| Engrish is fine but NOT dub. Dub is trash |
WHAT A LAUGHABLE ATTEMPT. YOU SHOULD JUST STAY WHERE YOU ARE, GROVELING AT MY FEET P.S. PLEASE HELP ME GAIN MORE PROFILE VIEWS |
| I prefer subs because anime is japanese, although there are anime from China. Unsure if those have other names like manga, manhwa and the chinese one for manga. |
 |
| 99% of the time no but its a case by case basis. It fucking bothers me so much that Galarian characters in Pokemon Journeys do not have a British or Scottish accent. Alejandro Saab does a good job in the anime, but the Masters actors for the Sword and Shield characters have a more realistic accent for their nationality. Idk why they didn't give the characters accents in the Journeys anime it would have really helped with the immersion |
This post is brought to you by your local transfem gamer goblin. Will not tolerate bigotry and will fight against "anti-woke" sentiment to make the anime community a safer place.  |
| no. when i first started watching anime, i would test out both the sub and dub versions and hope for a good dub bcos to me that was preferable, but now i just watch sub no matter what. |
Sealshark122 said: Dub is better then sub so yes........... I mean if cringing to death when watching English VAs try to do Japanese jokes or hearing words be dismembered by American accents is your objective you're not wrong. |
 |
| For some reason, I had an urge to watch Great Pretender in dub for that exact reason. I watched the first episode in dub because I thought it would feel better, being that they were Los Angeles. However, I ultimately continued the rest of the show with subs because I'm a subs person through and through so it didn't feel right to choose dub. |
desusama said: Also, they are not very good at pronouncing Japanese names. In the case of Haikyuu, it was hard for me to digest how "Kageyama" and "Hinata" was pronounced.Sealshark122 said: Dub is better then sub so yes........... I mean if cringing to death when watching English VAs try to do Japanese jokes or hearing words be dismembered by American accents is your objective you're not wrong. But again, taste is subjective. To each their own. Some people are happy with American accents and feel it's easier for them to follow. |
| Yes, but most of time I'm sure most dub doesn't include a varied amount of English dialects so sadly no. |
 just wanna feel wanted by someone other than the police π« |
| You can't really be more immersed from accent variety when the dub is just worse anyway. |
  |
| Yes. Sometimes I do like the dubs of English speaking settings |
 |
| I prefer if dub is a option for any anime, but that is rarely the case. |
 |
| depends on the anime or if i'm in the mood for dubs |
| I'd prefer all anime to have an English dub lmao |
 |
| Absolutely not. I don't watch or collect dubs. Hell, if I need to download something and it's dual audio I have a little script that demuxes the English dub and deletes it. |
 |
| Honestly it would be cool if they got(good) VA's from they're respective countries to voice act as characters from different countries. For example, they got a good russian VA to voice act as a russian person, etc. |
| I gave up on character of the week since it takes too much thinking. I'll just change my forum pfp to whoever I want every week lol. |
| No. I'll still watch it in subbed regardless but I the dub might make it better for some people |
 ManWild |
| Not that I prefer it or not, but I don't mind it. I can do some anime dubbed and majority of the stuff I watch is subbed. I mean if the dubbed is good for it and it's set in the Western side, sure I would probably think it'll match it a little more better. But yeah I have no issue whatsoever as long as it's well done. |
| Hmm this is an interesting question, I feel like an anime that fits perfectly under this question would be Hellsing Ultimate; but Hellsing Ultimate takes place in Europe, and for the dub; most characters in the series (besides Alucard) have a European accent such as Alexander Anderson who was Scottish, but the interesting thing is that his dub voice actor is literally from Scotland as well. The same can be said about Integra, her dub voice has an English accent but her dub voice actor is from the U.K. But what's also interesting is that in Hellsing Ultimate, the major has a german accent but his dub voice actor is from the U.K, but the dub voice is really well done. So I feel like in some cases it can be fine, I thought Hellsing Ultimate did a fantastic job with the dub but in other cases, it can be pretty cringy, an example of this would be Infinite Stratos where the girls come from different countries but they have accents in the dub and I found it to be really cringe Looks like I found the dubbed anime that @AnimeLeviathan wanted |
Zackack99Apr 17, 2021 2:15 PM
| If the entire show is set in that location, HELL YES!!!! Baccano's dub, as well as the one for 91 Days, absolutely FUCK. I'm a big fan of them :D |
 |
| I'd prefer if the western countries could all speak Japanese. |
| Who doesn't love the obnoxious fake accents of American voice actors... |
| Talking about dubs on MAL is such a lost cost because of the people aren't even willing to be open to the idea of a good dub. Also I have a strong feeling most of the people here haven't even watched a dub that came out in the last 10 years. Also do people who don't like dubs just hate all the voice acting in western video games? Since almost all dub voice actors also do VA work for games. |
Adimus_primeApr 17, 2021 2:50 PM
 |
| I frequently watch and enjoy American English dubs, and I used to think that dubs might be more appropriate for series set in English-speaking countries or perhaps even other western countries. But I found that the setting doesn't seem to correlate much to whether I enjoy the dub. I enjoy dubs of shows set in Japan just fine. Except may be when there's wordplay. The language spoken doesn't seem to factor into my cultural expectations. First, the cultural elements often aren't the focus of the show anyway, and besides, English is my native language, which means that stuff that I hear in English doesn't go through a filter of "it's in English!" when I listen to it. That said, the fact that it's my native language might not matter, since I don't think stuff goes through a filter of "it's in Japanese!" either when I listen to Japanese dialogue; instead it just sounds foreign. I know, cognitively, that it's Japanese, and I can recognize that it's Japanese based on the phonemes, but it's not the same as "feeling" something as being more fitting or less fitting to a story. |
| Avatar character is Gabriel from Gabriel DropOut. |
| I hate it when anime thinks that we need to hear the correct language being spoken whenever they are in a certain part of the globe. When I'm watching Golden Wind, my first thought isn't that they are speaking Japanese in Italy, it's that they are in Italy and that's all that matters to me. |
 |
_Malachite said: I'd prefer all anime to have an English dub lmao Same here. DmonHiro said: Absolutely not. I don't watch or collect dubs. Hell, if I need to download something and it's dual audio I have a little script that demuxes the English dub and deletes it. I do the same but for Japanese subs. I take out the Japanese audio to save space on my hard drive. I'm not going to ever watch it with Japanese audio, so there is no point keeping it. |
| In my mind, anime is in Japanese regardless of the setting. I used to watch dub as a kid, but that's only because I didn't know how to read. From then on, it was always sub. It makes me uncomfortable to watch dub and it feels like I'm not watching anime. I also prefer sub over dub because I think dub removes a lot of the character's personality conveyed in their speech by the Japanese voice actors. I also appreciate the communication hierarchy as it is meaningful to character interactions and reflects the Japanese culture (For example, referring to someone as XXX-san as opposed to referring to a friend or someone they want to tease as xxxx-chan). |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
-Hermit- said: I do the same but for Japanese subs. I never thought I would ever meet the anti-me. So this is what it's like to find your arch nemesis. One day, you and I will fight to the death. I will pick the weapons, you will pick the location. |
|
| If your definition of immersion is verisimilitude, sure. But I'll still watch Monster in its intended language. |
 |
Adimus_prime said: Talking about dubs on MAL is such a lost cost because of the people aren't even willing to be open to the idea of a good dub. Also I have a strong feeling most of the people here haven't even watched a dub that came out in the last 10 years. Also do people who don't like dubs just hate all the voice acting in western video games? Since almost all dub voice actors also do VA work for games. I have to totally agree with this. I prefer dub always and it seems like anytime I voice that opinion people attack me (not on here because I haven't voiced it till now) and its never the other way around in my experience always sub watchers telling dub watchers how stupid they are for having their own preference. |
 |
DmonHiro said: -Hermit- said: I do the same but for Japanese subs. I never thought I would ever meet the anti-me. So this is what it's like to find your arch nemesis. One day, you and I will fight to the death. I will pick the weapons, you will pick the location. Now this is the anime I want to watch. Imagine your final battle you speak in Japanese the entire time with subs they speak in English. You duel to the death. |
|
| nah, hell for even shows like Black Lagoon I watched it in sub, I just can’t keep a straight face hearing dub voice actors in anime; which is funny because in every other form of entertainment I have no problem like video game voice actors I like English for example I saw the Demon Slayer movie trailer in dub to see if it was any good and God was it horrendous legit sounds like a fucking parody |
snowykevinApr 17, 2021 6:48 PM
 |
| Immersive would be an anime to take place in those places and have the local language, why would we want to hear them speaking english? but anwsering the question...NO, I still prefer the japanese voice actors over the english one. |
 |
| It honestly depends if the dub is good enough to warrant a watch, and whether if I'm too tired, watching anime on Netflix on my phone, or if I want to watch it in the background (like I did with DB & DBZ) |
MAL EMOJIS - Get your specially formatted emojis for MAL forums.        |
| It certainly helps if the English dub is good. The famous ones, like Baccano, Hellsing Ultimate or Black Lagoon, where the characters are canonically speaking English anyway and all happen to have fantastic English voice acting, there isn't really any reason to watch the Japanese dub. |
| no for me sub is always better than dub in all the settings. |
| Honestly, I'd still stick with the sub. The only reasons I'll watch a dub is to ridicule it |
 |
snowykevin said: for example I saw the Demon Slayer movie trailer in dub to see if it was any good and God was it horrendous legit sounds like a fucking parody Okay I'm gonna be real, I'm usually a dub guy for the most part but this one is uhhhhhhh. Horribly miscast except for a few characters. I just dealt with the struggle of the sub for this one EDIT: Also that has nothing to do w this thread?? That's just you hating on dubs, not the topic |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Aside from today, when else has anime been considered mainstream?TheBlockernator - Yesterday |
13 |
by dibindibi
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Will the success of KNY have impact in western animation?thewiru - Yesterday |
19 |
by dibindibi
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» Anime you straight up hate. Not just dislike or find bad to watch, genuinely just hate, ( 1 2 )TheBlockernator - Sep 12 |
87 |
by Early_Morning
»»
38 minutes ago |
|
» Do you consider elves as good harem members?Catalano - 10 hours ago |
10 |
by rohan121
»»
42 minutes ago |
|
» Let's go, Rainbow Crown! Waifu War Hair Color-Edition! (Rainbow Crown Quarterfinals) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )TheMinkalex - Aug 15 |
552 |
by Szczelajo
»»
44 minutes ago |