| first i need to emphasize Overrated =/= Bad MHA Vinland Saga FMA:B all these 3 really doesn't offer anything or enhance any aspect other series of the same genre have. again, i'm not calling them bad its just that i find that they don't deserve the praise they get like #1 at MAL, #1 ongoing series at MAL, or Crunchyroll Awards. |
 |
| Overrated/Bad Hunter X Hunter At the beginning of the anime it is quoted that the world of HxH is full of different creatures, treasures, and unexplored places. I watched 80 episodes and not one bow featured it. I do not understand how people like something I did not buy with the proposal itself ... The name of the anime is "Hunter Hunter" but they barely come out to do bounty hunters and treasure work, it's very meaningless, he doesn't use the Hunter card after getting it. On the Hunter exam Netero asks Hisoka what he wants with the Hunter wallet, Hisoka replies, "I want Hunter license so I can kill without getting arrested." Really? In addition to threatening Netero he says this, they release Hunter License to passers, even a passing child can kill without going to jail. Greed Island Arch. Mindless powers and thrown out of nowhere, and I found it very annoying. Dropei HxH 4 times while watching, is an anime with a cool start but that has no connection, as I mentioned the problems of not complying with the very proposal quoted at the beginning of episode 1, most of the action is very average too. , I honestly do not know what the people saw good in this anime, I saw 80 episodes and nothing much ... |
death604 said: I understand you like FMBH, but honestly I can't like it ... When I watched it, I liked it, I saw it all in 5 days, but over time I didn't like it anymore because of the boring Fandom. And in the end there's a very meaningless inconsistency first i need to emphasize Overrated =/= Bad MHA Vinland Saga FMA:B all these 3 really doesn't offer anything or enhance any aspect other series of the same genre have. again, i'm not calling them bad its just that i find that they don't deserve the praise they get like #1 at MAL, #1 ongoing series at MAL, or Crunchyroll Awards. NOT TO SAY THAT A LOT OF FANBOY CREATES FAKES FOR 10, FULLMETAL WASN'T FIRST ON THE RANK. In this image posted by a moderator in Chihayafuru 3's discussion of fakes giving a rating of 1, we can see the rank without the fakes accounts  |
ProxyLainDec 23, 2019 1:58 PM
ProxyLain said: death604 said: I understand you like FMBH, but honestly I can't like it ... When I watched it, I liked it, I saw it all in 5 days, but over time I didn't like it anymore because of the boring Fandom. And in the end there's a very meaningless inconsistency first i need to emphasize Overrated =/= Bad MHA Vinland Saga FMA:B all these 3 really doesn't offer anything or enhance any aspect other series of the same genre have. again, i'm not calling them bad its just that i find that they don't deserve the praise they get like #1 at MAL, #1 ongoing series at MAL, or Crunchyroll Awards. NOT TO SAY THAT A LOT OF FANBOY CREATES FAKES FOR 10, FULLMETAL WASN'T FIRST ON THE RANK. In this image posted by a moderator in Chihayafuru 3's discussion of fakes giving a rating of 1, we can see the rank without the fakes accounts i find FMA:B overrated like i said in my previous post |
| |
| Underrated: ef: a tale of memories+melodies It has a 8 rating which is pretty good, but I feel it doesn't really get talked about enough in terms of romance anime. Fantastic character development and an emotional story that builds very nicely to each arc's conclusion. Hatsukoi limited Another great romance. Enomoto's growth as a character is particularly good and each relationship feels nicely fleshed out and all reach a satisfying conclusion. Overrated: Shigatsu wa kimi wa uso Sure it's good, but not an almost '9' rated good IMO. There's a lot of melodrama and monologuing that ruins it for me. Kimi no na wa I really just found this average. Don't get me wrong the art and music are amazing but everything else is just lacklustre to me. The romance element has almost no foundation since the characters barely even talk to each other in real life. Forgetting about each other immediately after interactions only further increases the superficiality of the romance. |
| [quote=ProxyLain] death604 said: In this image posted by a moderator in Chihayafuru 3's discussion of fakes giving a rating of 1, we can see the rank without the fakes accounts Stop spreading bullshit! That's reddit's anime list, and all the scores are based on nothing but the votes of Reddit users! http://www.redditanimelist.net/ |
-Aincrad-Dec 24, 2019 8:32 AM
 |
-Aincrad- said: I didn't know, but it doesn't change the fact that I have several fake accounts that gave 10 to FMABProxyLain said: I understand you like FMBH, but honestly I can't like it ... When I watched it, I liked it, I saw it all in 5 days, but over time I didn't like it anymore because of the boring Fandom. And in the end there's a very meaningless inconsistency NOT TO SAY THAT A LOT OF FANBOY CREATES FAKES FOR 10, FULLMETAL WASN'T FIRST ON THE RANK. In this image posted by a moderator in Chihayafuru 3's discussion of fakes giving a rating of 1, we can see the rank without the fakes accounts Stop spreading bullshit! That's reddit's anime list, and all the scores are based on nothing but the votes of Reddit users! http://www.redditanimelist.net/ |
-Aincrad- said: Myanimelist has no control over fake accounts, this is hard to control, for example: Death Note has over one million votes, do you really think a million people voted? an anime that is popular nowadays, on MAL hardly exceeds 500,000 members, and I ask you, where is one million members who voted for Death Note? Dragon Ball and Naruto is much more popular and in MAL has fewer members, look at the FMBH statues and see how much fake it gave 10, I did not know that the image I sent was a comparison of reedit with myanimelist, but as I said, it does not change the fact that it has many fakes that gave 10. One day more than 200k bills fell on the FMBH score, and out of nowhere it came back, myanimelist did not comment on that, these accounts are all fake, the score dropped absurdly from 9.24 to 9.10.ProxyLain said: I understand you like FMBH, but honestly I can't like it ... When I watched it, I liked it, I saw it all in 5 days, but over time I didn't like it anymore because of the boring Fandom. And in the end there's a very meaningless inconsistency NOT TO SAY THAT A LOT OF FANBOY CREATES FAKES FOR 10, FULLMETAL WASN'T FIRST ON THE RANK. In this image posted by a moderator in Chihayafuru 3's discussion of fakes giving a rating of 1, we can see the rank without the fakes accounts Stop spreading bullshit! That's reddit's anime list, and all the scores are based on nothing but the votes of Reddit users! http://www.redditanimelist.net/ |
| Keppeki Danshi! Aoyama-kun comes to my mind. It's a great comedy and it's a really unique story. I don't see many people talk about it, but I love it and I watched it twice. |
RadicalEntity said: NamikazeHime said: Keppeki Danshi! Aoyama-kun comes to my mind. It's a great comedy and it's a really unique story. I don't see many people talk about it, but I love it and I watched it twice. I like watching sports anime sometimes as it's pretty much slice of life (my favorite genre) to me. So maybe I'll give this one a try! Then you are gonna love this one, sport is not really a center of the story, it is a pure SoL. |
| Hyouge Mono - Historical/Samurai/Seinen. For anyone who loves historical and historical fiction period piece war dramas, art history, or military history. It's an exploration and really novel look at the late Sengoku period from the height of Oda Nobunaga's reign to Toyotomi Hideyoshi, the influence of historical figures like Sen no Rikyu and the tea ceremony on Japanese politics and many different aspects of life of the era, the reach of wabi-sabi philosophy in Japanese aesthetics, balance between the military government, daimyo, and ther merchants, etc. It does something pretty unusual because it looks at a series of conflicts that are usually only portrayed in military terms from the vantage point of art and the art movements; sometimes paintings and architecture, but with emphasis on pottery and its ritualistic uses. See what life was like for an ordinary daimyo who ascended the ranks in such a close look it can feel bordering on a Slice of Life at times. As well as how immersion in the arts could shape a person's whole worldview. It's very slow and detailed, but also with an air of satire and moments of black comedy and humor punctuated throughout. If you love history and films like Seven Samurai, The Last Samurai, etc. you'll probably get a lot out of this. Petshop of Horrors - Horror/Josei/Mystery/Supernatural. An episodic horror verging on anthology because there are only two main returning characters with an entirely different supporting cast and situation each episode, so it feels a bit reminiscent of Mushishi in that way. An otherworldly pet store in Los Angeles' Chinatown filled with creatures that you're not sure whether they're animal, mystical, or from some other dimension, run by a suave businessman who seems inhuman. Each episode a person desperate to recover from personal loss of a loved one or with desire or ambition comes hastily to the store and is given their heart's desire, but with specific instructions. People are dying in the city and the store is under investigation by a detective agency. Each episode can function as a kind of morality play. The Twilight Zone of anime. Beware that it's super short at only four episodes and apparently there's a lot more content in the manga. Angel Cop - Action/Sci-Fi/Police. Another short series. This time a six episode OVA. It was released at the end of the 80s ('89) but ran until the mid 90s and very much feels like an 80s/early 90s dystopian action thriller of the time that at one level is a gory shoot 'em up/splatter suspense with crowd appeal and on another is a political allegory with a heavy conspiracy theory bent. Reminds me of Total Recall, Demolition Man, They Live, and the Terminator series. About an alternative near-future (near-future to when it was released; now it would be in our past) in which Japan is a superpower with the world's largest GDP. Follows a specialized counter-terrorism police unit with a doctor on staff who is giving cybernetic enhancements a la GitS/SAC. There are a series of terrorist attacks across Tokyo, but a group of vigilantes with extrasensory and psychic abilities like pyrokinesis begin hunting the terrorists and start a conflict with the police unit. The terrorists may be agents of a foreign plot, the Japanese government may be corrupt/complicit, and there are strong dystopic/rotten world vibes. Similar to with Petshop, don't watch if you can't handle older animation that looks very 80s and early 90s, or controversial material. Aishiteruze Baby - Comedy/Drama/Romance/Shoujo. Should also be tagged as a Slice of Life really. It's funny. Usagi Drop, an anime I love, is up there as the number one Josei title, is very well known and well-regarded, and this is the closest anime I've found yet to it and somehow I rarely see it mentioned or acknowledged anywhere in any way. The best idea I could give to what it's like is that it's like watching a family sitcom and dramedy with a hefty Coming-of-Age undercurrent. Both Coming of Age for the older male lead and the young female lead. A highschool senior who is supposed to be 17-18 lives a pretty carefree life in his later days of HS, going out and drifting between different girls and doing what he pleases, but then his aunt abandons her daughter, his six year-old cousin, at their family home, and he is charged with the responsibility by his mom and older sister of raising her for an indeterminate period of time until her mother comes back. He has to totally rearrange his daily schedule and high school life, and comes to relate to his family in a different way and see his own life/future differently. This is like Usagi Drop if Daikichi was a high school teenager instead of a 30 year-old salaryman and if it were more than twice the length, with albeit a slighty messier execution without as good art style. Ie Naki Ko Remy - Adventure/Slice of Life/Historical/Drama. A World Masterpiece Theater anime (they generally adapt classic novels to anime) based on the 1878 French novel Sans Famille. A young girl in the French countryside is forced to go on a journey around the country with a traveling troupe led by an older man with a group of animals (a monkey and a few dogs) who travel by wagon. This is after her father returns from extended work in another part of the country and disowns her, telling her she's not his real daughter and forcing her out of the house. They go from many hardships and episodes which can have a leisurely pace just showing life on the road, singing or juggling in the marketplace to where it can get very dark with the group's safety threatened where they deal with thieves and criminals, homelessness, and other challenges, but they become more like a family as they make their quest. |
WatchTillTandavaDec 24, 2019 1:04 PM
| Hidamari no Ki It's adapted from a Tezuka manga and has a very interesting and unique storyline, following a doctor and a samurai through the final years or the Tokugawa period. It covers all the big events, people, struggles, issues and changing values of the time period while never stopping to be a personal drama with the doctor MC being based on Tezuka's own great-grandfather. Anyone interested in that historical time period should give it a try, it's quite interesting to see it through the lens of a doctor trying to make western medicine more accepted at a time when eastern medicine was dominant. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| I think Naruto is an underrated anime that isn’t talked about enough. It is objectively the greatest anime ever, and how it’s not unanimously respected as such baffles me. |
| Lolicons are scum. BABYMETAL is more metal than Metallica. Naruto is objectively the best anime ever. HxH 99' is decent. HxH 11' is bad. |
| 2019 Most Underrated 1. Babylon (8/10) 2. Beastars (8/10) 3. Dororo (6/10) 4. One Punch Man S2 (5/10) 2019 Most Overrated |
 |
| I think snk is underrated because it ain't number 1, until it becomes number 1 it will be underrated in my mind. It still isn't getting the respect I feel it deserve. Yes, its in the top 5 but that ain't enough. Hopefully season 4 gets the number 1 spot just to trigger these mal users more. |
| It's the most bog-standard generic faceless shounen action series that inexplicably gets money thrown at it. The very image of a 5/10 show that causes your eyes to glaze over and your jaw to slacken when exposed to it. |
 This glorious signature image was created by @Mayumi! I am the Arbiter of Absolute Truth, and here is my wisdom: "Anime was always influenced by the West. This is not news. Shoujo is the superior genre primarily aimed at young people. Harem/isekai are lazy genres that refuse any meaningful innovation. There is no 'Golden Age.' There will always be top-shelf anime. You should be watching Carole & Tuesday." |
| I personally enjoy it quite a bit. People on this website are very vocal about things they dislike, and people who do enjoy it either don't go on the forums or just don't bring it up so they won't be shit on. |
 |
| I was only able to stomach about 20 episodes of it meanwhile I finished Bleach despite thinking it was bad. So, that should tell you how I felt towards FT. |
What a beautiful Duwang |
| As someone with the biggest love-hate relationship with the series, I can perfectly understand why anyone would love it. There is definitely plenty of fun to be had and the entertainment value is there if you can switch off, but HOLY SHIT, I hope my 12 year old sister can write better than Mashima, good lord! I'm pretty sure he writes some of these arcs just to pass the time while he's taking a shit! It's actually sad lmao |
 |
ShaGray said: I guess everybody has their own opinion, I actually dropped Bleach I thought it was too boring Trust me I was on the verge of it multiple times myself lol |
| What a beautiful Duwang |
| Yeah, I'm with ya. I don't think it's all that good, but some people treat it like it's the devil when it's like mediocre at worst. It's enjoyable enough for what it is, and that you've found something that you can like regardless of its flaws. |
| "If it's not big, it's only a bust," some guy on the internet |
| It's honestly not that bad even though I dropped the manga back in 2012. I do plan on going back and finishing it eventually. I wouldn't worry about fans saying it's garbage or make fun of you for liking it. Fairy Tail has a lot of issues but it still is an entertaining show if you aren't overly critical about it. It's just a fun Shounen, it isn't trying to be Hunter X Hunter or My Hero Academia. Fairy Tail knows it's strengths which is fun characters and fan service and runs with it. I don't really think it deserves the hate it gets to be honest. |
| While the start isn't that bad, the further on in the show the worse it gets, resulting in probably one of the worst endings I've seen in a long running shounen. |
 |
| The reason why I hate it with passion is because that shit actually had potential I hate to see wasted potential like that. |
 β Aoishiβ βΏMy Profile βΏMyAnimeList βΏMyMangaList |
| It's not as bad as some people say it is, but it's not that great either. It get pretty repetitive with them over coming any challenge with the power of friendship (pretty cringy I agree) |
FakegooseFeb 7, 2020 2:03 PM
 "Do you know why snow is white? Because it's forgotten what color it's supposed to be." - C.C. |
| Bad? It isn't that bad if it's the first shounen fight anime you watch. Perhaps it's bad because it's derivative. Derivative means that it's a copy, imitation, of many that came before it, but you're not necessarily going to recognize it unless you've seen many examples to compare. I've been watching these long-running shows since Yu Yu Hakusho or DBZ, and I can say they're all kind of bad. Their goodness depends on what they do with the 10% of the originality they have control over. I guess people don't think Fairy Tale exercised its originality. But if you haven't gotten tired of the hero rising from the ashes against all odds and finding new power in dopamine and uncontrollable rage that breaks his body but he miraculously gets revived after every battle as if nothing ever happened structure (jk, I'm not far enough into Fairy Tale to know the prevalence of that), then you might still enjoy it. |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
| Never seen it. It doesn't look like it's for me. The art style doesn't stand out and it looks a bit generic, however looking at a trailer the animation looks top quality, and the scenery is very nice looking. If I did watch it I'm sure I would enjoy that aspect of it. |
| I dislike it mostly because I tend to hate all the long term shows, I can't stand them, they're too boring. I get to know FT because my little sister is very, very fond to it and since we live in the same house it is almost impossible not to get updated of this specific series. I mean, It is not THAT bad but the ecchi ruins it for me. I could say it has some entertaining arcs but that's just about it, only some parts is interesting to read but not in the whole. Also think too the Finale was a pretty decent one regardless of the hard criteria it received. If i were to recommend FT I would recommend you to read the manga mostly because it doesn't indulge as much as the anime does. |
 Manga Challenge βΈβ« βΈ Imdb |
| Everything about it screams overwhelmingly mediocre. I never call something "bad" without seeing it, but I can spot mediocrity from a mile away. |
 "I am not sure that I exist, actually. I am all the writers that I have read, all the people that I have met, all the women that I have loved; all the cities I have visited." β Jorge Luis Borges [url=]Goodreads[/url] | [url=]Letterboxd[/url] |
| The thing with Fail Tail, is that the adaption coud have been a lot better. If the studio woud have changed a few thing. Make it darker, people dies, that life, they don't came back to life 24/7 as they do in Fail Tail. People shoud have die more in the show too, to add in drama. But no, how many times did the guild leader of Fail Tail die and come back to life ? more times then I can count with my hands. I love fanservice, it's one of the best treats the anime world have to offer. But, you don't need fanservice to happen all the time. Fail Tail has more fanservice in the 10 first eps then DxD has in the whole anime serie. Friendship, is awlays nice, but it can't over come everything as it does in Fail Tail. I'm seeing a huge potential with Fairy Tail, but it failed. It's just a okej shounen, but it coud have been so much better. And if you think friendship and fanservice is the best a battleshounen has to offer. Then good for you. No one can force you to hate Fail Tail if you enjoy watching. I think people shoud enjoy what they want and ignor what the rest of the community thinks. If you shoud ignor you'r own feelings you will just get burned out and stop watching anime. And start hating it, lol. But if you'r Mal profile is up to date, you have for sure a lot of shows to watch. And you might understand at one point, that Fail Tail coud have been better if they woud have taking parts from another shows. And like I said above, ignor the retards that are telling you not to enjoy a show that you love. x) |
 |
| Ahhh. Well you seem to also like seven deadly sins which is another mediocre anime so maybe fairy tail is right up your alley? |
| @ShaGray. Well it exist way worse shows out there for sure. But people love to shit on everything they can. I just think it's sad that a show with this amount of eps and potential ended as it did. Chaning a few thing coud have made it beat the big three, but it didn't happen and will never will. And the best thing is to ignor what the people think in this community, as long as it's not FMAB, Death Note and JoJo everything else is trash. That's how MaL is build up on, bot account and some trashy shounen that is taking over the world. That's why it's pointless to care what the rest of the community think's. |
|
| Nope, it was actually a pretty good show until the end of Grand Magic Games Arc. After that it went downhill. But I did enojy first hundred or so episodes quite a lot. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Which is your favourite Anime in this list?PushedCaraway - Yesterday |
40 |
by rohan121
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» MULTIPLE UNRELATED anime that you think could be set in the same anime universeIpreferEcchi - 2 hours ago |
10 |
by Catalano
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» βοΈ Anime Winter 2024 Male Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 4 5 )ISeeLifePeople - Apr 14 |
235 |
by perseii
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» What will be the next KyoAni project? Tell me your thoughts. ( 1 2 )Pinoffin - Yesterday |
60 |
by Pinoffin
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» Anime adaptation wish listkuroneko99 - Apr 5 |
29 |
by Hitagi__Furude
»»
16 minutes ago |