers, Misuzu still dreams of that one festival, from a time in which the now dead and empty sky was still inhabited by the winged ones - thinking about all that still makes me cry, even months after watching it. The show is filled to the brim with yearning for dreams that seem so close, and are yet unreachable. But somehow, Misuzu withstands all the sorrow (for the longest time) and tries to find happiness in the smallest of the small things, and the setting is so idyllic and especially the ending conveys so much hope... It's like my heart was torn apart by the conflicting emotions. It's very hard to put into words what I feel, it's so abstract, like a dream. Maybe that's also due the fact that I watched it all in one go and then had a restless night. In any case, the impact of that show was big enough to instill in me the desire to visit the place it's based on in the real world. It also made me learn Japanese, just so that I can watch the show again in the original language. AIR is a very special show and it's understandable that it doesn't appeal to everyone (it's clearly made for emotional people who can understand complicated plots). I'm not even mad if you tell me it's the worst show ever - I just pity you for not being as enruptured as I am. Because in all honesty... these overwhelming feelings are what life was made for. |
InshadiuSApr 10, 2016 12:29 PM
danieltortoisee said: Instead, Misuzu died without the curse ever being broken, so it would inevitably be passed on to someone else and the whole cycle would start again. Nah, you misunderstood that! The curse was, in fact, broken. However, Kanna's/Misuzu's soul is still too great for a human being, causing the body to die after ~16 years, and that will continue forever. But there won't be any more sad dreams, there won't be any more solitude, and there won't be any more pain! PS: How in the world does this or this look ugly to you?! Like even the people who dislike the plot usually admit that the art is nice at least. Sure, everyone's taste is different, but you gotta admit, the lighting, the coloring and the animations are top notch and create a unique atmosphere in each individual scene. |
InshadiuS said: PS: How in the world does this or this look ugly to you?! Like even the people who dislike the plot usually admit that the art is nice at least. Sure, everyone's taste is different, but you gotta admit, the lighting, the coloring and the animations are top notch and create a unique atmosphere in each individual scene. With regards to that, that's just two moments out of hundreds within the show. I'm sure if I could be bothered I could find two moments in which the art was ugly. Also, to me at least and as someone who likes the art style of Key works, Air was the worst suspect in terms of "overly large eyes". To be fair though, the art can only be called ugly by current standards; when it came out, the art would have seemed much more impressive I'm sure, especially as this is a Kyoani work. As for the curse being broken, if the body dies after ~16 years I'd still say the curse isn't really broken. Sure, the sad dreams and solitude aren't there, but there will still be sadness when the body dies after 16 or so years (unless I'm misunderstanding you on this). |
| lol air is a very complex mastetpace in my opinion it is the most underrated anime on mal the amout of great symbolysme is great the characters are great the feelings are great the ost are great and I olive the art to be honest everything is great in that anime it was a little bit rushed tho |
AkerakaaaaiAug 8, 2017 12:17 PM
 |
kikyo1hinamora said: lol air is a very complex mastetpace in my opinion it is the most underrated anime on mal the amout of great symbolysme is great the characters are great the feelings are great the ost are great and I olive the art to be honest everything is great in that anime it was a little bit rushed tho I agree! It's already a decade since I saw the show and until now I can still feel the emotion. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| The visual novel was a masterpiece. So a lot of fans carried over. Furthermore, without air I would find it hard to breathe. |
| Air, my most favorite key anime of all time. I really like this show. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Air Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Animatronix - Mar 27, 2008 |
197 |
by EmmyMoomin
»»
Jan 11, 8:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Air Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )hznu - Aug 20, 2008 |
62 |
by EmmyMoomin
»»
Jan 11, 7:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Air Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Piroko - Nov 12, 2007 |
100 |
by KingYoshi
»»
Oct 12, 2023 12:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Air Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Genix - Oct 16, 2008 |
58 |
by Xenocrisi
»»
Oct 5, 2023 6:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Air Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Yukia-Kontan - May 30, 2008 |
74 |
by Xenocrisi
»»
Oct 4, 2023 12:30 PM |