Attack on Titan
Available on Manga Store
New
Sep 6, 2019 7:48 AM
#1
I remember when this episode came out and a lot of manga readers were pissed because this wasn't in the manga and that Araki messed up this part, even though it was stated that Isayama ask them to make that change. Now in retrospect this scene makes a whole lot of sense now. Also this scene has new meaning to it, I remember watching a few live reaction of this episode and persons were pissed that both Rod and Historia was staring at Eren as if he was the one that did it, now that it is confirmed its kinda funny in retrospect. I'm sure there is many more scenes there, but oh boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of it. Mod edit: Added a spoiler tag to the title. |
DeadlyRavenSep 6, 2019 12:16 PM
Sep 6, 2019 8:04 AM
#2
This most recent chapter has turned the whole series on its head and I love it. I feel like on rewatch I'm gonna see things in a new light |
Sep 6, 2019 8:41 AM
#3
>boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of Won't really comment on how good are the foreshadowing till everything is tied properly and actually making sense, but this is not the first nor the last time a work with mystery elements has foreshadowing placed throughout the manga and giving them a new meaning towards the end(manga like Pandora hearts,etc). It's only because of so much popularity of this series that an uproar is created, despite some things not making sense at all. ~ |
Sep 6, 2019 8:51 AM
#4
LoneWalkers said: >boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of Won't really comment on how good are the foreshadowing till everything is tied properly and actually making sense, but this is not the first nor the last time a work with mystery elements has foreshadowing placed throughout the manga and giving them a new meaning towards the end(manga like Pandora hearts,etc). It's only because of so much popularity of this series that an uproar is created, despite some things not making sense at all. ~ Hi Mr. Contrarian nice to see you here as well. Nothing in your post disprove my claim, so what is the point of this comment? Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Oh and there is more bombshell to come, sit tight and enjoy the ride! |
Sep 6, 2019 9:02 AM
#5
keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ |
removed-userSep 6, 2019 9:14 AM
Sep 6, 2019 9:29 AM
#6
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. |
keragammingSep 6, 2019 9:33 AM
Sep 6, 2019 10:37 AM
#7
keragamming said: I'm sure there is many more scenes there, but oh boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of it. It's about the only anime that I've watched that actually gets better the more I re-watch it. Obviously you aren't going to get genuine surprises from the plot twists that you did the 1st time around, but the little things that you previously didn't notice that you know do, make it more than worth the repeated viewings. |
Sep 6, 2019 10:43 AM
#8
keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. >the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Astonishing logic. Majority of fans voted certain re:zero, boku dake ga inai machi, episodes as 5/5 and hailed them as one of the best episodes in anime, are they seen as classics? A single chapter, in a series subforum, of an incomplete series, by a fan of the fanbase, hailing the favorite series as "classic" is some top tier delusion to say the least. Most of the readers in general manga community doesn't even post or vote in forums here(not to mention some of my friends, who aren't SnK fans have mixed or neutral opinions about the chapter, but it's not worth for them arguing with this fanbase), and majority fanbase don't dictate a series as classic. It's the majority general community of a complete series that sees whether a series is classic or not, only after seeing how everything has turned out. Seeing your comment reminds me of Game of Thrones. Majority of fanbase claimed it as a "classic" tv series even though there were quite a few criticisms in general community, only until last season aired and we know how it turned out. ~ Anyway just curious, I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. Congratulations! Wait, now can I see the proof do that you are a representative of millions of readers of manga community, voicing the same opinion that it's already a classic? Cheers, if you need help, I think a voting thread in the general manga forum to elect you with the opinion "SnK is already a classic" can be a good option!~ |
removed-userSep 6, 2019 11:00 AM
Sep 6, 2019 11:14 AM
#9
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. >the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Astonishing logic. Majority of fans voted certain re:zero, boku dake ga inai machi, episodes as 5/5 and hailed them as one of the best episodes in anime, are they seen as classics? A single chapter, in a series subforum, of an incomplete series, by a fan of the fanbase, hailing the favorite series as "classic" is some top tier delusion to say the least. Most of the readers in general manga community doesn't even post or vote in forums here(not to mention some of my friends, who aren't SnK fans have mixed or neutral opinions about the chapter, but it's not worth for them arguing with this fanbase), and majority fanbase don't dictate a series as classic. It's the majority general community of a complete series that sees whether a series is classic or not, only after seeing how everything has turned out. Seeing your comment reminds me of Game of Thrones. Majority of fanbase claimed it as a "classic" tv series even though there were quite a few criticisms in general community, only until last season aired and we know how it turned out. ~ Anyway just curious, I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. Congratulations! Wait, now can I see the proof do that you are a representative of millions of readers of manga community, voicing the same opinion that it's already a classic? Cheers, if you need help, I think a voting thread in the general manga forum to elect you with the opinion "SnK is already a classic" can be a good option!~ I was not talking strictly on votes, but on comments, I read every single comments on all these forums from various website to make this conclusion. Also there is a thing called sample size. The series has showed all the proof that it has a well planned plot and this chapter just like the basement reveal strengthen that point and I'm sure there is more to come as well. And yes, tv series like "lost" and game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good. The journey was still for the most part fantastic and also was very impactful during their airing and the medium overall. |
keragammingSep 6, 2019 11:24 AM
Sep 6, 2019 11:24 AM
#10
keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. >the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Astonishing logic. Majority of fans voted certain re:zero, boku dake ga inai machi, episodes as 5/5 and hailed them as one of the best episodes in anime, are they seen as classics? A single chapter, in a series subforum, of an incomplete series, by a fan of the fanbase, hailing the favorite series as "classic" is some top tier delusion to say the least. Most of the readers in general manga community doesn't even post or vote in forums here(not to mention some of my friends, who aren't SnK fans have mixed or neutral opinions about the chapter, but it's not worth for them arguing with this fanbase), and majority fanbase don't dictate a series as classic. It's the majority general community of a complete series that sees whether a series is classic or not, only after seeing how everything has turned out. Seeing your comment reminds me of Game of Thrones. Majority of fanbase claimed it as a "classic" tv series even though there were quite a few criticisms in general community, only until last season aired and we know how it turned out. ~ Anyway just curious, I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. Congratulations! Wait, now can I see the proof do that you are a representative of millions of readers of manga community, voicing the same opinion that it's already a classic? Cheers, if you need help, I think a voting thread in the general manga forum to elect you with the opinion "SnK is already a classic" can be a good option!~ I was not talking strictly on votes, but on comments, I read every single comments on all these forums from various website to make this conclusion. Also there is a thing called sample size. Also the series has showed all the proof that it has a well planned plot and this chapter just like the basement reveal strengthen that point and I'm sure there is more to come as well. And yes, tv series like "lost" and game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good. The journey was still for the most part fantastic and also was very impactful during their airing and the medium overall. If that was the case, then I am sure that you could have counted better than "two or three" negative/neutral comments of different users in the latest chapter forum here and then immediately coming to the great "conclusion". Or do you need help with counting too? Feel free to contact me anytime then~ oh and yes, check some specific re:zero(or boku dake) episode threads of hundreds of users claiming it as masterpiece, I am sure those are classics too. That's cool, according to you and many other fans. Tsubasa: reservoir chronicles, Vanitas no Carte and hundreds of other series also had well planned plot, at the same or better level than SnK, where is the classics tag? But wait >And yes, tv series like game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good So in other words, you actually have no idea what "classics" mean and just using it as a buzzword. Not worth my time then, at least the theory posts in chapter forum don't have this level of shabby arguments~ |
removed-userSep 6, 2019 11:33 AM
Sep 6, 2019 11:42 AM
#11
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. >the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Astonishing logic. Majority of fans voted certain re:zero, boku dake ga inai machi, episodes as 5/5 and hailed them as one of the best episodes in anime, are they seen as classics? A single chapter, in a series subforum, of an incomplete series, by a fan of the fanbase, hailing the favorite series as "classic" is some top tier delusion to say the least. Most of the readers in general manga community doesn't even post or vote in forums here(not to mention some of my friends, who aren't SnK fans have mixed or neutral opinions about the chapter, but it's not worth for them arguing with this fanbase), and majority fanbase don't dictate a series as classic. It's the majority general community of a complete series that sees whether a series is classic or not, only after seeing how everything has turned out. Seeing your comment reminds me of Game of Thrones. Majority of fanbase claimed it as a "classic" tv series even though there were quite a few criticisms in general community, only until last season aired and we know how it turned out. ~ Anyway just curious, I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. Congratulations! Wait, now can I see the proof do that you are a representative of millions of readers of manga community, voicing the same opinion that it's already a classic? Cheers, if you need help, I think a voting thread in the general manga forum to elect you with the opinion "SnK is already a classic" can be a good option!~ I was not talking strictly on votes, but on comments, I read every single comments on all these forums from various website to make this conclusion. Also there is a thing called sample size. Also the series has showed all the proof that it has a well planned plot and this chapter just like the basement reveal strengthen that point and I'm sure there is more to come as well. And yes, tv series like "lost" and game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good. The journey was still for the most part fantastic and also was very impactful during their airing and the medium overall. If that was the case, then I am sure that you could have counted better than "two or three" negative/neutral comments of different users in the latest chapter forum here. Or do you need help with counting too? Feel free to contact me anytime then~ That's cool, according to you. Tsubasa: reservoir chronicles, Vanitas no Carte and hundreds of other series also had well planned plot, at the same or better level than SnK, where is the classics tag? But wait >And yes, tv series like game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good So in other words, you actually have no idea what "classics" mean and just using it as a buzzword. Not worth my time then, at least the theory posts in chapter forum don't have this level of shabby arguments~ You are clearly not paying attention to what I am writing here, that was a example,"out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it." I wasn't saying this is indeed a fact that every 200 comments there will only be 2 to 3 negative comments, it could be a little more than 3 or even less than 3, the point I was making is that I hardly saw negative comments, instead it was mostly praise. For comparison, base off what I remember the basement reveal was also mostly positive, but if I should estimate and give you a a example I would say out of the 200 comments maybe around 40 persons would not have liked the reveal. Surprisingly when the anime aired the basement reveal, this episode got way more praise than any manga readers expected. Now you are using straw man arguments against me bringing up other series into this, and I'm not going to start a argument with you regarding which series is more planned out. So in other words, you actually have no idea what "classics" mean and just using it as a buzzword. Not worth my time then, at least the theory posts in chapter forum don't have this level of shabby arguments~ idgaf what you consider to be a classic, I'm so sorry for you when the final season airs, because classic is going to be thrown around with snk all year long, heck plenty of persons already regards it as a classic, especially since the airing of the latest season. Yes, the truth is we can't no a classic right away because it will take decades before we will know, but it doesn't stop persons from saying it will become one in the future base off evidence. So if we are done talking here, please go back from where you came from and stop being triggered by persons praising a series you don't like. Go make a thread that snk is overrated if that will make you feel better. |
keragammingSep 6, 2019 11:50 AM
Sep 6, 2019 11:47 AM
#12
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: LoneWalkers said: >Sorry to tell you, but whether you like it or not you are witnessing a classic in the making here that many years from now persons will recommend it to new anime fans as a masterpiece. >You have your opinion, and everyone else has theirs, but a single opinion wont dictate what is a classic from what isn't that is for everyone to decide. Do you realize that the hypocrisy level is off the charts in the two statements? You claim it's not for me to decide or dictate what's a classic or not because that's for others to decide, and in the same post, you, a single fan of series claim that an incomplete work is classic in making for the whole anime/manga community. Absolute genius! Probably one of the most hilarious argument/post I have seen in this entire forum, and that's an incredible achievement considering the posts in the latest chapter discussion. We both posted our respective opinions, maybe try to respect or not dismiss a different opinion next time in a thread which itself starts with another individual opinion,"cementing it as classic". ~ Look at the ratings for this chapter, I've been on many forums and it has been praise everywhere, sure out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it. You are the minority that is the point I am making, the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Never knew I needed to spell it out for you, I thought it was obvious. I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. >the persons who dictate whether this is a classic is the majority not the minority which you unfortunately is a part of. Astonishing logic. Majority of fans voted certain re:zero, boku dake ga inai machi, episodes as 5/5 and hailed them as one of the best episodes in anime, are they seen as classics? A single chapter, in a series subforum, of an incomplete series, by a fan of the fanbase, hailing the favorite series as "classic" is some top tier delusion to say the least. Most of the readers in general manga community doesn't even post or vote in forums here(not to mention some of my friends, who aren't SnK fans have mixed or neutral opinions about the chapter, but it's not worth for them arguing with this fanbase), and majority fanbase don't dictate a series as classic. It's the majority general community of a complete series that sees whether a series is classic or not, only after seeing how everything has turned out. Seeing your comment reminds me of Game of Thrones. Majority of fanbase claimed it as a "classic" tv series even though there were quite a few criticisms in general community, only until last season aired and we know how it turned out. ~ Anyway just curious, I am the voice of the majority, while you are the voice of the minority. Congratulations! Wait, now can I see the proof do that you are a representative of millions of readers of manga community, voicing the same opinion that it's already a classic? Cheers, if you need help, I think a voting thread in the general manga forum to elect you with the opinion "SnK is already a classic" can be a good option!~ I was not talking strictly on votes, but on comments, I read every single comments on all these forums from various website to make this conclusion. Also there is a thing called sample size. Also the series has showed all the proof that it has a well planned plot and this chapter just like the basement reveal strengthen that point and I'm sure there is more to come as well. And yes, tv series like "lost" and game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good. The journey was still for the most part fantastic and also was very impactful during their airing and the medium overall. If that was the case, then I am sure that you could have counted better than "two or three" negative/neutral comments of different users in the latest chapter forum here and then immediately coming to the great "conclusion". Or do you need help with counting too? Feel free to contact me anytime then~ oh and yes, check some specific re:zero(or boku dake) episode threads of hundreds of users claiming it as masterpiece, I am sure those are classics too. That's cool, according to you and many other fans. Tsubasa: reservoir chronicles, Vanitas no Carte and hundreds of other series also had well planned plot, at the same or better level than SnK, where is the classics tag? But wait >And yes, tv series like game of thrones will be regarded as classic even if there endings or final season were not good So in other words, you actually have no idea what "classics" mean and just using it as a buzzword. Not worth my time then, at least the theory posts in chapter forum don't have this level of shabby arguments~ the author of this post was showing admiration for the series. I also agree itll be a classic. Difference of opinions. You've said your piece. I dont see why you're persisting to argue. Furthermore arguing with sarcasm and a patronizing tone arent ways to change people's minds |
Sep 6, 2019 12:09 PM
#13
keragamming said: You are clearly not paying attention to what I am writing here, that was a example,"out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it." I wasn't saying this is indeed a fact that every 200 comments there will only be 2 to 3 negative comments, it could be a little more than 3 or even less than 3, the point I was making is that I hardly saw negative comments, instead it was mostly praise. For comparison, base off what I remember the basement reveal was also mostly positive, but if I should estimate and give you a a example I would say out of the 200 comments maybe around 40 persons would not have liked the reveal. Ah yes, basing it on "forum majority posts" , so remember the anime classic, re zero? or the already classic shounen, kimetsu no yaiba, because majority forum comments of specific episodes and chapters and episodes determine the conclusion to an "already classic", right? this is beyond hilarious now, see you another day!~ SnowStorm42 said: the author of this post was showing admiration for the series. I also agree itll be a classic. Difference of opinions. You've said your piece. I dont see why you're persisting to argue. Furthermore arguing with sarcasm and a patronizing tone arent ways to change people's minds Yes, I have literally no problem with what you claimed. But see who is the one who quoted and posted the hypocritical comment in the first place, when I just pointed out a different opinion that it's not a classic yet. I don't know why these fans can't stand negative opinions and immediately use "you are wrong, I am right because... majority fanbase say wow so great". Just wanted to show how shabby those arguments were, but you are right, these fans would never admit their mistakes so it's best to move on. |
removed-userSep 6, 2019 12:22 PM
Sep 6, 2019 12:25 PM
#14
@LoneWalkers I'm talking about cumulative of build up and planning since episode 1, the latest chapter is just as impactful as the basement reveal chapter, because it took the series right on its head and completely change the viewers perspective of the overall series and the main character of the series. Kimetsu is a shit example because even I brought up the fact that a single episode or to be exact the last 3 minutes of that episode can't make it all of a sudden AOTY candidate, Kimetsu wasn't even in the argument of being a classic. Kimetsu got praise for its beautiful animation scene, that is it, style with no substance, snk chapter 121 is a game changer to the series overall plot, that is a big difference. Re zero I can't say much about it, I like the series, but I do know it has a big following and as I said earlier, it will probably take decades from now to find out which series is a classic from which isn't, but that doesn't mean we can't make prediction on what we think will be a classic. Point is, the basement chapter and this latest chapter is the accumulation of older chapters since chapter 1, these are the type of chapters that make or break a series, that makes a series turn from a good series to a masterpiece series or vice versa. Every person has a time when they are watching anime and at a certain point will realise that this series is special and that at this particular point is when that series reach a new height. That is basically what I was saying this latest chapter did. For me snk has been just going up, I never knew that there would be another big bombshell that would rival the basement reveal and turn the series on its head once again. Persons have drop the series after the basement because they claim now with finding out all the truth they don't feel like continuing it anymore. With this single chapter, they are missing out on a big piece of series and many will never know what is fully going on in this world. @LoneWalkers Yes, I have literally no problem with what you claimed. But see who is the one who quoted and posted the hypocritical comment in the first place, when I just pointed out a different opinion that it's not a classic yet. I don't know why these fans can't stand negative opinions and immediately use "you are wrong, I am right because... majority fanbase say wow so great". Just wanted to show how shabby those arguments were, but you are right, these fans would never admit their mistakes so it's best to move on. This argument would have been avoided if you had just ask me to elaborate more on what I was saying in my original post, instead comparing snk with other series saying they even had done it better and saying all your other bullcrap, you wanted to start a argument and base off your comments in the past few chapters, it wasn't hard for me to put two and two together to know that you were just planting your next bait so we can argue it out, because you just can't stand persons praising this series or even saying that it is a classic. |
keragammingSep 6, 2019 12:45 PM
Sep 6, 2019 12:40 PM
#15
keragamming said: @LoneWalkers I'm talking about cumulative of build up and planning since episode 1, the latest chapter is just as impactful as the basement reveal chapter, because it took the series right on its head and completely change the viewers perspective of the overall series and the main character of the series. Kimetsu is a shit example because even I brought up the fact that a single episode or to be exact the last 3 minutes of that episode can't make it all of a sudden AOTY candidate, Kimetsu wasn't even in the argument of being a classic. Kimetsu got praise for its beautiful animation scene, that is it, style with no substance, snk chapter 121 is a game changer to the series overall plot, that is a big difference. Re zero I can't say much about it, I like the series, but I do know it has a big following and as I said earlier, it will probably take decades from now to find out which series is a classic from which isn't, but that doesn't mean we can't make prediction on what we think will be a classic. Point is, the basement chapter and this latest chapter is the accumulation of older chapters since chapter 1, these are the type of chapters that make or break a series, that makes a series turn from a good series to a masterpiece series or vice versa. That's just "two or three" people out of 200 users who were not amazed by those 3 minutes. I was amazed by Kimetsu, part of the fanbase, and already claiming it as anime classic because of that amazing production buildup of fight in the episode, just like other 200 people in the fanbase is claiming it's anime of the year already. Pretty easy, isn't it? >it will probably take decades from now to find out which series is a classic from which isn't, but that doesn't mean we can't make prediction on what we think will be a classic. Definitely, and similarly, the other way goes too for prediction about not being a classic. So finally admitted that you are wrong when you claimed "it has already cemented place as anime classic", that's great! we can reach an agreement and close this argument. Oh yeah, there are lots of chapters in future which can make or break or series, especially in this case where the series is ambitious and not everything makes sense yet. To downgrade from "decent" to below average series, we don't even need three chapters, and lots of series are examples of that. Maybe a little too early right to predict anything... oh never mind. |
removed-userSep 6, 2019 12:44 PM
Sep 6, 2019 12:51 PM
#16
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: You are clearly not paying attention to what I am writing here, that was a example,"out of 200 comments you will have one or three comments saying they either don't like it or is on the fence about it." I wasn't saying this is indeed a fact that every 200 comments there will only be 2 to 3 negative comments, it could be a little more than 3 or even less than 3, the point I was making is that I hardly saw negative comments, instead it was mostly praise. For comparison, base off what I remember the basement reveal was also mostly positive, but if I should estimate and give you a a example I would say out of the 200 comments maybe around 40 persons would not have liked the reveal. Ah yes, basing it on "forum majority posts" , so remember the anime classic, re zero? or the already classic shounen, kimetsu no yaiba, because majority forum comments of specific episodes and chapters and episodes determine the conclusion to an "already classic", right? this is beyond hilarious now, see you another day!~ SnowStorm42 said: the author of this post was showing admiration for the series. I also agree itll be a classic. Difference of opinions. You've said your piece. I dont see why you're persisting to argue. Furthermore arguing with sarcasm and a patronizing tone arent ways to change people's minds Yes, I have literally no problem with what you claimed. But see who is the one who quoted and posted the hypocritical comment in the first place, when I just pointed out a different opinion that it's not a classic yet. I don't know why these fans can't stand negative opinions and immediately use "you are wrong, I am right because... majority fanbase say wow so great". Just wanted to show how shabby those arguments were, but you are right, these fans would never admit their mistakes so it's best to move on. I think @keragamming is right in SnK will be a classic, and I think chapter 121 was one of the best chapters ever in anything. But he's also hypocritical towards @LoneWalkers. If he doesn't think that SnK will be a classic then that's his opinion. The only one who can tell if SnK will be a classic is Eren, who sees the future, or already living it, and changed it to his liking. Eren knows if SnK is a masterpiece or no XD |
Sep 6, 2019 1:06 PM
#17
LoneWalkers said: keragamming said: @LoneWalkers I'm talking about cumulative of build up and planning since episode 1, the latest chapter is just as impactful as the basement reveal chapter, because it took the series right on its head and completely change the viewers perspective of the overall series and the main character of the series. Kimetsu is a shit example because even I brought up the fact that a single episode or to be exact the last 3 minutes of that episode can't make it all of a sudden AOTY candidate, Kimetsu wasn't even in the argument of being a classic. Kimetsu got praise for its beautiful animation scene, that is it, style with no substance, snk chapter 121 is a game changer to the series overall plot, that is a big difference. Re zero I can't say much about it, I like the series, but I do know it has a big following and as I said earlier, it will probably take decades from now to find out which series is a classic from which isn't, but that doesn't mean we can't make prediction on what we think will be a classic. Point is, the basement chapter and this latest chapter is the accumulation of older chapters since chapter 1, these are the type of chapters that make or break a series, that makes a series turn from a good series to a masterpiece series or vice versa. That's just "two or three" people out of 200 users who were not amazed by those 3 minutes. I was amazed by Kimetsu, part of the fanbase, and already claiming it as anime classic because of that amazing production buildup of fight in the episode, just like other 200 people in the fanbase is claiming it's anime of the year already. Pretty easy, isn't it? >it will probably take decades from now to find out which series is a classic from which isn't, but that doesn't mean we can't make prediction on what we think will be a classic. Definitely, and similarly, the other way goes too for prediction about not being a classic. So finally admitted that you are wrong when you claimed "it has already cemented place as anime classic", that's great! we can reach an agreement and close this argument. Oh yeah, there are lots of chapters in future which can make or break or series, especially in this case where the series is ambitious and not everything makes sense yet. To downgrade from "decent" to below average series, we don't even need three chapters, and lots of series are examples of that. Maybe a little too early right to predict anything... oh never mind. @Nakamamonogatari Read this post XD that is probably where Eren comes into play. lol The argument here is that you came in this thread because you wanted to start shit, I will say it again, snk will be cemented as a classic anime. Its just that it hasn't happen yet because of time simple as that. Now the thing you don't seem to be getting is that, as I said earlier the majority of persons following this manga is claiming it to be a classic and once the final anime seasons air the majority of the persons will be saying that as well, if they already aren't, these said people will be the one recommending it to newer anime fans and its legacy will continue, we the people right now will decide what will become a classic in the future. This is why I said my statement holds more weight than yours simple because you are in the minority while I am a part of the majority. Yes, every opinion is equal, I do believe in that so I'm not saying that you are wrong, all I am saying is that majority wins unfortunately. There is many classic anime I don't like, cowboy bebop is one of them I don't think it deserve the praise it got, but hey, what can I do about it? I'm a part of the minority in that situation. I will stick with my opinion until I die, but I can't say this series isn't a classic simple because I don't like, it is and I can't do anything about that. Snk currently isn't simple because it hasn't even ended yet for time to start set it in motion, but once it reach that time, in 10 to 20 years from now and persons ask for recommendation for old classic anime and snk will be one of the top picks in most recommendation, you won't be able to argue with that. Just like Eva, I'm using it as a example because of your eva related pic and it is a perfect example of a classic. We the persons now in 2019 were not the ones that decided eva to be a classic, but actually the persons during its time, not to mention the impact it had to the industry during its airing as well. Those carrying it on to newer generation so they can experience it as well and start calling it a classic as well. Snk has the impact, certainly not as big as eva of course and snk has widespread of praise as well, way more than eva on average in this regard, because eva was more on the controversial side, not everyone liked it, it wasn't universally loved like fmab for example, eva became a classic more because of the impact it made for the industry imo than the writing itself. |
keragammingSep 6, 2019 1:17 PM
Sep 7, 2019 12:33 AM
#18
wow, I was hyped for disscussion here only to see some salty guy with rei avatar hijack it completely. great |
Sep 7, 2019 6:19 PM
#19
LoneWalkers said: >boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of Won't really comment on how good are the foreshadowing till everything is tied properly and actually making sense, but this is not the first nor the last time a work with mystery elements has foreshadowing placed throughout the manga and giving them a new meaning towards the end(manga like Pandora hearts,etc). It's only because of so much popularity of this series that an uproar is created, despite some things not making sense at all. ~ Shingeki no Kyojin is known between its fanbase to have huge foreshadowing. I have been here since the start. You probably dont know about shingeki no kyojin fan theories but every time a new chapter cames out, a lot of theories are created. Everyone is like "was that a foreshadow?" I can give you plenty of examples: Eren not following Zeke euthanasia plan was foreshadowed. Armored titan and Colossal Titan true identity was also foreshadowed And finally how shingeki no kyojin ends. Eren is going to activate the rumbling but somehow Armin stops him |
Sep 7, 2019 8:29 PM
#20
Funseco said: LoneWalkers said: >boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of Won't really comment on how good are the foreshadowing till everything is tied properly and actually making sense, but this is not the first nor the last time a work with mystery elements has foreshadowing placed throughout the manga and giving them a new meaning towards the end(manga like Pandora hearts,etc). It's only because of so much popularity of this series that an uproar is created, despite some things not making sense at all. ~ Shingeki no Kyojin is known between its fanbase to have huge foreshadowing. I have been here since the start. You probably dont know about shingeki no kyojin fan theories but every time a new chapter cames out, a lot of theories are created. Everyone is like "was that a foreshadow?" I can give you plenty of examples: Eren not following Zeke euthanasia plan was foreshadowed. Armored titan and Colossal Titan true identity was also foreshadowed And finally how shingeki no kyojin ends. Eren is going to activate the rumbling but somehow Armin stops him Hmmm interesting. I've never seen that third piece of foreshadowing brought up before. It'd be interesting to see how Armin is able to stop the rumbling. |
Sep 7, 2019 8:59 PM
#21
@WillofFire700 Armin wont stop the rumbling it will happen, its literally in the final audio. |
Sep 7, 2019 9:26 PM
#22
keragamming said: @WillofFire700 Armin wont stop the rumbling it will happen, its literally in the final audio. Yeah but do you believe that what Eren said was forshadowing that Armin will play a huge role in saving humanity? |
Sep 9, 2019 6:55 AM
#23
Belizariusz said: wow, I was hyped for disscussion here only to see some salty guy with rei avatar hijack it completely. great What do you expect? The attention whore does this for every thread for this series, imagine being THIS obsessed with a series you clearly don't care for. Anyways, to provide some actual substance unlike the stalking shitposter, I'm certain at this point the entire story about the Devil of All Earth will be linked soon as massive foreshadowing from early on if my theories for what's going to happen next are correct. I truly can't wait to see what's in store, this series has only gotten better and better as time's gone on. I also unironically believe this is the strongest modern example of a classic series in the making (aside from Mob Psycho 100 once the anime finishes adapting the source), and if Isayama nails the ending I sincerely think this'll be one of the all-time greats. |
ModernoirSep 9, 2019 7:00 AM
Sep 10, 2019 8:37 AM
#24
LoneWalkers said: >boy the rewatch value for this series has cemented it as a classic, because the readers/watchers get new perspective of what they thought was the truth only to realise it wasn't base off their perspective of Won't really comment on how good are the foreshadowing till everything is tied properly and actually making sense, but this is not the first nor the last time a work with mystery elements has foreshadowing placed throughout the manga and giving them a new meaning towards the end(manga like Pandora hearts,etc). It's only because of so much popularity of this series that an uproar is created, despite some things not making sense at all. ~ Things not making sense in a mystery is norm. The whole reason for the uproar is the fact that chapter 121 makes no sense at all. But at the same time it makes a lot of sense. |
Sep 15, 2019 9:24 AM
#25
https://youtu.be/InJyM6VFuu4 I don't know as l hadn't even watched AoT but this news was in my recommendation. The author looks rude. I may not enjoy that show but while searching in the aot forums here it looks like it has more focus on mystery than what nitpicking the video did, so l may watch it in future. |
PeetiSep 15, 2019 9:31 AM
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 15, 2019 11:18 AM
#26
Acting as if this is groundbreaking is hilarious though, it's been done over and over and over again... the ''PUT THINGS INTO A NEW PERSPECTIVE THROUGH A SUBVERSION AFTER A LONG TIME OF BUILD-UP OF EXPECTATIONS''. Then again Kerra always does this for Attack on Titan. I can see why someone like LoneWalkers would feel inclined to comment on the opposite side. A lot of really well received series that've been constantly said by fans to be ''TIMELESS CLASSICS'' faded into obscurity with time. Look at Kindaichi Case Files, a series that used to be so big in the 90s, now it's just an obscure show that mostly people who're deliberately looking for something like it watch. (Might I mention that the manga's sold more than Attack on Titan's by an entire 10 million copies?) But yeah, I'm having fun with the way the events are unfolding currently so it was definitely a good thing on Isayama's part to do. Whether it's actually good writing or not, we'll leave it to the future to decide. But I'm having a tough time convincing myself that it's gonna amount to much when the entire show's kept alive by Deus Ex Machina and hamfisted plot twists. Legit, if it wasn't cause of literal unexplainable bullshit, a lot of integral characters should've already been dead. The fact that they're not but should've been logically speaking makes everything past that point seem hard to take seriously. |
Anime List|Manga List | Discord: Azureal#2963 |
Sep 15, 2019 12:05 PM
#27
Peeti said: https://youtu.be/InJyM6VFuu4 I don't know as l hadn't even watched AoT but this news was in my recommendation. The author looks rude. I may not enjoy that show but while searching in the aot forums here it looks like it has more focus on mystery than what nitpicking the video did, so l may watch it in future. I'm not sure if you are trolling here, but that video was a troll video, the subtitles are wrong. XD SigmaticDoc said: Acting as if this is groundbreaking is hilarious though, it's been done over and over and over again... the ''PUT THINGS INTO A NEW PERSPECTIVE THROUGH A SUBVERSION AFTER A LONG TIME OF BUILD-UP OF EXPECTATIONS''. Then again Kerra always does this for Attack on Titan. I can see why someone like LoneWalkers would feel inclined to comment on the opposite side. A lot of really well received series that've been constantly said by fans to be ''TIMELESS CLASSICS'' faded into obscurity with time. Look at Kindaichi Case Files, a series that used to be so big in the 90s, now it's just an obscure show that mostly people who're deliberately looking for something like it watch. (Might I mention that the manga's sold more than Attack on Titan's by an entire 10 million copies?) But yeah, I'm having fun with the way the events are unfolding currently so it was definitely a good thing on Isayama's part to do. Whether it's actually good writing or not, we'll leave it to the future to decide. But I'm having a tough time convincing myself that it's gonna amount to much when the entire show's kept alive by Deus Ex Machina and hamfisted plot twists. Legit, if it wasn't cause of literal unexplainable bullshit, a lot of integral characters should've already been dead. The fact that they're not but should've been logically speaking makes everything past that point seem hard to take seriously. If you don't like it, you don't it's whatever man, we all have series we love that others think its trash, let me praise the series as much as I want, it doesn't hinder your experience at all. I'm not sure why this post is triggering so much people, it's just a fan of any series praising a series they love, nothing new here. I don't think there is anything that hasn't been done before at this point, does that mean we shouldn't praise series anymore for doing these things? Especially when this medium is full of isekai crap and shows full of mostly style but no substance? Also case files has how many volumes compare to attack on titan? Its not that impressive when case files has what over 70+ volumes? Compare to snk 29 volume and only is leading it by 10 million? It just shows how much of a bigger impact snk is to the entire world compare to case file, it has its audience but snk audience is way bigger and snk appeals to more, if you are implying snk wont be a classic, I will certainly disagree with you because snk has already solidify itself as a classic and once the 4th season is release it will put the icing on the cake. |
keragammingSep 15, 2019 12:10 PM
Sep 15, 2019 5:46 PM
#28
keragamming said: I don't know that much about AoT. I thought it was real. The only 3 things l know about it: 1. Monsters, 2. Mystery 3. That video.Peeti said: https://youtu.be/InJyM6VFuu4 I don't know as l hadn't even watched AoT but this news was in my recommendation. The author looks rude. I may not enjoy that show but while searching in the aot forums here it looks like it has more focus on mystery than what nitpicking the video did, so l may watch it in future. I'm not sure if you are trolling here, but that video was a troll video, the subtitles are wrong. XD SigmaticDoc said: Acting as if this is groundbreaking is hilarious though, it's been done over and over and over again... the ''PUT THINGS INTO A NEW PERSPECTIVE THROUGH A SUBVERSION AFTER A LONG TIME OF BUILD-UP OF EXPECTATIONS''. Then again Kerra always does this for Attack on Titan. I can see why someone like LoneWalkers would feel inclined to comment on the opposite side. A lot of really well received series that've been constantly said by fans to be ''TIMELESS CLASSICS'' faded into obscurity with time. Look at Kindaichi Case Files, a series that used to be so big in the 90s, now it's just an obscure show that mostly people who're deliberately looking for something like it watch. (Might I mention that the manga's sold more than Attack on Titan's by an entire 10 million copies?) But yeah, I'm having fun with the way the events are unfolding currently so it was definitely a good thing on Isayama's part to do. Whether it's actually good writing or not, we'll leave it to the future to decide. But I'm having a tough time convincing myself that it's gonna amount to much when the entire show's kept alive by Deus Ex Machina and hamfisted plot twists. Legit, if it wasn't cause of literal unexplainable bullshit, a lot of integral characters should've already been dead. The fact that they're not but should've been logically speaking makes everything past that point seem hard to take seriously. If you don't like it, you don't it's whatever man, we all have series we love that others think its trash, let me praise the series as much as I want, it doesn't hinder your experience at all. I'm not sure why this post is triggering so much people, it's just a fan of any series praising a series they love, nothing new here. I don't think there is anything that hasn't been done before at this point, does that mean we shouldn't praise series anymore for doing these things? Especially when this medium is full of isekai crap and shows full of mostly style but no substance? Also case files has how many volumes compare to attack on titan? Its not that impressive when case files has what over 70+ volumes? Compare to snk 29 volume and only is leading it by 10 million? It just shows how much of a bigger impact snk is to the entire world compare to case file, it has its audience but snk audience is way bigger and snk appeals to more, if you are implying snk wont be a classic, I will certainly disagree with you because snk has already solidify itself as a classic and once the 4th season is release it will put the icing on the cake. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 16, 2019 1:19 AM
#30
l will but you know how hard study is. My speed is watching one episode per day mostly so l will see it in the feuture. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 22, 2019 9:07 PM
#31
Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 22, 2019 10:17 PM
#32
Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. |
Sep 22, 2019 10:24 PM
#33
keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 23, 2019 5:13 AM
#34
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. |
Sep 23, 2019 5:58 AM
#35
keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 23, 2019 2:06 PM
#36
Peeti said: keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. |
Sep 23, 2019 6:54 PM
#37
keragamming said: Hehe, legends also say that you will start watching animu next year in a season which has Christmas.πPeeti said: keragamming said: Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 24, 2019 3:58 PM
#38
Peeti said: keragamming said: Hehe, legends also say that you will start watching animu next year in a season has Christmas.πPeeti said: keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. VS I read 135 chapter 2 years ago it was very normal . is there something new |
Sep 24, 2019 4:44 PM
#39
Peeti said: keragamming said: Hehe, legends also say that you will start watching animu next year in a season which has Christmas.πPeeti said: keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. Yep, Season 4! You got that right! |
Sep 24, 2019 7:15 PM
#40
Hhguf said: I read every manga few years ago. They were super normal, anything new?Peeti said: keragamming said: Peeti said: keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. VS I read 135 chapter 2 years ago it was very normal . is there something new |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 24, 2019 7:17 PM
#41
keragamming said: I had to got it right. After all, I m one of the legends who make these legendary quotes.Peeti said: keragamming said: Peeti said: keragamming said: Doo you like both? I will sea it in footure, very precisely and closely.β
Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. Yeah, I do. I read like 50 chapters of vinland saga a few years back gave it a solid 8/10. Yep, Season 4! You got that right! |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 25, 2019 10:29 PM
#42
keragamming said: I watched 9 episodes of Aot, they are good enuf to hook u. I didn't give it a solid 9 because it deserves better i.e. sexy 9. This series is a sexy π₯ 9 for me. Sad, but as a legend I can't give it a 10.Peeti said: keragamming said: Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. |
"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author). |
Sep 26, 2019 7:12 AM
#43
Peeti said: keragamming said: I watched 9 episodes of Aot, they are good enuf to hook u. I didn't give it a solid 9 because it deserves better i.e. sexy 9. This series is a sexy π₯ 9 for me. Sad, but as a legend I can't give it a 10.Peeti said: keragamming said: You say this is a plot driven series and then there is a character driven series airing i.e. Vinland saga according to you but people say that Characters are one dimensional of both in first season.Peeti said: Will it become as dangerous and horror as one of the best, so I can feel the fear? I want to feel the fear highly high. Yes, yes and yes! I think you will like it. You will have to watch it and make that judgement by yourself. That is good, but it only gets better, I really fell in love with the series when on season 1 episode 17, that is when I knew this series is special and that there is more than meets the eye. |
Sep 29, 2019 10:41 PM
#44
Why is there even a debate on whether this is a classic? It's one of the most sold manga and successful anime of all time. It left a deep impact on the medium and helped make anime mainstream and streaming services become relevant for the industry. And don't even get me started about the quality of the work itself, but a series doesn't have to be necessarily great to be a classic, as many of the said classics are just average. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Oct 4, 2019 11:28 PM
#45
DupeusT31 said: Why is there even a debate on whether this is a classic? It's one of the most sold manga and successful anime of all time. It left a deep impact on the medium and helped make anime mainstream and streaming services become relevant for the industry. And don't even get me started about the quality of the work itself, but a series doesn't have to be necessarily great to be a classic, as many of the said classics are just average. Because some salty MAL contrarians think they know better because they've watched some 90's/80's classics and therefore think their opinions are facts/god's gift to mankind. Always happens, it's best to ignore these tools |
More topics from this board
» 'Even a Child Can Do It': Shonen Jump Editor Calls Out Attack on Titan as Just 'Making a Lot of Noise'deg - Jul 18 |
6 |
by therealnagora
»»
Sep 13, 10:00 AM |
|
» Worst death of the series?Dragevard - May 29, 2021 |
3 |
by Kawaii_Otaku04
»»
Aug 3, 8:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 19 Discussionricardocsc - Oct 2, 2012 |
17 |
by Jeffrey8172
»»
Jul 11, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )keragamming - Jul 6, 2020 |
213 |
by Adam_________
»»
Jun 3, 1:39 PM |
|
» Why do you think the ending was perfect?kiyoymir - May 6, 2021 |
29 |
by HagePotPotato
»»
May 30, 11:25 AM |