| Clearly, the op is one of those types of people who think their favorite anime should be as highly rated as possible. I'll never understand topics like these. It really isn't even that serious. |
Hachiko75 said: Clearly, the op is one of those types of people who think their favorite anime should be as highly rated as possible. I'll never understand topics like these. It really isn't even that serious. You assume but it isn't one of my top anime and I did state it was a good anime but seem just wanted to know why viewers think this anime is cr*p which something I did not pick up upon |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Maybe because it's not that good? |
 |
Renaultclio101 said: Hachiko75 said: Clearly, the op is one of those types of people who think their favorite anime should be as highly rated as possible. I'll never understand topics like these. It really isn't even that serious. You assume but it isn't one of my top anime and I did state it was a good anime but seem just wanted to know why viewers think this anime is cr*p which something I did not pick up upon That's what they all say. "I simply want to know why people think it's a bad show." When your comments clearly state more than that. but that's just me. You're taking this too seriously in my opinion. |
| Let me point this out, the anime is already flawed at the start. "But how?", you say, well the whole story is predictable from the start. I'm not going to spoil anyone here but I'll say it here with my intuition (not yet finished watching), this will end up with Masamune accepting Adagaki and will forget the whole 'revenge' thing. It's so predictable that it's on the level with Nisekoi. I mean the characters are even similar with Nisekoi's. Adagaki = Chitoge, Masamune = Raku, Neko = Tachibana, and etc. All is predictable with the generic harem shit with 'no doubt' that the whole point of the plot (revenge) will be dropped faster than me dropping this shit. |
| This anime isn't the worst show of the season, but this show certainly leaves a little bit bad taste in my mouth. Aside from Yoshino and Futaba, I didn't really like any other characters in this show. Masamune is a little bit of a jerk, Aki is a annoying bitch that did nothing to redeem herself over the course of the entire running time, Neko and Kojuuroo is just kinda there, Gasou and Aki's 3 female friends is annoying and a waste of screentimes, and the others aren't even worth mentioning. The story and the plot is kinda lame and has no idea what it's suppose to be. The "revenge" plot is interesting on paper but that's pretty much the only good thing about the setup of the plot. I didn't hate this show and I kinda like a few things about it, but I really want to like it. The show isn't that good and I expected something better than this. |
| Haha this question again. I remember before when Mob Psycho 100 has a thread like this. Okay, lemme tell you my friend. The airing was just ended last March 23, 2017 so it may means some may wait to finish it like me. Or some have not yet know this anime. So, wait some couple of months if it is still have a low score then it just means that they don't see it like you. |
 |
I'm not a big fan of the secretary character. I find her "Hating on all men" attitude even more annoying than Aki's and I barely remember anything about her other than that. Huex3 said: Actually the revenge plot will depend on the person acting it. In this case it's Makabe. He's trying to get revenge but deep down he's not really a bad person that's why the revenge part became comedic rather than serious. His revenge is more of "proving himself" rather than "hurting Aki". I mean if he's seriously pursuing revenge out of hatred he'd probably use EVERYTHING. Recruit other people who hate Aki, use Futaba and Neko to make Aki jealous, blackmail Aki on her eating habits, etc. The point is the character is just using the revenge as a pretense cause Makabe is also a bit of a tsundere himself. So people saying stuff that "revenge plot is interesting on paper blah blah" probably haven't watch The Count of Monte Cristo (2002) and John Tucker Must Die (2006) movies. I get your point, but the execution could be so much better than what we got. Honestly, your idea of Masamune's revenge to "hurting Aki" plot line sounds more interesting than what we got in my opinion. |
Huex3 said: Fate_warrior95 said: Maybe because it's not that good? It's not as bad as people describe too. I've seen a lot of people who call it "trashy harem" or "generic harem" which clearly isn't the case for the anime. Couldn't agree anymore, seems like a lot of people haven't seen a true harem. For example in most cases , all you would see is an indirect kiss and if the female and male kiss, you either will never see it in the 12 episodes or it never happens until the manga finishes or something |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| It had a pretty interesting start but frankly it's just bad. |
    |
atKatlin said: Haha this question again. I remember before when Mob Psycho 100 has a thread like this. Okay, lemme tell you my friend. The airing was just ended last March 23, 2017 so it may means some may wait to finish it like me. Or some have not yet know this anime. So, wait some couple of months if it is still have a low score then it just means that they don't see it like you. I like to wait until anime finishes airing then I watch it which is the same for this series. Usually when it comes to MAL, it only means 1 thing the anime score will drop. I have never seen it go up once it finishes |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Actually I'm going to correct myself on my previous post. And I'm gonna make this short. This series is actually not that bad if you actually read the manga, judging by the adaptation, the adaptation is actually more of a cliff hanger with a facade to make it look like the author is pulling the 'Nisekoi' game on us but in reality things are much more unique and a deal of fresh air. So please read the manga first after judging the whole series. |
| it is now rated 7, 26 |
 |
| It screamed "Hey, I'm different." but still reverted back to being a sh*tty generic harem. How you can fall for a girl like Adagaki idek... |
Huex3 said: Renaultclio101 said: Couldn't agree anymore, seems like a lot of people haven't seen a true harem. For example in most cases , all you would see is an indirect kiss and if the female and male kiss, you either will never see it in the 12 episodes or it never happens until the manga finishes or something Yeah this is also confusing me. I mean even SNAFU has stronger harem elements than Masamune-Kun no Revenge, and SNAFU is an anime praised for being "Realistic". Hachiman's "loner-ness" is very relatable and realistic. The romance, however, is not. Because for some reason 8-man is the only man the other girls come in contact with... Don't get me wrong tho, SNAFU is very good. I've watched Ranma 1/2 (probably the holy bible of all harems out there) so that probably helps me appreciate this show more. Yeah I agree SNAFU is harem but it is different to this series and don't get me wrong but this series is good but SNAFU is just on another level. It is one of those anime where you can watch it many times and not get bored. I probably seen it 10 times |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Yato-Yaboku said: Actually I'm going to correct myself on my previous post. And I'm gonna make this short. This series is actually not that bad if you actually read the manga, judging by the adaptation, the adaptation is actually more of a cliff hanger with a facade to make it look like the author is pulling the 'Nisekoi' game on us but in reality things are much more unique and a deal of fresh air. So please read the manga first after judging the whole series. I agree with you and that is what I have been saying, people expect with the title "Revenge" to take somewhere in the middle of the plot where I have not seen the manga/LN but can easily tell it is not there yet. I had the same feeling of being similar to Nisekoi and I guess after the revenge it could be a drag on. For example Yamada and the 7 witches that anime finished nicely but the manga just dragged until it got to nowhere and things just jumping out. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
kikyo1hinamora said: it is now rated 7, 26 Sadly 7.24 now and don't even know why people are assuming this anime is the generic harem,romance when 90% of the similar anime are pussies to even attempt a kiss on the cheek or a quick mouth to mouth. Fang said: It screamed "Hey, I'm different." but still reverted back to being a sh*tty generic harem. How you can fall for a girl like Adagaki idek... *quote top line* I used to be a fan of tsundere but not anymore but I like Adagaki's tsundere personality. It comes down to preferences where some like lolicon and others are into different things |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
tragedydesu said: People are tired of generic harems Also they expected a revenge story and not another cliched story about hate turn to love ... Whoever came here expecting that?! I think it was more than obvious what this was going to turn out about, and I m sure we manga readers have told people before, what to expect from this, a generic but entertaining harem, that loses some points when the fatso arrives. |
 |
| it doesn't has any good romance for me I give it a score 7 ... |
 |
| I Actually Enjoyed It,One Of MY Favourites This Season!!!!!!! |
 |
| I guess the reason that in the beginning Musamune wanted to revenge, but he ended falling love with her. And viewers wanted to see his revenge, but the end wasn't as we expected. But honestly I think this anime should be 9/10 or 10/10 |
| The first half of the episode is fine, but the 2nd half is getting farther away from the Plot of the show which is to have revenge on Aki. The 2nd half feels like it's been focused on the two 3rd wheel which is Neko and Gasou, it's feels like the revenge is being forgotten. Plus they must have give Aki some clue that Pig's Foot is actually Masamune Makabe. |
 I am not a friend of justice. I am an enemy of evil. STAPLE STABLE |
| Dahell. I was in high hopes during the early episodes of this anime. But the few last episodes was total shit. I don't want another full season of dumb ass unconnected fillers, just stick with the main plot and give us an ending we are already EXPECTING. WE KNOW WHAT WILL EVENTUALLY HAPPEN, BUT WE WANT TO SEE IT ACTUALLY HAPPEN. #rageover |
| Duh, it's a generic highschool rom com that had no that we've seen hundreds of times |
 "The sun is my enemy, but the moon has been good to me." |
Harbur said: Krasa said: Dahell. I was in high hopes during the early episodes of this anime. But the few last episodes was total shit. I don't want another full season of dumb ass unconnected fillers, just stick with the main plot and give us an ending we are already EXPECTING. WE KNOW WHAT WILL EVENTUALLY HAPPEN, BUT WE WANT TO SEE IT ACTUALLY HAPPEN. #rageover They ended it halfway through the manga and gave us a really crappy ending as well, so OF COURSE the score is gonna be in the garbage. Ikr. The studio thinks we're some kind of dumb fucks who won't be able to figure out what the ending will be or they are milking the show, which is even sadder. The anime would have been a great rom com with an 8-9 score if done properly, but nooo lets add useless fillers here and there, prolong the show and milk the shit out of it. Mokir said: Duh, it's a generic highschool rom com that had no that we've seen hundreds of times Generic rom com can be great if actually done right. Most of us know what we are expecting when watching one. Not all anime has to be wildly different and be a master piece, sometimes we just want to take a break and watch a fun anime, but when we do so we sure as hell expect it to end on a satisfactory note. This one didn't do that, especially since they had such a great premise and my personal opinion great characters. |
| the last few episodes killed it for me. for me it was because of the really poor development. okay, number one, masamune is kinda just a jackass, which is totally fine, but he couldn't even stay a real jackass?? if you get what i mean? he obviously couldn't stick to his initial intention and it's obvious he started really falling for her so it's like "masamune-kun's revenge" MY ASS. he's just a really weak protagonist in my eyes. and even though he sort of changed, i still wouldn't even say that's good character development because by the end of the season, i feel like absolutely nothing changed overall at all. they were in the same spot as in the beginning of the anime which was incredibly disappointing. i really only liked neko (towards the end), the trap, & the fujoshi class rep. |
  ようこそ！ call me sofi. i love bnha & haikyuu!! & bl. dattebayo ！  |
Hachiko75 said: Mokir said: Clearly this user is a pig with one too many dimensions, and should know her place Sadly I think this is the best trolling you can do and I give you 0/10. Try again. @ HikariJake And there's nothing wrong with not liking something the op think is the best thing this season. Where did I say "this series was the best season", I forgot you assume because that is what you think and not facts.I have not even finished this seasons anime yet. Sorry to make you feel butthurt about black butler cause that anime was garbage. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Renaultclio101 said: Hachiko75 said: Sadly I think this is the best trolling you can do and I give you 0/10. Try again. @ HikariJake And there's nothing wrong with not liking something the op think is the best thing this season. Where did I say "this series was the best season", I forgot you assume because that is what you think and not facts.I have not even finished this seasons anime yet. Sorry to make you feel butthurt about black butler cause that anime was garbage. I'm simply going by all your comments that suggest to me you don't like that others don't like the anime. And if you are going to flat out insult someone by trashing an anime they like, you might want to start by looking at the anime they have seen. I don't watch Black Butler so that was just a fail. |
Huex3 said: Krasa said: Ikr. The studio thinks we're some kind of dumb fucks who won't be able to figure out what the ending will be or they are milking the show, which is even sadder. The anime would have been a great rom com with an 8-9 score if done properly, but nooo lets add useless fillers here and there, prolong the show and milk the shit out of it. Generic rom com can be great if actually done right. Most of us know what we are expecting when watching one. Not all anime has to be wildly different and be a master piece, sometimes we just want to take a break and watch a fun anime, but when we do so we sure as hell expect it to end on a satisfactory note. This one didn't do that, especially since they had such a great premise and my personal opinion great characters. Bruh have you even seen the source material for this series? It's barely at 40 chapters and it's already near ending. I agree that they stopped at a crappy spot of the manga tho. It's really dumb they should've just shown the scenes after the school play. Fact is they didn't, and we're going to be forced to watch another full season to receive any closure. |
tragedydesu said: People are tired of generic harems Also they expected a revenge story and not another cliched story about hate turn to love ... Rightly said. I actually was really intrigued by the plot start in which Masamune promises to take revenge on Aki, but then despite all his training, and tough guy act, he couldnt even get closer to her without the help of Aki's maid? That sucked. Not to mention at every critical point she is needed without whom Masamune is totally useless. And what do we have after patiently watching through it to see some actual revenge? He is really in love with her? Then what was the purpose of the whole badass start? |
| Best ending line in anime history = "My name is Saiki Kusuo. I am a psychic." |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Masamune-kun no Revenge Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 23, 2017 |
218 |
by Lkunnnss
»»
Apr 22, 2:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Masamune-kun no Revenge Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 23, 2017 |
371 |
by Fleicher
»»
Apr 18, 4:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Masamune-kun no Revenge Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Feb 16, 2017 |
145 |
by Cheese_Enjoyer07
»»
Jan 2, 5:02 PM |
|
Poll: » Masamune-kun no Revenge Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 9, 2017 |
235 |
by kirA_-_
»»
Dec 27, 2023 2:15 PM |
|
Poll: » Masamune-kun no Revenge Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 2, 2017 |
230 |
by kirA_-_
»»
Dec 20, 2023 4:42 PM |