xShinigami3125 said: It's subjective. A show you might rate 10/10 can be a 1/10 for me. There is no objectively good anime. The question is about what show truly is overrated like Gintama which is exclusively watched by their fans therefore only receive positive rating. Or just any show which receive unnecessary exaggerated amount of hype like MHA. |
| I think that Your Name , Boku no hero, Shingeki no kyojin , Mirai Nikki , SAO , Naruto , Dragon Ball ( The whole saga if you can say so),No game no life and would keep saying but I'll take a long post well although I like some |
 |
| This is actually the first time I see a thread like this... Go to forums type "overrated" in that search bar and you can see a thread like this created at least once in every two or three weeks... |
Hrybami said: xShinigami3125 said: It's subjective. A show you might rate 10/10 can be a 1/10 for me. There is no objectively good anime. The question is about what show truly is overrated like Gintama which is exclusively watched by their fans therefore only receive positive rating. Or just any show which receive unnecessary exaggerated amount of hype like MHA. If gintama has a high rating because it's exclusively watched by their fans then how do you explain the unnatural amount of 1/10 scores given by haters? |
| ppl don't think their opinions be wrong, but it do. |
AlanWeebus said: Hrybami said: The question is about what show truly is overrated like Gintama which is exclusively watched by their fans therefore only receive positive rating. Or just any show which receive unnecessary exaggerated amount of hype like MHA. If gintama has a high rating because it's exclusively watched by their fans then how do you explain the unnatural amount of 1/10 scores given by haters? Well they are most likely bots accounts. What else? But with the stats given by MAL it's hard to see that there are bots in both side also boosting gintama score with multiple 10's. Really, it's a pointless war so I give no importance. |
| These ones: Katanagatari TV · 2010 Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon TV · 2017 Ookami to Koushinryou TV · 2008 Golden Time TV · 2013 One Punch Man TV · 2015 One Outs TV · 2008 Hunter x Hunter (2011) TV · 2011 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood TV · 2009 Fate/Zero TV · 2011 Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch ;) |
| One Punch Man. Death Note. Sword Art Online. Attack on Titan. |
| FMAB Code:Geass Boku no Hero Academia Koe no Katachi Angel Beats Gintama Tokyo Ghoul Sora yori mo Tooi Basho Shingeki no Kyojin Jojo HunterXHunter Made in Abyss ....................... |
joshua10redAug 27, 2018 7:10 AM
 |
Hrybami said: xShinigami3125 said: It's subjective. A show you might rate 10/10 can be a 1/10 for me. There is no objectively good anime. The question is about what show truly is overrated like Gintama which is exclusively watched by their fans therefore only receive positive rating. Or just any show which receive unnecessary exaggerated amount of hype like MHA. Then how is the first season the 15th best anime of all time according to MAL? Surely that wasn't only watched by fans. Anyway, a show can never be overrated or underrated. You may, subjectively, believe that it is. But in the end a score is merely a numeric representation of the opinions of the people who watched it. If the people say it's a 9, it's a 9. That's all there is to it. Unless people are making alt accounts en masse to manipulate the votes -- and I'm pretty sure the MAL staff would notice if that happened -- or voting simply to promote a meme, without even watching the anime (Pingu), the score is never wrong. |
AllHailLelouch87 said: I think "overrated" is a very subjective term. What you find overrated may be even underrated for other person. Personally, I find Violet Evergarden to be very overrated. It has an 8.59 score in this website, and I can't really understand why. Yes, its visuals are outstanding, but... its story is only made to make you cry because of "feelings", and besides Violet Evergarden, there is no development for other characters. Heck, they all have the same personality. I think you are wrong but I still respect your opinion. I think VE is a great piece and deserves way more than it did. Yeah I don't like the characters either but that's it. I love the story and how it unfolds. I adore the concept and always think about how hard it would be to write something with that concept. And I binged the series when I had the Netflix subscription (F to that). I think you should also think about it. |
-Lightsbane- said: Hrybami said: The question is about what show truly is overrated like Gintama which is exclusively watched by their fans therefore only receive positive rating. Or just any show which receive unnecessary exaggerated amount of hype like MHA. Then how is the first season the 15th best anime of all time according to MAL? Surely that wasn't only watched by fans. What do you mean by that? Of course the first season is mostly rated by fans. At least you really need to tolerate it if you manage to sit through 200 eps. Which is mainly different from a single cours anime where basically anybody could input a score. I mean think about it for a second. |
Hrybami said: -Lightsbane- said: Then how is the first season the 15th best anime of all time according to MAL? Surely that wasn't only watched by fans. What do you mean by that? Of course the first season is mostly rated by fans. At least you really need to tolerate it if you manage to sit through 200 eps. Which is mainly different from a single cours anime where basically anybody could input a score. I mean think about it for a second. But you don't need to watch all 200 episodes to register a vote, right? I mean, I don't know how many you would actually need to watch for your vote to count, but I'm pretty sure it's not 100%. |
| Kimi No Na Wa is good but a bit overrated ReZero too |
-Lightsbane- said: Hrybami said: What do you mean by that? Of course the first season is mostly rated by fans. At least you really need to tolerate it if you manage to sit through 200 eps. Which is mainly different from a single cours anime where basically anybody could input a score. I mean think about it for a second. But you don't need to watch all 200 episodes to register a vote, right? I mean, I don't know how many you would actually need to watch for your vote to count, but I'm pretty sure it's not 100%. It's actually 40 episodes, but people rarely rate something when they haven't watched the whole thing first. And people who didn't like it at first don't usually bother with Gintama at all. So it leaves mainly only rooms for the fans to input their score and most of them rate 10 to everything gintama related. |
| Hunter X Hunter 2011, pretty much any anime that worshiped by normies. |
 |
| Technically every show that is both popular and high-scoring is overrated on MAL due to the broken scoring system that takes an aggregate of everyone. It also doesn't take the scores of people who dropped the show early on so its just flooded with positive reviews. Even so I do think there are a lot of shows that got waaaaay to much praise for what they deserved. A few anime that are a personal peeve of mine when I see way too many people praised a heavily flawed show would be: Erased-Sseriously, guys? An 8.55? This is why we can't have nice things... Kokoro Connect- Seeing people say they relate to the characters makes me cringe. Another- If everyone can agree that its a comedy, then that'll be fine and done. But people actually take this show seriously. Fate/Stay Night UBW- Played the VN route. It kind of sucked. Watched the anime. It really sucked. Noragami- People overlook the flaws in this show too much in favor of its (admittedly great) action scenes. Girls und Panzer- This show got a serious following. Just really stupid at times but it has waifus so it's completely fine. |
 Latest reviews: Wonder Egg Priority and A Couple of Cukoos |
Hrybami said: People rarely rate something when they haven't watched the whole thing first. I don't buy that for a second. People have no problem rating things they've dropped. I certainly don't. Sorry, but your whole supposition seems to be built on very shaky ground. It looks more like you have a personal problem with Gintama being in the Top 20. |
| This topic is disgustingly overrated. |
  xx0:44 ─🔘────────────── 04:44x ◀ xxxxxxxxx ❚❚ xxxxxxxxx ►xxxx |
| None, since overrated is a dumb buzzword. |
 |
wtf? are you implying that because erased got a high score we can't have nice animes? the hell tell me, I missunderstood right? |
Zehennagel said: wtf? are you implying that because erased got a high score we can't have nice animes? the hell tell me, I missunderstood right? Okay I was just kind of joking on that one. But Erased was an affront to the mystery/psychological genre which is already quite rare in anime. So if everyone expressed they loved it for reasons that I fail to comprehend, the anime industry would observe this and turn out more of the stuff that made it so flawed in the first place, hence, we wouldn't get any good mystery/psychological shows. But thank goodness the show was a flavor of the week and people left it as soon as it ended. |
| Latest reviews: Wonder Egg Priority and A Couple of Cukoos |
| anything that's popular and that I don't like is overrated. seriously, overrated is such a dumb term. well, in how it's used, imo. see, if someone watches a show that's popular and they don't like it, they will say "it's overrated" it never engages discussion, it isn't critisism. you've got to justify using it, otherwise it's just an insult."this show sucks" is exactly the same (well that's how the word is used most of the time and why I hate it. it's the same as saying "it sucks") UrbanSpaceman said: There is no overrated shows, there are popular shows that you don't like. agreed. |
raisin-kun said: Zehennagel said: wtf? are you implying that because erased got a high score we can't have nice animes? the hell tell me, I missunderstood right? Okay I was just kind of joking on that one. But Erased was an affront to the mystery/psychological genre which is already quite rare in anime. So if everyone expressed they loved it for reasons that I fail to comprehend, the anime industry would observe this and turn out more of the stuff that made it so flawed in the first place, hence, we wouldn't get any good mystery/psychological shows. But thank goodness the show was a flavor of the week and people left it as soon as it ended. ho okay, i get it. well indeed, without SAO who knows, we might not have that many isekai harem 12 episodes futureless animes every seasons. |
| Steins:Gate and Your name. One gets away with too many conveniences. The other is still the 2nd best rated anime on MAL just because it was one of the most widely relleased anime in the west for a while and every newcommer jumped on it and declared it the best anime movie they have ever seen. From these 2, I'd give Steins;Gate a pass for many reasosns, but Your name?! That mediocre rom-com that destroys it's story in the second half is nowhere near worthy of the 2nd place. |
| Welcome to club: Anime that Should Continue http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=37045 |
Sonal1988 said: UrbanSpaceman said: There is no overrated shows, there are popular shows that you don't like. Not true. I enjoyed FMAB and S;G, but the hype surrounding them is nauseating. that doesn't mean it's overrated? I too, liked these shows (gave a 7 and a 8) but the fact that it's getting so much hype is just because they're popular. SAO too, is getting hype but it's far from overrated since so many people hate it. |
Zehennagel said: that doesn't mean it's overrated? I too, liked these shows (gave a 7 and a 8) but the fact that it's getting so much hype is just because they're popular. SAO too, is getting hype but it's far from overrated since so many people hate it. Getting excessive hype is basically a show being overrated, unless the hype is negative, like in the case of that imouto anime that came out last year. People praise it as being better than it actually is, and the hype snowballs into said shows becoming "Classics" or "gems" in their genres. As for SAO, it's like the Kardashians - people just love to shit on it bc it's the popular thing to do. Well, that's what I think, anyway. |
  |
| https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1504768&show=1800 Go here and you'll find 30+ pages worth of answers have fun |
 |
BirthOfVenus said: I agree that Gintama is the most overrated anime. You didn't even watch it correctly and you're calling it overrated? |
|
| Clannad and To aru Index. Railgun is borderline for me, but it was much more enjoyable watching compared to a MC who is always handed a silver plate of victory. |
-Lightsbane- said: Hrybami said: People rarely rate something when they haven't watched the whole thing first. I don't buy that for a second. People have no problem rating things they've dropped. I certainly don't. Sorry, but your whole supposition seems to be built on very shaky ground. It looks more like you have a personal problem with Gintama being in the Top 20. I don't have a problem with gintama being in the top 20 since I don't hate that anime and it's up to you to acknowledge the protection given to sequel and longer show. You just have to browse the statistic page of any anime and you'll see that people don't often give a score before completed the show. |
Hrybami said: -Lightsbane- said: I don't buy that for a second. People have no problem rating things they've dropped. I certainly don't. Sorry, but your whole supposition seems to be built on very shaky ground. It looks more like you have a personal problem with Gintama being in the Top 20. I don't have a problem with gintama being in the top 20 since I don't hate that anime and it's up to you to acknowledge the protection given to sequel and longer show. You just have to browse the statistic page of any anime and you'll see that people don't often give a score before completed the show. Then I don't get why stuff like Dragon Ball Super is rated so low. Practically not even in the Top 1000, let alone 20. If it's only the hardcore fans watching hundreds of episodes to rate these shows, it should be a lot higher. |
UrbanSpaceman said: There is no overrated shows, there are popular shows that you don't like. Finally, someone who understands. If 8 out of 10 people like an anime then the remaining two cannot say (technically they can and a lot do) that the anime is overrated. It's popular and you don't like it, deal with it. |
Sonal1988 said: Zehennagel said: that doesn't mean it's overrated? I too, liked these shows (gave a 7 and a 8) but the fact that it's getting so much hype is just because they're popular. SAO too, is getting hype but it's far from overrated since so many people hate it. Getting excessive hype is basically a show being overrated, unless the hype is negative, like in the case of that imouto anime that came out last year. People praise it as being better than it actually is, and the hype snowballs into said shows becoming "Classics" or "gems" in their genres. As for SAO, it's like the Kardashians - people just love to shit on it bc it's the popular thing to do. Well, that's what I think, anyway. overpopularity and overrated is different. well, I don't think you didn't know that but I said it just in case. I personnaly hated kiseiju and found it shit because the characters were absolutely obnoxious to me, but it is highly praised and popular, that doesn't mean it's overrated, in my opinion. people don't praise it for being better than it is. it's just they liked it more than you think it's good(if that make sense) wow that post was a clusterfuck and I just threw a brunch of ideas without any coordination. well you'll understand. |
-Lightsbane- said: Hrybami said: I don't have a problem with gintama being in the top 20 since I don't hate that anime and it's up to you to acknowledge the protection given to sequel and longer show. You just have to browse the statistic page of any anime and you'll see that people don't often give a score before completed the show. Then I don't get why stuff like Dragon Ball Super is rated so low. Practically not even in the Top 1000, let alone 20. If it's only the hardcore fans watching hundreds of episodes to rate these shows, it should be a lot higher. If you want to compare the popularity of both Gintama and Dragon Ball you'll notice that dragon ball is not exclusively watched by hardcore fans. The first season of Gintama and Dragon Ball Z have about the same amount of members on MAL. Gintama is 94th most popular anime on MAL while DBZ is the 71st. So by these numbers Dragon Ball is more popular than Gintama. But the other statistic show that Gintama (although having less members) has about 2 times the number of dropped of DBZ and about 3 times less completed also compared to DBZ. That means that yes non-gintama fans are having more difficulties going trough something like Gintama as opposed as something like Dragon Ball. I've not seen Dragon Ball super so I don't know how it turned out, but seeing how so many people have managed to go trough dragon ball Z, I see no reason as to why Dragon Ball Super should be only watched by hardcore fans. Also when trying to compare it to Gintama which had significant difficulties gathering its audience within the first season, this doesn't make much sense to me. Or maybe there are less hardcore DB fans than hardcore Gintama fans, idk. Also what's overrated in gintama is the latter seasons which receive ridiculous sequel effect. (I actually prefer Gintama over Dragon ball just so you know). |
| Your Name - Average movie that is touted as some masterpiece. Your Lie in April - Painfully over dramatic and hard to take seriously. Massively overrated show |
 |
TTagain said: i agree, although I love the show its lacking in multiple areas. the plot is good but progresses very slowly and some episodes feel like filler.. Don't @ me bros and sis but my answer is My hero academia. |
Agree  |
| re:zero Its so bad imo characters like rem and emilia are very ordinary and pp keep calling them best girls the plot is insanely mundane and the graphics are very average the op and ed are quite unique tho |
More topics from this board
» What's an anime that didn't meet your expectations, and what's an anime that exceeded them? ( 1 2 )JKKH - Jul 18, 2022 |
61 |
by Ricchan__
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Is it over for newcomer boomers?LenRea - Apr 24 |
28 |
by LenRea
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » hate watching ( 1 2 )deg - Apr 14 |
50 |
by alshu
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Which is your favourite Anime in this list?PushedCaraway - 6 hours ago |
24 |
by Ricchan__
»»
30 minutes ago |
|
» Is watching a show for the cute girl weird?fallout45 - 2 hours ago |
11 |
by Horizon248
»»
31 minutes ago |