PandoraHearts
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- Brother love, which Vincent still cannot accept it, it seems. Nice, Break!! Not only he lost his left arm, he also made contract with Raven (again?)!! And that seal has no time... So sweet that Gil accepts Oz the way he is even if he's "fake". |
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
| Nice to see that Gil accepts Oz whether he is a "fake" or not Why do i feel like Oscar will betray them T_T |
 |
| That was nice brother love there. Oscar's arrive. Am I sensing something big will happen? |
 |
| Hm. That really seems to be my first thought on this chapter, 'hm'. I've read it at least five times already and I'm still not sure what to make of it. Dodo calls Rufus 'ru-kun'. At the very least that made this chapter worth reading, I cracked up, it's adorable, but makes me miss dear Cheryl. hmm. InfiniteDestiny said: Why do i feel like Oscar will betray them T_T Because a) there's been a general turn for the better and given this series few people trust it will last, and b) the ending tag line of this chapter is "is someone coming to their rescue? Well, that should be apparent, and drawing that much attention to it is suspicious c) This is pandora hearts, ergo any 'good' character should be taken with a healthy pinch of salt d) his expression. At the same time, I don't get the feeling Oscar will betray them - the expectation that every character in this series has some sort of dark secret is kind of over the top, and given what he just learned he has every reason for stress and strain to be on his face - but there's definitely some suspicion that he might. I wish this chapter was longer. I really do. Gil. Oh, Gil. I still don't like your character development, not at all, but it didn't anger me in this chapter, which is good. I almost said 'didn't disappoint me either', but there would have to be some faith in it in order for me to be disappointed, and I lost every ounce of that in the last chapter. At least I'm starting to accept it, and then I have far less of a problem. Gil's character has gone from being personally really intriguing and compelling to entirely 'meh?' Nothing's perfect, life goes on. Something that stood out to me in this chapter was Gil talking about relationships with chains, mostly because it seems so out of the blue, and... I dunno, a bit un-Gilbert ish. A bit of his one time role as Glen's successor coming through, I suppose. Hm. This chapter is just so 'hm'. I don't know whether I regard the bit with Gil and the chains as 'nice' or 'odd' or cheesy or... I just don't know. What I do know, though, is that I don't blame Glen one bit in this chapter, I enjoyed his frustration and condescension towards Pandora and there stupid contraptions, and I hope/wish there won't be ill will towards him. And really, I find myself kind-of-sort-of-maybe rooting for him. And! And, and and! Isn't the title page illustration exciting?! When I first glimpsed it, it seemed so epic and intense I immediately skipped to the next page (thinking iit might be a fancoloring of a later page (like in 73) and I didn't want to be spoiled). Looking back at it... Well, it's exciting! The clock tower from the first volume, the mysterious crown - like the one on the sixth volume cover - on the pendulum - wherever could that be going? Oh, please don't let the answer be nowhere! - the multitude of clocks, and although I'm wary of timetravel, I really wouldn't mind PH dabbling in it. I mean, it's been said multiple times that Glen has the power to change the world. So whyever can't he? The title - of all the 'hmm' things in this chapter, why is it called "falling?" Seriously, other than the cover illustration of Oz falling into Gil's arm, I don't get it. Why? What, falling, as in falling action? Alright, I seriously doubt PH would break the 4th wall like that, but, still. Vincent! You're either a moron who needs a hug, or an idiot who needs a slap. Which of those, I'm not quite sure as of yet. At the very least, you're interesting. Was anyone else reminded of Gil and Vince's reunion in volume three where Vince reached for Gil and was slapped away? Interesting parallel/reversal whatever. Also, Gil, I'm glad you've finally done something to support your little brother. I mean, aside from jumping a bullet, pfft. Heyyy.... Is there any answer (ever) for why Gil lost his memories in the first place? He's such a different person with them, losing them caused plenty of grief, how did it come about? All the same... I'm a little worried that series will be a letdown, even beyond the stark contrast between what I saw in Gil's character and /Gil's character/. It's not that I want a downer ending from this series, but the way things are suddenly swinging upwards... Leaves me behind. I kind of get the feeling that the characters get a boat load of problems and angst dumped on their backs, they fall down... And then the problems and conflicts just evaporate and they get up and keep walking. I dunno how accurate that is/will be, but that's kind of the sense I picking up now, and I don't like it. I want more conflict, more growth... Well, well, well, I wouldn't agree that Gil lacks 'growth' in these last chapters but... I guess its too quick, not delved into enough, jumping from point A to point B with only flimsy excuses that don't carry me through. Also, the world is breaking. Please, please, please don't suddenly give Alice (either of them) some barely legimate deus ex machina to just fix everything with minimum sacrifice. |
| Really good chap :D Glen is pissed XD Loved Gil's smile and how he accepted Oz. I smell sth fishy from the last page. Please let me be wrong. |
 |
| The way Gil cheered up Oz was so banal... |
 |
| Oscar will probably betray them. |
| ya, I have a bad feeling about Oscar. It would be great if he was like Gil and still accepted Oz after finding out the truth, but... I just don't feel like it will go down quite like that. |
| If Uncle Oscar betrays them, there will be tears... Not that this series doesn't make it a habit to rip my soul apart whenever it has the chance. I'm pretty sure the Gil/Oz ship rose back up after having sunk to the bottom of the ocean. Will Alice ever be back? |
| If it's not in red, I won't believe it. |
InfiniteDestiny said: Nice to see that Gil accepts Oz whether he is a "fake" or not Why do i feel like Oscar will betray them T_T Looks like I'm not the only one... lol... |
 "Have you ever encounter a wild beast that guarantees to never bite anyone?" ~ Roronoa Zoro |
No more to say. |
ワンダーランド花 ♥ |
| I very much doubt Oscar is an ally at this point. Hell, you can actually see Zai in the background on the very page before they run into Oscar. |
| I am really proud of Gilbert for everything he had done for Oz but still i cant help to feel a tinge of sadness for him :( Hopefully Gilbert and Oz could find a solution to solve this whole problem without having to sacrifice anyone... anymore... AND LASTLY Oscar better not do anything bad to them...if not i m going to kick his ass( in my dreams at least ;D) |
| The way Gil cheered Oz up seemed kinda weak to me... not to mention cliche. Although it was nice to see him smile like that when Oz persisted in calling him an idiot. Although I don't know why he would be happier having his memories, since he has so many more worries and burdens to carry around now. @Lacie111 I think the 'bad guys turning good' thing is simply Jun's way of giving them depth. She just doesn't balance it very nicely. The same with her multiple plots. Poor balance. I wouldn't consider Vincent to be good now, we're just seeing another side to him. He's still a deeply flawed character. I never considered him to be the antagonist of the whole manga, I used to think that was the Baskervilles. Every villain doesn't have to be pure evil, just as every hero doesn't have to be a saint. I think the "villain" was supposed to be Jack all along, we as the audience just weren't aware of it. We now know that back in the first volume when Alice (or whoever) was choking Oz, screaming "I'll never forgive you", she was referring to Jack. Also, Jack probably has a plan to regain his body, he mentioned something about it after he stabbed Leo. Although now that I think about it that had to do with the seal, which Oz doesn't have anymore since he rejected Alice. And Alice returned to the abyss didn't she? Next to her sister who is suddenly completely sane. Raemya said: The title - of all the 'hmm' things in this chapter, why is it called "falling?" Seriously, other than the cover illustration of Oz falling into Gil's arm, I don't get it. Why? What, falling, as in falling action? Alright, I seriously doubt PH would break the 4th wall like that, but, still. I thought about that too. It seems kinda ominous to me. The previous chapter is called "decision", referring to Gil, and now this one is "falling". Perhaps it's foreshadowing the consequences of Gil's decision. I mean, "falling" goes against the mood of this chapter and it makes it seem like everything is not working out as nicely as it seems. There's also Oscar to worry about, and though I don't think he'd betray Oz, it's still worrying. The only positive connotation I can put on that is falling in love, which is...odd. And slightly hilarious. |
SilverDemonNov 25, 2012 12:05 PM
| Love the brother love ajd caring!! Somethings are to be remembered some aren't .... But his brother and Glen calling him an idiot also Oz too.... I think it was awesome that Gilbert acepted Oz as Oz by far best moement Yay Break is ok wohoooooo!!! |
 |
| Great chapter, Gilbert was the highlight once again. I can't wait until Break is free, I really want to see him in action. 5/5 |
 |
| I don't think Oscar will betray Oz that simply. Remember when he told them (Oz & Gil) he treat them like his sons. Oz lived with his uncle since he was kid, so I think he isn't going to do something like that. What about Ada? What will she do with Oz and with Zai? And where is Echo now? I just hope she will not be replaced by Zwei. Ragna92 said: Great chapter, Gilbert was the highlight once again. I can't wait until Break is free, I really want to see him in action. 5/5 Totally agree. Also, we need reim and Sharon in the next retrace ;') |
| Great chapter! I shed a tear during the Gil and Vince moment, I love their relationship at this point and both of them as characters ;_; |
 |
| Gil should be even more awesome with a legit contract yaay! Was really cool how he just accepted Oz. I should be happy to see Oscar shows up but don't think it will end well.. |
 |
| That seems like a really big wide open death flag to me |
 |
More topics from this board
» Pandora Hearts RemakeChipichan - Oct 15 |
6 |
by Sasori56483
»»
Oct 15, 2:05 PM |
|
» Why does this manga have to be so confusing?ReMightyRon - Aug 6 |
11 |
by dixoncider8142
»»
Aug 10, 6:19 PM |
|
» Your favorite chapter?AsrielXL - Oct 13, 2022 |
9 |
by Tesadora
»»
Feb 8, 1:35 PM |
|
Poll: » Pandora Hearts Chapter 10 Discussiongdavge2003 - Apr 2, 2009 |
15 |
by doratea
»»
Jan 21, 2:41 AM |
|
» Is this better than Vanitas no Carte?AjiX101 - Feb 17, 2022 |
12 |
by Pixelated_Vision
»»
Jan 12, 4:50 PM |