| @Seikunai WATCHING Free! Watch episode 7 now! Shinsekai Yori- I'm excited about this one. I don't know why though... COMPLETED Cardcaptor Sakura- Did you watched this in Filipino dubbed or English subbed, because I can't stand Tomoyo's Japanese seiyuu's voice. Clannad: After Story- I'll watch it after Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom Durarara!!- Also excited about this. Fushigi Yuugi- You didn't continue with the OVAs? Gintama- This better worth my time... =) Jigoku Shoujo- I loved the second season the most. One Outs- Sports + Psychological! I can't wait to start this! PTW Fate/Zero- Get to it! K-On!- It was fine but they say season 2 was a big step up. |
Hiryu12Aug 23, 2013 10:48 PM
 |
| @ZTyrant Watching: First anime list I've seen where the person isn't watching anything. Completed: Its a lot of mecha, I like mecha anime but I don't watch a lot of it for some reason. Toradora - Looks out of place on this list and definitely dosen't deserve a 9, maybe a 7, those last few episodes were not that good to me. On Hold: Neon Genesis Evangelion - You'd do better to skim the last 1 or 2 episodes and just watch the end of Evangelion movie. PTW: Watch all the Gundam, some are not as good as others, but I still enjoyed them all somewhat. |
Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Still this. But I did made your view count higher.... =)Hiryu12 said: WATCHING Too... Much... Mecha... COMPLETED Toradora!- I'm glad you liked this so much. For me, it's not really a standout. Too overhyped for me. But it did had some moments. Voltes V- Really enjoyed this when I was a kid... =) ON-HOLD Keroro Gunsou- So you love frogs huh? xD PLAN TO WATCH Free! and GetBackers- will definitely secure your masculinity and heterosexuality. |
|
| Watching: Detective Conan - I watched it when it used to come on tv and tried to get back into it but too lazy to try and catch up. Free! - ....No comment....just no comment. Completed: Blood+ - A 50 episode+ anime I was able to watch all the way through, much better than Blood-C Digimon Tamers - Tamers is good, but i didn't think people would like better than the first 2 seasons. Dragon Ball GT - Should be an 8 and scored the same as Z. Fairy Tail - I really like this series as well, but a 10 may be bit too high. Fate/Prototype - I hope someone does something with this. GetBackers - Similar to Fairy Tail, I like this series, maybe not as much but a 10 seems really high for this series, maybe a 7 or 8. Mobile Suit Gundam Wing - This I can agree with. Outlaw Star - Glad I can finally buy this series, this was a good watch. Tekken - The first time I saw a naked female in a anime, movie still sucked though. Tekken: Blood Vengeance - You scored this too high, sure the fights looked cool, but that's about it. Yu Yu Hakusho - An old series with a lot of episodes that I can still go back and watch and enjoy. PTW; Bakemonogatari - Prepare your mind before you watch this, its a lot of dialogue but still really enjoyable. Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica - Epic series, I hope you enjoy this one. Ookami to Koushinryou - Its an anime about Economics basically, I still really enjoyed it though. |
HiroueyAug 23, 2013 11:24 PM
| WATCHING Nichijou- I saw the prologue OVA. I'm hoping the series itself is good. Rainbow- Prison sex? xD COMPLETED Cipher- Only a 9 now? Clannad: After Story- This better be worth my time... Death Note- I'm guessing you're not a fan of the second half of the show. One Outs- I really do hope I like this. Toradora!- A 9? No. ON-HOLD Kimi ni Todoke- Slow paced but very heartwarming DROPPED Higurashi- Why did you drop this? At least for me this looks promising. Shingeki no Kyojin- I liked you more now. PLAN TO WATCH Beelzebub- Good watch for mindless comedy. Biohazard- Might try this as well. Great Teacher Onizuka- Watch this now! |
|
Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Still this. But I did made your view count higher.... =)Hiryu12 said: WATCHING Too... Much... Mecha... COMPLETED Toradora!- I'm glad you liked this so much. For me, it's not really a standout. Too overhyped for me. But it did had some moments. Voltes V- Really enjoyed this when I was a kid... =) ON-HOLD Keroro Gunsou- So you love frogs huh? xD PLAN TO WATCH Free! and GetBackers- will definitely secure your masculinity and heterosexuality. |
|
| Hiryu12 Cowboy Bebop- One of the greatest of all time, a classic in the truest sense of the word. Death Note- I'd have given it a higher if it weren't for the mediocre second half. Dragon Ball- The Shounen that sky rocketed every other one we have today, hard to rate this one due to the nostalgia factor and it's importance. Fate/Zero- It was okay, I didn't love as much as other people but it had some good things going with the characters. Mobile Suit Gundam Wing- One of my favorites of all time, it can be goofy as hell at some points but I still love it. Naruto- Probably the most interesting out of the Big 3, though that's not saying much. I think it has interesting things going in the story but it is bogged down by all the flaws that come with being a battle Shounen. Serial Experiments Lain- Great series both story wise and art style wise. Summer Wars- Fun movie that has a gorgeous art style. Sword Art Online- Wasn't nearly as bad as people made it out to be, mostly just failed because of a seriously awkward premise on top of things that just didn't make sense. Trigun- One of my favorite anime of all time. Certainly has it's flaws, but it's story and uniqueness far outshine them. |
 |
| @ZTyrant Shared anime (2) with unknown compatibility. I'll just keep this short Most of your anime are mecha and unknown to many. Starts to watch more well-known anime. You gave Toradora! a 9, I feel that's too high considering you have only few anime in your list You have NGE in your on-hold. I suggest you finish it as soon as possible because you might experience confusion later on (and in End of Evangelion ._.) PTW Inferno Cop - Just watch it, and you will see the hype Deadman Wonderland - The violence might be too much for you, just saying. Might want to try out Higurashi or Elfen Lied first Shingeki no Kyojin - Hmmm you're planning to watch it after it finishes? Well considering the pacing of the anime, I guess that's alright Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - Just don't think too much while watching this (full of flaws) just go with the flow and you will see why it became one of my favorites |
BlueKiteAug 24, 2013 9:56 PM
| Watching: One Piece - That a pretty high score for it, I wonder if I'll think this way when I catch up. Completed: Angel Beats! - It's a good series, but I think its scored a little too high. Astarotte no Omocha! - Surprised I didn't like this one that much, the relationships between the characters just ruined this series for me. Eureka Seven - I think it should be scored a little higher and not have the same score AO, this one is much better than AO. Fate/Zero - I really enjoyed this series, can;t wait for the FSN remake. Freezing - The first person to give this show a score I can agree with. Umineko no Naku Koro ni - I had high hopes for this, people were saying its similar to Higurashi...They were wrong, this series was just very bad. PTW: Accel World Specials - I wouldn't waste my time with these, they made no sense. Kanon - You've seen the 2006 version, no reason to watch this one. |
HiroueyAug 24, 2013 10:12 PM
| (The airing shows on my hold list should actually be on my watching list. Just that I was going to play catch-up and I moved them to hold for a little while, but I am watching them.) Watching: Danshi Koukousei: This show was so fun. Literary girl was my favorite. FMA:B: Actually i'm rewatching that one too right now. I'm guessing you're watching the dub? I watched it dubbed first but now i'm watching with subs to see the difference. I still like the dub better. Danganronpa: Seems like you're on the fence about this. I am too, I shouldn't have completed the game because the anime is so poorly adapted. What shame. Watamote: I'm loving this as well. COMPLETED Kaichou wa Maid-sama you gave a 7, ouch that hurts me a little bit. I've just completed this a couple of days ago and I think this series is severely overrated and garbage tbh. I don't want to go too much into my dislike for this series, since I already commented on every single episode on the MAL forums. Let's just say I don't like tsunderes like Misaki or douchey creepers like Usui. I did like the imouto though, she was cute. Kara no Kyoukai: I really need to get on this. Everyone seems to have watched this except me. :( Shugo Chara: props for rating this a 1! LOL. I think I gave the first season a 5 but collectively I do hate Shugo Chara. SAO: 1/10 HELL YES. Haruhi movie: I may not be the series biggest fan but I did love this movie. I cri everytiem. Psycho-Pass: UNF DAT PSYCHO PASS. I had such a good time watching this weekly. Damn I miss this. Baccano: Best. ON-HOLD Gintama: whyyyyyyyyyyyyy is this on-hold? I cry. Hyouka: Yeah I agree that it's meh but it's really pretty to look at though. That's what kept me going until the end. Sakurasou: Idk what episode you stopped at either but this series goes way downhill after episode 12. There was no need for this thing to be 24 episodes long. DROPPED Ao no Exorcist: A-1 pictures fucked it up with a bullshit ending. They can never animate shounen. Hayate no Gotoku: We dropped it around the same episode. I like parodies as well but that series was kinda dull and it looked super cheap. Fairy Tail: More A-1 Pictures shounen fuckery. You should have seen the animation at the very last arcs it was bad. Shana: I haven't even seen this and I agree that Shana is just a fucking bitch. I hate tsunderes. Overall I think your dropped list is good. You didn't miss out on anything. PLAN TO WATCH Nichijou: One of my personal favorites. It's so freaking random but I love it. Lain: Buzzing powerlines ahoy. I think it takes a special kind of person to enjoy this series. Oda Nobuna: Idk I only watched like 3 episodes all I remember is lolis and shit. Also tits that bounced even whilst wearing armor. Spice and Wolf II: I prefer the first season. Obligatory Death Note. BTW Cool layout with delicious Kougami in the background. |
standAug 25, 2013 1:07 AM
Seikunai said: Watching Keroro Gunsou- Good that you decided to continue it. Neon Genesis Evangelion- You might not understand the first episodes, but please bear with it. Completed All That Gundam- I've seen it but I'm not bothering to put in my list. It's just a minute so it isn't that much. Chou Denji Machine Voltes V- I really loved watching this when I was a kid. :) Macross Plus- It's an amazing OVA, just as amazing as the original Macross. Toradora!- I'm one of the few people who like Taiga, really. On-Hold IGPX Immortal Grand Prix- Been planning to watch this. I've heard that it's a hidden gem. Plan To Watch Inferno Cop- Trying to watch the newer ones now, huh. :) Good. Macross- You should have watched this before Macross Plus but it's alright. Shingeki no Kyojin- Better start watching it to get into the newer scene. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann- It's an awesome mecha, but it's probably not like the other old mechas you've seen. |
 |
| @LegendsOfSushi/Sushi-kun Sure. SKIP ME. |
|
| Oh yeah I keep forgetting my plan to watch is basically only 'yet to be aired' stuff. @ZTyrant: Derp. Dude, ain't nothing wrong with a little K-On and no I don't know what you think of One Piece. Do tell. @Sushi-kun: lol SAO and Shugo Chara. Those two series can be best friends for all I care. Tomoki , idk he just annoyed me and I hated that he was drawn chibi most of the time. Thanks for your comments! Seikunai said: @LegendsOfSushi/Sushi-kun Sure. SKIP ME. Lol. I'll comment on yours. Seeing how we have ~high compatibility~ and all. Watching Hunter X Hunter: Dammit I'm reminded that I have to catch-up on this. I really enjoy it but I had been on a slight anime hiatus and now i'm left behind. Uchuu Kyoudai: Another one where I was left behind, but yes EXCELLENT 10/10. This series is wonderful. Feelings, feelings, feelings. I love it. Naruto Shippuden: The "Big 3" that I never tackled. I think i've read enough spoilers to keep me away from this. Though I'll admit I was a Naruto fan. Completed Amnesia: lol I don't blame you for giving this a 3. Angel Beats: I still have to watch this one... Beck: 10/10 wow. For some reason this didn't click with me but I can see why some people enjoy it. DRRR!: They really need to get on animating more of this. Devil Survivor 2: Yeah this was bland. Highly disappointing. FMP:I'll never watch this franchise because it doesn't seem like my thing and that's coming from someone who fangasms over KyoAni. Lucky Star: I've tried but I can never like this. Mushishi: Magical. I wish I could watch this again for the very first time. Sket Dance: This show was one of the best surprises i've had. Idk what character you liked the most but Switch is one of my all-time favorites. Tamako Market: 6/10, I agree. Somehow I expected more. Zoku Natsume: love it. I'll take season 5, 6, 7, 8, 9...infinity. on-hold I don't know many of these but I think Uchouten Kazoku is one of the gems airing this season. dropped Accel World: same here. There was just something about this... Elfen Lied: One of the most infamous. I doubt i'll ever watch this. Kitakubu Katsudou Kiroku: The hair on that one girl was just too distracting. plan to watch Arakawa Under the Bridge: if you ever watch this I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. It's so wacky, I really wish for a season 3. Come on SHAFT. Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin: Some things in this series are intense. Way too many feelings. This was difficult for me to marathon. TTGL Gurren-hen: Forever inferior to Lagann-hen. Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei: Enjoy the fastest speech and subs ever. |
standAug 25, 2013 1:53 AM
| @parfaited Watching: Free! - Really...what is so good about this, its about guys swimming, no thanks. Genei wo Kakeru Taiyou - The first episode started out so well, I was interested in this series, but as of now, it has become meh. People shouldn't compare this to Madoka. One Piece - Another person gives this a 10, I wonder if I'll think the same way when I eventually catch up with this series. Shingeki no Kyojin - Overrated?...Maybe, I think it deserves the hype a lot more than SAO. Completed: Bleach - That's a decent score for w/o fillers, but would it be with the fillers included? Bleach: Memories of Nobody - Probably my favorite Bleach movie and this one dosen't have as much fighting as the others. I really like Ichigo and Sena's interactions and really enjoyed the ending. Boku no Pico - Why is this on people's list, I have to purge this from my mind. Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai - This is really funny, surprised by your score though. I thought it'd have more ecchi moments, but that dosen't really bother me that it dosen't. Cowboy Bebop: Tengoku no Tobira - Don't get me wrong, this movie is good and reminded me of the old Cowboy Bebop feel, but 9 seems a little high, though I don't think I can argue about this score like with some other stuff. Fairy Tail - Sure boobs and ass are focus in this series, I just don't think it as bad as other shows out there. Though lately their has been a lot of focus on Lucy and her assets. Gintama - I keep thinking if I should watch this or not, some people really like it and some really don't like it. Still not sure yet. InuYasha: Guren no Houraijima - I agree with your best Inuyasha movie, but how can you call this one the worst, this one is much than the first 2. K-On! - People tell me to stay away from this series, I have my reasons for wanting to watch it and it may turn out to be ok, I hope it does at least. Mirage of Blaze - This!!!...I watched this back when I was little younger and knew no better, as long as it was anime, I wanted to watch it...this taught me not to do that. When I saw what I saw and looked back and saw all the hints, I really should have stopped watching this. Papa no Iukoto wo Kikinasai! - I think your being a little unfair to this one, the loli's aren't treated that bad in this. Seirei no Moribito - A really great series, glad I gave it a second chance, I saw on tv a few years back and wasn't that interested, but I should've given more of a chance back then. Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu (2009) - The score with this I can agree with, fuck endless 8. On Hold: Watashi ga Motenai no wa Dou Kangaetemo Omaera ga Warui! - If not for last weeks episode, this might've been the first anime I dropped. And wahy do people like Tomoko so much, she's kinda irritating. Dropped: Eureka Seven - I think you should pick this back up, just because you forgot the episode number dosen't mean you can't start over, its only 50 episodes and is a awesome series. Seikon no Qwaser - I really liked this series, but I just can't think of anything to convince you to pick it back up, it's not for everyone. |
HiroueyAug 25, 2013 2:57 AM
| MAL says our compatability is somewhat high (70.9%) which is cool but lets see how true that is. How we score (are image tags working again?):  Watching You're basically only watching stuff that's airing but you need to watch five episodes a day to stay up to date on all these shows at once! That's freakin' amazing... where do you find the time? KamiNomi - The new season is really good Monogatari - I've been keeping this on hold for a while since I really like marathoning this franchise with all its dialogue and random scenery. But I'm pretty sure that I will be rating this with an equivalent score to yours. One Piece - I recommend the manga. The story really is amazing but I'm not overly fond of the anime. Completed Your rating distribution basically goes from 5 (or 6) to 10 but that's fine I think MAL should let you decide how many different scores you need. Being able to rate on a scale from 1-3 would be handy imo but I'm getting off topic. You're 10's are really random but I think I can imagine you're reasoning behind each choice. Dragon Ball - I understand that Z being rated 10 probably has something to do with nostalgia factors but I don't understand why you rate this 8 then? Could it be that you watched DBZ before you saw this? Because that's blasphemy! If not then I'm amazed that you thought DBZ was better. Ouran Koukou Host Club - I didn't think this was all that great. Also after briefly skimming your list I pegged you as someone who mostly watches shounens and harems. But this is a reverse harem = something that the aforementioned type wouldn't enjoy all that much normally (I think I just admitted to belonging to that stereotype). Accel World - IMO this is not good enough to warrant an 8. It started out fine but ... meh ... I guess you would never rate this lower than a 7 though since your lowest rated stuff (discounting the things you absolutely hate - which you're bound to encounter given that you've watched 170 days of anime) is basically a 6. I don't know. Magi:whateversomething - OK this is definitely wrong. This series is not good. In fact it is very bad, Accel World is .. well, sure it's within reason but I don't even think whether you like Magi or not is subjective it's just plain bad. Sword Art Online - Considering that this is directly related to Accel World and that it is generally considered better (or is it? - Atleast I think so ^^) I think it's interesting that you rated it lower. I thought the first half season was actually really good. The fact that the second part is basically the first part repeated in a worse way I understand all the hate this gets but it's still a decent series (which your score rightly reflects). Dragon Ball Kai - I was genuinely surprised when I saw this on your list. You really like Dragon Ball don't you ... I thought this would a) be higher rated than DBZ or b) that you hadn't seen this since you'd already seen DBZ. The fact that you've seen both and rated DBZ higher confirms (in my mind) that you saw DBZ first and that nostalgia plays a big role in its high score. I wrote some rambling stuff about how I watched dragon ball but suffice it to say that I've actually seen all of DBZ but I don't have it on my list since I saw it when I was a kid on cartoon network waybefore I started watching anime so I have a basis for comparison (I watched like one third of DBZ again also after DBK) and I must say that DBK is just better made in every way. OK I ended up rambling a lot about the same things over and over again and I don't really have time to comment on all the stuff I want to so I'll end it here. Dropped I recommend dropping things. I started out never dropping anything and being proud of my resilience but that is a stupid sentiment. Dropping bad shows saves time and time is the most important resource in life. On-Hold Bleach - If you want to respond in any way then please post on my profile. I hope I didn't offend you in any way but if I did know that it was not my intention to do so. |
PawnDaAug 25, 2013 9:08 AM
| Big mecha fan + Toradora and Sergeant Frog |
 |
| Watching Blood Lad - Gotta love Staz <3 Danganronpa - I totally agree with that comment. Monobears laugh is funny by the way. Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita - Episode 8 & 9 (if I remember right) are f*cking brilliant. Princess Tutu - I really want to watch it. I'll probably start with this one next year if I'm fast... Rozen Maiden (2013) - I don't get why everybody hate Deen. They're not that bad... This remake is actually better than the original. Can't wait 'till we get to see desu again ∼ Uchouten Kazoku - first few episodes were so confusing. But it got better. Completed Byousoku 5 Centimeter - So sad... still overrated though. Clannad Movie - Ending was better than that one from AS. The rest was meh. Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko - Eating pizza like a boss. Hotarubi no Mori e - Loved the ending. Hourou Musuko - Interesting... it could have been better or worse. Kiss x sis (TV) - So boring... Only watching it because I've already seen the OVAs (only watched the OVAs because I wanted to try ecchi) I don't like to drop stuff even if it is a sequel or so. Do I still make sense? Kotonoha no Niwa - Dat art o-o Mondaiji-tachi ga Isekai kara Kuru Sou Desu yo? - Everything was mediocre. Psycho-Pass - Hope it'll get a second season with some backstories. SAO - Don't understand the haters nor lovers. On-Hold Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi - Why did you put this on hold? This is pretty good so far. Dropped Amnesia - Good you dropped it. You miss nothing. PTW Serial Experiments Lain - Confusing as hell, but finishing it will pay off. |
shiawase-pngAug 25, 2013 1:52 PM
Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Hiryu12 said: Still this. But I did made your view count higher.... =)Hiryu12 said: WATCHING Too... Much... Mecha... COMPLETED Toradora!- I'm glad you liked this so much. For me, it's not really a standout. Too overhyped for me. But it did had some moments. Voltes V- Really enjoyed this when I was a kid... =) ON-HOLD Keroro Gunsou- So you love frogs huh? xD PLAN TO WATCH Free! and GetBackers- will definitely secure your masculinity and heterosexuality. |
|
xxshiawase said: Watching Blood Lad - Gotta love Staz <3 Danganronpa - I totally agree with that comment. Monobears laugh is funny by the way. Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita - Episode 8 & 9 (if I remember right) are f*cking brilliant. Princess Tutu - I really want to watch it. I'll probably start with this one next year if I'm fast... Rozen Maiden (2013) - I don't get why everybody hate Deen. They're not that bad... This remake is actually better than the original. Can't wait 'till we get to see desu again ∼ Uchouten Kazoku - first few episodes were so confusing. But it got better. Completed Byousoku 5 Centimeter - So sad... still overrated though. Clannad Movie - Ending was better than that one from AS. The rest was meh. Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko - Eating pizza like a boss. Hotarubi no Mori e - Loved the ending. Hourou Musuko - Interesting... it could have been better or worse. Kiss x sis (TV) - So boring... Only watching it because I've already seen the OVAs (only watched the OVAs because I wanted to try ecchi) I don't like to drop stuff even if it is a sequel or so. Do I still make sense? Kotonoha no Niwa - Dat art o-o Mondaiji-tachi ga Isekai kara Kuru Sou Desu yo? - Everything was mediocre. Psycho-Pass - Hope it'll get a second season with some backstories. SAO - Don't understand the haters nor lovers. On-Hold Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi - Why did you put this on hold? This is pretty good so far. Dropped Amnesia - Good you dropped it. You miss nothing. PTW Serial Experiments Lain - Confusing as hell, but finishing it will pay off. Kamisami no Inai Nichiyoubi - feels like something I'd be better off marathoning in a go - it was a similar story with shinsekai yori and psycho pass Princess tutu is turning out to be much better than I originally thought; breaking the fourth wall constantly, with the narrator pointing out the characters flaws, and the characters interacting with narrator. Jinrui - love watashi's character, episode 2 was soo good, really looking forward to the rest byousoku 5 centimeter - manga is so much better Psycho pass - it's getting a s2, so good news? Lain - looking forward to it, but I've quite a lot on my watching that I'm neglecting (GITS: SAC, Jinrui, penguindrum, and cardcaptor for the most part) @Hiryu12 Makes use of upper end of scoring spectrum only, "masterpieces" are somewhat unexpected, watches both old and new anime. |
|
| @GoldenBRS watching Darker than Black: Kuro no Keiyakusha - if you dont like season 1 then stop watching cause season 2 is bad Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki - are you watching this by parts? anyways i liked this movie a lot, Hana is one of my fav characters Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin - melodramatic an goes downhill on its second half completed Black Lagoon: The Second Barrage - i actually liked this more than season 1, the new characters were more interesting imo Kara no Kyoukai 3: Tsuukaku Zanryuu - this was my fav of the series Kotonoha no Niwa - some of the best visuals ive seen, the story was ok Mars of Destruction - 2deep4you Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom - thinking back, i might have overrated this Redline - the visuals are jawdropping Steins;Gate - 2nd fav anime on hold Black Lagoon: Roberta's Blood Trail - that conlusion was brutal Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - if you arent enjoying this then you probably will dislike season 2 more dropped Bakemonogatari - this was the better of the series Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - i agree, very repetitive but 10 eps are enough you can just jump to season 2 which actually has a good story to tell Mirai Nikki (TV) - people like cause yandere Shingeki no Kyojin - a 1? nor even a 2 for soundtrack an animation? i dont think that this is a masterpiece but still... Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - that was the point were things get good ptw highly recommended Saint Seiya: The Lost Canvas - Meiou Shinwa Sengoku Basara Two (biased recomendation) Tenkuu no Shiro Laputa Perfect Blue Gungrave Mononoke Hime Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica medium recommended Neon Genesis Evangelion Chihayafuru Byousoku 5 Centimeter Katanagatari Binbougami ga! Hotarubi no Mori e Higashi no Eden The Animatrix Hataraku Maou-sama! Ookami to Koushinryou Ergo Proxy stay the hell away Beelzebub |
silversaintAug 25, 2013 8:36 PM
 |
| Watching Like how most of them are airing Completed Angel Beats - What kept it from being a 10? Baccano! - Only a 8?! Code Geass - Only an 8?! *Digital Slap* Death Note - Doesn't deserve a 10. Dropped The big 3 and Fairy Tail - I can see why, only reason I still watch One Piece is for the action scenes. |
| @silversaint Watching - Completed Beelzebub- Idk why but I liked Beelzebub's animation. Byousoku 5 Centimeter- Feels unfinished but I'm sure that's it. Akari is an asshole. Still loved the movie though Cat Shit One- Everything was predictable on this one. But this was actually good, I honestly thought it was a troll because of the name xD Clannad- Well that was a very low score. Well, I understand why. Clannad first season was kind of messy. Second season has a shitty first half but I thought that at the later parts, it became great. I mean the ending was pretty unrealistic but I think it's better to have it than rather have Nagisa and Ushio die. I'd destroy the Key HQ if they made it like that. D.Gray-Man- I actually liked the OST Full Metal Panic!- The plot wasn't weak.. For me. I think it was great. Ghost In The Shell: SAC- Don't see why you gave this such a low score. And 2nd GIG is lower than the original? What? Hyouka- Can't blame 'em for being repetitive. It's mystery and it's on school. I find the mysteries entertaining. Kara no Kyoukai- One of the few people I've seen that didn't like Kara no Kyoukai. 3rd is the highest? I personally think it's the least great in all along with 1. My favorite is 7. On-Hold - Dropped Gintama': Enchousen- This is for all the Gintama you've watched. Gintama has no definite plot, so why would you say 'no plot progression'? It's not 'unnecessary long', it's for entertainment so they're looking to have it long, and Gintama has a large cast of characters, just to give them proper screen time, serious arcs are not that weak, if you have seen Yoshiwara In Flames, Benizakura or Red Spider arc. But I'm happy you said that you liked the soundtrack ;) Plan To Watch Highly Recommended Aria The Animation (Natural and Origination too) Beck Danshi Koukousei no Nichijou Eureka Seven Great Teacher Onizuka Hunter x Hunter (2011) Kumo no Mukou, Yakusoku no Basho Mawaru Penguindrum Nana Monster Mononoke Natsume Yuujinchou Nichijou Usagi Drop @XiPwnUX99 Watching Psycho-Pass- Lolwut you gave it a 10 after watching only 1 ep? One Piece- I bet you're not really watching this because you gave it a 6 while you're on episode 609 Blood Lad- Aren't you pissed at the unnecessary fan service? Completed School Days- It is not the worst anime ever. How they presented the plot was good and they did not make any mistakes. If you hated or are terrified of the story then you are a wuss. But yeah, Makoto is an idiot. Really weird, all of the specials you gave them a 7 or lower. It feels like you haven't seen them at all and you just give them that score. But whatever. On-Hold - Dropped Elfen Lied- Good choice. Plan To Watch WATCH THEM ALL |
RadieneAug 25, 2013 10:05 PM
|
| Our compatibility is medium-high (67.8%) so we probably have pretty diverging opinions on things or different ways to rate. Here's how we rate:  Watching You seem to have the same habit as me with your watching section. I also have about 20 series ongoing a few of which are still airing and the others are sort of on-hold except for maybe one or two which I'm watching regularly. Hunter X Hunter (2011) - This anime is great! Considering that 42% of your list is rated 9 or 10 I think this is a perfectly justifiable rating. So Ra No Wa To - I loved this. I don't remember how I got myself to start watching it but I was thoroughly surprised and I consider this must watch in my own list. Shingeki no Kyojin - Although I thought this was going to turn out like SAO at the mid point in the series Completed You basically rate on a scale from 7-10 so I'll be thinking of 7 and 8 as sub tier ratings (almost 80% of your list is rated 7 and above). Going by the scoring system from your about me it seems that everything that your rate 5 or below is something you'd drop given the opportunity (for me its 4 and below). I also think that 6 is basically a score you reserve for shows from genre's you don't like but were OK despite that since you mention 7 being the highest possible score for those shows (belonging to genre's you dislike). Durarara!! - This isn't a series that commonly gets 10's in my experience.Iit might be because they didn't actually adapt the whole story from the light novels or because it gets compared to Baccano! often which is generally considered strictly better so it gets bumped to a lower rating, but I liked Durarara!! a lot so I support your score here. Especially since you rated Baccano! a 10 to. Mushishi - I've been considering raising my score for this to 10. It's really good ... to the point where it is easily rewatchable which imo is the highest praise you can give a show. Mawaru Penguindrum - This is the only anime I've ever seen which I couldn't rate. On one hand I was forcing myself to watch it even though I didn't enjoy it at all and on the other hand it has an epic ending and really cool mindfuck. I feel like if I'd rate it on a per episode basis I could do it but I have a hard time attaching a number to the whole series. However I feel like 9 is a bit high. I mean that's what you rated Hyouka, Steins;Gate, Shinsekai Yori and Death Note all of which I consider consistently as good or better than the absolutely best parts of MPD. I feel like you use too small a part of the rating scale to really convey what you felt about an anime with the rating. Of course your scores aren't meaningless but they're more difficult to understand for a third party. Toaru Kagaku no Railgun - What do people see in this series? I didn't like it but I also couldn't see anything special about it. There wasn't anything interesting about it and the characters which normally make watching stuff like this interesting were all really bad. For example the teleporter girl had crossed through the cute or funny territory (which is probably what she was supposed to be) and into very annoying. The other cop was also a really bad character. I watched all of it just to see if it would end with some cool fight or if there'd be more level fives or just SOMETHING interesting but nothing happened it was just all bad and predictable I felt like the rest of your scores were all easily justified but that's in part because I have a hard time grasping just how good something has to be to deserve some particular score. What I mean is that the quality of shows rated with, for example, 8 varies greatly IMO. On-Hold Don't recognize anything here. Dropped Nothing worth reconsidering. Plan to Watch I won't try to influence your choices with recommendations since it seems like everything here has a reason behind it and is something that you really will watch. For Haruhi Suzumiya I'd watch the first and last episode of the endless eight and skip the rest. I didn't know about it and didn't see the episode titles so I watched all 8 episodes in a row. I cannot say for sure that I maintained my sanity but it really was endless since I had no idea for how many episodes it would last. I can't imagine waiting for two months for it to finish. Also I think Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai NEXT is something you shouldn't watch unless they announce a third season (I'm assuming you're not that excited to watch it since you've seen the prequel but haven't started it even though its been finished for a while). It basically gets really exciting at the end and it would suck if there isn't going to be another season (sort of like Btooom!). If you want to find more stuff to watch then I think animeadvice.me is better at recommending to you than me. |
PawnDaAug 25, 2013 11:58 PM
| Hasn't watched that much. Scores seem okay for the most part. But you shit all over Black Lagoon and Fate/Zero. But what really shakes my faith in humanity is you gave Nisemonogatari a 7 yet you dropped Bakemonogatari after 2 episodes and said it was terrible? You fuckin nuts bro... I'd say watch more KnK since you liked the first one but you're insane so I don't expect you to listen to me. :) |
EckilsaxAug 25, 2013 11:59 PM
| Ooo, what a lovely tea party. |
Sushi-kun said: What the hell Eck? PawnDa gave an essay worth of typing for the person above him and you don't even give any effort to comment on their list and anime properly. There for I will just say that your list sucks. There. Oh and it needs the SSJMaster vs Xinil series too. I didn't know I had to analyze every other entry when I mentioned that I agree with most of his scores. I only commented on the entries that most stood out for me. And sorry but anyone who likes Nisemono and drops Bakemono during ep 2 is missing some marbles. @Mclovinballs I'm picking Ergo Proxy back up pretty soon. And I'm not entirely sure what you mean since he liked Nise just fine but dropped Bake while barely giving it a shot. |
EckilsaxAug 26, 2013 12:56 AM
| Ooo, what a lovely tea party. |
| Your list seems pretty good even though it's kind of hard to read with the background so dark. You made a mistake in dropping Ergo Proxy though Eckilsax said: anyone who likes Nisemono and drops Bakemono during ep 2 is missing some marbles. Does dropping them because they were "Shafted" count? I dropped it |
MclovinballsAug 26, 2013 12:59 AM
| I actually explained why it's like this in my Nisemonogatari entry. |
| Your MAL list brings all the boys to the yard. |
 |
| Sushi-kun Angel Beats!- It had some hilarious rogue beer bottles. Bakemonogatari- To be fair the plot was just there to put tits and quirky dialogue on screen. Bleach- No conversation that starts out with "Let's get something straight" has ever led to anything positive. Code Geass- Ass pulling twigs all over this bitch. Cowboy Bebop- Cowboy Bebop on... hold? No, no, no, you put other anime on hold for Cowboy Bebop. Dance in the Vampire Bund- You find near statutory rape amusing sir? Darker than Black- His coat is definitely that of the ultimate badass. Fate/Zero- I wish the show was just Rider and Gilgamesh talking, it would easily be a 10/10 then. FLCL- I watched this when it first aired on Toonami and again with the Blu-ray release. Still didn't understand a damn thing. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood- Watch the original afterwards, and prepare to have your expectations even higher. Ga-Rei: Zero- I plan to read the manga and I've already finished the series. S-Should I be scared? Higashi no Eden- Don't get your expectations too high. Highschool of the Dead- Kept some realism? May I remind you of Saeko's Matrix tits. Kuroshitsuji- Try viewing it from this angle- It's a horror anime about a demonic butler who wants to violently sodomize the young lord of a haunted manor. Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica- I disagree with the realism aspect. If a talking space cat(?) came up and asked me if I wanted to be a magical girl I certainly wouldn't say yes. Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai!- "It was funny but it was way too retarded and predictable." Fixed. Naruto- They haven't already?! It's been ages since I kept up with the anime but I was sure that's where it was leading to. Nisemonogatari- Yeah, toothbrushes get my dick hard to. Perfect Blue- Just like that pizza girl caught that man off guard with an ice pick. Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom- The biggest plot hole for me was how Zwei went from a playboy banging his boss with the giant tits to some guy pretending to be in highschool afraid of a biker loli. Pokemon- Gay? Brock made the show anything but gay by trying to bang everything with a vagina. Rosario to Vampire- What? That scene always made my pants tight. School Days- Makoto is in his Heaven, all is right with the World. Sekirei- I'd have liked it if it was actually like that, but it's more like all female Tekken with some extremely generic dude and a lot of sitting around at a hotel. Shingeki no Kyojin- Wait, when was he naked? That would explain all the Yaoi art however. Sword Art Online- Otaku Wish Fulfillment huh? That's actually not a bad way to describe it and the words scare me the more I think about them. |
ShrabsterAug 26, 2013 7:12 PM
|
| I'll make a version 2.0 WATCHING Keroro Gunsou- Try Shirokuma Cafe if you really like animals... hahahah xD Neon genesis Evangelion- Don't get why people love this. COMPLETED All That Gundam- Watched this yesterday when I saw your list and noticed it was only a minute long. A quick add to your list. Toradora!- A 9 is too high for this show. Only Ami was worth watching here. ON HOLD IGPX Immortal Grand Prix- It's only 13 episodes. Finish it to make your list longer. PLAN TO WATCH Shingeki no Kyojin- No. Gundam Titles- Gundam Wing should be the only one on your list. But apparently its not. Shit taste in Gundam titles. Free!- Yes! |
Hiryu12Aug 26, 2013 6:19 PM
|
ZTyrant said: Pretty boys are HOT! hahahah xD I'm just messing with you... You do know that I'm not into mainstream right? 0.oVersion 2.0 Watching: Azumanga Daioh: Still getting around to watching ths Hiryu12 said: Shingeki no Kyojin- No. Gundam Titles- Gundam Wing should be the only one on your list. But apparently its not. Shit taste in Gundam titles. Free!- Yes! Let me guess: You only appreciate pretty-boy titles in addition to shounen, right? And about Attack on Titan, I assume you hate it so much, you wouldn't watch it and/or touch it with a 100in. pole, even when the hype dies down. And quit assuming that Free! is on my PTW list. SKIP ME! Do Sushi-kun |
|
Sushi-kun said: Your list gave me AIDS. Here's a comment to most of your anime (completed, watching, on hold, dropped PTW) THEY'RE TOO OLD FOR ME TO KNOW! Your scoring and interests are very similar to mine, with a few differences here and there; fellow madoka, shinsekai yori, baccano, steins;gate, haruhi movie, and psycho pass fan. (lol at shugo chara hate) I recommend tatami galaxy, princess tutu, phantom requiem for the phantom, and ghost in the shell (the latter two of them being better (plot-wise) versions of darker than black. Lovely 90.4% compatibility btw |
|
| @AngelicHowl Watching Hunter x Hunter (2011) - Started watching this the other day. Up to episode 21. Nothing amazing so far. Watamote - Watching this was not all that comfortable as I could relate to some of the situations the MC was in. On-hold for the time-being. Completed Shinsekai Yori - Will watch when I find the time. Little Busters! - We gave this the same score. I did not like this at all. The MC (who I really wanted to punch in the face) and all the stupid melodramatic problems everyone had. Surprised I had the will to finish it. Kokoro Connect - Reading the LN. It's alright. On-Hold Planetes - A bit slow but the political themes and questions raised left me thinking long after it ended which is mainly why I liked it. Full Metal Panic - Be sure to watch Fumoffu. Very funny stuff. Slam Dunk - It was a nice sports anime with endearing characters, deserving of an 8/10 Kakumeiki Valvrave - It had various flaws but remained entertaining. High School DxD - Very nice if you like the ecchi/harem genre. The LN is particularly good. Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo - Overrated. Dragged on a bit too much towards the end. Did not empathise much with the characters. Dropped Samurai Champloo - Started watching this because it apparently had a very good dub. Didn't find it all that interesting so it's on-hold at episode 5. Plan to Watch Detroit Metal City - One of the funniest anime I have ever seen. |
 "Why did he have to surrender, what is more in the outside world, huh, sumptuousness, freedom? Nowhere in the world are you going to find them fools! Fools!" -USSR president, Future War 198X-nen |
| WATCHING Keroro Gunsou- Try Shirokuma Cafe if you really like animals... hahahah xD Neon genesis Evangelion- Don't get why people love this. COMPLETED All That Gundam- Watched this yesterday when I saw your list and noticed it was only a minute long. A quick add to your list. Toradora!- A 9 is too high for this show. Only Ami was worth watching here. ON HOLD IGPX Immortal Grand Prix- It's only 13 episodes. Finish it to make your list longer. PLAN TO WATCH Shingeki no Kyojin- No. Gundam Titles- Gundam Wing should be the only one on your list. But apparently its not. Shit taste in Gundam titles. Free!- Yes! |
|
| I don't like his list at all, but at least he likes Free! |
Xinil said: Thanks for joining MAL. JOIN MAH CLUB http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=38595 |
| The only thing that's good on your list is Free! (but only in episode 1) Completed only 35 titles and most of them are mainstream. Total hipster and anime noob. Layout is too common... |
|
More topics from this board
» You can only save 1 of the 3 users above you! v9 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KayKimii - Jan 28, 2023 |
9594 |
by Daniel_cr99
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Would you watch it?Shizuna - 11 hours ago |
13 |
by MitsukiHimeka
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Guess the user below you, if you guess correctly you exchange profile comments ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )removed-user - Aug 1, 2024 |
5686 |
by Daniel_cr99
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Ask the person below you a question. v37 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - Jun 27 |
5165 |
by Dostojevskij
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Would you pat or slap the above user? v.3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kunii - May 3, 2024 |
6942 |
by MitsukiHimeka
»»
8 minutes ago |