| Maybe I'm a little biased when saying this because KyoAni is my all-time favorite animation studio, but I don't get why seemingly everyone (on MAL) is bashing their rather new shows. Not a bit. I'm talking of Kyoukai no Kanata, Amaburi, Free! and so on. When it comes to Tamako Market I can understand the rather low opinions, but especially Kyoukai no Kanata which I absolutely loved experienced so much hate for -in my opinion- no reason. Also, many people say ,the quality has been decreasing heavily throughout the last years. I don't see any reason for this, too. Even only judging from the animation-point-of-view, they made huge progress, didn't they? And I also see no big dramatic losses. |
 |
| Kyoukai no Kanata has a weak plot. Amagi Brilliant Park doesn't get hate (unless it's from me). Free! has topless bishounen and most anime watchers are scared of the gay cooties. Tamako Market is moe with no substance. |
| Mostly because it sucks. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| Well they make stuff pretty I guess |
   I envy your delusion; I wish I could live in it  |
| Because they have never made a good Anime. |
 |
| I can insult their older shows too, if you'd like @OP |
| Cause they are not Gainax, hence, they deserve to be hated. |
| Honestly, I don't even look at which studio created what anime. But anyway, Kyoto Animation's stories are okay. I wouldn't say I like them or hate them. Their art isn't bad either. mayukachan said: Kyoukai no Kanata has a weak plot. Amagi Brilliant Park doesn't get hate (unless it's from me). Free! has topless bishounen and most anime watchers are scared of the gay cooties. Tamako Market is moe with no substance. Basically this |
 |
Mikotoba said: mayukachan said: I'm sure this is true from how people talk about it here. Free! has topless bishounen and most anime watchers are scared of the gay cooties. I've heard kyoani shows don't have very strong stories..? (out of their recent shows, i've only seen free!) I won't deny that the art looks great, though. Free! is the one with the strong story (if we're talking about Eternal Summer) but the rest are more comedy and moe-featured, so yeah. |
| kyoani is awesome, the haters just don't understand |
 |
| 2muchmoe4MAL |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
| They make boring shows |
 |
| No effort put in their shows |
| Because people are just jelly of AS's rank. |
Hulohot said: Cause they are not Gainax, hence, they deserve to be hated. To be fair, Gainax hasn't really done anything good either. |
|
Working_Designs said: NGE, nuff saidHulohot said: Cause they are not Gainax, hence, they deserve to be hated. To be fair, Gainax hasn't really done anything good either. |
| For me it has a lot to do with how their animation is so supreme, but their stories/plots don't seem to match up in quality most times. |
Cakedog said: Working_Designs said: To be fair, Gainax hasn't really done anything good either. The difference is Gainax will always have NGE and FLCL to fall back on. And TTGL. |
Erokirin said: For me it has a lot to do with how their animation is so supreme, but their stories/plots don't seem to match up in quality most times. |
Cakedog said: Hulohot said: And TTGL. I would have mentioned that but a lot of people seem to be split on whether or not it's any good. True, but it's still high ranked here in MAL (not that it matters) |
laraes said: mayukachan said: I can insult their older shows too, if you'd like @OP If it's honest opinion, feel free to do so Well, honestly I don't see them as "getting worse" since there's been a few notable ones recently like Eternal Summer, Hyouka, and Tamako Love Story. Their most popular works (Nichijou, Haruhi, K-ON, Lucky Star, Clannad) are all mediocre to me, but I think my opinion is unpopular. |
Feaor said: Because people are just jelly of AS's rank. |
| I just don't get WHY their stories are supposed to be bad or mediocre. Free! has an awesome plot to say the least. Aside from that, I think story is not everything. |
| |
| Cause 90% of their made anime is lame. The only thing that's good from them are Haruhi series ( S2 doe, ehh ). And Free maybe since a tad different and hilarious. |
 |
Hulohot said: Cakedog said: The difference is Gainax will always have NGE and FLCL to fall back on. And TTGL. NGE, FLCL, and TTGL are overrated garbage. |
|
mayukachan said: laraes said: If it's honest opinion, feel free to do so Well, honestly I don't see them as "getting worse" since there's been a few notable ones recently like Eternal Summer, Hyouka, and Tamako Love Story. Their most popular works (Nichijou, Haruhi, K-ON, Lucky Star, Clannad) are all mediocre to me, but I think my opinion is unpopular. Actually I have pretty much the same opinion. (Nichijou was great though) |
| |
John_h said: Cakedog said: No one really hates Kyoukai no Kanata, Amaburi, or Free!. They get hate for Clannad, Haruhi and K-On!, titles that get unfounded praise by the 90%. Unfounded? You're kidding, right? I haven't seen Clannad, but Haruhi and K-ON! deserve the praise they get. Working_Designs said: Because they have never made a good Anime. Dude, would you please watch something before you judge it? You're giving me a really really hard time when it comes to taking you seriously. Half of their Anime is "Moe Shit." You don't have to watch Moe to know you'll hate it. |
|
| They made Gay Swimming: The Animation and Lesbian Tea-Time: The Animation. Of course they're gonna be hated, don't you think? |
 |
| Did this turn into a moe vs no moe discussion? |
John_h said: Working_Designs said: You don't have to watch Moe to know you'll hate it. You're as shallow as ever, really. So, you think I'm shallow because I hate moe? |
|
Lancehot said: I guess this would be the thread to declare my enjoyment of Lucky Star More people should enjoy Lucky Star. |
|
John_h said: Working_Designs said: So, you think I'm shallow because I hate moe? No, you're shallow for thinking you can judge something without watching it. If something looks absolutely repulsive to me, and after seeing little clips of it to see what it's like, and it doesn't look any good, then in my opinion, that's a good enough reason to hate it. It's quite simple, really. You love Kyoto Animation(You even have K-on in your favorites,) and it pains you when anyone says something bad about it. |
|
FGAU1912 said: yhunata said: More people should enjoy Lucky Star. lol i ripped the my retned dvd of that anime and coneted them to sound files i like the humor of that show kyo ani or not I..... have absolutely no idea what you just said. |
|
yhunata said: They made Gay Swimming: The Animation and Lesbian Tea-Time: The Animation. Of course they're gonna be hated, don't you think? Because a group of friends of the same gender have always to be homosexual, now I get it. |
| |
laraes said: yhunata said: They made Gay Swimming: The Animation and Lesbian Tea-Time: The Animation. Of course they're gonna be hated, don't you think? Because a group of friends of the same gender have always to be homosexual, now I get it. Dude, check my scores for Free and K-On!.... and get with the times. I was obviously being sarcastic. |
|
More topics from this board
» If you were asked to briefly describe Japan's popular animation studios, how would you do it?Swyzen - 4 minutes ago |
0 |
by Swyzen
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Looks like mecha anime's are dead. RIP, giant robots. ( 1 2 3 4 )Gashadokur0 - Jun 23 |
169 |
by Timeline_man
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Has Ufotable Perfected Walking?Dragevard - Jun 24 |
21 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Is Poison Pontaro the most interesting villain in the last decade?Catalano - Yesterday |
6 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » how "loved" is your #1 fave character of all time ?ame - Yesterday |
30 |
by MinakoBestGirl
»»
16 minutes ago |