Best saga?
| What do you think is the best saga/arc |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| i know either Marineford or Ennies Lobby is going to win this,but I feel Sabaody Arc is the best arc of the series.It was short unlike other One Piece arcs and still Oda managed to give so much info. The Tenryubitos+11 Supernovas+Gol D Roger's Past+Will of D etc Not to mention,the seperation of the strawhats was a perfect icing on a well made cake |
| CP9 All the way. The Hype was real. GEAR 2ND! |
shaaaaan said: i know either Marineford or Ennies Lobby is going to win this,but I feel Sabaody Arc is the best arc of the series.It was short unlike other One Piece arcs and still Oda managed to give so much info. The Tenryubitos+11 Supernovas+Gol D Roger's Past+Will of D etc Not to mention,the seperation of the strawhats was a perfect icing on a well made cake Im the OP and I voted Sabaody bro |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Didn't we already have 100 topics like this one? |
short_review said: Didn't we already have 100 topics like this one? Yeah yeah who the fuck cares its one piece |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Punk434says said: Saboady is part of the 'War of the Best Saga' Anyways, the best arc is EL; the best saga is 'War of the Best'. Look bro, Shabondy is it's own thing. I don't care about the official saga listing. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Punk434says said: Badass1182 said: Lol, no it's not. It's the first arc of the saga as it introduces the war. Look bro, Shabondy is it's own thing. I don't care about the official saga listing. BTW, I don't even think there are officials sagas -- just arcs -- I just stated something that's apparent in the OP fandom. There are. I just don't care about them, or any official listings for one piece. Marine ford is about Ace, there is no fucking ace or anything about ace in Shabondy |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Skypiea arc! :D The story doesn't go back to that part so much but I think Oda is gonna surprise us in the future. Don't forget where Enel is now. ;-) Something tells me we're gonna see him again. |
Fullmetal-Ghoul said: What do you think is the best saga/arc If we're going by the way the wikia describes arcs and sagas as different things.. My favorite arc is Mock Town(Jaya), that's the one directly before Skypeia from Blackbeards statements, to the setting up of the best flashback in OP(norland), to the bar scene and to the scene where he only interfered when Bellamy wasn't directly hurting his friends(well..except zoro).. From Blackbeard and his argument at the bar(which is better moreso because of irony tho), to Blackbeard's "DREAMS NEVER DIE" statement, I feel like it embodies the themes of one piece and the greatest of it, too. As for sagas in general, the War saga was by far the largest in scale in OP history so far. So that I suppose, even if it doesn't have drum island or jaya. |
| ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ |
| To me it's Sabaody > Marineford > Fishman Island > Skypeia > Dressrosa > Alabasta > Thriller Bark > CP9 > East Blue > Punk Hazard I know everyone loved CP9, I feel like I'm the only one who wasn't very fond of it, heh. |
 (THIS WAY FOREVER) |
ak47 said: To me it's Sabaody > Marineford > Fishman Island > Skypeia > Dressrosa > Alabasta > Thriller Bark > CP9 > East Blue > Punk Hazard I know everyone loved CP9, I feel like I'm the only one who wasn't very fond of it, heh. For me it would be like Sabaody > Marineford > East Blue > CP9 > Alabasta > Skypeia > Dressrosa > Thriller Bark/Punk Hazard/Fishmen Island. |
| marineford ofc :) |
| For me it was mainly Marineford > CP9 > Sabaody Dressrosa comes after Sabaody, but if post-Dressrosa is a standalone arc, it could be somewhere between CP9 and Sabaody. |
Fullmetal-Ghoul said: Punk434says said: Lol, no it's not. It's the first arc of the saga as it introduces the war. BTW, I don't even think there are officials sagas -- just arcs -- I just stated something that's apparent in the OP fandom. There are. I just don't care about them, or any official listings for one piece. Marine ford is about Ace, there is no fucking ace or anything about ace in Shabondy   This is not the only time it's mentioned on Shabondy. There were lots of random people muttering about it. Shabondy was the start of the War of the Best saga whether you like it or not. It's like how Reverse Mountain is part of Alabasta's Saga. It may not seem relevant at first glance but an intro arc- which Shabondy was- is just as part of a saga as any other portion. This is a fail thread if you ask me. If you want to make a poll using arcs, then I find it unfair of you to exclude arcs that were really awesome, like Impel Down! If you want to say that Impel Down was part of Marineford, then you'd be wrong. Impel Down is part of the same SAGA as Marineford, yes, they are connected, but arcs and sagas are not the same thing. Shabondy is an arc. Impel Down is an arc. Marineford is an arc. All three of these arcs are part of the War of the Best/Marineford Saga. My favorite SAGA is the War of the Best because of three important arcs: Shabondy, Impel Down, and Post-Marineford. I actually wasn't a fan of Marineford, even though it was pretty awesome. Fact is, your poll makes no sense, so I'm not voting. Next time have your facts straight instead of sprouting stuff like: " There are. I just don't care about them, or any official listings for one piece. Marine ford is about Ace, there is no fucking ace or anything about ace in Shabondy" I don't care whether you abide by the official listings or not. I don't care whether you like 'em or not. But get your facts straight. Shabondy did include Ace. The entire world found out about the War during that arc. This is when shit starts to get real. Not only that, but the entire War of the Best Saga was thematically about how Luffy is weak and needs to get stronger. Just as how the entire East Blue Saga thematically is about friendship, gathering the crew, and proving one's strength and dreams. Shabondy was the start of that thematic meltdown. Luffy's character development (Yes, he has developed!) starts in Shabondy when he loses his friends and ends with his being reminded that he still has them after losing Ace later in Post-Marineford. I completely disagree with your statements. Completely. To shallow it down to the arc having Ace or not is bullshit. Why not include Alabasta and Enies Lobby as part of Marineford then? Technically they both were DIRECTLY related to the war. Ace was looking for Blackbeard and in episode 325, which was part of the Enies Lobby arc, had their battle. Also in Enies Lobby Shanks told Whitbeard to call Ace off Blackbeard. So, these had Ace and were instrumental to the War of the Best, so why not include them? Why? There are reasons. Reasons that exclude the fact that Ace was involved. The War of the Best SAGA has been determined by several things. It actually has LITTLE to do with Ace. Yes, saving Ace was the goal of the saga, and his execution was the major conflict, but that in no way relates the arcs that are part of the saga. The Saga is decided by mostly Luffy's evolution. Like I already said, the entire saga was mostly about Luffy discovering how weak he is and how little a fish he is in the wide sea. He's not all powerful. He's got a lot to lose and he won't be able to save everyone. The entire Saga had him LOSING. Every main villain he faced, he lost against. Kizaru, Santomaryu, Kuma, the Pacifistas, Magellan, and then Mihawk/the Admirals. It was all about him losing. The main character isn't Ace. It's Luffy. And the Sagas aren't only determined by what I already mentioned. It's also about how plot wise the arcs are connected. Shabondy may have had a separate overall plot- saving Camie- but that's usually how intro arcs are in One Piece. Intro arcs are generally related to the other arcs in a different way: with HUGE shadowing. For instance, Reverse Mountain/Laboon had nothing to do with facing Crocodile. The goal was to protect Laboon. That being said, the shadows in this intro arc are the two characters that were introduced and their relevance to the subsequent arcs. For Skypiea, Jaya had little to do with Skypiea in terms of goals and conflicts. Jaya's conflict was about saving the Ossan's (Norland's) treasure. Yes they wanted to find Skypiea, but that had little to do with the eventual showdown. Whether this all makes sense to you or not, I don't really care. It's too hot here and I've just lost the last of my "I want to discuss" desire. Adios. |
| My top 5 are in ranking order. 1. Summit War 2. CP9 3. Pirate Alliance 4. Alabasta 5. Skypiea |
| Without Sabody, Impel Down(..or the Empress arc for that matter) wouldn't have happened(which directly effects the events of the war arc), Kuma is the connecting factor. Kuma, from Sabody, sends Luffy to Amazon Lily..Boa helps Luffy get to Impel Down...Impel Down leads to the War. See? All connected. Okay, if we want to ORDER it and all..I can go all out, based on the wikia's definition of arcs. 1. Jaya - 2. Drum Island 3. Water 7/CP9/Enies Lobby 4. Alabasta 5. Skypeia If you want to count skypeia and jaya as the same arc, replace 5 with Impel Down. Best saga(according to Wikia) might be Summit War, or Sky Island, even if it only had two arcs. |
ashfrliebertAug 7, 2015 1:33 PM
| ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴロゴロゴロ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ ゴゴゴゴゴゴ |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1164 DiscussionFMmatron - Oct 28 |
6 |
by _l0gic
»»
1 hour ago |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1163 DiscussionFMmatron - Oct 20 |
47 |
by PrinceLied
»»
Yesterday, 10:16 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 910 DiscussionSuperRed - Aug 8, 2018 |
7 |
by Ashhk
»»
Oct 28, 4:36 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 620 DiscussionShiroiRyu - Apr 6, 2011 |
46 |
by Dumb
»»
Oct 27, 9:27 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 618 DiscussionsMug - Mar 16, 2011 |
49 |
by Dumb
»»
Oct 27, 9:17 PM |