How is this similar with SH? Well it's simple, when I first watched EschaLogy's first episode it made me feel I was playing a videogame and that's the same feeling you get when you watch SH. Digging deeper you'll find that these two series also share a similar RPG action/fantasy story that develops in an old village.
* The shounen lead isn't a LOSER; he's skilled at what he does, outgoing and outspoken, and is pretty good with a sword.
* The setting is that of a small community, but the atmosphere is laid back yet bustling with life.
* There's no upskirt panty shots. Okayfinewhatever. _(^_^)_/
* A girl in both these shows have a "tail."
Both anime are based on JRPGs and feel like the beginnings to a long story for a game. Both anime don't have much action, even though there are some, and both anime are more based on daily fantasy life rather than adventure, but there are things going on in the background that further the plot and lead to what should be the game. Altelier however, skips through parts of the story of the game and actually has an ending, while Shining Hearts is mostly like a prologue and doesn't have a resolution.
The lovelyness are the same with magical creatures and actions with slice of humor, only that Earl and Fairy has a slice of romance between two characters but who knows what Shining Hearts will have lest's watch ^^
Based on another popular JRPG franchise. Legend of Heroes and Shining Hearts main character has amnesia. He joins a guild/organization in order to find his lost memories. Soon he finds out his deep dark secret that will change him forever.
A young man finds himself babysitting another high school classmate who happens to live in the same building as him. He's also trying to appear to have a normal life and not let the crazies drag down his reputation, so to speak.
Based on a popular JRPG. Star Ocean franchise. The story of SH and SO both involve an amnesiac person in some way. In SO, our main hero must find a way back to his own world but also prevent this world's destruction. Along the way he meets companions who joins his quest.
Both series come from their popular JRPG. The story and characters are very similar. A civil war between countries occurs and the world is going be destroyed. Our heroes set out on a grand adventure to prevent it from happening. I also recommend other Tales of series: Symphonia, Eternia, Vesperia, and Phantasia.
Both Anime have "different worlds" In Ar Tonelico the worlds consist of islands floating in the sky, while in Shining Hearts it is your typical "different world" and crossing dimension scenario. The art work in both are very detailed.