Attack on Titan
| Usually even separate cours are split into 2 entries, yet in this case MAL made it one entry. It’s basically two shorter movies, at the very least. The stark difference in ratings should be noticable, otherwise some of the best parts of AoT are gonna get mixed with some of the worst parts of it. |
JedanKomadMar 4, 2023 2:25 AM
 |
YoshiYogurt said: A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. Agreed. Anilist has it split into two. Not sure why there has to be this giant discrepancy between sites. Now post-covid more than ever its a bitch to import between the sites since everyone has to split up entries in whatever way they want. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. |
|
| Yeah I agree. I guess the biggest question is what would you call the 2nd part. 'Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen Part 2' doesn't exactly roll off the tongue. |
  ๐ฃ๐ฐ๐ซ๐ข๐ค๐ฌ ๐ฉ๐ฐ๐ณ๐ด๐ฆ๐ฎ๐ข๐ฏ ๐ช๐ด ๐ต๐ฉ๐ฆ ๐ฃ๐ฆ๐ด๐ต ๐ข๐ฏ๐ช๐ฎ๐ฆ |
| You can at least "complete" this entry. Imagine having this dangling on your "watching" list until fall lol I like to have things organized |
Zander_SenpaiMar 4, 2023 2:38 AM
 |
| I agree there should be a split into two separate entries, each one for each part. However, it's not about whether someone likes the upcoming chapters that are going to be animated more than the ones that we could see in the first part. This shouldn't matter when making new entries, because I doubt anyone sane needs a gerrymandering version of anime rating, lol. It's about being faithful to the official naming. After all, Pony Canyon calls Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen's continuation not as "second episode", but as Part 2 (ใ้ฒๆใฎๅทจไบบใ The Final Seasonๅฎ็ต็ทจ๏ผๅพ็ทจ๏ผ) : Not to forget that even if we put everything aside, the split would be a logical thing to do. Some might be salty about it, I am aware of that. You know, that the final season of an anime might have 5 entries in total, but it doesn't matter. That's how it is and they are only names of the final seasons of the show. What's more important is content and structure. |
โจSaint Seiya Club๐ |
HorseManPerson said: Amazing, that would just be going along with the meme, I’d laugh my ass off on a title like that :dYeah I agree. I guess the biggest question is what would you call the 2nd part. 'Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen Part 2' doesn't exactly roll off the tongue. |
|
Adnash said: I agree with your whole comment, and of course, entries are never about ratings lol. I just added that as just another point that the watchers might consider, not the MAL admins ๐จHowever, it's not about whether someone likes the upcoming chapters that are going to be animated more than the ones that we could see in the first part. This shouldn't matter when making new entries, because I doubt anyone sane needs a gerrymandering version of anime rating, lol. |
|
Zander_Senpai said: I am doing exactly as you have stated. And I am happy about it.You can at least "complete" this entry. Imagine having this dangling on your "watching" list until fall lol I like to have things organized |
| It's just 1st special episode of 3rd Part of Final Season. And I don't want to see 4 separate entries with final season. |
| Eh no, I guess this is just a special/movie rather than a full blown tv series so maybe thats why it doesn't fall under that split-the-cour rule MugiwaraJopa said: YoshiYogurt said: A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. Agreed. Anilist has it split into two. Not sure why there has to be this giant discrepancy between sites. Now post-covid more than ever its a bitch to import between the sites since everyone has to split up entries in whatever way they want. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. Disregarding anilist and mal, which of these 2 you prefer, letterboxd or imdb ? I prefer imdb just a bit more cuz it has tv shows while letterboxd only has movies (its 5 star rating system is soo good tho) |
 |
MugiwaraJopa said: YoshiYogurt said: A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. Agreed. Anilist has it split into two. Not sure why there has to be this giant discrepancy between sites. Now post-covid more than ever its a bitch to import between the sites since everyone has to split up entries in whatever way they want. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. personally, i would vote for MAL. i love time stamping feature. they allocated a table/db in theri database for each anime for each user watch time. + rewatch counter. albeit, it's hard to use on mobile i think. easier on desktop mode/browser to complete the rewatch progress (make it count in rewatch counter) --- Za_Panda said: Disregarding anilist and mal, which of these 2 you prefer, letterboxd or imdb ? I prefer imdb just a bit more cuz it has tv shows while letterboxd only has movies (its 5 star rating system is soo good tho) Im using Simkl for movie/series at this moment. IMDb better compared to them? |
| It would be funny to see how much the score drops if they don't separate it. |
 |
| I second this, hoping MAL considers the option |
 |
| Pure agree. I hope admod respond to this. Btw, I have a question for you as fans guys, Will the next cour/episode be the end of series in other words are they adapting the Ending or... are there still many chapters/episodes to get to the ending, thanks |
| i mean i agree sorta in the sense that this feels entirely separate from the rest of whats to come. i feel like they should mark it as completed for now and see what news comes for the fall part. in the end idk why they didnt just wait until fall to release it all together, like im getting sick of waiting multiple months just for like 60 minutes of content and then bam i have to wait another 7 months like.. |
| i'm not too sure, the thought of more aot entries in my list sounds kinda annoying, there's already so much as it is. yeah, i'm fine with the way it is. |
 |
YoshiYogurt said: Thanks for your input, I might do exactly that, import, and see how it's like down the line.MugiwaraJopa said: A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. I'd say import your MAL profile over and set up your favorites and currently watching and see if you like it. I am a big fan of letterboxd. IMDB was always a crappy website to me Recently switched to Letterboxd and it's a much cleaner website indeed. Simple always works |
|
shuffle_017 said: Oh fair, yeah the mobile app is missing some features that the desktop website has, I think they're working on it, since they did add a tab for manga somewhat recentlyMugiwaraJopa said: A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. personally, i would vote for MAL. i love time stamping feature. they allocated a table/db in theri database for each anime for each user watch time. + rewatch counter. albeit, it's hard to use on mobile i think. easier on desktop mode/browser to complete the rewatch progress (make it count in rewatch counter) |
|
YoshiYogurt said: MugiwaraJopa said: I made an account there when MAL was down for 3 months straight in 2018. A bit off-topic but do you think Anlilist is better than MAL? Is it something like Letterboxd compared to IMDb, if you know those? Might make an account there. I do think MAL will at least consider separating these down the line. The tracking of seasonals/currently watching is much better since you can hit +1 right on the home page and it shows what youre behind on for currently airing with a red underline. Profiles let you show more favorites than MAL which is nice . but MAL UI is better for list sorting, better UI for checking seasonals by year/season , better UI for individual pages of anime. Anilist also like to be cleaner by not having any entries for recaps, which is dumb to me - why be an incomplate database? Anilist also tries to have a more "modern" look with their bloated UI full of square shapes and empty space. The biggest complaint people have with MAL is that it's "outdated" but to me Anilist is pointlessly trying to look new and cool. I'd say import your MAL profile over and set up your favorites and currently watching and see if you like it. I am a big fan of letterboxd. IMDB was always a crappy website to me Letterboxd mess many of the tv shows with some movies of same name, its a good place for movie but keep anime for here and TV shows for IMDB or Serializd. Letterboxd is pretty good I would say but not for TV shows or anime. |
| 2025 might be the year where I will be happy. This year is not happy year. |
Zander_Senpai said: I put it ''On-Hold'', a category I use for anime I'm not actively watching.You can at least "complete" this entry. Imagine having this dangling on your "watching" list until fall lol I like to have things organized |
MugiwaraJopa said: Oh fair, yeah the mobile app is missing some features that the desktop website has, I think they're working on it, since they did add a tab for manga somewhat recently both mobile app and mobile web. their UX is not 1:1 similar to a desktop ver at all, hahaha + I like the backup feature of MAL. I often export my list as a backup. not that I use the backup right away. But, I like to have that option. so, in case something happened to MAL and I need to migrate my list to another service, I could use that file for importing. probably need to do some scripting job to parse the list, etc. But, it's a doable option at least |
Jaiimy said: Zander_Senpai said: I put it ''On-Hold'', a category I use for anime I'm not actively watching.You can at least "complete" this entry. Imagine having this dangling on your "watching" list until fall lol I like to have things organized same. but of course, a separate entry would be better imho. but, this work as well. |
HorseManPerson said: Yeah I agree. I guess the biggest question is what would you call the 2nd part. 'Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen Part 2' doesn't exactly roll off the tongue. 'Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - The Final Part - The Final Episode' ROFL I can't wait for the moment i check "Completed" on this whole damn franchise and be done with it... |
Enri_eu said: Action shines in anime and i hope we get good climax battle.No, it will continue in the same part, lets stop with all this split bs. And it is funny how manga haters said that the series would go downhill after the rumbling started, then they said it would actually go down after 131 and now you say it will go downhill in the last part. Lmao your cope is so funny. |
| Seems a little excessive to me. But if this means some certain older entries are finally split, I'd be down. |
MugiwaraJopa said: I agree with your whole comment, and of course, entries are never about ratings lol. I just added that as just another point that the watchers might consider, not the MAL admins ๐จ Haha, I see, it's all good. By the way, have you considered creating a thread in the forum section dedicated to anime database requests on MAL as well? Surely a thread posted in that category has higher chances to be read or noticed by people responsible for the anime database on MAL, while a thread posted in an anime subforum might be easily omitted by them, especially if they are interested that much in Attack on Titan anime. Judging from how people reacted to the thread we are in right now I think there might be a lot of positive comments supporting the split written in a thread posted in the forum section I mentioned above. |
โจSaint Seiya Club๐ |
Adnash said: I don't really know much about MAL forums so thanks for letting me know. I might repost there later. Could be interesting to see whether LESS SPLITS or MORE SPLITS wins :)MugiwaraJopa said: I agree with your whole comment, and of course, entries are never about ratings lol. I just added that as just another point that the watchers might consider, not the MAL admins ๐จ Haha, I see, it's all good. By the way, have you considered creating a thread in the forum section dedicated to anime database requests on MAL as well? Surely a thread posted in that category has higher chances to be read or noticed by people responsible for the anime database on MAL, while a thread posted in an anime subforum might be easily omitted by them, especially if they are interested that much in Attack on Titan anime. Judging from how people reacted to the thread we are in right now I think there might be a lot of positive comments supporting the split written in a thread posted in the forum section I mentioned above. |
|
MugiwaraJopa said: I don't really know much about MAL forums so thanks for letting me know. I might repost there later. Could be interesting to see whether LESS SPLITS or MORE SPLITS wins :) No problem! I don't want to create such thread myself, to not seem like somebody "stealing" somebody else's glory of starting a discussion about this suggestion. :P Like I said before, I think the arguments are enough to at least consider creating a separate entry for the second minimovie. If there won't be any split, then on well. It's fine by me as well. After all, it's Kanketsu-hen, aka the concluding chapter. ;) |
โจSaint Seiya Club๐ |
| I know right, MAL makes separate entries for much, much less- heck even PV's sometimes even. The last episode of AOT kind of deserves its own entry, right? Plus if it stays like this it's just going to be awkwardly sitting in people's "watching" or "oh-hold" lists until the final part comes out. |
  NYANPASU  whiskey tango foxtrot |
| Yeah I agree 100 percent |
| please no, no more The Final parts... |
More topics from this board
Poll: » What is the endings biggest flaw? (SPOILERS) ( 1 2 3 )keinboesewicht - Jul 17 |
124 |
by Han-yuu
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Nov 4, 2023 |
1560 |
by Han-yuu
»»
Yesterday, 2:07 PM |
|
» Who are Top 3 characters in AOT In terms of writing alone?? ( 1 2 )vinnywizanime - Jul 22 |
84 |
by AoTFanFromBG
»»
Aug 23, 5:25 AM |
|
Poll: » SiM - UNDER THE TREE (Full Length Ver.) Anime Special Ver.LittleStar - Sep 27, 2023 |
7 |
by Ditophlips
»»
Aug 14, 10:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season - Kanketsu-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Koito91 - Mar 3, 2023 |
1055 |
by Dark_zarich
»»
Aug 8, 5:13 PM |