Fullmetal Alchemist
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Watching the episode. If it will end on where it should, it will be epic :3 - Bradley looks badass as always, even with one eye missing. ESPECIALLY with eye missing - Truly prideful entrance :3 - Thats got to hurt :/ - And here comes the trick no one saw comming :P - Promised Hour :3 - Thats.....got to hurt ._. - Bradley being badass again :3 - Uh oh....Mustang you better stop watching :3 - And the bombshell comes. - This episode contains a lot of truth mindfuck :3 Mod Edit: Fixed poll. |
KinetaJun 7, 2022 10:28 AM
 |
Fai said: THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Watching the episode. If it will end on where it should, it will be epic :3 good job discussing the episode. |
    |
| Poor Mustang...he's having a pretty tough time. Great episode. I have to look at it again with subs though...I wasn't able to understand everything. |
| Episode 59 Screencaps and Impressions: http://randomc.net/2010/05/30/fullmetal-alchemist-brotherhood-59/ |
HoaRy said: ずっと待ってた、おかえり。 Next week the anime is going to overtake the manga :( - even the preview now showed more than Vol.26 preview... have you even read the manga , what are you trying to say . . The manga is on chapter 107 mate , the anime is roughly on 103 . . . |
HoaRy said: ずっと待ってた、おかえり。 Next week the anime is going to overtake the manga :( - even the preview now showed more than Vol.26 preview... No. Last Chapter is episode 63. And epsiode 63 will come out after last chapter si released anyway :) |
|
| Man, I got chills when Al reunited with his body. And alright, Scar versus Bradley. |
 |
| Epic win episode 9009 over 5. How many times the table turned around i didn't count, it was like a roller coaster ride :D Chang May saves Riza by treating her wound with Xinganian Alchemy. Gold tooth doctor had his deserved transmutation. In the process he became a meat ball, and mustang lost his sight thanks to Bradley and Pride. So in the end scar will probably get the credit of annihilating Bradley for good. Too bad, we have a little girl and an animal in the human sacrifice chamber now, May Chang and Shao May to the rescue. <3 |
shanimebibMay 30, 2010 4:41 AM
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
| Yes . The poll didn't work wit me this time around . . I wanted a normal one . . And thats mainly because of the choices . . They aren't good enough . This episode gave me goosies :) it really did . . And for people who think mustang is overpowered , did you see how bradley pwned him down . . Wow . . The KING Rocks :) |
cnaw said: Yes . The poll didn't work wit me this time around . . I wanted a normal one . . And thats mainly because of the choices . . They aren't good enough . This episode gave me goosies :) it really did . . And for people who think mustang is overpowered , did you see how bradley pwned him down . . Wow . . The KING Rocks :) i cant wait for 107 to be animated in 3 weeks!! :D cnaw said: HoaRy said: ずっと待ってた、おかえり。 Next week the anime is going to overtake the manga :( - even the preview now showed more than Vol.26 preview... have you even read the manga , what are you trying to say . . The manga is on chapter 107 mate , the anime is roughly on 103 . . . thats what was gonna say lol |
mundo said: Honestly, drop the 9000 out of 5 crap. I love this anime and think it deserves all the praise in the world, but 9000 out of 5 should be done on really rare occasions for mind blowing episodes, not for 5 episodes in a row. Kennesty said: Gonna keep voting this a 1 because the poll is stupid. Just keep it as 1-5 out of 10 because over 9000 hasn't been funny in like 3 years and people have the right to vote it 1 if they didn't like the episode. If you can't handle other peoples opinions, then stop going on message boards. I am sorry but voting episodes like these past ~5 with 1 of 5 would either mean that the person is utterly biased troll or utterly amazing masochist. If someone hated fucking amazing episode like this, then he should just stop watching, and stop trobling themselves with this much awesomeness. Oh and if yo did not notice for past ~20 episodes, the very same person kept rating the episodes as 1 out of one, so yes. NO ONE in their right mind would rate stuff like this 1 of 5. I said that before and Ill repeat: Rating this 1 of 5 is as incomprehensible as rating naruto chapter 5 of 5. |
|
Kennesty said: Gonna keep voting this a 1 because the poll is stupid. Just keep it as 1-5 out of 10 because over 9000 hasn't been funny in like 3 years and people have the right to vote it 1 if they didn't like the episode. If you can't handle other peoples opinions, then stop going on message boards. have to agree with fai . . Kennesty , you actually sound like an absolute hater or a troll here . . If you'Re giving this episode a 1 on the base of this poll , then your the most disgusting form of troll i've seen . And if not , then care to explain what made you rate this episode a 1 . . . Without that , you're just a huge troll . . Don't agree wit you about the naruto thing though fai . . :) |
lafuria_suxMay 30, 2010 12:11 PM
| Just as usual: it's great! :) This episode (just like the other ones) felt so short! T_T MUSTANGGGGG! T_T I hope he won't be like this forever. Al's scene was so sad. Scar vs. Bradley! Now, Scar has a chance to win! :P |
asx-niciMay 30, 2010 3:49 PM
| Don't belive in yourself! Belive in me who belives in you! (TTGL) XD ...LOVE and PEACE!! ^_^ |
| If I hadn't read the manga I'd be like this "O_O" when Mustang lost his sight. Same goes to Al and his body. Amazing episode,as always. |
HawthorneKitty said: DeviantKaos said: He's a FIRSTfag, what do you expect.Fai said: THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Watching the episode. If it will end on where it should, it will be epic :3 good job discussing the episode. yus. posting the thread before it even finishes is so WIN huh. |
|
| I think I want to die........ |
Well one thing I've learned from this experience, is that a princess is still a princesss even when she is naked. |
| Great episode, Al gave up his body :( And geez guys who cares what the poll says, its just a poll and lets be honest, if you've watched 59 episodes of FMAB and aren't enjoying it then what the hell are you doing here? |
 |
| I sense epic battles are going to arrive next time! God this is already too late to be stated but why did Hoenheim have to be this sticky situation? |
 |
| Yea this episode was amazing but I cried about what happened to Roy.....so sad....not gonna lie I cried when this happened in the manga too......Poor Al having to give up his body but I honestly think he will be back.....next episode is gonna be epic....and.......yea not gonna say anything what happens next I promise :) But I really want the next episode now not gonna lie |
| My Favorite Anime/Manga: FMA (I support Royai and EdWin!) Soul Eater Bleach Naruto "It's bad enough he is useless on rainy days" Riza from FMA  |
| Interesting episode but wait, did they really do that to Mustang?!?! I can't accept it; not this one. Mei finally became useful and did something worth remembering. Al is ... uh, I guess his chivalrous attitude is too much for me. |
     |
| Epic. He gave up on his body? Even w/ a useless body like that I'd rather that than scrap metal, you can always bulk up to fight rather than risk not being able to get your body back. But I guess he did make a good choice, but will he be able to win the fight, it seems they all about to become sacrificial lamb. |
 |
| Great episode. The animation quality is excellent. Fully-fit Scar vs. half-dead Bradley will be one of the best fights. Should be an equal match (sorry, but Bradley in full health would kill Scar in about 10 seconds). I like how they explain Mustang's forced human transmutation, cuz they didn't rly do so in the manga. Also, the Homunculi should rightly fear flame alchemy, as it's awesome and blasts away anyone unless they're as quick as Bradley... Not gonna like waiting a week for the next ep... Also, what's with the 1/5 scores? This series is epic. If you hate the 9000/5 thing, then just score the episode 5/5 ^^ |
| I read through some other forums discussing this episode and I gotta admit, the part when Roy went blind just wasn't dramatic enough. He acted a bit too calm though it may be because he was in shock. That long stare between Scar and Bradley was a bit awkward...they should have cut out that scene. Honestly, it looked like Bradley was pinning down Roy for sexual assault for one second. -_- And the fact that the anime throws out Mustang in the rest of the scene (and manga) is kind of irritating...I mean, he's blind! |
TenzoX said: I read through some other forums discussing this episode and I gotta admit, the part when Roy went blind just wasn't dramatic enough. He acted a bit too calm though it may be because he was in shock. That long stare between Scar and Bradley was a bit awkward...they should have cut out that scene. Honestly, it looked like Bradley was pinning down Roy for sexual assault for one second. -_- And the fact that the anime throws out Mustang in the rest of the scene (and manga) is kind of irritating...I mean, he's blind! I'll agree with you, the 15-second stare-down between Bradley and Scar was a little overboard. And while the animation was consistently good for the episode, I feel they've kept the character design a little TOO simplistic for some of the characters; especially Scar. Other than these minor complaints, the episode was well-done. About the only other thing I think could have used improvement was the use of its soundtrack; they just used like the same three insert songs that they use 90% the rest of the time (Which I find to be one of the biggest disappointments of Brotherhood in general, which has an overall excellent soundtrack). Enough ranting from me though; twas' a great episode, overall. |
| Uh, yeah man. They said that a long time ago. ROFL at the "INTENSE STARING CONTEST." Way to fail, Bones. |
cleverca22 said: am i the only one who can count, i only see 4 'sacrifices' there, i dont remember mei being one of them is the 5th Hoenheim? That's what i was thinking, but i dont remember what he tried to resurrect. |
|
| Whether it was Mustang's forced human transmutation and resulting blindness or Al giving up on getting back his body, both were cruel and sad. At least Riza was saved and nasty goldtooth became a turd. The back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and so on between Scar and Bradley gave me a headache, but I can't wait to see the rest of their fight next time. I get the criticism about the poll, but score the episode not the poll. Geez. |
 |
cleverca22 said: am i the only one who can count, i only see 4 'sacrifices' there, i dont remember mei being one of them is the 5th Hoenheim? Yeah, I think it's him. Can't wait for the EPIC fight of Bradley and Scar >.< |
| This is a signature. |
| I'm impressed every week, everything is just so amazing: the art, the story, and of course the quality, this is the way anime should be done. OK, this episode took us to the end of 102, therefore: 60: chapters 103-104 61: chapter 105- half of 106 62: chapter second half of 106 - 107 63: chapter 108 Uggh, the math doesn't work out the only way this is going to happen is if they make episode 62 and 63 into one hour each. |
ShiraKiryuu said: Yea I can't either and Hoenheim is the 5th sacrifice along with the other 4 Mei went down there just to help outcleverca22 said: am i the only one who can count, i only see 4 'sacrifices' there, i dont remember mei being one of them is the 5th Hoenheim? Yeah, I think it's him. Can't wait for the EPIC fight of Bradley and Scar >.< |
| My Favorite Anime/Manga: FMA (I support Royai and EdWin!) Soul Eater Bleach Naruto "It's bad enough he is useless on rainy days" Riza from FMA |
Kracksickles said: cleverca22 said: am i the only one who can count, i only see 4 'sacrifices' there, i dont remember mei being one of them is the 5th Hoenheim? That's what i was thinking, but i dont remember what he tried to resurrect. lol he didnt resurrect anything he's like father remember?....he can use alchemy without moving |
alexcampos said: I'm impressed every week, everything is just so amazing: the art, the story, and of course the quality, this is the way anime should be done. OK, this episode took us to the end of 102, therefore: 60: chapters 103-104 61: chapter 105- half of 106 62: chapter second half of 106 - 107 63: chapter 108 Uggh, the math doesn't work out the only way this is going to happen is if they make episode 62 and 63 into one hour each. how does the math not work out? lol |
suigetsu00 said: alexcampos said: I'm impressed every week, everything is just so amazing: the art, the story, and of course the quality, this is the way anime should be done. OK, this episode took us to the end of 102, therefore: 60: chapters 103-104 61: chapter 105- half of 106 62: chapter second half of 106 - 107 63: chapter 108 Uggh, the math doesn't work out the only way this is going to happen is if they make episode 62 and 63 into one hour each. how does the math not work out? lol Because there is no way they can do chapters 106-108 the way I put it. It has to be hour long episodes, there is just too much material. Or maybe I'm wrong, and they'll find a way to do it, either way 4 episodes to go, lets all hope they're as good as the 59 previous ones. |
| omg .. he lost his sight o-o |
     |
suigetsu00 said: alexcampos said: I'm impressed every week, everything is just so amazing: the art, the story, and of course the quality, this is the way anime should be done. OK, this episode took us to the end of 102, therefore: 60: chapters 103-104 61: chapter 105- half of 106 62: chapter second half of 106 - 107 63: chapter 108 Uggh, the math doesn't work out the only way this is going to happen is if they make episode 62 and 63 into one hour each. how does the math not work out? lol It doesn't work out because 107 is ridiculously long (71 pages) and can't possibly fit into half an episode. 108 is rumored to be even longer. As for the episode itself: I'm still in shock. Hell, I read these chapters 5-6 months ago and I'm still in shock. Scar/Bradley fight was wonderfully handled, and I'm looking forward to seeing the rest of it animated. Loved Al's decision to come back in his armor body to fight- even though in hindsight it would have been better to just stay by the gate. But most of all... Roy's blind. IMO that's the biggest "Oh my god!" moment in the series so far, and frankly that says a lot, with some of the emotionally brutal moments in the show. Most major character deaths in anime haven't shaken me as much as Mustang losing his eyesight. |
 |
ArnoldK said: suigetsu00 said: alexcampos said: I'm impressed every week, everything is just so amazing: the art, the story, and of course the quality, this is the way anime should be done. OK, this episode took us to the end of 102, therefore: 60: chapters 103-104 61: chapter 105- half of 106 62: chapter second half of 106 - 107 63: chapter 108 Uggh, the math doesn't work out the only way this is going to happen is if they make episode 62 and 63 into one hour each. how does the math not work out? lol It doesn't work out because 107 is ridiculously long (71 pages) and can't possibly fit into half an episode. 108 is rumored to be even longer. ok...yeah i see your point, i know how long the chapters have been.....i've read em lol but i just assumed that they'd figure it out some how |
suigetsu00 said: Kracksickles said: cleverca22 said: am i the only one who can count, i only see 4 'sacrifices' there, i dont remember mei being one of them is the 5th Hoenheim? That's what i was thinking, but i dont remember what he tried to resurrect. lol he didnt resurrect anything he's like father remember?....he can use alchemy without moving oh okay. I just thought that in order to be one of the sacrifices you have to perform human transmutation. |
|
ArnoldK said: I'm still in shock. Hell, I read these chapters 5-6 months ago and I'm still in shock. Scar/Bradley fight was wonderfully handled, and I'm looking forward to seeing the rest of it animated. Loved Al's decision to come back in his armor body to fight- even though in hindsight it would have been better to just stay by the gate. But most of all... Roy's blind. IMO that's the biggest "Oh my god!" moment in the series so far, and frankly that says a lot, with some of the emotionally brutal moments in the show. Most major character deaths in anime haven't shaken me as much as Mustang losing his eyesight. My point exactly. I had to download episode 59 and watch it like several times to understand what's going on... Dibs to Shinichiro Miki's scream at 11:26 (Roy's voice actor) and honestly, I'm an anime follower, not a manga reader. As for manga like Naruto/Bleach, I follow the anime and never read the manga...but for FMA, it interested me too much so I went ahead to read the manga. Ugh. How could they blind Roy? Anyhow, as for the episodes being long, I think there are confirmed rumors that the last chapters of FMA are about 90 pages long. I doubt they can cram everything into four episodes...unless they want to make a movie or something. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - May 24, 2009 |
218 |
by Merra_
»»
Dec 22, 2:31 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 27 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Oct 11, 2009 |
299 |
by veryver
»»
Dec 16, 9:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 22 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - Sep 6, 2009 |
212 |
by PacJudes
»»
Dec 11, 7:28 PM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Apr 26, 2009 |
456 |
by Citizen_Insane
»»
Dec 11, 6:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Ahenshihael - May 17, 2009 |
180 |
by NewBigos
»»
Dec 6, 9:23 AM |