EcchiGodMamster said: the worst criticism i've ever heard i think everyone knows by now the fanservice ruined the scene/show Fanservice should have their time and place, if you are in a tense scene where lifes are at stake, dont stop the scene to give me a funny moment or a ridiculous clumsy fall to show some panty shot Freezing did fanservice correctly, Fire Forces fight between Rekka and Shinra didnt |
 |
Poulain said: Everyone who criticizes anime series without watching at least 75% of the episodes are automatically ridiculous in my book. No scratch it - I still believe you have to watch the whole thing before you make a review. You dont need to watch all of DBZ to know that Vegeta should have killed Cell when he had a chance, yes it makes sense due to his personality but it doesnt make it less stupid |
|
| "The show has lots of fanservice, so it's shit", even for those anime where the genre mentions that it's echhi. |
 |
Tristar_Shinobi said: Yesterday one elitist high iq stud made a forum where he ceitisized every aAnime and Anime fan for not being MATURE What was it about? R+ in old and new anime thread or im confused? |
| BANZAI NIPPON. Nippon is the Land of freedom. Nippon is the Land of Peace. Nippon is the Land of Justice and Prosperity. In Nippon, we trust. We love Nippon, we love Anime. Anime love us, Nippon love us. 日本 |
NeoYami said: EcchiGodMamster said: the worst criticism i've ever heard i think everyone knows by now the fanservice ruined the scene/show Fanservice should have their time and place, if you are in a tense scene where lifes are at stake, dont stop the scene to give me a funny moment or a ridiculous clumsy fall to show some panty shot Freezing did fanservice correctly, Fire Forces fight between Rekka and Shinra didnt That's a nice opinion. Too bad I dont agree Sometimes its what you don't like that makes it appealing to others |
EcchiGodMamsterOct 12, 2020 6:08 AM
   |
EcchiGodMamster said: NeoYami said: Fanservice should have their time and place, if you are in a tense scene where lifes are at stake, dont stop the scene to give me a funny moment or a ridiculous clumsy fall to show some panty shot Freezing did fanservice correctly, Fire Forces fight between Rekka and Shinra didnt That's a nice opinion. Too bad I dont agree Sometimes its what you don't like that makes it appealing to others Well if someone you love is burning and you are only focus on saving them the last thing you want is someone to appear and make burning jokes...you dont want to laugh at that moment but save your loved one |
|
| One piece fans understand a bunch of of the struggle with stupid stuff like this "the characters look lanky and long" "there are too many episodes" "the superpowers look stupid" |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| One piece fans understand a bunch of of the struggle with stupid stuff like this "the characters look lanky and long" "there are too many episodes" "the superpowers look stupid" |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
NeoYami said: EcchiGodMamster said: That's a nice opinion. Too bad I dont agree Sometimes its what you don't like that makes it appealing to others Well if someone you love is burning and you are only focus on saving them the last thing you want is someone to appear and make burning jokes...you dont want to laugh at that moment but save your loved one thank you for bringing real life into anime, how about we keep that separate, please |
|
EcchiGodMamster said: NeoYami said: Well if someone you love is burning and you are only focus on saving them the last thing you want is someone to appear and make burning jokes...you dont want to laugh at that moment but save your loved one thank you for bringing real life into anime, how about we keep that separate, please Being real life is irrelevant, the importance of the moment is and taking the tension away for stupid reasons ruins the scene...unless you dont take those scenes seriously My IRL example, while being insensitive, does accuractly represent how we as viewers should take serious scenes and should criticize authors from spoiling them without any reason to Theres a time and place for everything |
|
NeoYami said: EcchiGodMamster said: thank you for bringing real life into anime, how about we keep that separate, please Being real life is irrelevant, the importance of the moment is and taking the tension away for stupid reasons ruins the scene...unless you dont take those scenes seriously My IRL example, while being insensitive, does accuractly represent how we as viewers should take serious scenes and should criticize authors from spoiling them without any reason to Theres a time and place for everything Its Japanese culture and they can do whatever they want And no I don't take anime seriously and idk why ppl do, especially when a show is clearly full of comedic moments, they can use them whenever they want.. its one of the things that makes anime what it is If anime didn't do these things then it wouldn't be anime |
|
EcchiGodMamster said: NeoYami said: Being real life is irrelevant, the importance of the moment is and taking the tension away for stupid reasons ruins the scene...unless you dont take those scenes seriously My IRL example, while being insensitive, does accuractly represent how we as viewers should take serious scenes and should criticize authors from spoiling them without any reason to Theres a time and place for everything Its Japanese culture and they can do whatever they want And no I don't take anime seriously and idk why ppl do, especially when a show is clearly full of comedic moments, they can use them whenever they want.. its one of the things that makes anime what it is If anime didn't do these things then it wouldn't be anime Doing whatever you want doesnt mean its the correct way to do something(loot boxes in gaming for example). You dont need to take anime seriously, it is an hobby after all but imagine following a story and being invested in it but in critical moments you have a misplaced pantyshot, can you still respect the author and his story? Maybe if you dont have any experience reading/watching meaningful storytelling Imagine a pantyshot when Vegeta sacrificed himself; when Kamina died; When Eren lost his mother; Code Geass ending; Eclipse; Ace death...you get my point, all those moments were impactful because you were focus on what the characters went through in those scenes and not a pantyshot that will be forgotten right after...OP is filled with fanservice now but Oda knows when he should do it... |
|
Hrybami said: Well it does seem kind of odd to say that everything is subjective and then form an opinion that other people misunderstand certain things, implying that a truth exists, and that it is illogical for other people to judge plot holes, implying there is some kind of fact regarding the existence of plot holes that are supposed to be subjective.katsucats said: If plot-holes are subjective, then
Hm? Well of course it was my opinion and I never pretended otherwise. What did you expect? That I would claim "Everything is subjective!" then I'd get the fuck out? |
| My subjective reviews: katsureview.wordpress.com THE CHAT CLUB. |
katsucats said: Hrybami said: Well it does seem kind of odd to say that everything is subjective and then form an opinion that other people misunderstand certain things, implying that a truth exists, and that it is illogical for other people to judge plot holes, implying there is some kind of fact regarding the existence of plot holes that are supposed to be subjective.Hm? Well of course it was my opinion and I never pretended otherwise. What did you expect? That I would claim "Everything is subjective!" then I'd get the fuck out? Why do you always bring truth and facts into this? I've never mentioned anything regarding objectivity in my post. My view of things consist of what I perceive and understand and then how I interpret those different things. This is my subjective perception on the matter. Like, you know, an opinion? The entire world revolve around perceptions and understandings. People can (theoretically) misunderstand since nothing is factually proven on the let go. Unless something is philosophically or mathematically proven, I don't accept things at face value. I decide if I believe, don't believe or I'm not sure about something based on my own understanding of the world. I said that plot-holes are subjective in themselves. I decided I don't believe in them based on my own understanding. Here was my own understanding on plot-holes and why I don't think we should believe in them. I could rephrase my last paragraph to anything subjective. It no longer matter. Are you also one of those people who believe that if a post doesn't contain the mighty words "in my opinions" then the post must not be considered an opinion? Or are you so focused on textbook science that you forgot that the world was initially entirely subjectively based from POV of a human being? |
NeoYami said: EcchiGodMamster said: Its Japanese culture and they can do whatever they want And no I don't take anime seriously and idk why ppl do, especially when a show is clearly full of comedic moments, they can use them whenever they want.. its one of the things that makes anime what it is If anime didn't do these things then it wouldn't be anime Doing whatever you want doesnt mean its the correct way to do something(loot boxes in gaming for example). You dont need to take anime seriously, it is an hobby after all but imagine following a story and being invested in it but in critical moments you have a misplaced pantyshot, can you still respect the author and his story? Maybe if you dont have any experience reading/watching meaningful storytelling Imagine a pantyshot when Vegeta sacrificed himself; when Kamina died; When Eren lost his mother; Code Geass ending; Eclipse; Ace death...you get my point, all those moments were impactful because you were focus on what the characters went through in those scenes and not a pantyshot that will be forgotten right after...OP is filled with fanservice now but Oda knows when he should do it... Id love those anime even more if they had panty shots during those scenes but all that would do when it comes to what your saying is make me take the show less seriously which is what ppl should be doing in the first place imo Id definitely be a much bigger fan of titan if there were panties Oh and I'm glad to know I'm speaking w the arbiter of the "correct way things should be done", especially in fiction where freedom if expression is key |
|
| "[insert anime name]'s bad because it's fanbase is [insert derogatory term]" |
  |
| These come to mind: "People that like Rebuild of Evangelion are fake fans that only care about spectacle" <- no one ever said you can only like one "Iyashikei anime suck because nothing happens" <- its supposed to be chill & relaxing, hype should never be expected |
| ‘FMA 03 is bad because it doesn’t follow the Manga’ That in my opinion the worst excuse to hate on an Anime. 03 and brotherhood have the same characters, the same story structure around alchemy, but it just goes off course after episode 20. Don’t see it as an adaptation, but a different universe with the same characters that are adapted that go another path from their Manga counterparts. When there was no more volumes to be adapted instead of stopping Studio Bones continued and came up their own story within that universe. Also if FMA 03 hadn’t been as popular as it had been we’d have never gotten brotherhood. |
More topics from this board
» 🍷 AD Summer 2025 Best Girl Contest ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Shizuna - Sep 28 |
441 |
by Duado
»»
46 seconds ago |
|
» Do you think your favourite character(s) is a reflection of yourself?tanjiromybaby - 17 minutes ago |
3 |
by rxtxrd
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 4 5 )nirererin - Oct 9 |
242 |
by Duado
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» The "Backstory" Problem ( 1 2 )simonitro - Oct 12 |
54 |
by JaniSIr
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Evidences that anime was already mainstream pre 2020s.jacobPOL - 49 minutes ago |
4 |
by jacobPOL
»»
21 minutes ago |