Forum Settings
Forums

Can we now finally admit Chainsaw Man season 1 was the biggest failure in modern anime history?

New
12 hours ago
#1

Offline
Oct 2021
415
(No moderators of MAL; this post is not breaking the rules just because it's tackling a controversial debate within the anime community)
With that out of the way...

The CSM movie trailer with the NEW DIRECTOR (Tatsuya Yoshihara) just dropped and...

It absolutely DESTROYED season 1 in every department!!! I mean, just look at this absolute masterclass of direction and Animation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1n552v1ng0

This is literally what the pinnacle of Japanimation looks like.

This trailer is definitive proof that the previous director, Ryu Nakayama, is solely to blame for the complete financial failure of CSM season 1.

If Chainsaw Man had been as well directed as this new movie it would have been the biggest anime of our modern times! Instead, Jujutsu Midsen FRAUDULENTLY took that spot away from CSM, simply because it was lucky enough to receive a proper director from the beginning!

But it doesn't matter anymore, now that Ryu Nakayama is no longer in charge of ruining the franchise, we finally have a proper genius director like Yoshihara helming the production of Chainsaw Man! CSM's anime can finally "change the anime industry" like it should have done from the beginning!
Psycho_Goku11 hours ago
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
11 hours ago
#2

Offline
Sep 2020
5376
I remember people were more hyped up when CSM S1 trailer dropped and they started comparing it with JJK. Looks like we are back at it again.
11 hours ago
#3

Offline
Apr 2015
2527
It had everything, But it still bombed.

Sometimes I think, Perhaps if the season had 24 episodes, It might have been received better.

The beginning part of Chainsaw man isn't particularly that great in the manga, It's the middle part which is fantastic.
11 hours ago
#4
Offline
Aug 2021
540
AYOOO!!! Psycho goku is back with his BULLSHIT!!. Really missed you bro, welcome back
11 hours ago
#5
Offline
Mar 2021
352
trailer is peak 🥵
i didn't know these things about about 1st season, plus it's a movie production bro they went in all the way to bring something extraordinary tht's for sure , it's definitely jjk 0 movie success i guess, and also demon slayer movie is coming it will be another boost
Anime Rules the world
11 hours ago
#6
Offline
Jan 2021
43
man just how long u r gonna follow this rage bait shit? yes, chainsaw man wasn't a huge success when it came to bd sales. the reason wasn't really the anime but the japanese audience's hate towards nakamura.
jeffery_dahmer5 hours ago
11 hours ago
#7

Offline
Jan 2023
110
Why people hate S1? I really loved lol
11 hours ago
#8
Online
Aug 2023
22
Don't fall for the rage bait guys
11 hours ago
#9
The Flawed Bliss

Offline
Dec 2021
280
I had a feeling who this was gonna be after reading the title but even then I was surprised. it's psycho fucking goku less gooo!!! welcome back
11 hours ago

Offline
Sep 2013
285
Sure man, nice to see you back again though.
11 hours ago
Offline
Aug 2022
288
There aren't any anime out there with movie animation expect few of them in which chainsaw man is in
11 hours ago

Offline
May 2023
80
It's just a bait and switch trailer like season 1's. Get ready to be lured in by CRAPPA and buck-broken once again, Diaper.
10 hours ago
Offline
Jul 2019
19
Yo digo que nel pastel
10 hours ago
Offline
Jul 2022
712
It was amazing. Maybe it just didn't give the same vibe as the Manga. But no way it was bad.
9 hours ago
Offline
Oct 2019
730
No.
(character limit)
9 hours ago
Offline
Oct 2019
730
Oriorii said:
Why people hate S1? I really loved lol

Majority love it don't worry lmao
Just a vocal minority ya know
9 hours ago
Offline
Jul 2023
501
the movie trailer might be better, but there is NO way you called S1 a failure 😭
9 hours ago

Offline
Jun 2022
70
my guy psycho goku is back.
Even if we disappear from this world, our stories will remain.
9 hours ago

Offline
Jun 2022
70
TheBladeIsMe said:
It's just a bait and switch trailer like season 1's. Get ready to be lured in by CRAPPA and buck-broken once again, Diaper.

.....................
Even if we disappear from this world, our stories will remain.
9 hours ago

Offline
Feb 2022
94
I'm gonna be straight with ya, this looks way more generic of a shōnen than season 1, though you also have to think about what this trailer mainly showcases: action. Chainsaw Man just isn't about the fights, so you really can't form a complex opinion of the direction simply based on a trailer that mainly showcases fights. That being said, the fights look amazing, but everything before 45 seconds is honestly worse than season 1 in my opinion. It all feels so in your face, gone is the subtlety of the manga, the careful framing and evocative images, it's just another basic shōnen like JJK, at least when it comes to the direction. CSM is supposed to be cinematically directed in a clearly western style, but they just lost that here. I'm not saying that you can't prefer this, though I doubt you really got Chainsaw Man if that is your honest opinion.
Hello, please don't take anything I say as an insult, it is not meant as an attack against you as a person. If I directly disagree with you, that does not mean I think you are wrong, I am just more correct.
9 hours ago

Offline
Jun 2019
71
All I see is a man comparing the production and animation of a TV series with the production and animation of a movie.

I also see a man judging a series solely on the reception of a small part of public.

I just woke up and I'm already laughing.
9 hours ago

Offline
Aug 2014
775
Oh no, what are we gonna do now???
9 hours ago

Offline
Nov 2020
646
has been yapping since 2021. you have crazzy dedication, I'll give you that
9 hours ago
Online
Sep 2022
428
Psycho_Goku said:
(No moderators of MAL; this post is not breaking the rules just because it's tackling a controversial debate within the anime community)
With that out of the way...

The CSM movie trailer with the NEW DIRECTOR (Tatsuya Yoshihara) just dropped and...

It absolutely DESTROYED season 1 in every department!!! I mean, just look at this absolute masterclass of direction and Animation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1n552v1ng0

This is literally what the pinnacle of Japanimation looks like.

This trailer is definitive proof that the previous director, Ryu Nakayama, is solely to blame for the complete financial failure of CSM season 1.

If Chainsaw Man had been as well directed as this new movie it would have been the biggest anime of our modern times! Instead, Jujutsu Midsen FRAUDULENTLY took that spot away from CSM, simply because it was lucky enough to receive a proper director from the beginning!

But it doesn't matter anymore, now that Ryu Nakayama is no longer in charge of ruining the franchise, we finally have a proper genius director like Yoshihara helming the production of Chainsaw Man! CSM's anime can finally "change the anime industry" like it should have done from the beginning!

damn bro thats crazy 🗿🗿🗿
8 hours ago

Offline
Apr 2022
6463
speaking ill on nakayama in the big 2024, pretty corny behavior but you do you.
8 hours ago
Offline
Mar 2022
3
Reply to Oriorii
Why people hate S1? I really loved lol
@Oriorii Yeah. I love how they managed to nail the cinematic look of the manga.
8 hours ago
Offline
Jun 2021
38
Bro really said “biggest failure in modern anime history” 😭🙏
8 hours ago
Offline
Mar 2022
3
Reply to Lucianael
I'm gonna be straight with ya, this looks way more generic of a shōnen than season 1, though you also have to think about what this trailer mainly showcases: action. Chainsaw Man just isn't about the fights, so you really can't form a complex opinion of the direction simply based on a trailer that mainly showcases fights. That being said, the fights look amazing, but everything before 45 seconds is honestly worse than season 1 in my opinion. It all feels so in your face, gone is the subtlety of the manga, the careful framing and evocative images, it's just another basic shōnen like JJK, at least when it comes to the direction. CSM is supposed to be cinematically directed in a clearly western style, but they just lost that here. I'm not saying that you can't prefer this, though I doubt you really got Chainsaw Man if that is your honest opinion.
@Lucianael yes, exactly!
8 hours ago
Offline
Jun 2022
3
lol....................
8 hours ago
Offline
Apr 2023
16
it was one of the best animes ever humankind created, you idiot.
8 hours ago
Offline
Nov 2021
509
Just stop the hate already. It was excellent and indeed a faithful adaptation of manga. Hating it won't make you special.
7 hours ago

Offline
Oct 2021
415
Reply to Lucianael
I'm gonna be straight with ya, this looks way more generic of a shōnen than season 1, though you also have to think about what this trailer mainly showcases: action. Chainsaw Man just isn't about the fights, so you really can't form a complex opinion of the direction simply based on a trailer that mainly showcases fights. That being said, the fights look amazing, but everything before 45 seconds is honestly worse than season 1 in my opinion. It all feels so in your face, gone is the subtlety of the manga, the careful framing and evocative images, it's just another basic shōnen like JJK, at least when it comes to the direction. CSM is supposed to be cinematically directed in a clearly western style, but they just lost that here. I'm not saying that you can't prefer this, though I doubt you really got Chainsaw Man if that is your honest opinion.
Very pretentious post. I read Chainsaw Man 3 times, which pretty much makes me the biggest CSM fan in the world. Your "opinion" isn't appreciated here.
6 hours ago
Offline
Aug 2021
646
Psycho Goku has returned finally, we can enjoy more of his circus, now acting as the jester, with the plot twist that are going to come next, stay tuned!
6 hours ago
Offline
Jun 2019
5
This is bullshit coz season is so good maybe manga readers hated it but it's not bad
6 hours ago
Offline
Feb 2020
76
Have fun before your bullshit hate discussion becomes locked
6 hours ago
Offline
May 2022
954
I don't know what you're talking about, the animation looks the same as season 1, maybe a bit better because it's a movie and those are always more polished.
Season 1 is amazing, maybe it should have had another cour, but that's it.
5 hours ago
Offline
Jun 2021
102
No one's falling for this, little bro.
5 hours ago

Online
Jul 2015
12379
Two years and this guy is still coping and trying to bait lmao

5 hours ago
Offline
Apr 2022
32
Who the hell thinks that
4 hours ago

Offline
Feb 2022
94
Reply to Psycho_Goku
Very pretentious post. I read Chainsaw Man 3 times, which pretty much makes me the biggest CSM fan in the world. Your "opinion" isn't appreciated here.
@Psycho_Goku Believe what you want, if it validates your opinion.
Hello, please don't take anything I say as an insult, it is not meant as an attack against you as a person. If I directly disagree with you, that does not mean I think you are wrong, I am just more correct.
4 hours ago

Online
Sep 2020
1158
Chainsaw Man Season 1 was great. However this trailer far surpassed Season 1 animation IMO
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
4 hours ago
Offline
Oct 2024
54
I will do everything in my power to find a rule this violates to get it taken down. This peak trailer doesn't deserve a rage bait ass thread like this, we should be celebrating
4 hours ago

Online
Sep 2016
11088
That trailer got my hype up.
DesuMaiden said:
Nobody resembles me physically because I don't even physically exist.
4 hours ago

Online
Jan 2009
101678
Reply to Hdjwsiisiaooaoox
I will do everything in my power to find a rule this violates to get it taken down. This peak trailer doesn't deserve a rage bait ass thread like this, we should be celebrating
@Hdjwsiisiaooaoox wut he is actually praising the trailer of this though? he is just hating on season 1
4 hours ago
Offline
Jul 2016
52
"Biggest failure in modern anime history" 🤓 there was literally a show back in 2017 or 2018 that did so bad it didn't even get to finish its TV run.
3 hours ago
Offline
Jan 2023
34
Bait used to be believable
3 hours ago
Offline
Jul 2016
52
Izac_Kak said:
"Biggest failure in modern anime history" 🤓 there was literally a show back in 2017 or 2018 that did so bad it didn't even get to finish its TV run.

Also Uzumaki came out this year.
3 hours ago
Offline
Sep 2023
159
Psycho_Goku said:
(No moderators of MAL; this post is not breaking the rules just because it's tackling a controversial debate within the anime community)
With that out of the way...

The CSM movie trailer with the NEW DIRECTOR (Tatsuya Yoshihara) just dropped and...

It absolutely DESTROYED season 1 in every department!!! I mean, just look at this absolute masterclass of direction and Animation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1n552v1ng0

This is literally what the pinnacle of Japanimation looks like.

This trailer is definitive proof that the previous director, Ryu Nakayama, is solely to blame for the complete financial failure of CSM season 1.

If Chainsaw Man had been as well directed as this new movie it would have been the biggest anime of our modern times! Instead, Jujutsu Midsen FRAUDULENTLY took that spot away from CSM, simply because it was lucky enough to receive a proper director from the beginning!

But it doesn't matter anymore, now that Ryu Nakayama is no longer in charge of ruining the franchise, we finally have a proper genius director like Yoshihara helming the production of Chainsaw Man! CSM's anime can finally "change the anime industry" like it should have done from the beginning!

You truly are a psycho
2 hours ago
Offline
May 2024
1
0/10 ragebait bro cant be srs
2 hours ago
Offline
Mar 2021
423
Psycho_Goku said:
(No moderators of MAL; this post is not breaking the rules just because it's tackling a controversial debate within the anime community)
With that out of the way...

The CSM movie trailer with the NEW DIRECTOR (Tatsuya Yoshihara) just dropped and...

It absolutely DESTROYED season 1 in every department!!! I mean, just look at this absolute masterclass of direction and Animation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1n552v1ng0

This is literally what the pinnacle of Japanimation looks like.

This trailer is definitive proof that the previous director, Ryu Nakayama, is solely to blame for the complete financial failure of CSM season 1.

If Chainsaw Man had been as well directed as this new movie it would have been the biggest anime of our modern times! Instead, Jujutsu Midsen FRAUDULENTLY took that spot away from CSM, simply because it was lucky enough to receive a proper director from the beginning!

But it doesn't matter anymore, now that Ryu Nakayama is no longer in charge of ruining the franchise, we finally have a proper genius director like Yoshihara helming the production of Chainsaw Man! CSM's anime can finally "change the anime industry" like it should have done from the beginning!

More like According to you lol it wasn’t well received in Japan but that doesn’t make it a “failure” otherwise Mappa wouldn’t invest so much money into this project
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» New Teaser and coming next year

Dbagas8 - Yesterday

36 by Zane_0 »»
1 hour ago

» Are you saying Yutaka Nakamura is the key animator in CSM Reze movie?

DatajI - Yesterday

20 by M-T_S »»
6 hours ago

» HOLY PEAKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

DatajI - Yesterday

17 by LIVI___ »»
9 hours ago

» What are our expectations from the JUMP FESTA 2025

LIVI___ - Dec 4

33 by Washizo »»
Dec 19, 7:34 AM

» LEAK: Trailer INCOMING

LIVI___ - Dec 14

26 by YamiLoon »»
Dec 16, 7:50 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login