| Overrated NGE : Nothing to say I felt it was really boring with a lot of meh moments I don't get why a lot of people say it's a mind fuck because it barely shocked me. Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. RAINBOW: Oh man this anime really disappointed me I was so happy while watching it thinking I am gonna have a new favorite anime but nope it drastically went down hill after ep 11, the main character suddenly became an illogical idiot and then the second part of the anime happened where there is no plot and the main villain of the first part get handled pretty easily and then they move to character arcs where basically every character in their own respective arc have a dream or something they want to accomplish but in the end of the arc the fail to do it but the rest of the friends help that said character to move on or to deal with it and then repeat that formula in every single arc [ Problem happens > Problem get solved > repeat] so much wasted potential. Black Lagoon : This show is basically a non intentional parody of US actions movies we got Revy who is the cliche hot and powerful female character who is badass with a gun and shoots in sexy poses and have tattoos and short jeans with a sad background story, then the calm black guy with black glasses and oh did I mention that he is badass with a gun?! and then the nerdy looking Jewish guy who is peaceful and only handles computer related stuff. It follows the same action logic US action movies has, the bad guys shoot a million bullets but they never hit them or scratch but the good guys only win with two guns. There is not much of plot to speak off nor any noticeable character development maybe Rock but it only happened in a couple of episodes then he stuck to being a static character for the rest of the series. Eureka 7 : Where to even start, I hated all the character and the ones I liked got killed by the biggest dick in the anime, I am huge fan of romance but Renton and Eureka relationship is really disappointing, Renton basically is the typical wimpy guy who fell in love with Eureka in first sight and Eureka just kinda doesn't care for him that much until he leaves and she suddenly start developing feelings for him. I can go on and on about why I hate the characters but meh I don't really want to remember and the ending was so cheesy. Ughh Give me back all that time D: Underrated Bakemonogatari :D |
 |
tsudecimo said: Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. |
jal90May 27, 2013 2:00 PM
| Jyu-Oh-Sei is underrated |
yhunata said: I don't like you yhunata. And yes 17 episodes out of 175 is way to less to rate a anime let stand judge about it being crap. Hitman reborn had that 23 episodes of crap going on for example and i heard that LOTGH needs time to get fun, so yes. You don't see me hating on Naruto right? And i admit Fair tail is very cliche and stole a lot of things from other shonen but the most important part is that it is enjoyable. And is certainly more epic in 175 episodes than Naruto i bet.johnyjohny said: natssuu said: Don't judge a anime you dropped man.Fairy Tail and Angel Beats! Both have the same rating 8.59 which is ridiculously too high By that logic, would it mean that a person who dropped an anime on it's last episode should also not have the right to judge it? I didn't watch it to the last episode, but I know enough to say that Fairy Tail is overrated. Ow and tsudecimo tsudecimo said: Overrated NGE : Nothing to say I felt it was really boring with a lot of meh moments I don't get why a lot of people say it's a mind fuck because it barely shocked me. Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. My reaction to almost all your dislikes |
johnyjohnyMay 27, 2013 1:59 PM
 .. |
jal90 said: tsudecimo said: Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. |
|
SlothNamakemono said: Not going to lie, my mind has just been ninja'd.Venuduck said: Overrated: everything you like Underrated: everything I like Makes sense. But what if something I like happens to be something you like, this a problem for a greater mind than mine. |
Please learn about cel animation and its technical process. Learn how special effects and backlighting were done without computers. |
tsudecimo said: jal90 said: tsudecimo said: Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. |
johnyjohny said: natssuu said: Don't judge a anime you dropped man.Fairy Tail and Angel Beats! Both have the same rating 8.59 which is ridiculously too high Yes I do, 17 episodes and the show was already filled with fillers, Natsu's power ups were just ridiculous and heroine was only good for fanservice. I decided to read the manga and got bored immediately. |
johnyjohny said: Ow and tsudecimo tsudecimo said: Overrated NGE : Nothing to say I felt it was really boring with a lot of meh moments I don't get why a lot of people say it's a mind fuck because it barely shocked me. Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. My reaction to almost all your dislikes It's okay I know it's hard for you to use words and have an actual discussion, well at the very least don't use overused gifs.. @jal90: I think I would have liked it if I read the novel because from what I read here I think the light novel is much better than the manga and the anime. |
|
tsudecimo said: johnyjohny said: Ow and tsudecimo tsudecimo said: Overrated NGE : Nothing to say I felt it was really boring with a lot of meh moments I don't get why a lot of people say it's a mind fuck because it barely shocked me. Welcome to the NHK : I didn't really get the point of the story the character development was really iffy and I just hated that despicable senpai character. This post sums up my disappointment in this show. My reaction to almost all your dislikes It's okay I know it's hard for you to use words and have an actual discussion, well at the very least don't use overused gifs.. @jal90: I think I would have liked it if I read the novel because from what I read here I think the light novel is much better than the manga and the anime. Anime follows the novel, manga went off the rails |
daniyan said: No need to defend that which you enjoy, friend. tsudecimo said: daniyan said: Agreed with Angel Beats!, i don't like it much, and fortunately isn't a Kyo Ani produced anime, if it was, maybe can would have even best rating, this anime deserves an 8 but no more than 8.3. Kyoani fag in a nutshell. Hey, at least i didn't watched K-on! and can still not watching this anime yet. But i have to accept your offense in a good manner and consider it as constructive criticism. If he really thinks you're a KyoAni fag just for wishing that they had produced a certain show, then that's a bit presumptuous and unfortunate on his part. And by the way, there's absolutely nothing wrong with watching, liking, and enjoying K-On! In fact, you should go watch it now. Seriously. Go. Now. Sincerely, A KyoAni Fag |
 |
johnyjohny said: yhunata said: I don't like you yhunata. And yes 17 episodes out of 175 is way to less to rate a anime let stand judge about it being crap. Hitman reborn had that 23 episodes of crap going on for example and i heard that LOTGH needs time to get fun, so yes. You don't see me hating on Naruto right? And i admit Fair tail is very cliche and stole a lot of things from other shonen but the most important part is that it is enjoyable. And is certainly more epic in 175 episodes than Naruto i bet.johnyjohny said: natssuu said: Don't judge a anime you dropped man.Fairy Tail and Angel Beats! Both have the same rating 8.59 which is ridiculously too high By that logic, would it mean that a person who dropped an anime on it's last episode should also not have the right to judge it? I didn't watch it to the last episode, but I know enough to say that Fairy Tail is overrated. I wasn't talking about natssuu. I was asking a rhetorical question. Fairy Tail was great until the Oracion Seis arc. After that, the villains just got plain horrible. And so did Natsu's power-ups. In fact, Natsu's power-ups were plain ridiculous. And the happenings. As for Naruto, the original Naruto was great (obviously, there were no fucking fillers until they reached episode 130). Up until then, the enemies were great, the fights were great and the development was great. Then came Shippuden which fucked the whole thing up with it's fillers (post pain-arc fillers, that is). |
 |
AndyRayy said: daniyan said: No need to defend that which you enjoy, friend. tsudecimo said: daniyan said: Agreed with Angel Beats!, i don't like it much, and fortunately isn't a Kyo Ani produced anime, if it was, maybe can would have even best rating, this anime deserves an 8 but no more than 8.3. Kyoani fag in a nutshell. Hey, at least i didn't watched K-on! and can still not watching this anime yet. But i have to accept your offense in a good manner and consider it as constructive criticism. If he really thinks you're a KyoAni fag just for wishing that they had produced a certain show, then that's a bit presumptuous and unfortunate on his part. No, I called him a Kyo ani fag because he said he would rate it higher if Angel beats was made by Kyo ani. |
|
| KyoAni are were a way better studio than PA Works. But they were making K-On Season 2 at that time which I personally think was a much better use of their time. |
 |
lol Trigun and Cowboy Bebop are neither overrated nor underrated; both are masterpieces that are widely acknowledged as such    |
yhunata said: Well if you say so i have not seen it until episode 15 or so. Btw that fairy tale arc was pretty shitty yes but it was a filler arc, and after that they follow the manga again. But you know what i give Naruto a try some day again.johnyjohny said: yhunata said: I don't like you yhunata. And yes 17 episodes out of 175 is way to less to rate a anime let stand judge about it being crap. Hitman reborn had that 23 episodes of crap going on for example and i heard that LOTGH needs time to get fun, so yes. You don't see me hating on Naruto right? And i admit Fair tail is very cliche and stole a lot of things from other shonen but the most important part is that it is enjoyable. And is certainly more epic in 175 episodes than Naruto i bet.johnyjohny said: natssuu said: Don't judge a anime you dropped man.Fairy Tail and Angel Beats! Both have the same rating 8.59 which is ridiculously too high By that logic, would it mean that a person who dropped an anime on it's last episode should also not have the right to judge it? I didn't watch it to the last episode, but I know enough to say that Fairy Tail is overrated. I wasn't talking about natssuu. I was asking a rhetorical question. Fairy Tail was great until the Oracion Seis arc. After that, the villains just got plain horrible. And so did Natsu's power-ups. In fact, Natsu's power-ups were plain ridiculous. And the happenings. As for Naruto, the original Naruto was great (obviously, there were no fucking fillers until they reached episode 130). Up until then, the enemies were great, the fights were great and the development was great. Then came Shippuden which fucked the whole thing up with it's fillers (post pain-arc fillers, that is). |
| .. |
johnyjohny said: Well if you say so i have not seen it until episode 15 or so. Btw that fairy tale arc was pretty shitty yes but it was a filler arc, and after that they follow the manga again. But you know what i give Naruto a try some day again. Oracion Seis was in the manga. The first filler arc was the Daphny (?) filler arc. After that, it was the first arc that came after the time skip. There were about two filler episodes before the Oracion Seis arc, but that's all the filler that was in Fairy Tail. |
|
yhunata said: ow that arc. No don't think that was a bad arc. No around episode 125 until 150 is a filler arc that did not apear in the manga.johnyjohny said: Well if you say so i have not seen it until episode 15 or so. Btw that fairy tale arc was pretty shitty yes but it was a filler arc, and after that they follow the manga again. But you know what i give Naruto a try some day again. Oracion Seis was in the manga. The first filler arc was the Daphny (?) filler arc. After that, it was the first arc that came after the time skip. There were about two filler episodes before the Oracion Seis arc, but that's all the filler that was in Fairy Tail. |
| .. |
| OVERRATED: Suzumiya, Gintama, Code Geass, K-on, Bakemonogatari... UNDERRATED: it's hard to say, maybe Nichijou... All my opinions are based not only on MAL. |
Jaguer91Jun 3, 2013 10:00 PM
I luv u |
| Overrated: Naruto, FMA, Bleach...etc. Underrated: ....perhaps Helling? |
| overrated - sword art online (action good writing meh-bad, doesn't deserve massive hype and following) though, im rather disconnected from the anime community so i cant quite say anything, though im willing to back baccano! as underrated |
rigamortisJun 3, 2013 10:21 PM
DeathStroked said: What other anime is in the "etc."?Overrated: Naruto, FMA, Bleach...etc. Underrated: ....perhaps Helling? |
Please learn about cel animation and its technical process. Learn how special effects and backlighting were done without computers. |
| Shingeki no Kyojin. Hahahahahaha. |
 |
| There are a billion different things that I'd be warranted in listing as overrated, but to name just a few (some of which I still enjoy regardless): DBZ Trigun Cowboy Bebop Oreimo Strike Witches Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann Fullmetal Alchemist (original and brotherhood) Outlaw Star ToLoveRu Ikki Tousen Queen's Blade Neon Genesis Evangelion Karas Akira Another Angel Beats Code Geass R2 Gundam Wing Redline Bleach Naruto One Piece Fairy Tail Mondaiji-tachi ga Isekai kara Kuru Sou Desu yo? Saint Seiya As for underrated: IGPX Gundam X Gosick Love Live School Idol Project Gundam Seed (in some circles) Rozen Maiden |
| Salmon is delicious. |
| Overrated - Cowboy Bebop. It was alright, but it gets way too much hype than it deserves. Granted it was likely amazing for its time. Underrated - Bakemonogotari/Nisemonogotari. A lot of people don't like it and it doesn't get the credit it deserves because it is so mainly focused on dialogue. Nobody really notices how witty and funny it is. |
| Overrated: Gintama, Naruto, SAO Underrated: Ga-Rei: Zero, Trigun, City Hunter |
 |
| The most underated is School Days, most people hate it because of it being different instead of being the same usual cliche high school romance anime. Plus most just don't get what the show was trying to be and whine about it for unjustified reasons. |
 |
| Can't remember if I've posted here before... Overrated: Toradora! Ouran Highschool Host Club Welcome to the NHK! (I just didn't like it...) Underrated So Ra No Wo To Revolutionary Girl Utena Gunslinger Girl B Gata H Kei (My favourite ecchi) |
| Sword Art Online is seriously overrated. Even i as a SAO fan am starting to think that this anime should have less attention. |
 |
Elit3Blaze said: Well then you aren't paying attention.Sword Art Online is seriously overrated. Even i as a SAO fan am starting to think that this anime should have less attention. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Cbubbles said: el_putazo said: DeathStroked said: What other anime is in the "etc."?Overrated: Naruto, FMA, Bleach...etc. Underrated: ....perhaps Helling? Probably One Piece and other inexplicably popular modern series structured exactly like Dragon Ball Z. That's almost just as vague as "etc". |
 |
| Overrated: Evangelion Underrated: Welcome to the NHK |
| Overrated: Angel Beats. Underrated: There are many, but for the sake of argument, I will go with Haibane Renmei considering it is very similar to Angel Beats yet was made about 8 years prior. |
Cbubbles said: el_putazo said: DeathStroked said: What other anime is in the "etc."?Overrated: Naruto, FMA, Bleach...etc. Underrated: ....perhaps Helling? Probably One Piece and other inexplicably popular modern series structured exactly like Dragon Ball Z. What? How is One Piece in any way structured like Dragonball Z? |
| Overrated: Aside from the long-running anime, I'd have to say ef - a tale of memories. That's the last time I have high expectations for an anime series. Underrated: Kaidan Restaurant {not so much underrated as underexposed}, Cat Soup, and Sasami-san@Ganbaranai. |
"For you all lives are created equal, that's why I came back to life. But you've finally come to realize it now, haven't you? Only one thing is equal for all, and that is death."  |
filmftw1 said: Do the companies structure the anime? The manga does. I guess having filler arcs between arcs is similar in them.IntervisioN said: What? How is One Piece in any way structured like Dragonball Z? ... one being that both are produced and animated by the same studio? |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| Mars of destruction Based on my enjoyment, I don't even know... |
Please learn about cel animation and its technical process. Learn how special effects and backlighting were done without computers. |
| Type-Moon fanboys always rage at how their doujin H-game visual novel never got an anime adaptation. I mean, come on, it's not that bad. |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
I find Type Moon series as whole to be overrated. From my experience, they try too hard to be more than they really are. |
| Salmon is delicious. |
All of the Type Moon's anime are seriously overrated. They are some of the best examples of over-used CGI methods, generic cookie cutter character designs and boring plots. Yet. Lots of people worship trashy shows like Fate and Kara like crazy. :P |
| Most underrated anime ever.. Devil survivor 2. |
 |
| Most overrated anime: Ano Hana Most underrated anime: Zettai Karen Children Cman107 said: Overrated: Angel Beats. Underrated: There are many, but for the sake of argument, I will go with Haibane Renmei considering it is very similar to Angel Beats yet was made about 8 years prior. Haibane is absolutely nothing like Angel Beats. DeathStroked said: Overrated: Naruto, FMA, Bleach...etc. Underrated: ....perhaps Helling? Bitch FMA is way above you! Don't you dare talk trash about it! |
lucjanJun 6, 2013 1:45 AM
 |
Leapling said: Most underrated anime ever.. Devil survivor 2. Not at all. |
| Genocyber |
Please learn about cel animation and its technical process. Learn how special effects and backlighting were done without computers. |
More topics from this board
» If your favorite anime exploded in popularity to the point that everyone in socmed talks about it, would you like it or not?Rinrinka - 13 minutes ago |
3 |
by Zarutaku
»»
21 seconds ago |
|
» Would you or have you watched anime with your family (1 or more members)?ToastWithNutella - 9 hours ago |
27 |
by BitChilly
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» Guys I did it!TsutanaiFuun - 8 hours ago |
22 |
by BitChilly
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» What anime song (intro, outro, j-pop) of the ringtone do you use right now?Kiryotsu - 8 hours ago |
13 |
by Zettaiken
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» Let's Hope the Whole "Girls Golfing" Is A New Thing That Keeps Going...simonitro - 7 hours ago |
6 |
by MasterTasuke
»»
23 minutes ago |