Forum Settings
Forums

Why is dandadan rated 18+ (TV-MA) literally every streaming site i go? Outside of north america, its between 14-16, even in middle east.

New
Oct 5, 12:27 PM
#1
Offline
Sep 2025
19
For some reason, on the viz manga site and amazon prime (for the anime), dandadan is rated 18+ (TV-MA) but chainsaw man is rated 16+ (TV-14) even though the shear violence and gore in CSM and the mature themes would make dandadan look like a kids show in comparison. I don't think it is even remotely comparable the themes in chainsaw man vs dandadan (I have watched both anime myself). I made a post on r/amazonprimevideo about this (Cannot post pics at mal properly so i already made a reddit thread): https://www.reddit.com/r/AmazonPrimeVideo/comments/1nuxrin/whos_running_the_age_ratings_at_prime_video_usa/. This makes completely no sense at all.
Oct 5, 12:39 PM
#2

Offline
Sep 2016
22088
Probably because of the sex assault scene, and North Americans seem to infantilize their teens when it comes to sex, so it's rated 18+
*kappa*
Oct 5, 12:54 PM
#3
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to Zarutaku
Probably because of the sex assault scene, and North Americans seem to infantilize their teens when it comes to sex, so it's rated 18+
@Zarutaku So, is middle east/ south asia more tolerant, i dont think so. Look at the age ratings in india, it is pg-16/ua16+ (just a guidance, not a restriction).
Oct 5, 7:32 PM
#4
Offline
Oct 2023
445
mg1109 said:
is middle east/ south asia more tolerant, i dont think so. Look at the age ratings in india

That might very well be the case these days. The west is heading towards a nanny state mentality. US always had it's fair share of bs, UK is already pushing into 1984 with its internet laws, and I have also heard some wild things from Europe. Like the Demon Slayer movie was strictly rated 16+ which is overkill.
Oct 5, 11:05 PM
#5
Nostalgia Rules!

Offline
Jun 2008
14449
I think it depends on the region, some reading boards that are just a few years short of an 18 and up rating are still considered mature. Kind of like when ADV used to rate some of their more hardcore anime 16 and up.
Oct 6, 4:29 AM
#6

Offline
May 2018
12409
Maybe for the attempt at rape (and worst) in episode one.
There wasn't actual rape and Momo kicked their asses, but who knows what the censors really aim at...total lack of "social immunity"?
Oct 6, 5:48 AM
#7
Offline
May 2016
2084
As other mentioned, it's likely the rape scene. Killing someone is usually okay with a 12+ rating, while if you showcase a single pair of boobs, then it's instantly 16+ for example.

Captain-577 said:
UK is already pushing into 1984 with its internet laws

Lol
The only wild thing is that you compare that law to 1984.
Oct 6, 6:03 AM
#8
Offline
Jul 2016
81
Different cultures see the topic of sex differently. And yeah in America that's considered 18+ automatically
Oct 6, 6:24 AM
#9
Offline
Apr 2014
581
Reply to ktg
As other mentioned, it's likely the rape scene. Killing someone is usually okay with a 12+ rating, while if you showcase a single pair of boobs, then it's instantly 16+ for example.

Captain-577 said:
UK is already pushing into 1984 with its internet laws

Lol
The only wild thing is that you compare that law to 1984.
@ktg dude they have police coming into people homes to attempt to force them to apologize over rude posts they make online or go to jail, the place is actually completely cooked right now.
Oct 6, 6:31 AM
Offline
May 2016
2084
Reply to niconiconii27
@ktg dude they have police coming into people homes to attempt to force them to apologize over rude posts they make online or go to jail, the place is actually completely cooked right now.
@niconiconii27 Have you read the law? If not, then why are you lying about it?
No, the law does not include anything about "rude posts".
Oct 6, 7:12 AM
Offline
Apr 2014
581
Reply to ktg
@niconiconii27 Have you read the law? If not, then why are you lying about it?
No, the law does not include anything about "rude posts".
@ktg it isn't possible to speak to a person that doesn't live on the same planet as me.
Oct 6, 7:30 AM
Offline
May 2016
2084
Reply to niconiconii27
@ktg it isn't possible to speak to a person that doesn't live on the same planet as me.
@niconiconii27 I live on planet reality where we make statements based on facts and truth. When will you leave planet dreamworld, so we could talk?
If you had any idea about what the law is about, then you would have quoted the relevant lines from it. It's not that hard, but you just simply admitted that I'm right and you did lie about it.
Oct 6, 11:41 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
2749
Reply to Captain-577
mg1109 said:
is middle east/ south asia more tolerant, i dont think so. Look at the age ratings in india

That might very well be the case these days. The west is heading towards a nanny state mentality. US always had it's fair share of bs, UK is already pushing into 1984 with its internet laws, and I have also heard some wild things from Europe. Like the Demon Slayer movie was strictly rated 16+ which is overkill.
@Captain-577 Wait, Demon Slayer is a 16+ in Europe? The only country that comes to my mind as that stuck up when it comes to ratings in Europe is Germany. Otherwise "what even is a content rating"?

East of the former Iron Curtain it's really not that bad, people here already felt censorship once (communist period) and it's not coming back, at least anytime soon. My country even has an explicit constitutional prohibition of censorship, which I don't think is that common of a prohibition even worldwide. So the state here can only advise that something should not be watched or read but not outright prohibit. Free speech laws here are also read generally in a more similar manner to what the US does than how Western Europe does it, as an added bonus, and most people lean towards being pro-free speech in the American way.
Hot Blood saves lives.
Oct 6, 12:19 PM
Offline
Sep 2022
424
Reply to mg1109
@Zarutaku So, is middle east/ south asia more tolerant, i dont think so. Look at the age ratings in india, it is pg-16/ua16+ (just a guidance, not a restriction).
@mg1109 Yes, the middle east probably is more tolerant than the usa. The Christians have been afraid of sex from the start. Before the start in fact. They were scared of sex when they were still Neo-Platonists. America was founded by the most intolerant of an intolerant world.
Oct 6, 12:22 PM
Offline
Sep 2022
424
Reply to ktg
@niconiconii27 Have you read the law? If not, then why are you lying about it?
No, the law does not include anything about "rude posts".
@ktg It kinda does; it's a bit ambiguous. And the letter of the law doesn't matter when the police are at the door. The case might get chucked out eventually but that's no help in the short term.
Oct 6, 1:08 PM
Offline
May 2016
2084
Reply to therealnagora
@ktg It kinda does; it's a bit ambiguous. And the letter of the law doesn't matter when the police are at the door. The case might get chucked out eventually but that's no help in the short term.
@therealnagora Firstly, it does matter, because they can act based on laws even if they are standing at your door. So if that law does not say that they can imprison you because of "rude comments", then they won't be able to even if they are doing jumping jacks at your door.
Secondly, based on this interpretation, every law works like that. I could call the police for any reason to your house. I could state that you are making bombs.
Thirdly, this has nothing to do with the law. They had the same authority before the law as they have after when it comes to "rude comments".
Oct 6, 8:25 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
I mean the latest CSM reze arc movie is rated R13+ in indonesia, 15+ in uae (both are uncensored). Dandadan is rated UA 16+ in india, S2 is rated UA 13+. Latest demon slayer movie is ua13+ for infinity castle. IN most of middle east, dandadan is 16+ on netflix and prime. Only in US, Can mex (netflix and prime copy us age ratings) as well as south korea, saudi arabia that they are 18+ . Demon slayer infinity castle is rated as low as pg-12 in oman and egypt.
Oct 6, 8:28 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to ktg
As other mentioned, it's likely the rape scene. Killing someone is usually okay with a 12+ rating, while if you showcase a single pair of boobs, then it's instantly 16+ for example.

Captain-577 said:
UK is already pushing into 1984 with its internet laws

Lol
The only wild thing is that you compare that law to 1984.
@ktg 16 is fine, 18 should be reserved for things like berserk, dorohedoro, fire punch or idaten deities.
Oct 6, 8:29 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to Izac_Kak
Different cultures see the topic of sex differently. And yeah in America that's considered 18+ automatically
@Izac_Kak I think america is supposed to me more liberal than south asia, no?
Oct 6, 8:30 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to niconiconii27
@ktg dude they have police coming into people homes to attempt to force them to apologize over rude posts they make online or go to jail, the place is actually completely cooked right now.
@niconiconii27 Uk is definitely screwed right now. I would rather live in china where i can confortable say rude things against people (who are not from the government) but still wont get arrested.
Oct 6, 10:09 PM
Offline
May 2016
2084
Reply to mg1109
@niconiconii27 Uk is definitely screwed right now. I would rather live in china where i can confortable say rude things against people (who are not from the government) but still wont get arrested.
@mg1109 Nice, we have a troll account here...
You can say "rude things" about other people. The UK's internet law does not say anything about "rude things". That's why this is a lie.
Also, in China because that would be considered a destructive behavior, you would lose social points and if you lose enough points, you won't be able to even leave your city. That's how China works.
Oct 6, 10:45 PM

Offline
Feb 2016
15026
Reply to mg1109
@ktg 16 is fine, 18 should be reserved for things like berserk, dorohedoro, fire punch or idaten deities.
@mg1109
This kind of content is rated R when shown in theaters, and M (17+) when in a video game. 18+ is rare and usually pornographic. I'm expected to believe Americans can watch and play just about anything at 17, but need to wait an addition year for manga? The notion is laughable.
その目だれの目?
Oct 6, 10:46 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to Lucifrost
@mg1109
This kind of content is rated R when shown in theaters, and M (17+) when in a video game. 18+ is rare and usually pornographic. I'm expected to believe Americans can watch and play just about anything at 17, but need to wait an addition year for manga? The notion is laughable.
@Lucifrost Yeah. We need to abolish the mpaa and change it with bbfc. M/ R (17) is effectively the highest age rating in the US (sweden and other scandanavian countries peaks out at 15).
Oct 6, 10:50 PM

Offline
Feb 2016
15026
Reply to mg1109
@Lucifrost Yeah. We need to abolish the mpaa and change it with bbfc. M/ R (17) is effectively the highest age rating in the US (sweden and other scandanavian countries peaks out at 15).
@mg1109
I am not familiar with bbfc. In what way is it better than mpaa?
その目だれの目?
Oct 6, 10:52 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to Lucifrost
@mg1109
I am not familiar with bbfc. In what way is it better than mpaa?
@Lucifrost BBFC is mpaa but for UK. They are more transparent on how they age rate things. There is no seperate age rating system for movies and tv shows. They are also less prudish than US considering the fact that US is getting more prudish than south asia. BBFC Description
Oct 6, 11:00 PM

Offline
Feb 2016
15026
Reply to mg1109
@Lucifrost BBFC is mpaa but for UK. They are more transparent on how they age rate things. There is no seperate age rating system for movies and tv shows. They are also less prudish than US considering the fact that US is getting more prudish than south asia. BBFC Description
mg1109 said:
They are also less prudish than US

I feel R rating is plenty lenient in America since any kid is allowed to see it with parents, and barely anything gets rated NC17.
その目だれの目?
Oct 6, 11:04 PM
Offline
Sep 2025
19
Reply to Lucifrost
mg1109 said:
They are also less prudish than US

I feel R rating is plenty lenient in America since any kid is allowed to see it with parents, and barely anything gets rated NC17.
@Lucifrost You are on the whim of your modern reddit parents (who are stupid most of the time). If you see reddit today, many parents do not let their kids watch op (one piece) until they turn 14. I know what i am saying is crazy but people are turning conservative for some reason on anime. I guess due to me too movement? I see claims of misogyny and whatnot against anime on reedit. I remember my mom watched sixteen candles which was rated pg in 1985 and that has more sexually gross stuff than R rated movies/anime of today. Many of these anime would be rated PG if they were released in 1980s. I am glad i had parents who are libertarian on such stuff.
Oct 7, 6:06 AM
Offline
Jul 2016
81
Reply to mg1109
@Izac_Kak I think america is supposed to me more liberal than south asia, no?
@mg1109 That's mostly come down to the people not as much the institutions

More topics from this board

» Do you have an anime addiction?

HarrierDuBoisFan - Jul 1, 2023

47 by RainyEvenings »»
2 minutes ago

» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

nirererin - Oct 9

248 by nirererin »»
10 minutes ago

» Animanga in unexpected places?

thewiru - 6 hours ago

2 by RainyEvenings »»
11 minutes ago

» Are there anime NOT for beginners?

thewiru - 9 hours ago

37 by SoumyaUkil73 »»
16 minutes ago

» ☀️ Anime Summer 2025 Male & Female Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 )

ISeeLifePeople - Oct 5

120 by TitanOfPlasma »»
31 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login