Well it seems there's some unsatisfied mopers in this forum. Whatever the case, I found the overall literary aspect of this arc to be sound. The falling action was a bit fast-paced, though. In the end, Jill never got a happy ending... her life will continue on the same way as it's always been. The difference is that she acknowledges her life to be a "battlefield" now, and has taken a vow to fight against it. I.e. "crying and biting her way through," as she says. Hopefully this means from now on she won't take BS from here dad.
Still, the last few panels of her smiling were very brief. Just before she was shown talking about the vivid sky or whatever, she really was hopeless. When she was begging Guts to take her with him, and after everything that's happened to her, Guts demonstrated the kinda demons that lurk around him.
If anything, after everything, Jill should be traumatized. I mean major PTSD. Nothing good happens in that chick's life. How is she not on the verge of suicide? Where does she get her will to live? How does she know things will change for her? She's going back to her village in which she'll continue to face cold, hunger, probably war, neglect, abuse, perhaps molestation? Her best friend is dead and she witnessed unspeakable violence several times throughout the arc. Geez, I reinstate, this is by no means a happy ending for Jill.
I kinda liked Jill as a character, though. (And disagree with the comment above mine.) She was the first female character in a long, long time that wasn't just a vessel for sexual abuse. She was barely the victim of lust or sexualized acts and she wasn't just a 'princess' or a 'slave' or anything... she was an actual adolescent girl that tagged alongside Guts (for a little bit), and was shown to persevere even when faced against literal demons/monsters. She shrieked a lot, but that's just what young women tend to do... if anything, she shrieked and pansied FAR far less than the usual damsel in this manga. The droopy, unsure expression she constantly wore was also appealing -- there was something very mature about it. I don't know why but she was just a good (female) character.
The arc itself I wasn't TOO crazy about. I'm not even sure how much the overarching plot progressed. This seemed like one big side story -- just another adventure Guts and Puck got themselves into -- and aside from those eloquent knights it doesn't seem like much of this was for the sake of the longrun. Not only that but I wasn't to into the whole "fairy/elf/mystical forest" aspect... although I appreciate a solid change in pace, in that the enemy was drastically different from the usual: bug-themed AND female. This was a good arc; just not one that I personally found interesting.
Last but not least, even though Griffith is a dick, I understand every single thing he did throughout the end of this arc. His coldness towards Jill was justified, especially after the beating he just took. And I, myself, kinda hoped he'd slay Rosine. After the atrocities she committed, she definitely didn't deserve to die on her own accord. And I love Jill, but I wouldn't have blamed Guts if he sliced through Jill when she tried to barricade Rosine from his sword. Like I said, Guts took quite a beating and he needed to wrap things up. Jill shouldn't have been as dumb so as to compromise the retribution Guts was about to deal.
Final note: Puck. He's aight. I don't think comedic relief is necessary but it's always a fresh change of pace to go from a gritty battle to a simple, pudgy, goofy Puck bit. |