How do you rate the 3D of the monsters? (I'm making a list about this, poll)

I feel like these are very biased poll choices.

Agreed. If they put this poll on Dorohedoro they'd probably get shit on.

Didn’t ‘Overlord’ have an awkward, random 3D dance scene? ‘I’m a Spider, So What?’ would randomly switch to 3D during fight scenes (I know why they do it from a budget, time, etc point of view). If I remember correctly, ‘Black Summoner’ had one character that was 3D basically 24/7 when nothing else was in 3D.

I don’t mind 3D, and actually liked the story for this one itself. You get used to it when the entire episode is 3D like ‘Duke of Death and his Maid’. I hate shows where it’s 2D and randomly switches in and out of 3D. The only time where the switching didn’t bother me so much during a scene was the dance scene in ‘Tearmoon Empire’.

I’d actually have to try to think in order to remember other bad or okay 3D moments in a primarily 2D anime.

The monsters looked like they were made from chocolate and fresh out of the mold. Shiny and slick. Made me hungry!
When making your list, remember to put Girls Band Cry right up there at the top, not difficult considering it’s probably one of the best anime period.

The cgi itself wasn’t even bad though, they just did a bad job at blending it with the 2d and overused it for the human characters. Though if I recall, that kinda stopped being as much of an issue in the second half. But the models were good and they did an ok job at animating them. Above average, as far as anime cgi goes.

Some 2d shows I can think of with worse cgi would be Overlord, Arifureta, Shield Hero, Blue Lock, Demon King Academy, Kingdom, The Demon Sword Master, and pretty much any anime done by studio A-Cat. And I’m sure there’s plenty others that I’m not remembering.

And for fully 3d shows, Ex-Arm blows all the competition out of the water. Berserk 2016 and Seven Deadly Sins: Grudge of Edinburgh are pretty awful as well from what I’ve seen and heard.

Nah, you’re good, I didn’t assume you hated it at all. I only said what I did at the end because I know most people hate 3D (i.e. it was meant as a general comment, not to anyone in specific). From what I’ve seen, many won’t even give a show all in 3D a shot because it’s too jarring. Imo, it’s just something people have to get used to and then it doesn’t bother you like it does initially.