Heart Gold or Soul Silver
Pokemon Heart Gold
37.7%
20
Pokemon Soul Silver
62.3%
33
53 votes
| I had a conversation with my friend since he saw the poster for Heart Gold and Soul Silver @ Game Stop. And im planning to get Heart Gold 1st then Soul Silver. But my friend likes Soul Silver more. So in your opinion, which version do you like better? Edit: Since now most ppl in the world have the game available in their region i guess ill turn it to a discussion thread. |
xDoN904Mar 15, 2010 10:27 PM
 |
| Soul Sliver. But I'm planning to get both. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Separating the same game into two different games is nothing but a ridiculous profit strategy. I don't really get why anyone would want to buy both when they're pretty much the samething. People don't actually take the "gotta catch em all" seriously, right? Right? (And even so, they could just trade pokemon from earlier games instead of catching the few exclusives.) And none of the exclusives are particularly good, except maybe Gliscor, Arcanine, and Skarmory. But if I had to choose, I guess Gold so I can see Kyogre instead of Groudon. |
TachiiJan 17, 2010 2:20 PM
| I'll buy one and get the other for my homebrew cart thingmajing. Tachii said: ;w;People don't actually take the "gotta catch em all" seriously, right? Right? But in my defence, I did have the money to spare. And I likely wouldn't have bought these two anyways, seeing how I could just get the other ones from other games, like you said. I've already caught them all, just not in a single game yet. But who cares. |
| Am going to get Soul Silver. |
| Heart Gold, for no other reason than I got Gold way back when. |
 |
| Hopefully when I decide to get them I'll have enough money for both but if I don't I'm going to go with Soul Silver. |
        |
| getting both but, Heart Gold all the way |
| I already have heartgold in Japanese. If I get one in English, it will be Soulsilver to balance myself out. |
 |
| btw for moar info of version-esclusive and other misc. info, check out http://www.serebii.net/heartgoldsoulsilver/ |
| Soul Silver. I'm so psyched for this, Pokemon Silver was my favorite game in the series, and I spent a LOT of my free childhood playing it. Hearing about the re-release made me one of the happiest people on earth. |
| There is no emotion; there is peace. There is no ignorance; there is knowledge. There is no passion; there is serenity. There is no death; there is the force. |
| Im curious to whether these two games are a newer version of pokemon gold & silver. Are they? I better go looking for my R4 cartridge anyway...along with my long untouched DS. |
     |
Retsu-kun said: I'm pretty sure they won't, as HG and SS includes all the changes that Crystal had, plus they didn't make a remake of Yellow after FR and LG.If I ever change my mind about getting the remake, I'll probably wait until they release the "whatever" Crystal remake. |
| I have both. I'd say SoulSilver is better because it has better "version exclusive" pokemon. I just wish that the stantler sprite wasn't so ugly though, because I really wanted a stantler on my team and I hate looking at it now. Something about it just doesn't seem right... Like it's disproportionate. |
| Only getting SoulSilver since I think Lugia looks better on a box. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
HawthorneKitty said: rofl, Ho-oh always look like it's on dope or something.Only getting SoulSilver since I think Lugia looks better on a box. |
| Imma name my Lugia Luigi. |
| I'le get both ^^ |
 |
| Well... i want the heart gold version. |
| Or maybe Luger. |
Baman said: It just keeps getting worse and worse. );Or maybe Luger. |
| Well I'll clone up a bunch and give them different names. Luigi, Luger, Lactase, Laks, Luthor, Lundberg. |
| HeartGold, Ho-Oh is better than Lugia...plus I got the original Gold Version. But I do plan on getting both. |
 |
| Getting both. |
| I'm choosing SoulSilver mainly for Skarmory and Groudon. It doesn't really matter since I caught all of them in my Pearl version though. |
 |
stirfry said: Im curious to whether these two games are a newer version of pokemon gold & silver. Are they? I better go looking for my R4 cartridge anyway...along with my long untouched DS. Yes, Heart Gold and Soul Silver are remakes of the original Gold/Silver but with the latest game mechanics and a bunch of new content/3rd and 4th gen pokemon added in. Makes me wonder if they'll be doing a Crystal remake... I got Gold when it came out... so this time, I think I'll be going for Soul Silver. |
 |
| I wonder if they can do a revamp of the old school Red and Blue games. Not really a fan of the newer "generations". |
PenguinSuitChiyo said: I wonder if they can do a revamp of the old school Red and Blue games. Not really a fan of the newer "generations". They already did that. Fire Red and Leaf Green. Although it does contain pokemon from the later generations in it as well. |
|
Wasabi said: Personally, i didn't like the remake of the originals. It was idk very plain to me with little new features.PenguinSuitChiyo said: I wonder if they can do a revamp of the old school Red and Blue games. Not really a fan of the newer "generations". They already did that. Fire Red and Leaf Green. Although it does contain pokemon from the later generations in it as well. |
|
feder said: I already have heartgold in Japanese. If I get one in English, it will be Soulsilver to balance myself out. This. Though, my boyfriend will be getting SoulSilver in English when it comes out in April, so I dunno if I should bother getting it too. I got the original Gold first, so I figured I'd get HeartGold too. Also, Gold is a warmer colour and at the time I bought it I was pretty depressed, so it sound weird, but it really cheered me up. That and the fact it was Pokemon :P |
 Check out SunnyCon! The North-East of England's newest and biggest convention of anime, manga and Japanese culture! Now a club on MAL too! |
| Heart gold. Ho-oh > Lugia |
| If Ho-oh looked less like a chicken I'd probably get heart gold. Meaning I'll be getting silver, again. |
Houzai said: Now how in the world does Ho-Oh looks like a chicken in any way?If Ho-oh looked less like a chicken I'd probably get heart gold. Meaning I'll be getting silver, again. |
|
PsychoDon904 said: Houzai said: Now how in the world does Ho-Oh looks like a chicken in any way?If Ho-oh looked less like a chicken I'd probably get heart gold. Meaning I'll be getting silver, again. I'd say he looks more like a peacock than a chicken.... |
|
Wasabi said: PenguinSuitChiyo said: I wonder if they can do a revamp of the old school Red and Blue games. Not really a fan of the newer "generations". They already did that. Fire Red and Leaf Green. Although it does contain pokemon from the later generations in it as well. Oh shoot your right haha. Well I guess I meant a DS version of it. :P |
cabbit-chan said: feder said: I already have heartgold in Japanese. If I get one in English, it will be Soulsilver to balance myself out. This. Though, my boyfriend will be getting SoulSilver in English when it comes out in April, so I dunno if I should bother getting it too. I got the original Gold first, so I figured I'd get HeartGold too. Also, Gold is a warmer colour and at the time I bought it I was pretty depressed, so it sound weird, but it really cheered me up. That and the fact it was Pokemon :P It's coming out in March, not April. :P (or where I'm from anyway). Anyways, I'm going to be going with Soulsilver, I already played HeartGold on my computer. :P. There are patches from them in English for DS Emulators for those who want to try either one of them. Pretty fun game. |
PenguinSuitChiyo said: Well, considering HG/SS feature the old region with the gyms and all, plus the added bonuses of being able to catch the birds and Mewtwo, as well as having a chance to get the first starters, I guess that's as far as you'll come.Oh shoot your right haha. Well I guess I meant a DS version of it. :P |
| SoulSilver, i got Silver, so logic says get its second form as well |
     |
| I've already sunk five million hours into Silver; might as well do the same for its DS counterpart... |
| i already have soul silver japanese, about half way done with it. silver was my favorite so i had to chose soul silver. besides, lugia rocks that rainbow bird any day. and that poke walker thing is pretty convenient. i went skiing for a weekend, took my togepi with me, and he grew a few levels, and caught some stupid bug pokemon. |
 |
More topics from this board
» What do you like the most about pc gaming?jacobPOL - Sep 24 |
23 |
by walktheplank
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» How are your pc builds?jacobPOL - 1 hour ago |
0 |
by jacobPOL
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» Is There Any game that's you're looking forward to getting ?VabbingSips - Aug 9 |
40 |
by PokeProX
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Nintendo vs. Sega Philosophystefanoiulli1999 - Oct 7 |
20 |
by memeticmeme
»»
8 hours ago |
|
» Has Expedition 33 become the new "elitist game"?Tropisch - Oct 10 |
24 |
by vault-dweller
»»
10 hours ago |