Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (4) « 1 [2] 3 4 »
Nov 6, 2011 3:49 AM
Offline
Oct 2011
5
The episode was enojayable, I wouldn't say it was good though it seems to be taking a really childish approach.
I don't really get why they said that this was going to be "more faithful to the manga" and they're cutting/changing things left and right, episode 5 and 6 are completely different from the manga and they pretty much cut out a whole manga chapter here (the sushi part) o_O oh well this is definitely going fast, episode 7 looks kinda boring, imo, judging from the preview.
Nov 6, 2011 4:26 AM

Offline
Dec 2007
865
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.
Nov 6, 2011 5:29 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
314
Meddigo said:
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.


it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"
Nov 6, 2011 5:35 AM

Offline
Oct 2011
741
this is not good ---- the animators are too fucking lazy - look at their facial expressions while being chased---- the same thing happened in episode one when gon jumped to save katso

the "happy" music is getting gayer and gayer they need to remove it and never used it at all- this isn't kindergarten-- the rest of the bgm is fine

pacing is good

the extra beard on netero is fucking annoying
the way he jumped was too rushed and too "destructive" which was pretty lame' in '99 he landed perfectly :\ it just didn't feel right

Hanzo's Ninja moments were great
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Nov 6, 2011 6:53 AM

Offline
Feb 2009
5567
Aya Hirano in my HxH?
What is this I don't even...
Nov 6, 2011 9:18 AM

Offline
Jun 2011
354
"Screw the rules I have green hair" - My first thought seeing Menchi with green hair xD. But it doesn't mean I hate it :P

It's not the end of the world for me if they skipped out the Sushi (part of it was mixed with the pork), the story still made sense and the Egg getting was changed so that it was easier to explain how everyone who got an egg passed.

To me, it's still good, but I acknowledge that the music is getting old (I didn't mind it for the first 2 or 3 eps).

But I wanna mention that the things missed out from the manga are:

  • Kaito
  • Mito's explanation + Gon's initial relationship with nature (AND BEAR D:)
  • Sushi

Kaito will return when relevant. Mito and Gon talk later.
We will never see sushi. That's the only thing lost forever, stop trolling >.>
Nov 6, 2011 9:26 AM

Offline
Jan 2008
18428
Looks like Aya Hirano got her job back.

It was an alright episode.
Nov 6, 2011 9:34 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
4874
Kaito will return when relevant.

That is a long ways away to not have information that was relevant enough to be put in the first volume of the manga.
Mito and Gon talk later.

This talk could be just as empty as it was before if the writers decide to keep with the quick, low information pacing.
We will never see sushi. That's the only thing lost forever, stop trolling

We are only 6 episodes in which gives the writers plenty more chances to cut down on information in order to save on time.

Nov 6, 2011 9:45 AM

Offline
Feb 2011
139
WHERE THE HELL is Sushi part!?
WHAT THE HECK is that updraft wind!?
Is that all for Hunter exam phase two!?
And that fan service, what!?

Ok ok enough for the rant. I Can only hope next episode will be better..
"To some, online is more important than seeing friends, eating and even breathing."

<!--link--><a href="http://myanimelist.net/animelist/kuruta_tribe&sclick=1">

Nov 6, 2011 9:59 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
4874
pokymon said:
Meddigo said:
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.


it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

It'll be cut(lol) of course.

Nov 6, 2011 11:27 AM

Offline
Oct 2011
342
Anime_Name said:
pokymon said:
Meddigo said:
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.


it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

It'll be cut(lol) of course.


Dude honestly just stfu, if u don't like it then don't watch it. Just because it's about Hunter x Hunter doesn't mean u have to watch it (I only say that because people use the excuse of wanting to see the Chimera Ant Arc or because it is still Hunter x Hunter). Stuff got cut out I know but literally I think the only reason some people watch this is to nitpick at what changes. The original had stuff that wasn't in the manga, did u complain this much then to? I honestly feel this would get more appreciation if there wasn't already the previous anime. I don't care what anyone says, I have watched the old anime mutiple times and read the manga multiple times and I think this version is good but not better than the original. I'm sick of people who say they don't like this version but continue to watch just to bash it. I will continue watching and am so glad that they decided to reboot Hunter x Hunter.
Nov 6, 2011 11:37 AM
Offline
Aug 2007
51
As a big fan of the sushi test, this episode was a major disappoint. Most disappointing episode yet for me. Glad to see Menchi ready to kick Todo's butt though.

The spider-eagle test was a little lame...

"It takes courage to choose to give up." Nothing special or courageous seeing how to get and return with an egg but it did help with Todo's scene a little bit. But he looks much more like a coward since everyone already showed what to do if you weren't dumb.

Poor Hanzo. Was hoping to see if Killua might mention that Gon must be a dog for comedic laughs. Here's hoping for the fun Midnight Game. Killua looks way too ecstatic and happy in a pleasant way than I thought he would about his plans as Hunter...
KageNov 6, 2011 11:48 AM
Nov 6, 2011 12:27 PM

Offline
Apr 2011
1700
Good episode. Can't wait until next week.
Nov 6, 2011 12:40 PM

Offline
Jun 2011
71
Great episode! also looking forwards for the next one xD
Nov 6, 2011 12:51 PM

Offline
Aug 2011
419
really enjoyed this scene, not too upset about the sushi part being taken out!! the egg part was great, and nice lesson we've learnt from this episode!! (somehow, gourmet hunters just remind of toriko... :/ )

Paul said:
Looks like Aya Hirano got her job back.
.


LOOOL man, hirano did a great job as menchi!!! XD
Nov 6, 2011 1:24 PM

Offline
Feb 2011
487
Not going on a hate rampage, because the sushi part got cut out.
But I'd still liked to see it. It was the most fun after all (way more fun, then the pig-part enhancement).
They just should've kept the pig and egg part shorter, like in the original.

But what's with that updraft? Was it really necessary to put that in? Not that it was bad or anything. Just felt like a waste of time (sushi *cough*)

Oh and Gon doing the job for all the other applicants sucks(with the pigs AND the updraft). What the duck, seriously.

Next episode will be somewhat important. The ball-catching minigame shouldn't be bad.
But even more excited to see, what happens after that, when Killua'll bump into the two no-name applicants... :x
Nov 6, 2011 1:28 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
48
Another episode where the original is far superior.
Nov 6, 2011 1:57 PM
Offline
Aug 2010
5
Kuchenlight said:

Next episode will be somewhat important. The ball-catching minigame shouldn't be bad.
But even more excited to see, what happens after that, when Killua'll bump into the two no-name applicants... :x


Ball game will happen bumping into the two no-name applicants won't me thinks :B
Nov 6, 2011 2:17 PM

Offline
Apr 2011
4658
I liked that cleavage zoom, didn't think it was necessary though.
Nov 6, 2011 2:45 PM

Offline
Apr 2009
269
Zoddguts said:
Another episode where the original is far superior.

Strongly disagree with your view. Original wasn't bad, and i really liked sushi part, but it wasn't logical. 'Make some god-knows-what kind of food and make it perfect!'... No comment. Also good thing is this episode contains most of essential material from original 9-10 eps, so it's like 2 in 1. Also a part with an egs of the Spider Eagles was done really well. So, no complains. Can't wait to see next one.=]
Nov 6, 2011 2:50 PM

Offline
Apr 2007
184
x4m said:
Zoddguts said:
Another episode where the original is far superior.

Strongly disagree with your view. Original wasn't bad, and i really liked sushi part, but it wasn't logical. 'Make some god-knows-what kind of food and make it perfect!'... No comment. Also good thing is this episode contains most of essential material from original 9-10 eps, so it's like 2 in 1. Also a part with an egs of the Spider Eagles was done really well. So, no complains. Can't wait to see next one.=]


But that was the point, that it wasn't logical. If it had been a good test everyone would have failed and Netero wouldn't have to show up.


I don't like the fact that Gon pretty much wins the exam for everyone. Like this more or less everyone could have passed if they would just stay close enough to him to hear all the explanations.
Nov 6, 2011 2:52 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561872
So far I'm liking it, no boring moments to drag it along
Nov 6, 2011 2:56 PM

Offline
May 2009
152
I'm just not finding myself enjoying these eps as much as I'd like to. Everything just seems so empty besides Leorio. He seems funnier this time around. It just seems like a kiddy show so far. Maybe it's that damn bgm. It is just so terrible...
.
Nov 6, 2011 3:15 PM
Offline
Jun 2010
296
Kuchenlight said:

Oh and Gon doing the job for all the other applicants sucks(with the pigs AND the updraft). What the duck, seriously.

Next episode will be somewhat important. The ball-catching minigame shouldn't be bad.
But even more excited to see, what happens after that, when Killua'll bump into the two no-name applicants... :x

Lol yeah. Did they seriously wait for Gon's okay to jump? Why do they trust him with their lives like that? In the original there was a river so you could live from the fall but in this case that was way to risky. Think they want to emphasize in how special Gon is or something. The pig scene included. Also sorry since the no name applicants never appeared in the manga so they won't appear.
Valaskjalf said:
I liked that cleavage zoom, didn't think it was necessary though.

It was lol. In the manga Netero looks at her tits and says oh ho look at those boobs in his mind. I didn't know he was a pervert til recently in the manga though and then after looking back on that chapter.
BitchMaster said:
Ummm... Did you, lyk, read the most recent chapters?


YUP :) Current chapters are getting good. why do you ask?
pokymon said:
Meddigo said:
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.


it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

Sorry if you're referring to how that girl wanted revenge on Killua I really doubt that will be in this version. I checked and it wasn't in the manga. If that's what you're talking about lol.
x5exotic said:

the extra beard on netero is fucking annoying



lol i thought so too but in the manga he has it. Didn't realize that.



"There is someone that I must meet again. And until that day... not even Death himself can take my life away!"
Nov 6, 2011 3:36 PM
Offline
Nov 2008
354
Eh...
The original is basically more faithful at this point. It adds some filler (nice filler, imo) while this cuts things. I wasn't fond of the sushi part but this was at the same level... just shorter. Someminor details are more faithful to the manga, yes, but that doesn't justify them cutting and changing this many things in only 2 episodes.
I don't really see the point of watching this over the original. Even the animation isn't better, the low budget really shows. It's just more colorful and new in style. I'll probably drop it.
It's still a nice show but if I want HxH I already have the manga and 90 episodes of anime that is superior.
Nov 6, 2011 3:58 PM
Offline
Aug 2007
51
Ollyx2OxenFree said:
Kuchenlight said:

But even more excited to see, what happens after that, when Killua'll bump into the two no-name applicants... :x
Also sorry since the no name applicants never appeared in the manga so they won't appear.
pokymon said:

it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

Sorry if you're referring to how that girl wanted revenge on Killua I really doubt that will be in this version. I checked and it wasn't in the manga. If that's what you're talking about lol.



I believe they're all referring to the two applicants that Killua meets after he leaves the game. Which is in the manga.
Nov 6, 2011 4:41 PM

Offline
Aug 2010
3232
PLOT x PLOT

Oh god that examiner..

so hot
Nov 6, 2011 4:42 PM

Offline
Oct 2007
150
I have to agree that this sequence was better in the original series. Don't get me wrong, there's nothing bad about how it panned out in the remake, it just didn't have room to breathe. I agree that Netero shouldn't have made an earth-shattering kaboom when he landed, but we have to have some excitement in the episode, it seems.

I can't believe "screw the rules, I have green hair" didn't cross my mind despite me flailing about Menchi's hair during the episode. Thank you, whoever pointed it out.

It should be safe to assume Anita will be cut out of what follows. I hope the exchange between Leorio and Kurapika isn't, however. The awkward shower scenes in the original cracked me up.
Nov 6, 2011 4:48 PM

Offline
Sep 2007
205
So many people are complaining about cuts or comparing it or whatever, I'm sure all the new viewers are finding it hard to get room for discussion, hahaha. I do have to say though that while the bgm wasn't so bad at first, hearing the same tracks repeated over and over again is starting to get to me too.

This ep was alright, but the exam is staring to get to the more interesting parts next ep, so I'm pretty excited about that~~!
Nov 6, 2011 5:42 PM

Offline
Mar 2009
572
fearthebeard85 said:


Dude honestly just stfu, if u don't like it then don't watch it. Just because it's about Hunter x Hunter doesn't mean u have to watch it (I only say that because people use the excuse of wanting to see the Chimera Ant Arc or because it is still Hunter x Hunter). Stuff got cut out I know but literally I think the only reason some people watch this is to nitpick at what changes. The original had stuff that wasn't in the manga, did u complain this much then to? I honestly feel this would get more appreciation if there wasn't already the previous anime. I don't care what anyone says, I have watched the old anime mutiple times and read the manga multiple times and I think this version is good but not better than the original. I'm sick of people who say they don't like this version but continue to watch just to bash it. I will continue watching and am so glad that they decided to reboot Hunter x Hunter.


1. We can't dislike something if we don't watch it. Once we do watch it, of course we can complain about it. Just 'cause we have dissenting opinions doesn't mean we can't state them. Why should only people who like the anime get to talk about it?

2. We're not watching it to nitpick; we're watching it to compare. It's not like we want it to fail. If we're watching the remake, it's because we love Hunter x Hunter and want it to succeed. Of course we'll make comparisons; the original existed, so why pretend it didn't?

3. The original had filler, but the filler felt very in-place, natural for the most part. There were some weaker fillers, but it definitely still felt like one package. Why would we complain about good filler, if it only adds to the anime?

4. The reason we complain is because the original anime showed us to what potential animators could achieve with the quality of content given, and then some. The new Hunter x Hunter couldn't achieve the potential the original could, even by alternative means. It also didn't succeed in staying true to the manga, which was what the makers claimed it would do.

I'm a big fan of the original anime, not so much the manga just 'cause of the average art. I really wanted the new anime to succeed, but it ultimately was a disappointment. An expected disappointment for me, but still I wanted it to fare well. I'm hoping it'll slow down a little once it reaches the point where the original ended.
Nov 6, 2011 5:44 PM

Offline
Feb 2011
487
Kage said:
Ollyx2OxenFree said:
Kuchenlight said:

But even more excited to see, what happens after that, when Killua'll bump into the two no-name applicants... :x
Also sorry since the no name applicants never appeared in the manga so they won't appear.
pokymon said:

it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

Sorry if you're referring to how that girl wanted revenge on Killua I really doubt that will be in this version. I checked and it wasn't in the manga. If that's what you're talking about lol.



I believe they're all referring to the two applicants that Killua meets after he leaves the game. Which is in the manga.

This.

It's most likely this just won't be in the next episode.

But that'd finally go beyond "uuuh u haters shall leave" stuff. Scenes like that are a crucial part of Killua's personality and his relationship with his family. That shouldn't be left out no matter what.
Same goes for the scene in the tower, of course.
Nov 6, 2011 5:47 PM

Offline
Jul 2011
4463
I'm excited for next episode... more Killua. Did anyone else see that super weird Killua scene in the preview? o.o

I like this version too so far. The pacing is nice and doesn't feel dragged on. :)
Nov 6, 2011 5:49 PM
Offline
Aug 2010
207
Continues to be a very enjoyable show. Kind of tempted to go read the manga now, but I don't want to spoil the anime.
Nov 6, 2011 6:09 PM

Offline
Oct 2011
342
Keilis said:

1. We can't dislike something if we don't watch it. Once we do watch it, of course we can complain about it. Just 'cause we have dissenting opinions doesn't mean we can't state them. Why should only people who like the anime get to talk about it?

2. We're not watching it to nitpick; we're watching it to compare. It's not like we want it to fail. If we're watching the remake, it's because we love Hunter x Hunter and want it to succeed. Of course we'll make comparisons; the original existed, so why pretend it didn't?

3. The original had filler, but the filler felt very in-place, natural for the most part. There were some weaker fillers, but it definitely still felt like one package. Why would we complain about good filler, if it only adds to the anime?

4. The reason we complain is because the original anime showed us to what potential animators could achieve with the quality of content given, and then some. The new Hunter x Hunter couldn't achieve the potential the original could, even by alternative means. It also didn't succeed in staying true to the manga, which was what the makers claimed it would do.

I'm a big fan of the original anime, not so much the manga just 'cause of the average art. I really wanted the new anime to succeed, but it ultimately was a disappointment. An expected disappointment for me, but still I wanted it to fare well. I'm hoping it'll slow down a little once it reaches the point where the original ended.


I'm not saying u can't state your opinion I just don't understand that if you've got through 6 episodes and are still dissappointed then why continue to watch? The original was good and I loved it but I feel that it will ultimately be the downfall to the the new version because people compare them too much. I want this version to succeed but in my opinion it's going to end up getting canceled due to people not being able to put the old one in the past and watch this one with an open mind set, that and because it's low budget. I am almost 90 percent sure at this point that it will end after the 45 episodes that have been ordered due to these reasons I stated, at this point, not only will they not get to the Chimera Ant Arc but they won't even make it to Greed Island. I just can't believe how this series averages an 8 on this site which is fairly good but then when people comment on it almost all of it is negative. The last thing that bugs me is that I've been told before that I'm not a fan of Hunter x Hunter just because I support this version, I don't get how wanting this anime to be a finished adaption of one of the best manga makes me not a fan.
Nov 6, 2011 6:34 PM
Offline
Jan 2010
6
Alright, for me, who has read the manga up until the latest episode and who has also watched the older 1999 ver. of the Anime, this episode was very disappointing. I was fine with the other episodes before this, because they went at the pace the Manga kind of went at, but once they hit episode 6, they took out many scenes from the manga that I felt was needed to be able to flesh out the characters. If they kept the Sushi Scene, It would've helped develop the story also. ; u; Then I also found it weird how Netero all of the sudden agreed to going once he heard about the situation. There have been many exams where they all failed and no one passed. Also, when they were going to make the Boiled egg, they switched how they got up... I personally don't like the draft Idea. I'm stuck to how the original way is, how they climbed onto the webs (Since they were strong in the Manga) and climbed back up themselves. And they didn't even make it seem like it were a test of observation. They didn't even show the scene where they actually cook the egg. =__=;; This episode just... made me frustrated. Also, they seem to make Killua's personality brighter than it actually is. I'm not saying that Killua is a depressing child or anything, but I just can't imagine him yelling "Yahoo~!!" just because they were sliding down a hill. o__e;;; //shot to death. And then there's that preview... Okay, I can see Killua do that if it were for chocolate and sweets but... uh.. &gt; u&gt;;; I'm sorry about my rant guys.

This episode really disappointed me ; A; Don't get me wrong, I love Hunter x Hunter. It's possibly because I read the manga that I feel upset about this. Since many scenes were left out, I just feel that the characters are going to have a hard time developing in the 2011 Anime. But that's just my opinion. (The manga is always better, in my opinion.)
JunnChiiNov 6, 2011 7:21 PM
Nov 6, 2011 6:37 PM
Offline
Aug 2007
51
Don't take out your frustrations on everyone who are disappointed because of one person saying it. By telling everyone who may be disappointed to shut the fuck up you are no better than anyone who might have told you that you aren't a fan. People who do so are not "fans"; no one has any right to tell anyone else that they are not a fan of something.

I've tried not comparing both anime to each other, what I am doing is comparing this anime to the manga. My failing is being somewhat of a purist. I basically want the anime to be an animated version of the manga. I was disappointed with both the original and the 2011 version in terms of what is and wasn't included.

Things that make me cringe:
Still, the BGM. So very much the soundtrack of this show. The ED song as well.
I felt like Menchi was just acting too much of a brat (almost like how Gon was acting in the 1999 anime in this time) whining the whole time. It was too hard accepting the reasoning for the test.
Buhara's voice.

Things I liked:
Hisoka pointing Leorio out when Gon and Kurapica look for him
Menchi having her knives out.
Netero's voice.
Nov 6, 2011 6:54 PM

Offline
Oct 2011
342
There was one person who kept posting negative comments over and over who is who i was telling to stfu, I don't have problems with people voicing there opinoins or dissappointments, I just can't believe it's so hard to find people who actually like this version. I'm sorry for snapping at anyone, I just want to see this get farther than the old one and get a full adaption of the manga, which means hopefully no more hiatisuses. This is one of the greatest shounen series ever so I want to see it get a full version, not one that gets halfway through again and then is done.
Nov 6, 2011 7:00 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
48
The guy I'm going to quote know's what's up.

I disagree with this assessment pretty strongly. While on the surface it appears similar, with the tools being laid out for them and whatnot, when you actually think about it at all the Madhouse version makes no sense at all. The candidates are told to hunt pigs and given a bunch of knives and a firepit. Okay, so what's the test? To make something tasty? How does this test anything at all, other than skill at cooking? Menchi's reason for getting mad doesn't make as much sense either.

The point of the sushi was all about observation and logic. They're told to make handmade sushi, which is the cuisine of a small island nation. They're given a bunch of knives, but no source of heat. They have rice and vinegar, and Menchi waits for their entries with a pair of chopsticks and a small dish of soy sauce. The test is to figure out what the heck sushi is supposed to be. Given the clues, you can guess it's seafood because of the island nation and the knives, you know it's raw because there's no heat, you know it's something you create with your hands and is of the size to be picked up by chopsticks and dipped in the soy sauce. It's an actual test. It's clever. And the only reason Menchi gets mad is because Hanzo gives the answer away in a disrespectful way.

Removing the sushi part removes the test entirely. What we're left with is just an examiner who gets mad at the drop of a hat and fails everyone for no reason.


^ Which is why the old version is the superior version. This EP drop the ball by taking out the Sushi test.
Nov 6, 2011 7:01 PM

Offline
Mar 2009
572
fearthebeard85 said:


I'm not saying u can't state your opinion I just don't understand that if you've got through 6 episodes and are still dissappointed then why continue to watch? The original was good and I loved it but I feel that it will ultimately be the downfall to the the new version because people compare them too much. I want this version to succeed but in my opinion it's going to end up getting canceled due to people not being able to put the old one in the past and watch this one with an open mind set, that and because it's low budget. I am almost 90 percent sure at this point that it will end after the 45 episodes that have been ordered due to these reasons I stated, at this point, not only will they not get to the Chimera Ant Arc but they won't even make it to Greed Island. I just can't believe how this series averages an 8 on this site which is fairly good but then when people comment on it almost all of it is negative. The last thing that bugs me is that I've been told before that I'm not a fan of Hunter x Hunter just because I support this version, I don't get how wanting this anime to be a finished adaption of one of the best manga makes me not a fan.


For me, I'm watching it because I want to see how they adapt Yorkshin. I want to see what they can do with it, because even if they do a shoddy adaptation of it, the content is still good. The thing is, it's getting an 8 here because people don't think it's terrible as an anime in general; however, compared to the original anime, it's underwhelming. We don't think it's crap or anything, and in fact, I'd say it's pretty OK. The negative comments aren't because we think it sucks; we're just disappointed, but we realize it's still OK work. At least, I think people are thinking that.

And I'm sure you're a fan. I respect that. People come to like different adaptations. It's just this one generally is less liked than the original. You're a fan if you think you're one. Don't let people tell you otherwise lol.
Nov 6, 2011 7:03 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
48
To put it simply he needs to man the fuck up. People will have different opinions from you. Some positive some negative. Deal with it.
Nov 6, 2011 7:31 PM

Offline
Oct 2011
342
Zoddguts said:
To put it simply he needs to man the fuck up. People will have different opinions from you. Some positive some negative. Deal with it.


I voiced my opinion and others voiced theirs, I agree the original is better but this one isn't terrible. I respect your opinion to, I should stop bitching about it because some people will like certain aspects of it and at the same time will dislike certain aspects of it. I for one so far have been mostly disappointed with the fact that they cut out the scene with Kite and that all of the applicants follow Gon's lead. Is there anything else I need to man up about? I will not be as arguementative anymore because as someone else said that is just problematic. Back to what I initially was going to put in my OP. It was a decent episode but I never really cared for the second phase, I always liked the airship episodes so can't wait to see what happens. And again, I will not belittle anyone else's opinions anymore because that was just stupid.
Nov 6, 2011 7:49 PM

Offline
Aug 2008
1009
fearthebeard85 said:
The original was good and I loved it but I feel that it will ultimately be the downfall to the the new version because people compare them too much. I want this version to succeed but in my opinion it's going to end up getting canceled due to people not being able to put the old one in the past and watch this one with an open mind set, that and because it's low budget. I am almost 90 percent sure at this point that it will end after the 45 episodes that have been ordered due to these reasons I stated.

This remake has a completely different target audience than the first series. Most of the people watching it on TV in Japan would not have seen the first series, and would not be comparing them.
Nov 6, 2011 9:17 PM
Offline
Nov 2007
2010
I'm not really sure why they added extra stuff this week and last week and cut out the sushi part D: Admittedly, the original dragged it out a bit much, but even then. Bad move, Madhouse, bad move. I really hope this doesn't set a precedent.
Oh well, I still enjoyed the episode.

As for Menchi, I don't think her hair colour was ever confirmed in the manga? So the pink/green is the animators' guessing game.
Nov 6, 2011 10:52 PM

Offline
Sep 2010
4874
fearthebeard85 said:
Anime_Name said:
pokymon said:
Meddigo said:
Ep 7 should be Netero playing keepaway from Gon/Killua iirc.

I liked that in the original TV series at least.


it should be more than that and I'm anxious to see how they will deal with "that particular scene"

It'll be cut(lol) of course.


Dude honestly just stfu, if u don't like it then don't watch it.

That last post was a joke because of "that particular scene."

Just because it's about Hunter x Hunter doesn't mean u have to watch it (I only say that because people use the excuse of wanting to see the Chimera Ant Arc or because it is still Hunter x Hunter).

Well I want to watch the definitive version of Hunter x Hunter, don't blame me is the definitive version makes more changes and cuts than the original.

I don't care what anyone says, I have watched the old anime mutiple times and read the manga multiple times and I think this version is good but not better than the original. I'm sick of people who say they don't like this version but continue to watch just to bash it.

Sure you don't. You not caring about what anyone says perfectly explains your ragin over what I said.Other people think what is being done should be bashed and that this new version isn't good. Who's right? I'm certainly not going to shutup about my complaints just because you think the show it good, I don't. Deal with it.

Nov 6, 2011 11:19 PM

Offline
Jul 2011
254
Good as an episode, a failure when it comes to the whole 2nd test. 3/5

Overall disappointing, though. Cutting down on non-manga filler is all well and good but too much is being left behind and this is only the 6th episode. Makes me worried about what's to come. I've enjoyed this new one so far but it really isn't living up to the old one, which is a shame. At least it will go longer then the old one, right? Something to look forward to.
Nov 6, 2011 11:59 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
31
As much as I liked the sushi part in the manga, I'm ok with it being cut because it's nonessential and probably would've made phase 2 last more than one episode... which is not ok by me. It's fun in the manga when you can just read it at any pace you want, but in anime form they have to be more careful about not being boring and I'm fine with them leaving out a few details.
Nov 7, 2011 12:29 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
4874
probably would've made phase 2 last more than one episode... which is not ok by me.

Why? What is the big deal about number of episodes. It would have been 1 more, hardly record breaking.
Well I am going to love seeing what's OKAY to cut because it's nonessential next time.
If an anime is based on a manga then the boring bits should come too because who knows, somebody might have liked the boring bits.

Nov 7, 2011 4:08 AM

Offline
Nov 2007
456
Good episode, not great.

It'll get REALLY good with genei ryodan. Greed Island episodes are going to be the best.
Nov 7, 2011 8:12 AM

Offline
Aug 2007
257
6
Horrible, just horrible. I've completely lost my faith now and I'm starting to wish the remake would never happen. I never thought it would be possible for me to hate Hunter x Hunter anime but they've managed to screw everything up. So far every episode was either bad, ugly or bad and ugly. But the last two were just horrible. In this one the joke about Leorio's face being the same was omitted (which is one of my favorite scenes) and instead we've had filler sliding scene and creators showing us the search for boars. A minute was wasted to see how Gon and others go through the woods to find pigs, lol. And while I'm at it, it's hard to believe they wouldn't see pigs from this high ground (even if we take into account that trees would obstruct the view). But this was acceptable. What was not however was the method of incapacitating the boar. Apples falling from a tree could KO the killer-boar? Are they f*cking serious? If it was so easy that a mere apple could do that this species would be long gone. That's just ridiculous and treating the viewer like an idiot. And Menchi evaluating pigs was a fail. They've mixed up two tests into one, a brilliant idea. NOT. They've cut out some great scenes and prevented the viewers from getting to know better some of the characters. They also didn't show that Menchi deserves the title of a Hunter and that she could do sth none of the participants (except certain two individuals) could. Getting the eggs was sth that 42 Hunter candidates could easily achieve. And updraft? Are you kidding me? If the wind would be so strong that it could hold a person I don't see how the eggs could be still where they are.
FAIL.

Also, talk about being lazy, spider webs are in rectangles, lol. Another proof that old anime had better graphics. And the trumpet music is really annoying. It could fit a slap-stick comedy not HxH.
Nov 7, 2011 10:20 AM

Offline
Oct 2011
342
oh well, only 40 more episodes of this until it gets canceled so no big deal I guess
Pages (4) « 1 [2] 3 4 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 147 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Sep 16, 2014

399 by Mikayuu1234567 »»
Sep 21, 3:36 PM

Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 148 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Haine - Sep 23, 2014

965 by Gard______ »»
Sep 21, 9:09 AM

» I hate Chimera Ant Arc seriously... ( 1 2 )

animecritic81 - Mar 13, 2021

69 by Moonlit_Senpai0 »»
Sep 18, 6:30 AM

Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 135 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Jun 24, 2014

920 by circusmelody »»
Sep 17, 2:18 PM

Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 133 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Stark700 - Jun 10, 2014

228 by circusmelody »»
Sep 17, 1:30 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login