For fans: What makes one piece a masterpiece? For haters: What makes one piece trash?

Feb 7, 2022 8:36 AM

#2

Yumerei

busy week =_+

Offline

Dec 2014

3053

The art style, the adventure theme, the feels.

.

CURRENT: semi-hiatus (busy)

Vibes

EXTENDED FAVORITES

Feb 7, 2022 8:54 AM

#3

Lucifrost

Offline

Feb 2016

15016

Yumerei said:
The art style, the adventure theme, the feels.

I too dislike the art style and the feelings One Piece instills in me.

その目だれの目？

Feb 7, 2022 9:00 AM

#4

Yumerei

busy week =_+

Offline

Dec 2014

3053

Lucifrost said:

Yumerei said:
The art style, the adventure theme, the feels.

I too dislike the art style and the feelings One Piece instills in me.

Yes, I agree. That's what makes it a masterpiece

.

CURRENT: semi-hiatus (busy)

Vibes

EXTENDED FAVORITES

Feb 7, 2022 9:18 AM

#5

WeFeed

Offline

Dec 2019

1643

I love it for the characters, the feels, the action, the worldbuilding, the comedy, the adventure and the art style.

Sucks that the pacing is pretty bad but nothing you can really do about that with long running animes

But you can just read that manga if you don't wanna deal with the pacing

Feb 7, 2022 9:28 AM

#6

WolfSaber

Offline

Feb 2020

1736

What about those that think it's just alright like a solid 6 or 7.

Feb 7, 2022 9:33 AM

#7

Satyam1234

Offline

Feb 2022

48

CyborgSaber said:
What about those that think it's just alright like a solid 6 or 7.

I also feel the same. He excluded us from the conversation.😢

Feb 7, 2022 9:34 AM

#8

Satyam1234

Offline

Feb 2022

48

Yumerei said:

Lucifrost said:

I too dislike the art style and the feelings One Piece instills in me.

Yes, I agree. That's what makes it a masterpiece

bro just taking everything positively. Great energy!

Feb 7, 2022 9:40 AM

#9

Phosphophyllita

Offline

Oct 2018

5807

This dog made me realize how great One Piece is

If you're a fanboy, please don't waste my time.

Watch more movies, please.

Perhaps, this is hell.

Feb 7, 2022 9:52 AM

#10

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561864

The right word is depends.

I follow both the manga and the anime. In anime it has its weak points, especially in rhythm. And of course, especially in the animation at the beginning, which is very painful.
In the manga, the pace is frenetic, Oda's artwork and traits are very detailed and pleasant to read. What makes One Piece unique is its universe, which for me is the most amazing thing in the anime world.
And of course, the strong point of One Piece, is telling a story and its narrative that is very deep. The development of characters and work is unprecedented.

Feb 7, 2022 10:15 AM

#11

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

Feb 7, 2022 10:20 AM

#12

User-Name

Offline

Dec 2007

8126

hmm, one piece is the only shounen anime with story being consistent for more than 5 arcs, while there are big and epic one while there are also small ones, the story never is in downhill. one piece is masterpiece for that fact alone.

My Anime List | My reviews (My latest review) | My Death Note review | Pokemon anime without fillers guide

Feb 7, 2022 10:41 AM

#13

inklingboi08

Offline

Jan 2020

123

M_Danyal said:
The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

When I started watching, the series had 972 episodes. When I finished, it had 995. This disproves your point completely.

If you're hungry, eat!

Feb 7, 2022 10:52 AM

#14

A_G_N

Offline

Jun 2020

882

Let me give you reasons that is not related to the events or arcs or character writing.

First of all, character acting is atrocious. Humour is childish, the emotional scenes are absolutely ridiculous with how moronic it looks - snotting and crying up a river of tears.

Second of all, cringe and corney dialogue. It's about as dramatically moronic as you can expect from a anime/manga series. Action scenes... about as cartoonish as you would expect from this characters.

Third of all, and I don't like how One piece fans have made thousand reasons to defend heir series - from an artstyle and series perspective. This exists for all anime, but disturbingly big for OP.

I don't know if it's because it's been regurgitated a thousand time over the years that people have just convinced and conditioned themselves to think that is HAS to be. Even if they might not be true

Fan reasons btw goes like "One piece is pretty bad" = "Oh yeah, the anime is bad and has paing issues, the manga tho - might just be the peak of fiction, the second coming of the bible, even better infact. Written with the blood of christ himself."

Wtf is anime/manga/Ln fans and using words like masterpiece and peak of fiction to describe their shitty childish series? I also don't get how most anime reviewers also goes about this way gor anime in general. Speedrunning losing credibility for reviews...

Fourth of all, Artstyle - I don't give a shit if it's ugly or unnatractive. Which rule of anatomy is One piece using exactly though? And which method of biology and pyshics does the series use too?

It's an unspoken rule among good writers to not touch the physics and biology of people, and the world. Unless it's narratively used with. It didn't need to be explicitly stated - because Logic and reasoning. But guess it had to be said.

It would've been still fine, if they while not following biology to a T, still had base reasonable appaearance. These wother world looking characters like big momma and shit I mean.

But One piece has straight up cartoonish looking characters, with Jojo like clothes and shit. How in the hell is an adult ever supposed to look at that and take that seriously.

There's the reasonings, if a medium has all this shit. Forget the plot and characters, there isn't a need for any other reasoning(also narrative shit would take long)

It's probably great written.... for an anime... and if you are a adult with a childlike mind.. if you think it's great written that is. Doesn't matter if you watch it for fun though, so this isn't for those people who watch shit for for dumb fun.

So don't get offended. Also don't care if it's the best selling manga, sales has absolutely no hold over criticisms. Especially when anime fans froth over this shit, it's not a surprise it is.

Feb 7, 2022 10:56 AM

#15

Catalano

Offline

Oct 2010

21963

I am a hater but I don't think it's trash, it's only that I dislike some aspects of the show a lot, it doesn't suit my taste anymore. And to be honest, it suited my taste in the beginning, East Blue saga is one of the best sagas ever created in anime.
I don't have the mood to write all that, some OP fans already know of my opinions so yeah

Feb 7, 2022 11:02 AM

#16

BerriesSan

The Attack Titan

Offline

May 2019

1940

One piece is a 10/10 cuz im a very old Mario fan and they both are in the same vain. Paper Mario and One piece feel so similar, one piece is just a lil more "serious". That playful imaginative adventure is SOOO addicting.

Feb 7, 2022 11:11 AM

#17

Nachtmonkey2737

Offline

Nov 2019

516

inklingboi08 said:

M_Danyal said:
The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

When I started watching, the series had 972 episodes. When I finished, it had 995. This disproves your point completely.

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

Feb 7, 2022 11:20 AM

#18

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

inklingboi08 said:

When I started watching, the series had 972 episodes. When I finished, it had 995. This disproves your point completely.

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

inklingboi08 said:

When I started watching, the series had 972 episodes. When I finished, it had 995. This disproves your point completely.

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

I'm talking about Humans ^^^^^^^^^^^

Feb 7, 2022 11:24 AM

#19

Kot_Schlyopa

Offline

Aug 2021

633

A_G_N said:
Let me give you reasons that is not related to the events or arcs or character writing.

First of all, character acting is atrocious. Humour is childish, the emotional scenes are absolutely ridiculous with how moronic it looks - snotting and crying up a river of tears.

Second of all, cringe and corney dialogue. It's about as dramatically moronic as you can expect from a anime/manga series. Action scenes... about as cartoonish as you would expect from this characters.

Third of all, and I don't like how One piece fans have made thousand reasons to defend heir series - from an artstyle and series perspective. This exists for all anime, but disturbingly big for OP.

I don't know if it's because it's been regurgitated a thousand time over the years that people have just convinced and conditioned themselves to think that is HAS to be. Even if they might not be true

Fan reasons btw goes like "One piece is pretty bad" = "Oh yeah, the anime is bad and has paing issues, the manga tho - might just be the peak of fiction, the second coming of the bible, even better infact. Written with the blood of christ himself."

Wtf is anime/manga/Ln fans and using words like masterpiece and peak of fiction to describe their shitty childish series? I also don't get how most anime reviewers also goes about this way gor anime in general. Speedrunning losing credibility for reviews...

Fourth of all, Artstyle - I don't give a shit if it's ugly or unnatractive. Which rule of anatomy is One piece using exactly though? And which method of biology and pyshics does the series use too?

It's an unspoken rule among good writers to not touch the physics and biology of people, and the world. Unless it's narratively used with. It didn't need to be explicitly stated - because Logic and reasoning. But guess it had to be said.

It would've been still fine, if they while not following biology to a T, still had base reasonable appaearance. These wother world looking characters like big momma and shit I mean.

But One piece has straight up cartoonish looking characters, with Jojo like clothes and shit. How in the hell is an adult ever supposed to look at that and take that seriously.

There's the reasonings, if a medium has all this shit. Forget the plot and characters, there isn't a need for any other reasoning(also narrative shit would take long)

It's probably great written.... for an anime... and if you are a adult with a childlike mind.. if you think it's great written that is. Doesn't matter if you watch it for fun though, so this isn't for those people who watch shit for for dumb fun.

So don't get offended. Also don't care if it's the best selling manga, sales has absolutely no hold over criticisms. Especially when anime fans froth over this shit, it's not a surprise it is.

I agree with most of what you said. Its fans also say that it'll get good after idk how many 100s of chapters lol. The 1st 100 chapters were pile of shit ngl.

Feb 7, 2022 11:32 AM

#20

Nachtmonkey2737

Offline

Nov 2019

516

M_Danyal said:

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

I'm talking about Humans ^^^^^^^^^^^

wdym dude,reading doesnt take that much time.I saw like 200-300 anime eps and rest all just read the manga,thats why i caught up quicker.Anime of one piece has horrible pacing and no way i was gonna watch the whole thing,but its the only show in the big 3 i would recommend

Feb 7, 2022 11:42 AM

#21

A_G_N

Offline

Jun 2020

882

Cestlavie_ said:

A_G_N said:
Let me give you reasons that is not related to the events or arcs or character writing.

First of all, character acting is atrocious. Humour is childish, the emotional scenes are absolutely ridiculous with how moronic it looks - snotting and crying up a river of tears.

Second of all, cringe and corney dialogue. It's about as dramatically moronic as you can expect from a anime/manga series. Action scenes... about as cartoonish as you would expect from this characters.

Third of all, and I don't like how One piece fans have made thousand reasons to defend heir series - from an artstyle and series perspective. This exists for all anime, but disturbingly big for OP.

I don't know if it's because it's been regurgitated a thousand time over the years that people have just convinced and conditioned themselves to think that is HAS to be. Even if they might not be true

Fan reasons btw goes like "One piece is pretty bad" = "Oh yeah, the anime is bad and has paing issues, the manga tho - might just be the peak of fiction, the second coming of the bible, even better infact. Written with the blood of christ himself."

Wtf is anime/manga/Ln fans and using words like masterpiece and peak of fiction to describe their shitty childish series? I also don't get how most anime reviewers also goes about this way gor anime in general. Speedrunning losing credibility for reviews...

Fourth of all, Artstyle - I don't give a shit if it's ugly or unnatractive. Which rule of anatomy is One piece using exactly though? And which method of biology and pyshics does the series use too?

It's an unspoken rule among good writers to not touch the physics and biology of people, and the world. Unless it's narratively used with. It didn't need to be explicitly stated - because Logic and reasoning. But guess it had to be said.

It would've been still fine, if they while not following biology to a T, still had base reasonable appaearance. These wother world looking characters like big momma and shit I mean.

But One piece has straight up cartoonish looking characters, with Jojo like clothes and shit. How in the hell is an adult ever supposed to look at that and take that seriously.

There's the reasonings, if a medium has all this shit. Forget the plot and characters, there isn't a need for any other reasoning(also narrative shit would take long)

It's probably great written.... for an anime... and if you are a adult with a childlike mind.. if you think it's great written that is. Doesn't matter if you watch it for fun though, so this isn't for those people who watch shit for for dumb fun.

So don't get offended. Also don't care if it's the best selling manga, sales has absolutely no hold over criticisms. Especially when anime fans froth over this shit, it's not a surprise it is.

Guy ngl this made me laugh😂 I can respect all ur other opinions but calling it Childish is just wrong
There's freaking Genocide, Slavery, corruption e.t.c
I don't think those themes are for people below the age of 12

Another common mistake. Anime having R rated themes doesn't mean good writing. Infact it goes against the series. Who in their right mind would give a world that has these themes, characters who look and act this ridiculous.

It would've been like berserk with One piece artstyle.

Anime casually puts in sexual and rape shit in the regular, to show a kind of misplaced sense of good writing. SAO and Re-zero have rape and gore themes too. It's still childish tho.

By childish what people mean is, it's more of how the characters act and what feel they give off that makes it childish. Not the mature rating my man.

Feb 7, 2022 12:02 PM

#22

A_G_N

Offline

Jun 2020

882

Cestlavie_ said:

A_G_N said:

Cestlavie_ said:

A_G_N said:
Let me give you reasons that is not related to the events or arcs or character writing.

First of all, character acting is atrocious. Humour is childish, the emotional scenes are absolutely ridiculous with how moronic it looks - snotting and crying up a river of tears.

Second of all, cringe and corney dialogue. It's about as dramatically moronic as you can expect from a anime/manga series. Action scenes... about as cartoonish as you would expect from this characters.

Third of all, and I don't like how One piece fans have made thousand reasons to defend heir series - from an artstyle and series perspective. This exists for all anime, but disturbingly big for OP.

I don't know if it's because it's been regurgitated a thousand time over the years that people have just convinced and conditioned themselves to think that is HAS to be. Even if they might not be true

Fan reasons btw goes like "One piece is pretty bad" = "Oh yeah, the anime is bad and has paing issues, the manga tho - might just be the peak of fiction, the second coming of the bible, even better infact. Written with the blood of christ himself."

Wtf is anime/manga/Ln fans and using words like masterpiece and peak of fiction to describe their shitty childish series? I also don't get how most anime reviewers also goes about this way gor anime in general. Speedrunning losing credibility for reviews...

Fourth of all, Artstyle - I don't give a shit if it's ugly or unnatractive. Which rule of anatomy is One piece using exactly though? And which method of biology and pyshics does the series use too?

It's an unspoken rule among good writers to not touch the physics and biology of people, and the world. Unless it's narratively used with. It didn't need to be explicitly stated - because Logic and reasoning. But guess it had to be said.

It would've been still fine, if they while not following biology to a T, still had base reasonable appaearance. These wother world looking characters like big momma and shit I mean.

But One piece has straight up cartoonish looking characters, with Jojo like clothes and shit. How in the hell is an adult ever supposed to look at that and take that seriously.

There's the reasonings, if a medium has all this shit. Forget the plot and characters, there isn't a need for any other reasoning(also narrative shit would take long)

It's probably great written.... for an anime... and if you are a adult with a childlike mind.. if you think it's great written that is. Doesn't matter if you watch it for fun though, so this isn't for those people who watch shit for for dumb fun.

So don't get offended. Also don't care if it's the best selling manga, sales has absolutely no hold over criticisms. Especially when anime fans froth over this shit, it's not a surprise it is.

Guy ngl this made me laugh😂 I can respect all ur other opinions but calling it Childish is just wrong
There's freaking Genocide, Slavery, corruption e.t.c
I don't think those themes are for people below the age of 12

Another common mistake. Anime having R rated themes doesn't mean good writing. Infact it goes against the series. Who in their right mind would give a world that has these themes, characters who look and act this ridiculous.

It would've been like berserk with One piece artstyle.

Anime casually puts in sexual and rape shit in the regular, to show a kind of misplaced sense of good writing. SAO and Re-zero have rape and gore themes too. It's still childish tho.

By childish what people mean is, it's more of how the characters act and what feel they give off that makes it childish. Not the mature rating my man.

I kind of disagree,
If u say something is childish doesn't it mean it gives an impression it was made for kids? like
U can't show SAO or Re zero to anyone below 13, regardless of how bad the writing
I can understand if it's the characters or the art style feel childish, but when it comes to plot or the overall story i don't think ur définition of Childish applies imo

Well, that's fine. It's just blood and gore and all that has become pretty common in games and series. It's become pretty desensitized and such. But since my context was given, it makes sense and that's fine.

Feb 9, 2022 4:47 AM

#23

Yuu_Kanzaki

Offline

Feb 2021

4761

I'm not a fan nor am I a hater of One Piece, but I don't like the art and Luffy's voice.

"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio-

Feb 9, 2022 4:50 AM

#24

Dinorexy007

Offline

Dec 2020

2730

For fans: Like Everything except for pacing(though I don't have problem)

For haters: Without even watching,just hate bkz of it's length

For your Information:

Feb 9, 2022 4:51 AM

#25

Gator

Offline

Apr 2013

38262

What makes it a masterpiece: the anime pre-timeskip
What makes it trash: the anime post-timeskip

Feb 9, 2022 4:56 AM

#26

spectrojan

Offline

Jun 2020

1872

M_Danyal said:
The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

It's a mistake to think everybody operates similarly to you.

This anime shit is addictive

Feb 9, 2022 4:59 AM

#27

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

spectrojan said:

M_Danyal said:
The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

It's a mistake to think everybody operates similarly to you.

Yes, normal human beings do operate like what I quoted, which seems common sense to me

Feb 9, 2022 5:01 AM

#28

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

Yuu_Kanzaki said:
I'm not a fan nor am I a hater of One Piece, but I don't like the art and Luffy's voice.

Dude stop spitting some facts here tho, they gonna get butthurt

Feb 9, 2022 5:17 AM

#29

animeforlife808

Offline

Sep 2021

156

I kinda like how lively and energetic the characters are . Their interactions are fun to watch , it funny and good .
I kinda hate the pacing and certain arcs ( skypiea ) , prolonged fights , and the plot armour is toooooooooo much

Feb 9, 2022 5:19 AM

#30

spectrojan

Offline

Jun 2020

1872

M_Danyal said:

spectrojan said:

It's a mistake to think everybody operates similarly to you.

Yes, normal human beings do operate like what I quoted, which seems common sense to me

Oh okay so if someone were to start One Piece now, provided that it has over 1000 episodes, he would be considered "not normal" then? The episode count for One Piece has long been far higher than most other anime. One Piece having 1000+ episodes is no different than when it was 900+ episodes as they're basically the same length when you're comparing it to most other anime. How many people do you think have picked up One Piece in the last 5 years? When the episode count has been 750+. Quite a few, including myself and many others ik. It's not a question of "common sense" whether a person would like to start a 1000+ episode anime or not, it's a question of preference. And yes, there are people that like the prospect of being witness and enjoying a 20 year+ epic saga/journey.

This anime shit is addictive

Feb 9, 2022 5:30 AM

#31

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

I'm a Fan

It is in NO WAY A MASTERPIECE, have you seen the pacing
If we're talking about the manga, I wouldn't know because I'm an anime-only fan, but I heard that the manga has good pacing so it might be a masterpiece

Feb 9, 2022 5:42 AM

#32

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:
The One Piece Fandom is not gonna grow anymore. The fans who are watching it from the start are the only ones who will finish the show. Not a single newbie is gonna watch this show. The 1000 episode limit cross just proved it

What about the people who considers the length of the show as a challenge, like how I did, ik for a fact that im not the only person in the whole world that thinks the length of One Piece is a challenge

Feb 9, 2022 5:43 AM

#33

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

Nachtmonkey2737 said:

hold on are we the same person?i started when it was at 972 too but caught up when it was at 990 cause i mostly read the manga

I'm talking about Humans ^^^^^^^^^^^

bruh, everyone knows that if you watch anime you have already thrown away your humanity

Feb 9, 2022 5:45 AM

#34

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:

spectrojan said:

It's a mistake to think everybody operates similarly to you.

Yes, normal human beings do operate like what I quoted, which seems common sense to me

what makes a human normal, please indulge me with your normal knowledge for I know that I am filthy for not knowing how humans should act

Feb 9, 2022 10:05 AM

#35

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

VVBROS said:

M_Danyal said:

Yes, normal human beings do operate like what I quoted, which seems common sense to me

what makes a human normal, please indulge me with your normal knowledge for I know that I am filthy for not knowing how humans should act

Broo chilll! No need to get emotional. I'm just saying like in general even if a show is a near perfect everyone would hesitate at hearing it's 1000+ episodes. Taking everything in account about 75 to 80% of the people will flush it away even if they plan to watch it. Plus there are a lot of factors like it's animation is like so childish and cartoonish and also chracters are literally like the cartoons 10yo s watch, not trolling. That takes away the interest too. So u guys enjoyed it, good for u. In simple, No one I know is gonna watch it.

Feb 9, 2022 10:19 AM

#36

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

VVBROS said:

M_Danyal said:

Yes, normal human beings do operate like what I quoted, which seems common sense to me

what makes a human normal, please indulge me with your normal knowledge for I know that I am filthy for not knowing how humans should act

In case of Naruto it is opposite. Even if Naruto series is also nearing 1000 episodes probably in a year it will reach, people are still gonna wanna watch it. Why? First of all it's immensely popular and a wide culture phenomenon. Second it's animation is on next level as compared to One piece. Third, the fight scenes are just, in simple words, Mind-blowing. Oh and characters are much cooler and loved worldwide, like their art and everything. I mean when a dude or especially a girl looks at Luffy, or Sami the first image in mind is not "cool", unlike Naruto characters. See Kakashi again for further understanding. Zorro is a bit cool I think, I saw his popular swords pose with the red eyes and sword in mouth

Feb 9, 2022 10:24 AM

#37

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

Now don't get angry you asked me a question this is the simple answer. Like u have to accept the truth, like don't force anything on others. Peace!

Feb 9, 2022 10:30 AM

#38

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

M_Danyal said:

VVBROS said:

what makes a human normal, please indulge me with your normal knowledge for I know that I am filthy for not knowing how humans should act

In case of Naruto it is opposite. Even if Naruto series is also nearing 1000 episodes probably in a year it will reach, people are still gonna wanna watch it. Why? First of all it's immensely popular and a wide culture phenomenon. Second it's animation is on next level as compared to One piece. Third, the fight scenes are just, in simple words, Mind-blowing. Oh and characters are much cooler and loved worldwide, like their art and everything. I mean when a dude or especially a girl looks at Luffy, or Sami the first image in mind is not "cool", unlike Naruto characters. See Kakashi again for further understanding. Zorro is a bit cool I think, I saw his popular swords pose with the red eyes and sword in mouth

M_Danyal said:
Now don't get angry you asked me a question this is the simple answer. Like u have to accept the truth, like don't force anything on others. Peace!

Bruuh, u did not give AoT a 7 and and a...... 5? (this guy's doing cheap drugs) sorry. And here I was thinking oh a good reasonable dude here. I see you are one of those people! SMH

D_DocFeb 9, 2022 10:35 AM

Feb 9, 2022 10:49 AM

#39

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:

In case of Naruto it is opposite. Even if Naruto series is also nearing 1000 episodes probably in a year it will reach, people are still gonna wanna watch it. Why? First of all it's immensely popular and a wide culture phenomenon. Second it's animation is on next level as compared to One piece. Third, the fight scenes are just, in simple words, Mind-blowing. Oh and characters are much cooler and loved worldwide, like their art and everything. I mean when a dude or especially a girl looks at Luffy, or Sami the first image in mind is not "cool", unlike Naruto characters. See Kakashi again for further understanding. Zorro is a bit cool I think, I saw his popular swords pose with the red eyes and sword in mouth

M_Danyal said:
Now don't get angry you asked me a question this is the simple answer. Like u have to accept the truth, like don't force anything on others. Peace!

Bruuh, u did not give AoT a 7 and and a...... 5? (this guy's doing cheap drugs) sorry. And here I was thinking oh a good reasonable dude here. I see you are one of those people! SMH

bruh I didn't even realize I gave aot as a 7 and I gave s1 a 6 tf was wrong with me

Feb 9, 2022 10:56 AM

#40

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:

VVBROS said:

what makes a human normal, please indulge me with your normal knowledge for I know that I am filthy for not knowing how humans should act

In case of Naruto it is opposite. Even if Naruto series is also nearing 1000 episodes probably in a year it will reach, people are still gonna wanna watch it. Why? First of all it's immensely popular and a wide culture phenomenon. Second it's animation is on next level as compared to One piece. Third, the fight scenes are just, in simple words, Mind-blowing. Oh and characters are much cooler and loved worldwide, like their art and everything. I mean when a dude or especially a girl looks at Luffy, or Sami the first image in mind is not "cool", unlike Naruto characters. See Kakashi again for further understanding. Zorro is a bit cool I think, I saw his popular swords pose with the red eyes and sword in mouth

bruh, One Piece is literally the highest selling manga and the second most sold comic(first is superman, I think it overtook batman last year, idk exactly when but it was pretty recent), I'm pretty sure that means it is popular. About the animation thing, I don't really give a shit about animation while watching anime so I can't say anything about that, everything else I agree with you

Feb 9, 2022 1:05 PM

#41

hazecloud

Offline

Jan 2018

33322

new objective: do not give microphone to big mom. on topic, I just hope the filler is not on par with the entirety of boruto. so much writing can be done the one piece world is ripe for the taking.

I don't like it when author made the time skip but it's handled better than the existence of boruto.

Feb 9, 2022 6:39 PM

#42

MrSpenfo

Offline

Aug 2018

440

There are countless things I like about One Piece; the unique art style, the characters, the comedy, the fights, the list goes on, however none of those makes One Piece a masterpiece by themselves. What makes One Piece a masterpiece is how it differs from 90% of stories. Most stories are about how the world of the story shapes and molds the main character into a new person, but One Piece is not about that. One Piece is about how the main character changes and reshapes the world of the story. This is why the crew getting new wanted posters is always exciting; it gives an opportunity for Oda to touch base back to the places that the crew has visited on their journey, to give the people from those previous islands a chance to not only react to news about the Straw Hats, but also gives the opportunity to show how the island has changed since the crews departure.

Poyo.

Feb 9, 2022 6:47 PM

#43

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561864

I don't hate it. I just want people to stop telling me I should watch it.

Feb 9, 2022 6:54 PM

#44

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

561864

MAN, I really hate those people who require themselves to create a new account just for asking a single question

Feb 9, 2022 6:59 PM

#45

Rndmguypassingby

Offline

Sep 2020

1560

The world building, the antagonists, adventure, the side characters, peaks

Feb 10, 2022 4:27 AM

#46

VVBROS

Offline

Dec 2020

293

M_Danyal said:

In case of Naruto it is opposite. Even if Naruto series is also nearing 1000 episodes probably in a year it will reach, people are still gonna wanna watch it. Why? First of all it's immensely popular and a wide culture phenomenon. Second it's animation is on next level as compared to One piece. Third, the fight scenes are just, in simple words, Mind-blowing. Oh and characters are much cooler and loved worldwide, like their art and everything. I mean when a dude or especially a girl looks at Luffy, or Sami the first image in mind is not "cool", unlike Naruto characters. See Kakashi again for further understanding. Zorro is a bit cool I think, I saw his popular swords pose with the red eyes and sword in mouth

M_Danyal said:
Now don't get angry you asked me a question this is the simple answer. Like u have to accept the truth, like don't force anything on others. Peace!

Bruuh, u did not give AoT a 7 and and a...... 5? (this guy's doing cheap drugs) sorry. And here I was thinking oh a good reasonable dude here. I see you are one of those people! SMH

Also what do you mean by those type of people, just asking

Feb 10, 2022 8:46 AM

#47

Crack

Offline

Feb 2021

2347

luffy's face carries the whole story for me

Feb 10, 2022 8:47 AM

#48

Zelkiiro

Offline

May 2016

3547

One Piece is neither.

It is a good and fun adventure story following a lovable cast of characters that has been stretched to the absolute breaking point with filler and padding and every technique there is in the book to make a 100-episode story into a 1000+ episode story.

This glorious signature image was created by @Mayumi!

I am the Arbiter of Absolute Truth, and here is my wisdom:
"Anime was always influenced by the West. This is not news.
Shoujo is the superior genre primarily aimed at young people.
Harem/isekai are lazy genres that refuse any meaningful innovation.
There is no 'Golden Age.' There will always be top-shelf anime.
You should be watching Carole & Tuesday."

Feb 11, 2022 6:41 AM

#49

D_Doc

Offline

Nov 2020

302

VVBROS said:

M_Danyal said:

Bruuh, u did not give AoT a 7 and and a...... 5? (this guy's doing cheap drugs) sorry. And here I was thinking oh a good reasonable dude here. I see you are one of those people! SMH

Also what do you mean by those type of people, just asking

U know which peope I am talking about!

Feb 11, 2022 6:44 AM

#50

Baka3301

Offline

Jan 2021

934

one piece is gonna be a masterpiece until zoro stops getting lost

"Many people die with their music still in them. Too often it is because
they are always getting ready to live. Before they know it, time runs out."

Poll: » One Piece Episode 1074 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) AhriTheS3xyFox - Sep 2, 2023	209	by svtsalty »» 5 hours ago
Poll: » One Piece Episode 1145 Discussion ( 1 2 ) IzanaSolos - Sep 28	79	by PrOxAnto »» 6 hours ago
Poll: » One Piece Episode 1144 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) IzanaSolos - Sep 21	127	by PrOxAnto »» 6 hours ago
Poll: » One Piece Episode 719 Discussion ( 1 2 ) FeelSide - Nov 21, 2015	86	by gannoncannon55 »» 11 hours ago
Poll: » One Piece Episode 718 Discussion ( 1 2 ) G_Spark233 - Nov 14, 2015	73	by gannoncannon55 »» 12 hours ago

For fans: What makes one piece a masterpiece? For haters: What makes one piece trash?

More topics from this board

Poll: » One Piece Episode 1074 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » One Piece Episode 1145 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » One Piece Episode 1144 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » One Piece Episode 719 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » One Piece Episode 718 Discussion ( 1 2 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters