Which path to take?
| So I'm considering what to do here. I have watched fate Zero and thought it was solid. But I was wondering what to do now since their is a visual novel, a previous FSN, and now a FSN 2014. : What are your thoughts? Thanks. EDIT: I know I have time to play the VN (well unless the game is ridiculously long) before the anime starts since the anime won't start until the Fall 14' season. |
 |
| As long as you don't watch DEEN's anime, you're good. |
 |
| http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1199615 http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1201499 DEEN's adaptations are mediocre at best and crap at worst. Other than that, the VN is 30-60, maybe 70 hours long, depending on how fast you read. If you are interested in the VN, just go for it. |
| Play the VN(or if you're able to, play the original VN then the Realta Nua port and play all 3 routes - Fate, Unlimited Blade Works, Heaven's Feel then try to get all the Ends bad or good.) After the VN, ignore the mediocre adaptation decay atrocity that is Fate/Stay Night DEEN 2006.... It's your choice if you want to watch the UBW movie or not. Wait for F/SN x Ufotable 2014 due October. (If you're able to, play Fate/Extra or watch Carnival Phantasm to pass time lol) |
 |
| In exactly this order: 1) Play the Visual Novel. AVOID the shitty previous FSN adaptation. AVOID the shitty UBW movie that abridges the hell out of it. here's a decent spoiler-free summary on why watching previous adaptations is NOT a good idea 2)Watch Fate/Zero OR Read Fate/ Zero 3)Wait for FSN remake |
 |
| You can do anything you want as long as you read the VN. |
| And I mean that in the most sexually painful way possible. |
StormNA said: Play the VN, watch FSN 2014 only. I don't think the new anime will ever be a replacement for the VN since it will presumably only animate one route's worth of content (and it seems possible that it might be an original route at that). But I'm sure it will be an amazing experience that shouldn't be missed out on. You also need to watch Fate/Zero. Again. We have no information what the FSN remake covers, nor how long it is in terms of ep count. STop. |
|
| No dude. Ignore the plebs above. They are trying to troll you. What you want to do is Watch Carnival Phantasm first to get into Fate Then you want to watch the UBW movie then the DEEN anime You can skip Fate/Zero if you want because that anime was fucking garbage There's no point in reading the VN because the DEEN anime covers everything and gives sufficient information Afterwards you watch Carnival Phantasm again. The 2014 anime is gonna be shit too because it's made by Ufotrash |
| As a child, I was told that society is a melting pot of talents; knowledge and experience combined to form important alloys that will contribute to mankind. When I got to highschool, however, I thought that it's more like a river in which the water represents our peers while we ourselves are the stones in the river. Constant erosion by mindless majority sheeping has made us lose our unique edge. After I hit the age of 18, I realized that I've been wrong all along. Society is no melting pot. Society is no river. Society is a person, a very skilled rapist, and he has fucked us all. |
BloodRequiem said: Watch Carnival Phantasm first to get into Fate You do realize though that even if Carnival Phantasm had mostly Fate/content that he'd have to have knowledge on Tsukihime or Melty Blood or even watch the anime that doesn't exist right? or you weren't being serious and I just wasted my effort in this serious reply lol XD |
|
| Step 1: Download Fate/Zero Step 2: Masterbate to Urobuchi's terrible writing (at least his last few years worth of work) Step 3: Go to Mal Forums and call people stupid for watching anime that isn't depressing. |
damastah said: You wasted your effort.BloodRequiem said: Watch Carnival Phantasm first to get into Fate You do realize though that even if Carnival Phantasm had mostly Fate/content that he'd have to have knowledge on Tsukihime or Melty Blood or even watch the anime that doesn't exist right? or you weren't being serious and I just wasted my effort in this serious reply lol XD SolviteSekai said: Step 1:be a trollStep 1: Download Fate/Zero Step 2: Masterbate to Urobuchi's terrible writing (at least his last few years worth of work) Step 3: Go to Mal Forums and call people stupid for watching anime that isn't depressing. step 2:fail step 3:act as if you are successful |
ssjokg said: damastah said: You wasted your effort.You do realize though that even if Carnival Phantasm had mostly Fate/content that he'd have to have knowledge on Tsukihime or Melty Blood or even watch the anime that doesn't exist right? or you weren't being serious and I just wasted my effort in this serious reply lol XD Dangit. |
|
Fai said: ^In exactly this order: 1) Play the Visual Novel. AVOID the shitty previous FSN adaptation. AVOID the shitty UBW movie that abridges the hell out of it. here's a decent spoiler-free summary on why watching previous adaptations is NOT a good idea 2)Watch Fate/Zero OR Read Fate/ Zero 3)Wait for FSN remake pretty straightforward |
  |
| Why is there no "Watch DEEN's FSN and ignore the VN and the remake" option? Anyway, pretty much this: Fai said: In exactly this order: 1) Play the Visual Novel. AVOID the shitty previous FSN adaptation. AVOID the shitty UBW movie that abridges the hell out of it. here's a decent spoiler-free summary on why watching previous adaptations is NOT a good idea 2)Watch Fate/Zero OR Read Fate/ Zero 3)Wait for FSN remake |
 |
-Riptide- said: There's no need for stupid troll vote filters.Why is there no "Watch DEEN's FSN and ignore the VN and the remake" option? |
|
| I watched Fate/Zero when it was airing.. it was okay (gave both series a 7). I think I'm going to play Fate/Stay Night, play the sequel (Hollow/Atarxia?) , and then after all that is done I'll watch the anime (I'll more than likely be done with the VN's by the time it FSN 2014 starts airing). I'm not even going to bother with all the spin-off material (video games, light novels, manga, spinoff anime), just way too much content and don't feel like slogging through all of that (had a simular sort of situation when I was trying to figure out what Muv-Luv content to get into, eventually decided to just play through the original trillogy and ignore all spin off stuff). After I'm done with Atarxia I'm planing on playing G-senjou no Maou.. |
| |
midnightblade said: So you will never play G-senjou no Maou.After I'm done with Atarxia I'm planing on playing G-senjou no Maou.. |
| Sequel might not be the right word. hollow ataraxia is a sort-of fandisc. The main story is rather short. About the patch: While a few weeks ago a patch was "leaked", I'd say 20-40% of the text were still garbage and not really translated. Yes, an 88% patch was released yesterday by the new team, but even the validated parts are getting revalidated because the new team has to check whether the old team messed up something. I don't think it will take that much longer. Perhaps when the new FSN anime airs. |
C-Core said: Sequel might not be the right word. hollow ataraxia is a sort-of fandisc. The main story is rather short. About the patch: While a few weeks ago a patch was "leaked", I'd say 20-40% of the text were still garbage and not really translated. Yes, an 88% patch was released yesterday by the new team, but even the validated parts are getting revalidated because the new team has to check whether the old team messed up something. I don't think it will take that much longer. Perhaps when the new FSN anime airs. At worst it will take up till PS-Vita Ataraxia re-release. THat should rile up interest in translating it far more. |
|
Fai said: C-Core said: Sequel might not be the right word. hollow ataraxia is a sort-of fandisc. The main story is rather short. About the patch: While a few weeks ago a patch was "leaked", I'd say 20-40% of the text were still garbage and not really translated. Yes, an 88% patch was released yesterday by the new team, but even the validated parts are getting revalidated because the new team has to check whether the old team messed up something. I don't think it will take that much longer. Perhaps when the new FSN anime airs. At worst it will take up till PS-Vita Ataraxia re-release. THat should rile up interest in translating it far more. Things would be easier if someone could actually crack open the Vita, so they can extract the voices. Otherwise, they must record every line manually and that's a ton of work. Should take a while. |
C-Core said: Fai said: At worst it will take up till PS-Vita Ataraxia re-release. THat should rile up interest in translating it far more. Things would be easier if someone could actually crack open the Vita, so they can extract the voices. Otherwise, they must record every line manually and that's a ton of work. Should take a while. The problem with translating Vita games is because of its damned Kernel... Had it been a PSP though... |
|
| I find it weird that nobody managed to crack it yet.It's been more than 2 years since its release. |
ssjokg said: I find it weird that nobody managed to crack it yet.It's been more than 2 years since its release. Well, even FSN RN Vita is only translated partially (Fate and a partially-translated UBW. HF is 0% progress atm.) so yeah... Something about Sony placing coding restrictions on Vita games via the Vita card... |
|
damastah said: I dont know much about those things but I dont understand what Sony did with Vita that other companies cant do with games and consoles.ssjokg said: I find it weird that nobody managed to crack it yet.It's been more than 2 years since its release. Well, even FSN RN Vita is only translated partially (Fate and a partially-translated UBW. HF is 0% progress atm.) so yeah... Something about Sony placing coding restrictions on Vita games via the Vita card... |
ssjokg said: damastah said: I dont know much about those things but I dont understand what Sony did with Vita that other companies cant do with games and consoles.Well, even FSN RN Vita is only translated partially (Fate and a partially-translated UBW. HF is 0% progress atm.) so yeah... Something about Sony placing coding restrictions on Vita games via the Vita card... Maybe they didn't want the issue of the ease of people to hack into a PSP's system, to remain in the Vita? There are rumors that too much tinkering with the Vita to enable "homebrew" may cause an RSOD(red screen of death) similar to the PS3. On-topic: I still say play the VN, skip DEEN atrocity, and wait for UfotablexFSN 2014. |
|
damastah said: I think that this should go without saying :pOn-topic: I still say play the VN, skip DEEN atrocity, and wait for UfotablexFSN 2014. |
|
Botato said: 8 people voted to watch it.damastah said: I think that this should go without saying :pOn-topic: I still say play the VN, skip DEEN atrocity, and wait for UfotablexFSN 2014. |
ssjokg said: They want to troll OP into watching a mediocre adaptation.Botato said: 8 people voted to watch it.I think that this should go without saying :p |
|
Botato said: ssjokg said: They want to troll OP into watching a mediocre adaptation.8 people voted to watch it. Dafuq you talking about man? The DEEN adaptation had some of the best scenes ever. |
| As a child, I was told that society is a melting pot of talents; knowledge and experience combined to form important alloys that will contribute to mankind. When I got to highschool, however, I thought that it's more like a river in which the water represents our peers while we ourselves are the stones in the river. Constant erosion by mindless majority sheeping has made us lose our unique edge. After I hit the age of 18, I realized that I've been wrong all along. Society is no melting pot. Society is no river. Society is a person, a very skilled rapist, and he has fucked us all. |
BloodRequiem said: Botato said: They want to troll OP into watching a mediocre adaptation. Dafuq you talking about man? The DEEN adaptation had some of the best scenes ever. I'm not sure why you keep trying to be sarcastic. It's not funny anymore and if it's a troll attempt, it's a very poor one. |
BloodRequiem said: Botato said: They want to troll OP into watching a mediocre adaptation. Dafuq you talking about man? The DEEN adaptation had some of the best scenes ever. Agreed. I hope they bring back CGI Dragon soon. Best part is Latex Sakura though. |
| And I mean that in the most sexually painful way possible. |
JabonHR said: BloodRequiem said: Dafuq you talking about man? The DEEN adaptation had some of the best scenes ever. Agreed. I hope they bring back CGI Dragon soon. Best part is Latex Sakura though. The dragon is canon though. I don't get why they added H-scenes to the VN when they already had a cool dragon from the anime. |
antonn said: I don't get why they added H-scenes to the VN when they already had a cool dragon from the anime. I don't know what you're getting at. The dragon from the anime (2006) obviously came after the h-scenes from the VN (2003/2004) and it was Nasu who told DEEN to replace the h-scene with the CG Dragon. What most people are making fun of is the poor execution. |
C-Core said: antonn said: I don't get why they added H-scenes to the VN when they already had a cool dragon from the anime. I don't know what you're getting at. The dragon from the anime (2006) obviously came after the h-scenes from the VN (2003/2004) and it was Nasu who told DEEN to replace the h-scene with the CG Dragon. What most people are making fun of is the poor execution. |
antonn said: C-Core said: I don't know what you're getting at. The dragon from the anime (2006) obviously came after the h-scenes from the VN (2003/2004) and it was Nasu who told DEEN to replace the h-scene with the CG Dragon. What most people are making fun of is the poor execution. I am sorry but this made my day.First day at work after the vacation;I needed that. |
| Man this prologue is pretty slow so far XD Pour dat tea archer |
| |
| Don't worry it gets interesting someday |
|
midnightblade said: You cant imagine how slow they made it in the anime, even with skipping a TON of stuff.Man this prologue is pretty slow so far XD Pour dat tea archer |
| Damn, I got baited, haha. I'd say the summoning ritual in the Realta Nua 2012 version is very pretty and interesting. When I read the prologue for the first time, I instantly became a fan of Rin's. |
| My order: Watched F/SN Read the VN Watched and read F/Z simultaniously Going to watch 2014 version. I don't know why people hate the anime/fate route so much. |
 |
doom19876 said: I don't know why people hate the anime/fate route so much. Fate route is the least interesting, due to so many infodumps of info regarding the world-building of how everything works, and it doesn't do anything with Shirou's ideals. Saber's cute though. |
| And I mean that in the most sexually painful way possible. |
| Fate route isn't bad per se; it only pales (lots) in comparison to the other routes. But I still find it interesting, even more if it's played again after completing the whole game. And it's get better gradually the further you read. |
JabonHR said: doom19876 said: I don't know why people hate the anime/fate route so much. Fate route is the least interesting, due to so many infodumps of info regarding the world-building of how everything works, and it doesn't do anything with Shirou's ideals. Saber's cute though. Well actually it doesnt do anything about how Shirou thinks about themHe is just dead set on following the. A for the anime, isnt it obvious that it would be hated if they adapted the least awesome route and managed to screw things up from the 1st second? |
JabonHR said: You changed your avatar from superior Rin to shitty Saber.Saber's cute though. Who are you. ssjokg said: I never really understood what was the point of the Saber vs. Gil fight there.A for the anime, isnt it obvious that it would be hated if they adapted the least awesome route and managed to screw things up from the 1st second? |
|
Botato said: Something about Gil making Saber his wife by force or something. Or just to make the climax look cooler.ssjokg said: I never really understood what was the point of the Saber vs. Gil fight there.A for the anime, isnt it obvious that it would be hated if they adapted the least awesome route and managed to screw things up from the 1st second? |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 22, 2014 |
1086 |
by tobifiy
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 15, 2014 |
623 |
by tobifiy
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 25, 2014 |
1046 |
by tobifiy
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» The story for Fate is ass ( 1 2 )Rockyjams909 - Nov 5 |
76 |
by Exlirae
»»
Yesterday, 8:29 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 11, 2014 |
1267 |
by red1130
»»
Oct 26, 6:25 PM |