| Reactions about the 2 OVAs of CLANNAD.. |
 |
| Tomoyo's OVA was fantastic, but Kyou was one of my favorite characters. As of now, I guess i'll go with Tomoyo. But, Kyou's story is a fine example of how to do a love triangle RIGHT. I wish both had more than one episode, though. Especially Kyou's. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
| its great. i mean, kyou... well, im not really that surprised though cause i completed the visual novel already. in tomoyo's route, that's why i really made some waterworks, haha... even though i know what's going to happen already, its great. |
| I enjoyed both OVAs a lot. I love Kyou but story-wise, the Tomoyo story was better. However, the way they animated Kyou's episode with the juxtapositions used all the time was great as well. I can't really say which one I liked more. The whole Clannad franchise is just beautiful, to quote what aero said. |
 staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| I liked Tomoyo's better than Kyou's...I liked the story a lot better. ^^ |
 Ciel-Kun! Daisuki! <3 |
| Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T |
 |
zhaka said: Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T Yeah, but she did that in the Visual Novel too. I never did quite get why she did, though. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
usasoldiern said: zhaka said: Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T Yeah, but she did that in the Visual Novel too. I never did quite get why she did, though. Same here...right Tomoya said that he liked long hair???Then why did she?! For the record....She ownz with long hair |
 Happy Birthday Shiori!!! I'm bored. If you are too, click the link.. |
mrlolz said: usasoldiern said: zhaka said: Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T Yeah, but she did that in the Visual Novel too. I never did quite get why she did, though. Same here...right Tomoya said that he liked long hair???Then why did she?! For the record....She ownz with long hair Yeah "Why She Cut her long Hair" Is Still Mystery for me... |
|
| i like the kyou chapter more because i like kyou but its a pity that she cut her hair |
     |
| She cut her hair because she wanted the love from Tomoya that she couldn't get because he was dating her sister, Ryou. So she cut her hair so she can look like Ryou and pretend to be her to go on a date with Tomoya. As for the two OVAs, Tomoyo's was a lot more touching and Kyou's had a pretty slow beginning which is why it felt like it was too short. Tomoyo's OVA was fit perfectly in the 24mins time frame. Work vs Love triangle.. Life sure is harsh. |
    |
| Kyou is by far my favorite character / arc, so it's hard to judge without my own bias... Kyou's arc had a LOT to fit in, and I thought they did a great job of boiling it down to one episode. Tomoyo's arc was very well done, and went at a smoother, slower pace than Kyou's. Still, I'll have to go with Kyou's. mrlolz said: usasoldiern said: zhaka said: Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T Yeah, but she did that in the Visual Novel too. I never did quite get why she did, though. Same here...right Tomoya said that he liked long hair???Then why did she?! Guys thats the whole point... she cut her hair because she wanted Tomoya to stay with Ryou, even though she really liked him too. Everything she was doing was contrary to how she really felt, and she thought that she really wanted to help Ryou... but it was just hurting her. |
theeggman85Jul 23, 2009 4:53 PM
     |
| I really love this OVA's, the both are so cute <33. The Tomoyo's OVA is better :3 |
Kurogashi said: She cut her hair because she wanted the love from Tomoya that she couldn't get because he was dating her sister, Ryou. So she cut her hair so she can look like Ryou and pretend to be her to go on a date with Tomoya. As for the two OVAs, Tomoyo's was a lot more touching and Kyou's had a pretty slow beginning which is why it felt like it was too short. Tomoyo's OVA was fit perfectly in the 24mins time frame. Work vs Love triangle.. Life sure is harsh. Good point.... |
Happy Birthday Shiori!!! I'm bored. If you are too, click the link.. |
theeggman85 said: Kyou is by far my favorite character / arc, so it's hard to judge without my own bias... Kyou's arc had a LOT to fit in, and I thought they did a great job of boiling it down to one episode. Tomoyo's arc was very well done, and went at a smoother, slower pace than Kyou's. Still, I'll have to go with Kyou's. mrlolz said: usasoldiern said: zhaka said: Tomoyo Is much better i think for the story and the ending i don't like Ending for kyou because she cut her long hair T-T Yeah, but she did that in the Visual Novel too. I never did quite get why she did, though. Same here...right Tomoya said that he liked long hair???Then why did she?! Guys thats the whole point... she cut her hair because she wanted Tomoya to stay with Ryou, even though she really liked him too. Everything she was doing was contrary to how she really felt, and she thought that she really wanted to help Ryou... but it was just hurting her. It was impossible for her feelings to stay in there any longer, right?? |
Happy Birthday Shiori!!! I'm bored. If you are too, click the link.. |
| I really love kyou even more than Tomoyo But , I prefer tomoyo's OVA because it was more touching And the ending was better than kyou's |
 |
| I would say Kyou chapter without any doubts, but as many said, that it would have been better if it have been made into a movie, or a longer OVA. |
!Damn, im HOT today! :D! |
Kurogashi said: She cut her hair because she wanted the love from Tomoya that she couldn't get because he was dating her sister, Ryou. So she cut her hair so she can look like Ryou and pretend to be her to go on a date with Tomoya. Work vs Love triangle.. Life sure is harsh. See, that goes against Kyou's selfless attitude so I doubt that was why she did it. Plus, she acts nothing like her sister. So, I think what eggman said makes more sense for her character. Oh, and by the way: I watched Kyou's ova again. I actually enjoyed it more the second time, so maybe i'll end up liking it more in the long run. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
| Tomoyo chapter was by far superior. Not just as stand-alone, but also as the OVA or 24th episode that completed the masterpiece that was Clannad. The Kyou chapter was more like a special, an extra. |
| Tomoyo's seemed better but I liked Kyou's more. |
 |
aswani said: Tomoyo chapter was by far superior. Not just as stand-alone, but also as the OVA or 24th episode that completed the masterpiece that was Clannad. The Kyou chapter was more like a special, an extra. Yeah, I felt like Tomoyo's was more "epic"....in a way.... |
Happy Birthday Shiori!!! I'm bored. If you are too, click the link.. |
| Tomoyo Ova was better, Kyou irritated me a lot in her OVA. Kyou OVA was good but nothing compared to Tomoyo OVA, I like Kyou OVA a little because I discovered more about Ryou and her personality, and she really rocks. |
 |
| stepping aside my Tomoyo fan side XD... i still think the Tomoyo OVA was better... the Kyou OVA made me like Ryou more =) |
  |
| I didn't like the Kyou-Ryou switch... :( |
| Click on this. I dare you. | MAL Fantasy Football League | Currently Watching List RWBY Club. RWBY is anime. Deal with it. |
| Tomoyo desu~ ^_^ |
 -- I'm looking for "The One" and I'll find her more quickly if I audition two at a time. Think you can do better? -- -- The World God Only Knows -- Toaru Majutsu no Index -- Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai -- |
| Personally, as characters -- I prefer Kyou over Tomoyo. Kyou simply appears to be more... lively. However, as far as the OVA's... the Tomoyo OVA appears to be better executed. Better story flow and makes a bit more sense. |
| Click on this. I dare you. | MAL Fantasy Football League | Currently Watching List RWBY Club. RWBY is anime. Deal with it. |
| Tomoyo's has more drama than Kyou's, but I prefer them both |
 When the rosario on her chest is taken off, Moka's vampire inner self awakes.  |
| I haven't watched Kyou's OVA yet, but imo the Tomoyo one is clearly made in response to the clamoring visual novel players. I would imagine people watching the OVA without playing through the game to be missing out on a LOT, seeing as how it's an entire route condensed into 1 episode and labeled as AU due to the Tomoyo x Tomoya setting.. |
| I don't really remember Tomoyo's Arc as that I watched it several months ago but I did give it a "10". I just watched Kyou's Arc and gave it a "10" too. Honestly, I don't know which one is better for the obvious reason and I don't plan on re-watching Tomoyo's Arc either. Watching the anime makes it somewhat pointless to play the visual novel as that you will get the "Endless Eight" deja vu feeling. |
 |
| Don't know since I didn't like either =/ |
| I like Kyou's Arc more since it's more typical, not plain as Tomoyo's Arc. Oh also it's because I like Kyou more =) |
Kira01 said: Watching the anime makes it somewhat pointless to play the visual novel as that you will get the "Endless Eight" deja vu feeling. There's a LOT to the visual novel than anime, both in Clannad and in general. Just because KyoAni follows Key's work closely doesn't mean they didn't cut out parts. Obviously, 48 episodes isn't nearly enough to cover 100+ hours of gameplay (50 if you are really, really fast) |
| For the story Tomoyo's is much better, but her "expressionless-beautiful-face" makes me unattracted.. I liked Kyou's expression more, but the story is too short or maybe too "Accelerated" |
 |
| I adore Kyou and find her as the best couple with Tomoya, but Tomoyo's arc was way better by a long shot in my eyes. Kyou's story is better, but it was too short as a lot of people say. I like Tomoyo's arc because it touched me more then Kyou's. |
| IG: @ChrisCrossCrash "There isn't a single guy who doesn't want to spoil his girl." --Amagami SS |
`the truth is >_< i can't choose >_< hm.. i like them both :D but i more like kotomi & fuko em right? :DD |
| invisible signature \m/ |
| maybe Kyou =) but the story is too fast, i think it's better if Key make it into 2/3 chapter instead of forced it into 1 chapter visual novel's way to tell Kyou's arc is better than the OVA |
| i liked kyou's chapter better, it also seemed more liekly because in episode 23 it hints at the fact that she probably liked him when she saw him sleeping. Tomoya's chapter seemed slower and not as exciting. |
 |
| Both of them are good, but i think that there need more episodes for every girl (not enough information in one episode) i've played game so i'm ok but others may have some problems with understanding situation |
 Some userbars: My Badges: |
| Tomoyo chapter was better IMO... Kyou's chapter felt rushed plus I have a thing against tsunderes xD plus I hated that they kissed plus... poor Ryou u.u |
setsuna91 said: maybe Kyou =) but the story is too fast, i think it's better if Key make it into 2/3 chapter instead of forced it into 1 chapter visual novel's way to tell Kyou's arc is better than the OVA Maybe Key was showing only the ending because if they make it a 2 or more episodes.. the real plot of CLANNAD will be confusing and other fans can't choose from the gals of CLANNAD.. |
|
| I'm a Nagisa fan so I guess I really don't mind >_<... But I think Kyou's deserved more time (and they should probably make special 2) and Tomoyo's was a little too emotional. Anyway... they're both great, but I think I like Kyou's better. |
Emzice08 said: Maybe Key was showing only the ending because if they make it a 2 or more episodes.. the real plot of CLANNAD will be confusing and other fans can't choose from the gals of CLANNAD.. hmmm... that's sound make sense, yeah it just an appendix i think so it's okay but i like kyou's arc in visual novel ^^ just one word, "cool~" |
setsuna91 said: Emzice08 said: Maybe Key was showing only the ending because if they make it a 2 or more episodes.. the real plot of CLANNAD will be confusing and other fans can't choose from the gals of CLANNAD.. hmmm... that's sound make sense, yeah it just an appendix i think so it's okay but i like kyou's arc in visual novel ^^ just one word, "cool~" Me either i like kyou's path in visual novel..but my favorite path is except for nagisa..the kotomi's arc..because tomoya and kotomi are childhood friends.. |
|
| I liked both.Both were so sad and touching.But if i were 2 choose,i'll pick Tomoyo's. |
Emzice08 said: Me either i like kyou's path in visual novel..but my favorite path is except for nagisa..the kotomi's arc..because tomoya and kotomi are childhood friends.. hm~ IMO the best 3 except Nagisa is Kyou > Fuko > Tomoyo =) |
More topics from this board
» Huge directory of Clannad wallpapersMalus92 - Sep 24, 2012 |
3 |
by KingOfPneumos
»»
Feb 12, 2024 8:38 AM |
|
» How many males except me has Clannad as nr1 anime? ( 1 2 )martver - Sep 2, 2012 |
64 |
by desu_ruka
»»
Feb 12, 2023 10:16 PM |
|
» when it was releasedKradaxe - Dec 25, 2021 |
4 |
by Kradaxe
»»
Feb 13, 2022 8:17 PM |
|
» Clannad vs Kanon vs Air TVTutti_Love - Dec 22, 2007 |
17 |
by Endless_end
»»
Dec 29, 2021 2:09 PM |
|
Poll: » Favourite anime arc in Clannad ( 1 2 3 )game8910 - Mar 22, 2008 |
113 |
by Endless_end
»»
Dec 29, 2021 2:08 PM |