Monogatari Series: First Season
BestListMAL said: The fact that you didn't drop ex-arm makes me wonder how far you'd make it into this showgekojay said: You clearly don't understand my list as it's too complicated for you, but I don't rate based on the Total Episode Count, I base it on the Episodes I have watched, if that 14,700 episode show is so bad I drop within 2 episodes then it would be bottom, last place on my list.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058796/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_2 I found this man's perfect show You won't mind the 5.2 IMDb rating becuase there are 14,700 episodes! Enjoy! |
I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
BestListMAL said: It's for the average mean score MAL users have, not the average score of all animeBro's either trolling or is high on bath salts or some shit cuz this is some of the most unintelligable shit I've ever read yet again you are failing to understand pretty basic stuff. what is hard to get? the AVG MAL score is 6.5 but that is for all anime ever made, me personally I only mainly watch highly rated anime so if you check MAL's averages for only the shows I have watched, it would have a much higher average than 6.5, maybe about 8.1 if I guessed. Making my mean score below average. |
| I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
It's for the average mean score MAL users have, not the average score of all anime ok but literally read my bio, my list is factual, there is evidence behind it, it can not be disproved. I may have a high mean score, but all evidence backs up that is correct. |
BestListMAL said: Oh shit I didn't read that. My bad. You are correct. Have a nice day.It's for the average mean score MAL users have, not the average score of all anime ok but literally read my bio, my list is factual, there is evidence behind it, it can not be disproved. I may have a high mean score, but all evidence backs up that is correct. |
| I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
| Time spent on certain things =/= enjoyment of certain things. I know you will counter that with "you are just hate watching", but how does that make any sense? Is everything that you do in a day really enjoyable for you? Is walking through the rain also a form of hate-living if you don't enjoy rain? If I watch a decently good show that is 12 episodes long, that does not mean that I think it is 4x better than a really good 1-hour long movie that I have only watched once. After all, who would watch a movie 4 times, especially when said movie relies on plot-twists and unexpected revelations that will only be unique the first time watching it. Whatever, this is a joke account that was created with the sole purpose of pissing people like me off. Congrats, you win. |
   |
playgamewithme14 said: some One Piece youtuber went to see Film Red in cinema like 30+ times and will no doubt continue rewatching it in the future, that is a situation where a movie deserves a high score (maybe not for you or me, but for that guy) whereas the example you gave, if the movie relies so heavy on certain things that it can't be rewatched, then it isn't as good as you may believe. Time spent on certain things =/= enjoyment of certain things. I know you will counter that with "you are just hate watching", but how does that make any sense? Is everything that you do in a day really enjoyable for you? Is walking through the rain also a form of hate-living if you don't enjoy rain? If I watch a decently good show that is 12 episodes long, that does not mean that I think it is 4x better than a really good 1-hour long movie that I have only watched once. After all, who would watch a movie 4 times, especially when said movie relies on plot-twists and unexpected revelations that will only be unique the first time watching it. Whatever, this is a joke account that was created with the sole purpose of pissing people like me off. Congrats, you win. |
BestListMAL said: Watching a movie 30 times and still thinking it is enjoyable means it must be really good in that person's eyes, I agree.some One Piece youtuber went to see Film Red in cinema like 30+ times and will no doubt continue rewatching it in the future, that is a situation where a movie deserves a high score (maybe not for you or me, but for that guy) whereas the example you gave, if the movie relies so heavy on certain things that it can't be rewatched, then it isn't as good as you may believe But what you are saying is that a movie or a show should refrain from being shocking, surprising, and should not rely on unexpected plot-twists, since it would not make a second rewatch as enjoyable. I watched Perfect Blue a few weeks ago with a friend, and it blew our minds. We talked about the movie for 3 hours after, which I think indicates our enjoyment more than slogging through a 12 episode season. However, would I watch Perfect Blue again if you asked me? No, not right now. The memory of it is so fresh, and I know all of the surprising things that will happen, so a second rewatch will not be as enjoyable for me. Does that mean the movie isn't as good as I make it out to be? Well, that's where we differ in opinion. |
|
ktg said: how can you claim to objectively rate a show when your ratings aren't even based on facts, my ratings literally have factual, mathematical reasoning behind them, yours are subjective opinions. That doesn't make it better. A show's quality has nothing to do with your enjoyment. For example, the animation won't become better and better every time you watch it. While the score should represent the show's qualities. And by your logic, everything is better that you watched compared to shows you haven't watched yet. |
| No one claims that they can objectively rate a show That's literally an oxymoron |
|
| this just happens to be one of the best pieces of media ever made, I don't think people are particularly generous with this. it should be rated higher really. |
 |
First, your list has zero "factual, mathematical reasoning". You subjectively decided how much time what ratings should be. Like you've spent 86 hours watching Naruto, you've spent 193 hours watching Naruto Shippuuden and you gave it a 10 and lastly you've spent less than 10 hours on ToraDora and you gave it a 10. So your "factual, mathematical reasoning" says 193, 86 and 10 hours are the same. You even fk'd up your method: One Piece movie 5: 1 hour, 35 minutes and you gave it a 5. One Piece movie 7: 1 hour, 34 minutes and you gave it a 5. While the shorter Seishun Buta Yarou wa Yumemiru Shoujo no Yume wo Minai which is 1 hour, 30 minutes got a 6. That's not all, Steins;Gate Movie: Fuka Ryouiki no Déjà vu also 1 hour, 30 minutes and you rated as a 7. Second, generally, your rating system never can be factual. You have a scale of 10 while the shows' length has infinite options. The shortest shows on the website are less than 1 min long. If you were factual you would even try to differentiate between 11, 12 or 13 episode long series. You don't do that, because you know your rating system is stupid. Third, you are wrong here too. Just because I don't share my methods on my profile, doesn't mean I don't have one. I rate a show objectively as possible on a 2-9 scale and change a bit (+-1) based on my enjoyment. In this case it is as objective as it can be and still shows my opinion. So like every shows that got 10 on my list is a show that I enjoyed. But just because I enjoyed a show it can get a 10. As for the movies, One Piece movie 5 and 7 I class as being 4 episodes, as you would need 1 Hour 40 Minutes of screentime to be 5 episodes. (sometimes I make exceptions and round up, not for these crap tho) That Bunny Girl Senpai movie is also 4 episodes of screentime, therefore it is not a fight on screentime but my enjoyment, so 4eps of bunny girl which I enjoyed more than 4 eps of non-canon movie gives bunny girl the win. (see my list is always 2 steps ahead of your baseless accusations, that is what it means to be factual). I also do differentiate between 11, 12 and 13 episode shows but sometimes they fall into the same rating. |
| Ya'll need to stop taking the bait from these accounts. Dude types like his only two YouTube subscriptions are Richard Dawkins and Chess.com I mean, by this logic since I tend to rewatch trashy isekai often, and Bleach once every two or so years to scavenge some dopamine from my nostalgia, they're all deserving of a 10. Good bait though. |
| loool Nice troll thread, going to be fun reading through this pero~ |
 |
These sentences perfectly prove my point, because this means your ratings system has nothing to do with facts. It is not factual, because as you said it, you make exception, but sometimes not, sometimes consider other factors etc. I guess you are correct, when two things have the same episode count, then I use subjective ratings like everyone else. But for the most part my ratings are factual.This is exactly what you call subjective rating. It's pretty pathetic that you keep lying. :) |
Daddi4900 said: well, I definitly agree with Silent Voice, because it's so good I've rewatched it 4 times making it the equivilent to a 24 episode show. If all anime movies were so good they could be rewatched that many times, then this debate wouldn't be happening. The idea that length and quality of media are at all correlated is fallacious. It's entirely reasonable to tell a short, poignant story in a small timeframe that hits like a truck, and it's also possible to tell a long story over hundreds of episodes, to the detriment of the pacing of each. Anime movies like Your Name, A Silent Voce, or like the top 5 Ghibli movies are all among the most popular anime media in the west. If you want an answer specific to these movies, though, I think they paint a beautiful picture of Araragi's relationships with Kiss-Shot, Oshino, and Hanekawa. The bossa musical motif is beautifully-executed, and bro on God the quality of art and animation is insane. |
domata said: if the 500 eps were as bad as you say, you wouldn't have watched them.has to be one of the dumbest things ive read, having a 500+ episodes doesnt mean shit if theyre mid. Nice bait |
| Thread locked for not encouraging discussion. Anime Discussion Rules: 2.e Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage meaningful and/or civil discussion. Examples include: e.ăMAL community data .e.g.ăQuestioning the score/ranking/character favorite counts e.g.ăSaying that series X should have a higher/lower score/count e.g.ăSpecific reviews, moderation of data/community content/reviews, etc. Concerns about the website should be reported using the appropriate buttons or designated MyAnimeList boards. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kizumonogatari Part 1: Tekketsu-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Djidji - Jan 29, 2016 |
228 |
by WaterMage
»»
Dec 18, 4:07 PM |
|
» Should I watch this before the series?Rockyjams909 - Jul 10 |
46 |
by Phantomnocomics
»»
Aug 25, 12:53 PM |
|
» Disregarding the fact that the internal monologues were omitted, how good of an adaptation do the people who have watched the movie think it is?Mado_Mura - Jan 10, 2016 |
6 |
by IconoclastiCrow
»»
Mar 5, 7:00 AM |
|
Poll: » What would you do if you have your limbs chopped off, laying in the ground and no one notices you?TheRayquaza - Jan 22 |
16 |
by dicloflom
»»
Jan 23, 8:55 PM |
|
» Needs the gore tagRaltsPokemon - Dec 15, 2023 |
5 |
by RaltsPokemon
»»
Dec 18, 2023 10:40 AM |