Forum Settings
Forums

...why is Miyazaki treated like an anime authority?

New
Pages (3) « 1 2 [3]
Sep 17, 3:15 PM
Community Mod
Online
Sep 2024
620
Thread Cleaned

Posts which violate the Site & Forum Guidelines have been removed
Sep 17, 3:19 PM

Online
Feb 2014
5014
Reply to HokutoMumyoZan
He's taken seriously by white Hollywood and US animation and comic industry and censorship apologists people because his works are masterpieces and he's a major figure of anti-consumerism.

Despite him and Studio Ghibli dumping out cheap merchandise and would look the other way if he ever had Anno's licensing opportunities.
@HokutoMumyoZan
I had a friend of mine jokingly call him "The Japanese Adorno" and I can't stop thinking about it.
Sep 17, 6:42 PM

Offline
Jan 2008
793
Because he's an old man, and people are fond of Ghibli. That's really it.

Oh, and also because Ghibli movies are often very wholesome and beautiful (he is a fantastic artist, that's undeniable).

He's always been critical of the industry and of other artists in general. He's very much an "I am an artist and anyone who doesn't make art the way I do is not" type of person, and it shows if you've ever really paid attention to the way he acts.

It's kind of like that meme of Miyazaki (ghibli) vs Miyazaki (demon souls). One makes horrors and is a happy man inside, one males happy fantasies and is a detached man inside.

Supreme Seireitei - Captain of the 10th Court Guard Squad



Sep 17, 7:29 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
164
Maybe because……
1) he's been animating since 1963
2) he’s an extremely talented animator
3) Gibli studios (which he cofounded) is overall very well received even amongst non anime fans.
4) two oscar winning movies - spirited away and the boy and the heron under his belt.

Sure not everyone agrees with his opinions and he’s becoming more and more “old man yelling at clouds”, but one can’t simply overlook his contributions to anime as a whole.
Sep 18, 12:57 AM
Nostalgia Rules!

Offline
Jun 2008
13838
Because he's popular and mainstream. I personally don't consider him any kind of authority, he's good but nobody should have that power.
Sep 19, 2:20 AM

Offline
Feb 2015
4147
This thread becomes even funnier, once you realize @TheWiru never watched ANY Miyazaki anime (or anything else by Ghibli) at all. Not even the most popular ones like Princess Mononoke or Chihiro. How would you even know if he's overrated or not? Just watch some of his stuff and you will see for yourself if it holds up or not. 🙄
Sep 19, 3:57 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
2729
Reply to MelodyOfMemory
Because everyone copies his stuff. It's hard to see any Japanese media (and even some international media) without seeing some reference to Nausicaa, Castle in the Sky, etc. Like, Hideaki Anno specifically modelled the Evas off his work on the God Warriors for Nausicaa.
@MelodyOfMemory
>everybody copies his stuff
Yeah, no. Throwaway references to Miyazaki aren't really "copying him". In fact I rarely see anybody seriously try to ape Miyazaki, like he's left in this "comfy visuals and serious themes" niche of his own. A few have tried here and there but even then it doesn't come off as "Miyazaki but done by somebody else".
Hot Blood saves lives.
Sep 19, 11:12 AM

Online
Feb 2014
5014
Reply to AshitaNoJonas
This thread becomes even funnier, once you realize @TheWiru never watched ANY Miyazaki anime (or anything else by Ghibli) at all. Not even the most popular ones like Princess Mononoke or Chihiro. How would you even know if he's overrated or not? Just watch some of his stuff and you will see for yourself if it holds up or not. 🙄
AshitaNoJonas said:
How would you even know if he's overrated or not?

I don't, which is why I never used the word "overrated" here.
Pages (3) « 1 2 [3]

More topics from this board

» Is there an antagonism against the sheer concept of "anime"?

thewiru - 1 hour ago

6 by Szczelajo »»
5 minutes ago

» Old video game you surprised doesn't get anime yet?

m_alhafidz - Today

9 by jacobPOL »»
5 minutes ago

» Anime Tourism ( 1 2 3 )

tchitchouan - Sep 14

109 by jal90 »»
7 minutes ago

» If you BUILT A HAREM with only 3 Anime Girls (or Anime Boys), who would you pick and why!?!?

IpreferEcchi - Sep 19

23 by Saputrai »»
13 minutes ago

» Crunchyroll reveals their Fall 2025 Season Lineup!

StarBloom_64 - 7 hours ago

7 by Zarutaku »»
15 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login