Toshokan Sensou

In the year 1989, the Japanese government passed the Media Betterment Act, allowing a group of soldiers known as the Media Betterment Committee (MBC) to destroy and censor any "problematic" media under the guise of protecting public morals. As a response, regional governments established the Library Defense Force (LDF), whose members take up arms and put their lives on the line to protect freedom of expression. At the top of the Kanto branch of the LDF stands the Library Task Force (LTF): an elite squad consisting of only the most exceptional fighters.

As a high schooler, Iku Kasahara experienced the terror of censorship first-hand when she refused to surrender the newest volume of her favorite series to MBC agents. She only came out unscathed thanks to a lone member of the LDF, who protected her and her beloved book. Now in her 20s and still unable to forget the man who saved her, Kasahara joins the LDF in the hope of becoming just like her prince.

But LDF training turns out to be far more rigorous than she could have imagined, and her instructor, LTF member Atsushi Doujou, seems fixated on making her life a living hell. Given her struggles, Kasahara is shocked when she is selected as one of the two new LTF recruits as a result of Doujou's recommendation. As Kasahara does all she can to become worthy of the LTF and unravel her enigmatic superior's motivations, she wages war—both on the battlefield and in her personal life.

[Written by MAL Rewrite]

Doujou, Atsushi Main

Maeno, Tomoaki Japanese

Kasahara, Iku Main

Inoue, Marina Japanese

Shibasaki, Asako Supporting

Sawashiro, Miyuki Japanese

Komaki, Mikihisa Supporting

Ishida, Akira Japanese

Tezuka, Hikaru Supporting

Suzuki, Tatsuhisa Japanese

Asahina, Hikaru Supporting

Ono, Daisuke Japanese

Tezuka, Satoshi Supporting

Yoshino, Hiroyuki Japanese

Inamine, Kazuichi Supporting

Satou, Haruo Japanese

Nonomiya, Shizuka Supporting

Nazuka, Kaori Japanese

Orikuchi, Maki Supporting

Tanaka, Rie Japanese

Takeuchi, Fumie Producer

Hosokai, Kousuke Producer

Nishimura, Tomoyasu Producer

Hamana, Takayuki Director, Episode Director, Storyboard

Reviews

Jul 10, 2008

Archaeon

Recommended

Toshokan Sensou (or The Library Wars), is another one of those odd anime that I seem to end up reviewing. The show has a nice premise which is reminiscent of Orwell's 1984 and Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 all rolled into one.

The anime is based on a series of four light novels by Arikawa Hiro (entitled Toshokan Sensou, Nairan, Kiki, and Kakumei respectively), which were published from 2006 to 2007. The novels were later serialized in two mangas. The first manga was made by Yumi Kiiro, and published in Lala magazine from September 2007. The second was made by Furudori Yayoi, and was published Dengeki Daioh magazine ... from November 2007. The twelve episode anime was made by Production IG, and released in April 2008 on Fuji TV's Noitamina (which is animation written backwards) timeslot.

Story

The basic plot for the novels is based on the "Statement of Intellectual Freedom in Libraries" that went into effect in Japan in 1954. The story is set 30 years after Japan passed the Media Enhancement Act in 1989, a law which effectively gave control of all published material to the government. The law was passed in an effort to censor any media that could be deemed as hazardous to Japanese society, but 30 years later blanket censorships, book burnings, and a culture of fear and exclusion have become the norm for society, as Media Enforcement troops are everywhere.

Because of this, and because of a tragedy that occured 20 years prior to the beginning of the story, the libraries now have their own defense forces, and the main character, Kasahara Iku, joins the Kanto Library Defense Force as she was saved by a member of the that team some years back. The show follows her struggle to become a good librarian and a good member of the defense team.

Art

The art style is very much hit and miss. Although the characters are nicely designed Production IG have adopted a style that has quite noticeable black borders around characters and objects. This give the show a far more "cartoony" feel than it should possibly have, especially during the dramatic moments. This "cartoony" feel can be off putting to some people, whilst others may be oblivious to it.

The backgrounds and settings are well designed, but overall they aren't anything special. The animation itself is usually quite smooth and flowing, although there are some glaring faults (the scene in episode 11 with a van crashing through a barrier made from two buses and receiving no damage is a prime example).

Sound

The sound is okay overall. The OP is nice, if unmemorable, as is the ED. The VA's are quite good overall. Inoue Marina plays the role of Iku very well, and her voice suits the design of the character. The same goes for the rest of the VA's with their resepctive characters. The sound effects are pretty good throughout the show. Most of these are used in the more dramatic or action filled moments to good effect.

Characters

The characters weren't bad on the whole. Iku is a nice enough lead on the whole, although I found it a little off putting that she is a stereotypical "jock" (i.e. all muscle and no brain). She is determined and caring, but coupled with that is a short temper, reckless behaviour, a dislike of serious study and classrooms, and a endency to overreact. This can make her character confusing as it's sometimes unclear how the show is trying to develop her.

The other characters (Doujo Atsushi, Shibasaki Asako, Tezuka Hikaru, etc), receive very little development throughout the course of the show, especially given the fact that the show is about Iku. This makes the show unbalanced as, although we are clear about what drives Iku, we are rarely shown any of the other chaacters' motivations.

Enjoyment

Here's the reason why I said this show is a bit odd. It never seems to settle on being one thing as it has drama, action, suspense, comedy, and even romance all mixed into it. he unfortunate thing though, is that it never quite pulls of the comedy, the romance is a little on the limp side, the drama is sometimes hammed up, and the suspense is normally easy to work out. Couple this with the cartoon style art and the show is difficult to take seriously.

However, the show is enjoyable on the whole, especially if you don't treat it as a serious anime. It's effectively a coming of age story and as such it actually works on quite a few levels.

Overall

Toshokan Sensou isn't a bad show on the whole. Yes, there are some obvious failings in the show, but it is still rather enjoyable in a no-brain kind of way. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone who wants a serious show, or to anyone who wants a comedy. Although the basic premise is a serious one, the show works better as a straightforward action anime, and as such it's not a bad way to waste half an hour (hence my overall score of 7).

If you're going to watch the show then don't have any expectations of high drama, challenging concepts, or any kind of socio-political message. It doesn't require any introspection or deep philosophical ponderings, and the best advice is to watch it in the same way you'd watch Die Hard, Rush Hour, or any other action movie.

Reviewer’s Rating: 7

What did you think of this review?

Nice 213

Love it 1

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Archaeon (211)

Show all

214

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Sep 6, 2018

JuneNephthys

Mixed Feelings

Toshokan Sensou, or Library Wars, its English name on Crunchyroll, is beautiful monotony. As many of you already know, Production I.G. is known for animating very pretty things.

• I.G. collaborated with GAINAX for the End of Evangelion and other very successful projects. You may be thinking, well duh, Luna. Get to the point! The point is: The actual director of this series, Takayuki Hamana, apart from the studio, hasn't worked on much.

• This isn't always something that ruins a series. I mean, he did direct Beast Player Erin… which was a very concrete world-building series, but dry on all other aspects, like on ... character building.

• Library Wars suffers from the same issues, where the technical aspects are solid, but the characters, aside from the main two, don't get enough screen time. Even though there is a sweet romance between Iku and Atsushi.

• I got bored of the same interactions of Iku being like, "Hey, I'm the loud, stubborn, impulsive tomboy." And Atsushi responding with the atypical grumpy, male tsundere attitude. Often, having the habit of telling Iku that she's a monkey or that she looks better than usual, grumble grumble.

• If a guy treated me like that in real life, I would for-sure dump him! ANYWAY, it was neat how the series was a callback to Orwell's 1989 and Bradbury's Fahrenheit with the media banning clause, issued by an oppressive government, but the show doesn't seem to know if it wants to be a childrens’ show or something for adults.

• The characters use REAL guns in their war against the book burning faction, but no one actually dies. There's no mention of the government even taking serious action against the book-preserving faction EVEN AT THE CLIMAX at the end of the fucking sequel movie: Kakumei no Tsubasa, nor does any of the implied concerns ever escalate in the series.

• I mean, c'mon, even the infamously goofy Gundam SEED took itself more seriously with politics and there were protesters getting shot and killed by police because they didn't want genetically enhanced humans.

• How am I supposed to take this (supposed) war against ideals seriously when the random people who are interviewed on the street in the Library Wars TV Series seem like they don't care about the armed feud between these people and the government?

• Uh, people are shooting guns at each other over book censoring, I guess I'm okay with it. I mean, I could understand if the people we're being silenced by the government, but the show makes no indication of this AT ALL!

• One character gets shot thirty-two times and is still walking in the next episode, and of course when a character goes into a coma out of shock, they wake up! There is no realism and severity in this series, at least make a background character dieーfor christ sake!

• I felt like I was watching a survival game or paintball match with how placid the atmosphere is, and it doesn't help that at the end of the movie, the law is changed so that the two factions can now only fight each other with… rubber bullets? What?

• Girls und Panzer, which had girls in middle school sparring seriously in a tank equivalent of LARPING: got more real! Miho in Girls und Panzer even has PTSD from a tank match with her sister.

• The matter of war being treated more like a game and the romcom aspect sticking out, made it impossible for me to take it seriously. If you like really nice animation, then it's definitely worth a watch but I felt the the beautiful visuals were wasted on a vapid, wishy-washy story that didn't know what it wanted to be, other than military fetishism. I give Library Wars a 5/10 and hope that Takayuki Hamana does better with the Lyrical Nanoha films.

Reviewer’s Rating: 5

What did you think of this review?

Nice 5

Love it 1

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by JuneNephthys (188)

Show all

6

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Feb 5, 2021

AnimeEnjoyer420

Not Recommended

Summary: Toshokan Sensou is an unfortunate case of a solid premise (what if libraries had their own militaries to fight off censorship?) wasted on uninspired material and a scattershot approach to genre that causes the tone of the series to careen wildly from one scene to the next. The pieces of a good show can sometimes be found here, but it's ultimately a disappointment that never capitalizes on the ideas that it has.

Positives:

+ Intriguing premise. Though it never really makes the most of it, the sight of people in military fatigues doing book readings for children at the local library before fighting off ... jackbooted government thugs trying to do Fahrenheit 451 to their Clifford the Big Red Dog books is admirably goofy and unique.

+ Some good side characters. In particular, Shibasaki and Tezuka are interesting and I would have liked to see more of them, even though it wasn't as though they were sidelined or anything.

+ Looks pretty good for being over 10 years old. It's not perfect (see negatives section below) but generally looks solid. The art style is very reminiscent of Archer as well, it's got a different look to it that you don't see very often.

+ Ending was kind of nice. I wasn't really feeling the love story between Kasahara and Dojo for most of the series, but they managed to hook me a little with some nice scenes in the last episode.

Negatives:

- Unlikeable main character. It's very hard to root for Kasahara at points in this show. She's incompetent and emotionally fragile, unable to handle simple criticism from a superior office or put up with a single day of mild hazing without crying. She regularly displays poor judgment and puts others in danger because she doesn't think through the consequences of her actions. She is constantly criticized for these things by her superiors and yet they still put her on an elite special forces team, despite the fact that she can't even reliably hit a large, stationary target during weapons training. She messes things up constantly and is still shown favoritism and given duties and promotions far beyond her actual demonstrated capabilities, and then still whines about how her superiors are too mean to her when she fails. She sucks and I didn't like her at all.

- Tries to be too many different things at once. This show tries to be a military action story, a shoujo rom com, and Fahrenheit 451-style social commentary all at once, and ends up not doing any of them particularly well. The action scenes lack drama and the fact that dozens of people are shooting actual guns at each other for hours at a time and not a single person ever dies lends an air of absurdity to the whole thing. The rom com aspect is not especially well done. For some reason they decided to transport all the high school rom com tropes like blushing girls literally running away from their feelings into this series, which follows a military unit full of adults. I fear for how well they will be able to defend freedom of expression from fascism if they can't even make eye contact with someone they have a crush on.

- Uninspired and the social commentary lacks bite or purpose. The Fahrenheit 451 type setting of this series is quite literally just a setting. This series has nothing interesting or new to say on the subject. The message is "censorship bad, join your local library" and that's it. If you're watching this series expecting profound satire or political commentary, you will be sorely disappointed.

- Strange animation problems. Though the series mostly looks fine, there are some times when the character models get all wonky or look like they're moonwalking. Kasahara in particular sometimes takes on a weirdly frumpy appearance when you see her walking around.

- Lack of compelling villains. The Media Cleansing Committee are just faceless thugs. They seem sinister when they're first introduced in the opening episode, but only become less frightening with time. They take L's constantly, never winning even one time during a confrontation over the course of the series. They're Big Brother meets the Washington Generals. They aren't threatening and you never feel as though they're a significant obstacle to the main characters. Tezuka's brother occasionally shows flashes of being an interesting villain, but they never follow through on this and all of the tension dissipates when he exits the story for extended periods of time.

Reviewer’s Rating: 4

What did you think of this review?

Nice 6

Love it 1

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 1

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by AnimeEnjoyer420 (153)

Show all

8

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

"War" Anime

by Literallythor

28 Entries · 2 Restacks

Shojo Beat Anime Adaptations

by Violet9876

50 Entries · 38 Restacks

a random collection of anime adaptations (2000-2024)

by Cunfre

50 Entries · 2 Restacks

North American Anime & Manga Releases for February

Here are the North American anime & manga releases for February Week 1: February 6 - 12 Anime Releases Gedo Senki DVD Gedo Senki Blu-ray & DVD Combo Heisei T...read more

Feb 5, 2018 10:23 AM by Sakana-san | Discuss (5 comments)

North American Anime & Manga Releases for November

Here are the North American Anime & Manga releases for November Week 1: November 3 - 9 Anime Releases Blessing of the Campanella Complete Collection Fairy Tail C...read more

Nov 4, 2015 1:59 PM by trebmeg | Discuss (20 comments)

	Poll: Toshokan Sensou Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 ) dtshyk - Jun 26, 2008	62 replies	by LuxuriousHeart »» Feb 5, 4:29 AM
	Poll: Toshokan Sensou Episode 11 Discussion dtshyk - Jun 19, 2008	42 replies	by LuxuriousHeart »» Feb 5, 4:02 AM
	Poll: Toshokan Sensou Episode 10 Discussion dtshyk - Jun 12, 2008	32 replies	by LuxuriousHeart »» Feb 5, 3:03 AM
	Poll: Toshokan Sensou Episode 9 Discussion dtshyk - Jun 5, 2008	36 replies	by LuxuriousHeart »» Feb 5, 2:05 AM
	Poll: Toshokan Sensou Episode 8 Discussion dtshyk - May 29, 2008	35 replies	by LuxuriousHeart »» Feb 4, 2:15 AM