DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
ImaVampire said: Reborn to find eachother in the next life the ending was fantastic By Far The Best Anime show of the Season You are watching shit this season then. Shitty nonsensical end is nonsensical no matter how much bullshit people come up with, its still bullshit. |
Oosran said: This pretty much sums up my feelings. I was satisfied and the ending was more emotional than I thought it would be possible with the current settings.Tenshi's more love than usual (She'll always be Tenshi for me~), and Yuri's more tsundere than usual. And that song is absolutely horrible. (lol Mapo tofu~) The second one.. Is worse. Countdown to dispersion: Naoi gone: Check ✔ Yuri gone: Check ✔ Hinata gone: Check ✔ Tenshi gone: Check ✔ D': <3 Otonashi gone: Check ✔ Wut end: Check ✔ O.o Also. Despite the disappointment that I've been reading about like.. Everywhere. I was pretty satisfied with this anime, from start to end. Did, like, very much actually. |
| After a heart transplant it's not like everything is all back to normal. I think the longest anyone has lived after a successful heart transplant is 20 years or so. Some die a year after the transplant, some 3 years, some 5 years, etc. |
| Key definitely lost it's magic on this one...there were plot holes everywhere, and the ending was left relatively open ended. This leaves a bad taste in my mouth, just like that garbage called Air...however it entertained me more than air in many different ways while still making me look forward to each new episode. I'm being generous by giving it a 9/10..so much left unanswered and so much left plot wise that was never explained. However, like Code Geass it was a fun ride no matter how shitty it was. |
| Ok™ |
| Eh guys, if everything is just going to be sum up, the whole series would become so predictable. It is just the way manga and anime works;they let you have your own ending. |
| love or hate, i couldn't care less |
| I thought to wroted like this but you did it before me, you got a point there for sure. Otonashi died indeed then she wouldn't had his heart LostGamer said: In just reading the last few posts I see a lot of confusion. Here is my take: - Time in the "dead" world is irrelevant or non-linear thus it would explain why Kanade was there longer. - Kanade was never dead, she explained that she wanted to thank him and somehow had gone to that world to find him. - Otanashi died how else would Kanade get his heart? The last 30 seconds reflect reincarnation and fate, not uncommon in romance/dramas involving death. That is how I make sense of things anyhow. :) Its open to another season but I think it would be anticlimactic. Though looking back at Clannad and Clannad ~After Story~ I think Key could find some way to pull it off :) |
Nothing ventured, nothing gained (Girls und Panzer der Film ) / from Nishizumi Miho |
| To be honest this ending was alright with some strong emotional moments. Angel Beats! felt too rushed and anyone who says it's the best they've seen, probably needs to watch more anime. I'm a bit biased as I was a pretty strong advocate of OtonashixYuri, but the premise of a 13 episode anime with so many characters was just plain stupid. 6/10 for me, dropping from an 8/10 during episodes 11 - 13. |
| So Yuri just disappeared like that? And before Hinata?? Does that mean Hinata is more important than Yuri? And she didn't even say a thing to Otonashi and Hinata. Also, the personality change was not really needed. Otonashi's plan....went according to plan. He let everyone disappear then decides to stay with Kanade. That doesn't make any sense!! He has some hidden agenda after all. And what is with that talk about the heart? Could have done with more explanation. And what was that last part? They were reborn? Does not compute. Guess Otonashi turned into a stalker and decided to just grab a person he doesn't know in that life. Please, do not explain or speculate further about the meaning of all these things here, because it really won't help that this show failed at explaining everything. Do not excuse that this doesn't have more episodes as a lot of shows did well with just 13 episodes. It needed a good writer and producer. It has a good idea but it was wasted by poor execution, unneeded moments and plot holes. 7/10 and that's a low score from me. inb4 people trying to speculate further about the ending and wishing for a second season, which definitely won't happen. |
 |
| 8/10 due to the fact that the last few eps however rushed seemed to save the series from utter stupidity into somthing..... plot wise i guess, and the first half of the series is alwatys good for the lolz |
 |
| Episodes I loved were just ones that showed the relationships between the SSS and developed characters, such as Guild. I did enjoy it but was left skeptical with what was happening at times, but I would've loved this to be a 24 episode anime. |
| By the way, Otonashi is a plotting scumbag douche. He made everyone dissapear and then has a change of heart (haha, heart) and wants to stay because of Kanade, and then he tries making her stay with him. What a selfish prick. |
| anyone know the ending song for this episode? |
controlmajortom said: By the way, Otonashi is a plotting scumbag douche. He made everyone dissapear and then has a change of heart (haha, heart) and wants to stay because of Kanade, and then he tries making her stay with him. What a selfish prick. And that's when Kanade makes sure he doesn't stray off his path. I'm sure most people would have second thoughts about making their lovers disappear. Good episode, though not nearly as good as the series could have been. |
| Nice ending. Really emotional near the end, even if it was a bit overdramatic. This anime wasn't really anything special, but a good watch nonetheless. I'm glad they all passed on and continued to live. :) |
     |
| After the ED it's look like Kanata was waiting for someone and check the cellphone |
Nothing ventured, nothing gained (Girls und Panzer der Film ) / from Nishizumi Miho |
| aw.. already finished.. i want to know how yuri, tenshi and the others died.. and i dont get it when tenshi and otonashi talked about their heart? wats up with that.. anyways nice ending. 8/10 |
     |
Blackbird said: After the ED it's look like Kanata was waiting for someone and check the cellphone She was waiting for her new black boyfriend. Otonashi is gonna be in for a surprise that his precious Kanade is getting railed by a brotha |
| Ok™ |
| Holy crap this thread is filling up fast. I enjoyed this show....but I wish there was more time for the ending and epilogue. I'll give this an 8/10 because I did enjoy this show. I thought Clannad and Kanon was better though. Maybe there will be a longer remake like there was for Kanon, that would be awesome. |
| "My Soul, Your Beats" very fitting song for the series. Otonashi's heart and Kanade's soul. |
| In the previous episode, the program said that love can not manifest itself, and if it did the after world would become an eternal paradise for the person that manifested love. Because Otonashi began to love Kanade (i.e. manifested love), it is implied that Otonashi will probably stay in the afterlife forever or until Kanade dies again and they finally meet each other once more. The after scenario in the end where "Otonashi" and "Kanade" (I am putting quotes because that Otonashi and Kanade are not necessarily the characters that we saw during the anime) meet is probably a parallel world. |
| *confused* :S |
 |
| The Ending was interesting... so they met again in a new life? |
     |
| All this for that... Dunno about the time frame or whatever but Kanade ended up there anyway. In fact all of this doesn't make sense at all... Way too much stuff unexplained, that special episode better be something that enlighten us and not one of those stupid onsen/beach episodes -_- Also the girls personalities changed way too much since previous ep, WTF... I'll keep the 1st half of the series and forget the rest... |
 |
| HOW COULD THEY END IT LIKE THIS?? that was way too cruel :( otonashi didn't even get an i love you too...... but at least he's got another chance :) way too short and alot of other characters didn't even get a chance for a dedicated episode 8/10 |
 |
| The question that's been picking at the back of my neck this entire series was: why is it only high school students; what about adults and children who died with regrets? I'm just going to guess that either they died at that age or returned to that age to relive their high school life...although that wouldn't make much sense if their time in high school was fulfilling but adulthood wasn't...oh well. For this episode itself, for me it was quite a bit of a tear-jerker, especially during the Yuzuru x Kanade scene and epilogue. As with many other people have said and thought, Key wasted a good chance to have a solid 24 episodes of pure win, and would be remembered for years to come that would rival classics like works from Hayao Miyazaki. Unfortunately, most likely due to financial issues and/or the higher ups being stupid dicks; that didn't happen. If time was the issue, I wouldn't have minded waiting for them like I did with Time of Eve (and was it ever a long wait for a mere 15 minutes, giving a reason to see tomorrow), if it meant more and/or better episodes and ending. I would have really liked to see at least the favourite characters of everyone have a bit more screen time like Shiina, TK the enigma...etc. But a good thing that happened was the (opinionated) scene where Yuzuru and Kanade were reborn and were able to meet again. Although if it were up to me, I would have crammed some of the other characters like finding Waldo in the background walking past Kanade to see if anyone would notice. |
Estoy_GordoJun 25, 2010 9:37 PM
Rhedak said: Also to clear some stuff up: It was explicitely stated that Kanade got Otonashi's heart transplant and that her regrets from her previous life were never being able to thank the one that allowed her to life on. So yes, he did die, no coma ending. So the bit at the end must have been their next life. Something doesn't match up properly with that. Kanade was in the Battlefront long before Otonashi came along. If she got his heart, that would mean that he must have died before her, and that she would have arrived at the battlefront after he did. Anyway; the show was crap. Pacing was far too quick, too much stuff left unexplained, and it had the potential to be loads better. (Plus, I didn't feel attached to any of the characters in the slightest, except for maybe TK). |
 |
| Such a bittersweet episode. I liked it. And I find the sudden disappearances quite effective. Like I said before, there doesn't need to be bangs and flashes when they go. I think it was intentional to leave a lot of questions unanswered so that all of us would spend forever debating it. The biggest one for me is why was Otonashi in that final scene when he didn't disappear form the world like the others? But, while I agree it was frustrating to have no answers, I can't hate the anime for it. As we have all said before, this seriously needed to be 24 eps long. Let us hope there is enough lasting interest in the show to warrant a remake. For that case, I will be buying merch (and I'm cross my fingers for a Yui model). |
| *Cries!* ahhhh!!! Dammit! I promised myself I wouldn't cry when this ended dammit! That ending...was so sad!! *sniff* they're all gone now.....*cries more*....8/10 *sniff* dammit I just watched two of the shows I liked end in the same day! That's it! No more romances for me! I'm gonna cry too much! |
KenjuJun 25, 2010 9:48 PM
 |
| last few episodes has been blah for me. Therefore 8/10 to 7/10 |
  |
| T.T im crying alot its sad and happy at the same time (i actually started screaming "YES!" when yuzuru confessed lol ...well not good its 12:30 am lol) |
 |
| I'm really pleased with the ending.. ^_^ I thought Otonoashi might not be clear with his feelings for Kanade at the end, but glad that wasn't the case.. Never expected Kanade being the recipient of Otonashi's actual heart, but still a nice twist.. So in the end they were given a second chance in life I guess.. Though I find it puzzling finding both Otonashi and Kanade alive, since Otonashi's heart was transplanted to Kanade right? so how come Otonashi is still alive? Another world maybe? Argg, this will be bugging me until I get a clear explanation.. XD Guahh, why didn't they show Kanade's face at the last scene, oh well fanart will be popping out anyways.. >_< Cheers for Angel Beats! =) |
 |
dragonair15 said: Ok, Tenshi-Kanade said that she wanted to thank the person who donated the heart to her soo much that se got lost and wandered to this world => this mean Tenshi is not dead but in somekind of coma states nearest to death. Which also means Otonashi is dead for sure with his heart inside kanade's. and i assume she wakes up in real world The how the hell they show him being alive at the end of the show? im confused, Yuri' change in personality is suck... she is better off with cold and smart look. Kanade got the heart transplant but still died soon after. All she was able to accomplish with the heart transplant was the opportunity to live longer. |
| Im glad I watched this even though it wouldve been soooooo much better with more than 20 eps or something like that, so many characters and story that got wasted but oh well... I liked the reincarnation stuff at the end, those two deserve to be together! |
 |
game8910 said: AmityDaydreams said: Rhedak said: Also to clear some stuff up: It was explicitely stated that Kanade got Otonashi's heart transplant and that her regrets from her previous life were never being able to thank the one that allowed her to life on. So yes, he did die, no coma ending. So the bit at the end must have been their next life. She got a heart transplant and died anyway? HAHA this is what I thougth too...they also never explained how Yuri or Kanade died slightly incorrect they never explained any of the deaths but yuzuru's as for kanade it could be possible that she died because her body rejected the heart (which would suck) |
|
| Dammit, I need to watch something that will kill my heart, cause I feel all sad and emotional after watching that! |
|
| Aww... KEY knows how to make an anime that I really like ^^ I seriously enjoyed this last episode; it's definitely the best and most entertaining one. Overall, this series should have used a lot more explanation, as there were still many things incomplete. I agree with everyone that this should have been a 24 episode anime. Nonetheless. I still loved this show. I don't regret picking this and following it through at all :) Until next time... *leaves* |
 Thanks, person who gave me this on another site a long time ago, lol. |
| Okay ending, wasted potential due to the lack of time and overly large cast. It did not meet up to the hype it generated but still was decent. I really liked what Yuzuru was wearing at the very end. I want that. My regret when watching this episode is that I've been poisoned by the nico video of a Kamiya Hiroshi imposter singing Ren'ai Circulation as Izaya. Both instances of Yuzuru saying "se no..." immediately made me imagine the next line being "demo sonna n ja dame~" XD Also, I want to eat mapo tofu. |
KantarouJun 25, 2010 9:56 PM
 |
| I'm not a fan of Otonashi x Kanade.. & never will. That's why I voted 1. It was such a nice anime yet.... it ended up a 'rush'. It would have been better if Jun Maeda made it a little longer.... but I do understand that the title itself speaks louder. "ANGEL BEATS" A very nice Kanade who doesn't have a heart... etc.. etc.. etc.. yet I would have love the anime if Otonashi is with Yuri. Just my own perspective. |
 |
| あなたは日本の翻訳を使用しました。あなたは悪い人！ <img src="http://i43.tinypic.com/656179.png" border="0" /> |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Angel Beats! Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )game8910 - Apr 2, 2010 |
679 |
by Meriurin
»»
Yesterday, 12:04 AM |
|
Poll: » Angel Beats! Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )game8910 - Apr 9, 2010 |
486 |
by actuallyaladdin
»»
Nov 25, 8:58 AM |
|
Poll: » Angel Beats! Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )ShibuyaRiver - Jun 11, 2010 |
377 |
by Arl0r1t
»»
Nov 22, 2:53 AM |
|
» Is there any chance for a remake of "Angel Beats!" with more episodes? Would anyone else like to see it get a remake? ( 1 2 )no_comparisonBM - Jun 23 |
50 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Nov 22, 2:16 AM |
|
Poll: » Angel Beats! Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )ShibuyaRiver - Jun 4, 2010 |
664 |
by Arl0r1t
»»
Nov 22, 2:13 AM |