| I felt the same thing while watching the scene and it had substracted a lot of its effect. If it was anime original, as was stated by someone, then it was a bad directorial choice. It is hard to get a dramatic effect from something that otherwise seemes nonsensical judging by how the characters would have behaved if they were left to do that seemed was the most reasonable in a situation like that. It reminded me in a sense of the lengthy monolouges of shounen during battle scenes that I hate so much (nonsensical actions in a situation in which they shouldn't take place happening just for the dramatic effect). |
IshitatesoFeb 17, 2024 10:18 PM
 |
A-lil-weeb-dog said: Mao Mao was hurt, and bleeding heavily, and bro decided to carry her to safety…. IN A SLOW POWER WALK?!? Motherfucker, she's losing a fuck ton of blood and you decided to do a boxing walk-out intro(with the music and everything) taking your sweet ass time too, You have a crush on her right? Hurry tf up, she's bleeding!! She did hurried her best for you. I know she's not gonna die cuz she's the protagonist, but come on!!! Why are you letting her bleed out, she could have died if this was a different type of show with how slow you were moving(he better be thanking the author for that) I love Jinshi as a character and his dynamic with Mao Mao, they are cute together and around each other. But damn do I have to vent when I saw just how much she had to bleed out because he was dead on “walking menacingly” at a snail pace, after she sacrificed her safety to save his life too! TLDR: I don't have an issue with the realism, I’m mad at how slow-ass Jinshi was, why are you guys keep on bringing up something that I didn't say? Read the post please, goddamnit! It's not about how unrealistic the scene is, it's about how Dumb Jinshi was in the scene Agreed, I am also getting mad that he's walking so slowly, but maybe... he cares about his noble status? I mean the King doesn't run Idk. |
| bro had to pull the kaneki walk to be cool |
 |
| It's for the cinematic experience, gotta go with it lol |
  🇸🇪🇹 🇧🇾⦂ 🇨🇴🇿🇮🇮 🇨🇦🇷🇩 🇨🇴🇱🇱🇪🇨🇹🇮🇴🇳 🇩🇪🇱🇮🇻🇪🇷🇾 |
| It's no Aku no Hana GOAT walking scene, but it was still very nice. Though I can see it ruining immersion for some. |
Ishitateso said: I felt the same thing while watching the scene and it had substracted a lot of its effect. If it was anime original, as was stated by someone, then it was a bad directorial choice. It is hard to get a dramatic effect from something that otherwise seemes nonsensical judging by how the characters would have behaved if they were left to do that seemed was the most reasonable in a situation like that. It reminded me in a sense of the lengthy monolouges of shounen during battle scenes that I hate so much (nonsensical actions in a situation in which they shouldn't take place happening just for the dramatic effect). it is semi original, in the manga it's only told to Maomao when she wakes that Jinshi carried her in his arms and was a bit pushy regarding treatment and resting place. I wouldn't have had that much issue with the scene if he at least had stopped the bleeding. it's a very powerful scene, given who Jinshi is, carrying a servant is absolutely shocking, I also think that's the main reason Lakan is so speechless(besides her injuries). And I know that Jinshi has to keep a little bit of composure, but damn, hurry your pace ... |
 |
Reply to Dayan
Ishitateso said:
I felt the same thing while watching the scene and it had substracted a lot of its effect. If it was anime original, as was stated by someone, then it was a bad directorial choice. It is hard to get a dramatic effect from something that otherwise seemes nonsensical judging by how the characters would have behaved if they were left to do that seemed was the most reasonable in a situation like that. It reminded me in a sense of the lengthy monolouges of shounen during battle scenes that I hate so much (nonsensical actions in a situation in which they shouldn't take place happening just for the dramatic effect).
I felt the same thing while watching the scene and it had substracted a lot of its effect. If it was anime original, as was stated by someone, then it was a bad directorial choice. It is hard to get a dramatic effect from something that otherwise seemes nonsensical judging by how the characters would have behaved if they were left to do that seemed was the most reasonable in a situation like that. It reminded me in a sense of the lengthy monolouges of shounen during battle scenes that I hate so much (nonsensical actions in a situation in which they shouldn't take place happening just for the dramatic effect).
it is semi original, in the manga it's only told to Maomao when she wakes that Jinshi carried her in his arms and was a bit pushy regarding treatment and resting place.
I wouldn't have had that much issue with the scene if he at least had stopped the bleeding.
it's a very powerful scene, given who Jinshi is, carrying a servant is absolutely shocking, I also think that's the main reason Lakan is so speechless(besides her injuries). And I know that Jinshi has to keep a little bit of composure, but damn, hurry your pace ...
| @Dayan Yes, the whole problem with that scene could have been solved with one short scene of Jinshi making a makeshift bandage from a torn piece of his cloth and then showing less blood dripping on the streets. As I said it seems that the fault was on the part of the episode director, they should have paid attention to telling the story in a way that did't break immersion by showing unreasonable behaviour for the sake of dramatic effect (which was actually ruined because of it). |
IshitatesoFeb 18, 2024 2:46 AM
|
Ishitateso said: @Dayan Yes, the whole problem with that scene could have been solved with one short scene of Jinshi making a makeshift bandage from a torn piece of his cloth and then showing less blood dripping on the streets. As I said it seems that the fault was on the part of the episode director, they should have paid attention to telling the story in a way that did't break immersion by showing unreasonable behaviour for the sake of dramatic effect (which was actually ruined because of it). they didn't even need to show the scene, just show her leg wrapped while being carried, and they could even have had one or two blood drops fall for dramatic effect without having everyone screaming "HURRY UP" in their heads during the whole scene. |
| |
| Mao Mao suffered from 2 things : 1) Concussion - Slow Walk good 2) Blood Loss - Slow walk Reaaaallly bad Unfortunately the episode director forgot that it isnt Bleach and Characters die if they lose 3 Hektoliters of Blood. If this Scene got 1/5 Blood on the floor it would be perfect ... |
| Ugh...another one taking an Anime scene, trying desperatly to translate it into his nitpicky reality xD Dude...it's a Show. Relax. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kusuriya no Hitorigoto Episode 19 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 17, 2024 |
285 |
by QueenMissFit
»»
3 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Kusuriya no Hitorigoto Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 23, 2024 |
348 |
by Heliac123
»»
Yesterday, 11:44 AM |
|
Poll: » Kusuriya no Hitorigoto Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 27, 2024 |
109 |
by 0207xander
»»
Oct 11, 4:14 PM |
|
» Maomao is kinda overrated ( 1 2 3 )-Ezra- - Jun 25 |
126 |
by 0207xander
»»
Oct 3, 3:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Kusuriya no Hitorigoto Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )KANLen09 - Oct 21, 2023 |
205 |
by M1kasaYu1
»»
Sep 4, 10:31 AM |