Fullmetal Alchemist
Johnny00 said: No, but I think some other anime are getting underrated because of it. what do you mean? Are you talking about the fanbase's 1s or just cause the fact that some series are under it? |
 ManWild |
| Maybe it is. Why is it relevant though? |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
Mashal166 said: ManWild said: i don't think fmab should be number 1 on MAL since I think there are many other animes that are way better.what do you mean? Are you talking about the fanbase's 1s or just cause the fact that some series are under it? oh, I see. I think just because it's not first, doesn't mean it can't be well known though. So I don't think it's the end of the world if a series you like has a high rating even if it isn't number one (If that makes any sense) |
ManWild |
| Anyone else love the quality of fmab threads |
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type 'πππΈππΈπππΈππΈ'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges.  |
| If you mean overrated as in the MAL definition of overrated(score higher than what I think it should be) I guess I agree since I rated it an 8. But I can whole heartedly admit it’s probably one of the best anime ever made as it has had an impact on the medium and specifically the western fan experience. I think it’s ok to not think FMAB is the best thing ever made in the medium and you can personally think other anime are better. It’s called having an opinion. This is an aside addressing one of your other comments. Do you really think people have not watched or heard of HxH, S:G, AoT, Code Geass, or Mob and have also watched FMAB? These are all the most basic popular anime people have watched. It’s not unique to think they are good, just like FMAB they are all commonly agreed to be high quality. It’s it not unique or nuanced to think they are good. |
 |
RebelPandaSFan said: That's really true, any anime can be the best anime ever to someone else, I just don't understand why soooo many people consider fmab literally the best Anime ever when there are many other animes that outclass it, just like HxH, AOT Code geas and Mob Psycho 100.(All Masterpieces) Well that is if they have actually watched those .I think it's okay, but best anime ever created is a relative term. I prefer steins gate and vinland saga to be above this but fmab hugely appeals to audience |
 a wise user of MAL said: Just to clarify, adaptations should absolutely stand on their own |
| I'm not actually sure that many people think it's the best ever made, it's more a case it's been viewed by a huge western audience because of its massive appeal to both new people to anime and the old hats of the medium. It's definetly great, with little competition against it for the top shoen anime but ya there their are better shows bit that doesn't mean it's bad that the general audiences pick it as their number one. The idea that other shows should have the crown is sillyness. If the shows are actually better then the fandom does acknowledge it, otakus talk alot more about Eva or ghost in the shell then they do fmab but furthermore while those shows may be considered better by some, if they don't have the mass appeal, then they won't be number 1. Eva proves this by being way bigger in Japan then Fmab. It's all about perspective really, I wouldn't let it bother you to muchππ. |
   |
| I don’t think it is the best anime of all time or anything, but I do think it is worthy of a decent amount of praise. I thought it was excellent |
| oh look it's a monthly overrated thread. Every time I see these threads just makes me think it is either another elitist or the idea of people having different taste is too hard to grasp. Being so fixated on rating from any sites will just make your experience that much less. The number of times I have seen MAL users using overrated, underrated is honestly cringeworthy. It just sounds like grade-schoolers debating whether apple or oranges is better. |
Mashal166 said: i think u r right it's definitely not best show ever and ig ye it is overrated in high scored anime ik it's good anime to watch but calling it #1 doesn't seem fit with it...when i started knowing it's #1 show ever i really thought it will something special but it wasn't it was a good to watch but i really expect something best since it is #1 show in mal.still thinking how it's best high score anime in mal i gave it 8/10I finished the Anime a few months ago. I really enjoyed the anime, Edward is one of my favourite characters in anime. But is this the best anime ever created? I don't think so. I have definitely seen way better shows. I know what I'm saying is a crime to weebs but that is just what I think. What do you guys think? |
OvergrownRover said: and so what? Did I ask? Imao...Nah it’s amazing and Top 3 anime ever for me |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
LustKamisama said: oh look it's a monthly overrated thread. Every time I see these threads just makes me think it is either another elitist or the idea of people having different taste is too hard to grasp. Being so fixated on rating from any sites will just make your experience that much less. The number of times I have seen MAL users using overrated, underrated is honestly cringeworthy. It just sounds like grade-schoolers debating whether apple or oranges is better. I hear ya, people seem to get Uber fixated on scores around here, way to many trying to put all the anime they've seen on an impervious sliding scale. Image rating every live action film you'd seen compared to every otherπ . I rate most stuff way to high but at the same time surely the point is to watch great shows we enjoy and drop the rest. Who cares if the biggest group of people love fmab? It's a great show well worthy of praise, what's the point in getting worked up over it lol. |
|
| If I'm being honest, I don't know why this show is the #1 rated anime on MAL, I didn't enjoy it all that much, and I don't know anybody who has rated this show higher than an 8. |
 |
| But the plot is so good and almost perfect and the animation is best of that time. It does deserve the top spot untill some other anime does it better |
| Nope, I think this Anime deserves its rating.. This Anime is an MASTERPIECE from start to finish. |
| Yes, I think it is! |
 |
LeEggBread said: If I'm being honest, I don't know why this show is the #1 rated anime on MAL, I didn't enjoy it all that much, and I don't know anybody who has rated this show higher than an 8. hi if you don't know why its hard to make you know why |
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type 'πππΈππΈπππΈππΈ'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges. |
Mashal166 said: I finished the Anime a few months ago. I really enjoyed the anime, Edward is one of my favourite characters in anime. But is this the best anime ever created? I don't think so. I have definitely seen way better shows. I know what I'm saying is a crime to weebs but that is just what I think. What do you guys think? Nah,you are not alone.Its really a good anime.But the best?Its Subjective.For me its Code Geass and Monster.Its definitely a bit overrated |
  "I had a dream. Under the full moon, I was a child embraced by nostalgic warmth. But when I wake from the dream, only a vague sense of longing remains...that, too, will soon disappear with a single tear like mountain dew"  |
| I don't think anyone claimed it as "best anime ever created" it's just highly rated and is well respected among anime fans. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Mashal166 said: agree with you yes it is an overated shit.I finished the Anime a few months ago. I really enjoyed the anime, Edward is one of my favourite characters in anime. But is this the best anime ever created? I don't think so. I have definitely seen way better shows. I know what I'm saying is a crime to weebs but that is just what I think. What do you guys think? |
 "No one can rewrite the stars How can you say you'll be mine? Everything keeps us apart And I'm not the one you were meant to find It's not up to you you It's not up to me When everyone tells us what we can be How can we rewrite the stars?" |
Scordolo said: bro #1 spot=best anime for majority of people. And ask the people who have fmab in their favourites that is fmab the best anime . I bet you that majority of them will say yes. And everybody gives rating on the basis of if they like it or not. So if someone have it in its favourite and gave it a 10 then obviously they have claimed that it is the best anime for them. That's why the rating system exists. You just don't rate to respect an anime.I don't think anyone claimed it as "best anime ever created" it's just highly rated and is well respected among anime fans. |
"No one can rewrite the stars How can you say you'll be mine? Everything keeps us apart And I'm not the one you were meant to find It's not up to you you It's not up to me When everyone tells us what we can be How can we rewrite the stars?" |
| why the fuck thread are always the same and redundant? i'm bored and tired of seeing it,especially the one who say overrated resulting in low standard scores |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )adamantine - Sep 20, 2009 |
184 |
by grimjaw1513
»»
Yesterday, 11:05 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 23 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Ahenshihael - Sep 13, 2009 |
199 |
by grimjaw1513
»»
Yesterday, 11:03 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 46 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )removed-user - Feb 28, 2010 |
221 |
by Certified_gooner
»»
Aug 30, 12:17 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 45 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )removed-user - Feb 21, 2010 |
183 |
by Certified_gooner
»»
Aug 30, 11:36 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 22 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - Sep 6, 2009 |
218 |
by grimjaw1513
»»
Aug 26, 3:04 AM |