Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Nov 24, 7:52 AM

Offline
Mar 2015
122
The amount of ya’ll who are defending the season simply because it’s one punch man instead of critiquing the show genuinely is absurd. Season 1 was excellent and was animated by a marvelous studio. Season 2 was a bit mediocre. Season 3’s animation is absolutely abysmal and it shows. This isn’t a small IP, I’m not sure why yall are settling for sub-par quality for a show we’ve already waited years for a season 3 for.
Nov 24, 8:08 AM
Offline
Jun 2024
146
Reply to Jomei-Jiro
There likely is people hating on it just because it's the current trend, that will always happen but objectively it's a very bad season.

- Garou slide being a png moving down a hill diagonally with no dirt or dust flying up.
- Ripper being drawn as a female when the character is a male
- Atomic Samurais hair being chopped off at the top in episode 6
- episode 6 having weird neon filters put over it during the first half which made no sense as to why it's used and just looks bad
- Scenes where it's clearly still images with very basic animation to try and pass it off as animation, leading to it being a slideshow.
- A scene where, in the manga, Genos and Fubuki are climbing stairs but in the anime it's just a still image of the side of Saitamas apartment building
- An approximate two minute hot pot scene that was boring and uninteresting which was barely animated
- Lack of Saitama fighting - I assume he's going to fight at some point in S3 but with the quality of the animation overall, I don't have high hopes it'll be good
- Characters looking stiff and awful with no depth perception or shading, particularly Genos' new design from the doctor - in the Manga it looks sick, in the anime it looks dull and boring.
- Whole scenes being drawn awfully, the one that comes to my mind is episode 6 where the heroes are storming out of the HQ. If you compare the manga vs anime shots, the Manga wins every time for looking better.

I'm sure i'm forgetting some more in the above list that I could add but overall, it's a really bad season which likely comes down to Bandai Namco. I don't think the season will be cancelled, they'll see it out for another 6 weeks but unless a miracle happens, i'd be shocked if they announce a season 4.
@Jomei-Jiro Latest update: Captain Mizuki had 6 fingers and three Bs on her chest, which made fans suspect they are using AI which ruin honest drawings before animate, aside from censoring her design.
Nov 24, 9:52 AM

Offline
Oct 2014
15856
I think it's mostly disappointment. I'm sure there are other anime out there with worth animation that have higher scores, but the OPM manga and S1 were both loved, and it's the downfall that people are rating this based on. It's the disconnect between expectations and reality. If people see a show from a brand new studio based on a manga they've never heard of they don't expect it to be good. OPM is a popular manga. The author's other work, Mob Psycho 100 got great scores for all three seasons because Bones committed to adapting the entire thing well. People wanted this to be great, and so it's devastating when it sucks, a lot more than when the 5th best isekai of the season sucks because you were already expecting that one to.

You do get a bit of the popularity effect as well. There were lots of people who thought SAO was the worst anime ever made because they had only seen like 50 anime. OPM having such a big fanbase does mean a lot of its audience has no experience with the truly atrocious stuff so this could very well be the worst anime they've ever seen. I saw someone even when it was 5.2 think that "this must be the lowest rated anime on the site" because they are not used to true garbage. They're not comparing this to Skelter Heaven or Vampire Holmes, they've never heard of those. They're seeing a sequel to an anime they love being barely even animated. It's a new level of trash they aren't used.
Nov 24, 2:33 PM

Offline
Jan 2021
3379
It's literally only because of the atrocious animation, the writing in S1 wasn't any better than the one in this season and it was filled with unfunny jokes. You hear many complaints about animation because OPM is very popular, so people who have barely watched anything will treat it as the worst thing that have ever happened in the industry when in reality it isn't even the worst anime airing right now, mind you, these complaints are valid because the animation is really bad, but OPM was always a bad series and that is unrelated to animation.
Nov 24, 3:37 PM
Online
Jan 2025
142
AbsoluteTF said:
ahan0306 said:
idk maybe bcs its one of the worst adaptation of a big manga? and I've seen promise neverland s2 and blue lock s2. there is nothing this anime done to elevate the source material, and that's the whole point of an anime😭✌️

That’s not the whole point of the anime lol if you want to be accurate the whole point of an anime from a manga id to make more money then anime is fine and I don’t see the problem

um no anime is supposed to be an advertisement to a manga. therefore it needs to be better than the manga, so ut can attract non manga readers into buying the manga
Nov 24, 4:37 PM

Offline
Apr 2022
8217
Reply to AMBITZZ
@ryzxgum if you think OPM is just about Saitama you're in the wrong here buddy
@AMBITZZ i never said it's only about him, i said he's the only character worth caring about in the show.



Mod Edit: Removed baiting.
ScaryOwlNov 26, 10:15 AM
Nov 24, 4:57 PM

Online
Apr 2021
754
bc this series is about fights and action, more so in this arc, therefore if the animation is not up to the standards ppl dislikes it. Plus it makes a lot of noise since its a popular title
Nov 24, 10:11 PM

Offline
Oct 2022
1398
The short and easy answer is croppedhead.png
Go read Sousou no Frieren and One Piece they're the best thing ever
Nov 24, 10:14 PM
Offline
Nov 2020
911
Reply to ryzxgum
@AMBITZZ i never said it's only about him, i said he's the only character worth caring about in the show.



Mod Edit: Removed baiting.
@ryzxgum that's the same thing dawg.
Nov 25, 1:14 AM

Offline
May 2021
2410
Reply to diamondd24
S2 is hated because of trend, it ain't even that bad, it just not that good compare to masterpiece like S1. S3 in the other hand, have bad animation, bad pacing, and bad style, I rather get those weird gloss on S2 than the weird rainbow ahh style
diamondd24 said:
it ain't even that bad

Yeah CS GO sound effects
weird texture lighting
severe decrease of the quality of animation.

Yeah it ain't that bad. Sit down please
Nov 25, 1:23 AM
Offline
Mar 2024
1
OPM3 is a puckin’ joke… Really bad compared to other anime with less budget, it's normally impossible to have such a result with so many means per episode... it stinks of embezzlement
Nov 25, 6:30 AM

Offline
Nov 2020
1027
I won't list the reasons because your question is extremely dishonest, you know perfectly well why people hate it xD

I really don't understand people like you. You defend a product that doesn't meet the bare minimum in terms of production quality, and who are you doing this for? A corporation that doesn't care about you and supplies you with complete crap?
Nov 25, 11:29 AM

Offline
Feb 2014
5826
Reply to Ba-Cii10
I won't list the reasons because your question is extremely dishonest, you know perfectly well why people hate it xD

I really don't understand people like you. You defend a product that doesn't meet the bare minimum in terms of production quality, and who are you doing this for? A corporation that doesn't care about you and supplies you with complete crap?
@Ba-Cii10
I mean, I know SOME of the complaints people make, I just don't think they're as catastrophic as people were saying.
There's legitimate criticism, but people will also spam nonsensical ones (e.g. Complaining about a lack of continuity of the background in a scene with Garou... when in reality he changed places. Complaining about the slide... when he IS sliding on the manga. Complaining of "Low animation and too much color palette change"... when JoJo does that all the time).
Nov 25, 12:12 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
1476
thewiru said:
Complaining about a lack of continuity of the background in a scene with Garou... when in reality he changed places.


This is exactly a great example of bad animation/ bad direction. Continuity matters. I remember when the remake of Boogiepop Phantom came out, the whole first episode was ment to be a lapso of literally months, but due to bad continuity everything felt like it was just a couple of days, giving the sense of attachment towards the main girl from the male co-protag just jarring and non sensical.

thewiru said:
Complaining about the slide... when he IS sliding on the manga.


Because the slide is literally a PNG just being dragged down with zero animation. There's no debris moving around, dust or even grass moving. Someone on reddit even pointed out how a simplistic slide from season 1 looks more alive than Garou looking like some dvd screensaver.

https://old.reddit.com/r/OnePunchMan/comments/1oc832u/garou_sliding_vs_amai_mask_sliding/

thewiru said:
I just don't think they're as catastrophic as people were saying.


Yeah, this is just being cynical. <insert dog cartoon in room on fire>


Nov 25, 12:52 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
361
It doesn't even feel like an anime, it's like a slideshow of pictures with some elements moving now and then.
They got great voice actors that's it.
It's also one of the best drawn manga out there, while the anime is one of the worst animated which makes it extra bad.

People with no experience in animating could just use coloured panels from the manga and animate them with ease in Photoshop, which wouldn't be that different from what they have animated.

Yes, it's very very bad.


Let's say that an original anime series was animated this way, noone would watch it.
I mean is https://myanimelist.net/anime/3287/Tenkuu_Danzai_Skelter+Heaven even worse than this?
Nov 25, 3:47 PM

Offline
Jan 2011
230
I mean, if they wanted to cut corners - specially with the Evangelion level of tight schedule they have - at least hire an art director and do something that has some style.

Nobody complains about Ikuhara shows or David Production, Shaft, etc.
Nov 25, 4:20 PM

Offline
Apr 2022
8217
Reply to AMBITZZ
@ryzxgum that's the same thing dawg.
@AMBITZZ it means other characters are there, they're just not worth caring about.




Mod Edit: Removed baiting.
ScaryOwlNov 26, 10:18 AM
Nov 25, 4:40 PM
Offline
Aug 2013
629
I think it is obvious

If you are looking for a deep reason? No deep reason ... they already hated S2 when it wasn't even bad did you expect them to love S3? obviously not
Nov 25, 6:16 PM
Offline
Nov 2020
911
Reply to ryzxgum
@AMBITZZ it means other characters are there, they're just not worth caring about.




Mod Edit: Removed baiting.
@ryzxgum There are many great characters most notably Garou, Metal Bat, King etc. and the entire point of ONE PUNCH MAN is that it's not JUST about One punch man.

Mod Edit: Removed baiting.
ScaryOwlNov 26, 10:19 AM
Nov 25, 8:26 PM
Offline
Apr 2018
172
Messup BGM, very few Frame per scene, reuse a lot of scene.
Nov 26, 3:47 AM
Offline
Aug 2017
4
I personally don't like it cause they give saitama a screentime of 5seconds an episode and the rest is boring bs. Nothing is wrong with the artstyle idk whats wrong with the people who have problems with the prefectly fine artstyle when we have bigger problems here. I'm tired of this being the regular on this show season 1 was great but now it doesn't feel like their show anymore, I wanna see more of saitama and genos. 2nd season was the same they can't keep this going
Nov 26, 10:21 AM
Community Mod
~The Scary Owl~

Offline
Sep 2024
666
Thread Cleaned

Please refrain from arguing with other users.
Nov 26, 11:04 AM

Offline
Oct 2017
868
Nobody is "disliking" One Punch Man for being One Punch Man, the motive of the disliking is the absolutely atrocious final product presented, with terrible animation, weird cuts, the triple boob.

I argued in other places that OPM S2 was unnecessarily hated by the people, because of the worse-than-average animation, since OPM 2 involved more social critique. But now it's completely impossible to defend S3 due to the mentioned above.

If I present an appaling report/work/animation/drawing in my work, I would be immediately fired. There's absolutely no excuse to present this to the public, and if you need time to draw/animate, just cancel the airing and ask for a new slot in a future season, it won't be the first nor the last time it occurs, and it has more dignity.
"What a Player, what a Champion here at Wimbledon, the first man to win 8 Championships."
Andrew Castle on Roger Federer winning his 19th Grand Slam title.
Dec 2, 12:58 PM
Offline
Feb 2024
14
I honestly think that most people are overreacting. I get that this season is a major downgrade from its predecessors; however, I don't think it has the worst animation ever. I dare to say that it has animation comparable to most anime -not great, but it gets the job done. Most people are also overlooking its stronger points, like its music and story. They did not butcher the plot, unlike The Promised Neverland season 2, so it can't be that bad.
Dec 2, 4:02 PM
Offline
Nov 2018
309
this whole One Punch Man discourse since season 2 came out is just an entire psychosis based on commodified ignorance.
Season 2 revisionism is so funny given that the rhetoric was similar and that was in 2019, getting worse based on the idealistic ignoring of the production circumstance and the production being worse (its funny because morons are just focusing on the animation, when that pretty much never matters) doesn't change that.
Also the Problems people have with the plot it being based on the manga doesn't matter because the colors are pretty, so the anime gets all the slander
Flick_onDec 2, 4:20 PM
Dec 6, 2:04 AM
Offline
Jun 2024
9
Reply to SuperDuperKnight
@Quithryx I didn't say much in the beginning specifically to avoid seeming like I was jumping on the hate bandwagon, but even I couldn't defend the show after these past few episodes. The characters barely move, even what is drawn isn't done very well, and it's frankly very distracting, especially for an action genre show in which fluid motion is a big part of the visual storytelling. This isn't just a typical slice of life. They even try to do techniques to avoid showing the lip flaps to save on the animation, like in the last scene of the ep 7 in which they show a panorama of the group from the back while they're talking.

I'll be honest, your post seems like the type of post a hardcore fan would make to cope that a show they like is rightfully getting criticized. I've seen this plenty of times before. "Sure there are some flaws but it's still good." It's always some version of that line. But it's not good. Not even close. The animation of someone's snot in Gnosia was better than OPM season 3, and Gnosia isn't even an action genre show.
@SuperDuperKnight Yeh I guess that's true.
There was also that moment in ep 7 or 8 iirc where we saw the fat due who eats a lot (no idea his name mb chat) and literally the food was teleporting into his hand and then from his hand to his mouth and stuff and it's not like his power is teleportation or anything it's just super lazy animation
also lowkey I'm not some huge fan but the hate is just too much yeah its not good but like yall are making it seem like worst anime of the century.
Dec 8, 7:53 PM
Offline
Jul 2022
18
Reply to Quithryx
@SuperDuperKnight Yeh I guess that's true.
There was also that moment in ep 7 or 8 iirc where we saw the fat due who eats a lot (no idea his name mb chat) and literally the food was teleporting into his hand and then from his hand to his mouth and stuff and it's not like his power is teleportation or anything it's just super lazy animation
also lowkey I'm not some huge fan but the hate is just too much yeah its not good but like yall are making it seem like worst anime of the century.
@Quithryx The reason why there is hate is because of the expectations. The series became very popular and although season 2 wasn't as good, there was still a ton of hype for season 3, especially from the long wait. Unlike something like ex-ARM, which not many people have heard of before, One Punch Man, both character and series, has become very iconic in anime. To see it get treated like this vs some random property that most people don't know about is why it's getting so much hate.
Dec 11, 11:46 AM
Offline
Jun 2024
9
Reply to SuperDuperKnight
@Quithryx The reason why there is hate is because of the expectations. The series became very popular and although season 2 wasn't as good, there was still a ton of hype for season 3, especially from the long wait. Unlike something like ex-ARM, which not many people have heard of before, One Punch Man, both character and series, has become very iconic in anime. To see it get treated like this vs some random property that most people don't know about is why it's getting so much hate.
@SuperDuperKnight truth
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Softhenic03 - Yesterday

143 by TomuKun »»
30 minutes ago

Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

IzanaSolos - Dec 7

146 by TomuKun »»
58 minutes ago

Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

IzanaSolos - Oct 19

347 by Antagonized »»
4 hours ago

Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

IzanaSolos - Oct 12

508 by Antagonized »»
5 hours ago

Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Softhenic03 - Nov 2

259 by Lighshyper1 »»
6 hours ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login