Attack on Titan
| Since people can't behave and keep making thread about these, you can all have a special thread to talk about these topics. This thread will also be heavily moderated. If you can't discuss these in a civil fashion, you will be at risk of receiving a warning of a ban. Please read the Site & Forum Guidelines before posting. Reminder of some rules and rules for this thread:
This is mostly an anime only thread, please use spoiler tags. If someone repeatedly posts spoilers without tags, it will be a trolling rule violation. Here are the Site & Forum Guidelines, the Anime Discussion Rules and the Anime Series Episode Discussion Rules. Want to read the old Rumor & Leaks Thread? You can find it here. All other threads concerning these topics will be either locked, merged or removed. The same goes for all ranting/blog threads. There are plenty of places where you can discuss, there's no need for a new thread every five minutes. Gossiping threads will be removed too. Anything concerning the community being x or y. |
anime-primeJan 10, 2022 2:42 AM
 |
| Fuck!! I have been waiting for this thread for 2000 yrs!! Thanks mod-chan! Please do something abt those alrdy made 20 threads too! |
| Top 10 reasons why anime-prime is best forum mod |
    ☁ |
| Finally no more idiots repetitively doing some war over an animation, never once saw a thread where people talk about the characters and story :( |
"......If I told you that I was a real witch, would you believe it?"  |
CQLLIST said: Yeah the only thing there has been ever since the ep aired,Finally no more idiots repetitively doing some war over an animation, never once saw a thread where people talk about the characters and story :( This is shit That is shit You are shit Everything is shit Makes me chukle tbh. |
CQLLIST said: Threads here are always either animation debates, ship wars or blatant attempts to spoil anime watchersFinally no more idiots repetitively doing some war over an animation, never once saw a thread where people talk about the characters and story :( |
Sir-CJan 10, 2022 1:43 AM
 |
| Thanks @anime-prime that was pretty based of you. |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
| k mod san ..sorry I didn't know that I couldn't make threads comparing and discussing the animation quality of the attack on titan. i will avoid making threads that discuss like that from now on. and what am i supposed to do about this thread .. .the delete option is not there: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1985813 |
Stawberry Milk Supremacy  |
| anime-prime has come to save us. I hope people will learn how to use this thread instead of creating more. DarkGamerA said: It's fine, I don't think you'll be able to delete it. Leave it be. Also, it's not that you can't make threads, it's just getting out of hand. You can now find at least 2 of the same thread. People just attack the forums and start popping out threads instead of browsing first to see if the topic has already been discussed. k mod san ..sorry I didn't know that I couldn't make threads comparing and discussing the animation quality of the attack on titan. i will avoid making threads that discuss like that from now on. and what am i supposed to do about this thread .. .the delete option is not there: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1985813 |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
| You know the situation is bad when the Mods have to step in. Thanks for this. |
 |
| I have to say that I don't notice much changes in the art, just as good as last season. The CGI in episode 1 looked great though, blended in nicely with the 2D. Much much better than what they did last season. Production-wise I am really satisfied with episode 1. |
| Holy shit. Things are really out of hand here huh. Well. So... Honestly, I prefer Mappa's 2D artstyle more. Also their CGI wasn't half bad in part 1 but its definitely improved this part. I think the reason isn't the bad CGI here. Its more about the fact that how frequent it is used. Wit Studio's CGI was atrocious (colossal titan) but barely anyone complained because it was only used for handful of scenes. |
 |
anime-prime said: Since people can't behave and keep making thread about these, you can all have a special thread to talk about these topics. This thread will also be heavily moderated. If you can't discuss these in a civil fashion, you will be at risk of receiving a warning of a ban. Please read the Site & Forum Guidelines before posting. Reminder of some rules and rules for this thread:
This is mostly an anime only thread, please use spoiler tags. If someone repeatedly posts spoilers without tags, it will be a trolling rule violation. Here are the Site & Forum Guidelines, the Anime Discussion Rules and the Anime Series Episode Discussion Rules. Want to read the old Rumor & Leaks Thread? You can find it here. All other threads concerning these topics will be either locked, merged or removed. The same goes for all ranting/blog threads. There are plenty of places where you can discuss, there's no need for a new thread every five minutes. Gossiping threads will be removed too. Anything concerning the community being x or y. How are you gonna implement poll topics to this mega topic? Seems like you did a dick move to me |
 |
| The cgi was pretty good, slightly Better than previous season's. The animation was great. Dunno why people keep on complaining about it. |
 |
| The CGI was good and really blended in with the 2d animation. And the 2d animation was fantastic. I actually prefer MAPPA's style. And thanks for making this thread. anime-prime is indeed the best mod. |
 |
CQLLIST said: , never once saw a thread where people talk about the characters and story :( You haven't been that much active during part 1 then. So many people were arguing with Gabi's actions, Zeke's backstory and more. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
KiR4T said: As someone who prefers accuracy and consistency more, I also prefer MAPPA's style. Although WIT's may have the higher peaks in action-heavy scenes, but they tend to sacrifice the dialogue-heavy parts with still images.Honestly, I prefer Mappa's 2D artstyle more. Also their CGI wasn't half bad in part 1 but its definitely improved this part. I think the reason isn't the bad CGI here. Its more about the fact that how frequent it is used. Wit Studio's CGI was atrocious (colossal titan) but barely anyone complained because it was only used for handful of scenes. |
I just realized that all of my favorite characters, beside being stunningly beautiful, also happen to be exceptionally skilled murder machines. \('-')/ I'm level  on mal-badges. View my badges. |
| I thought the art was definitely a step up. The character models look more consistent, the facial expressions look a little more vibrant and expressive and it overall just looks and feels a lot more polished. The animation sequences for the Jaw and Cart Titan were really good, and the CGI models didn't stand out as much against the 2D backgrounds : they've been blended to look much more natural. There were still a couple of tiny nit-picks here and there, but you'll find that with most TV anime anyway. |
xenosysJan 10, 2022 6:56 AM
| they improve the camera movements this season and added some more effects like dust or smoke but the models are still the same cannot wait for the 3D colossal titan debut like we saw in the OP |
| This tweet is from director of Vinland Saga S1, also took part of direction in eps 7 Part 1 Final Season from what i remember, i just thought i put something he said here i censored his account name because i'm scared of some harassers potentially lurking around here so...  |
jackoffwankerJan 11, 2022 4:30 AM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
jackoffwanker said: This tweet is from Shuhei Yabuta, director of Vinland Saga S1, also took part of direction in eps 7 Part 1 Final Season from what i remember, i just thought i put something he said here i censored his account name because i'm scared of some harassers potentially lurking around here so... in other words praise the staff especially directors and animators rather than the studio staff list > studio name exceptions exist like Ufotable and KyoAni that do all their work in-house with their own in-house staff |
deg said: jackoffwanker said: This tweet is from Shuhei Yabuta, director of Vinland Saga S1, also took part of direction in eps 7 Part 1 Final Season from what i remember, i just thought i put something he said here i censored his account name because i'm scared of some harassers potentially lurking around here so... in other words praise the staff especially directors and animators rather than the studio staff list > studio name exceptions exist like Ufotable and KyoAni that do all their work in-house with their own in-house staff you're right, i rarely praise MAPPA because i feel bitter towards the higher-ups hopefully the staff gets a long holiday and compensation they deserve after AoT is fully wrapped up |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| It’s actually funny how this topic blew up and is still such a big deal. Even Nanatsu fans weren’t this crazy and they’ve got it way worse. The new OP is btw visually quite impressive. Even more so when you consider it was done by one person. |
MaceChanJan 10, 2022 3:01 PM
| Epic thread. OP looked great. Tbh not a huge fan of these screaming ops. Reminds me of Death Note op2, but the song had some moments. ED looked and sounded great. CG was definitely better which is nice. My only complaint - They've used the Ashes on the Fire track by Kohta like half a dozen times since Final started... AND THEY LITERALLY PLAYED IT TWICE THIS EP. Yeah it's good, but not as good and definitely not as iconic as some of the Sawano tracks. - Where tf are the Sawano tracks? |
 |
| The Op is just fine, I liked the lyrical part of it, the shouting part sounds cringe to me. Visuals are good tho. Ending song is really great it has became one of my fav, the visuals and lyrics are really fine asf. CGI also improved, but while I was watching the ep I felt nothing. When I read the manga I really loved this fight I was soo hyped to watch it but I wasn't excited while watching it.The fight felt like it was better in the manga. Well I hope I will enjoy the next eps. But I am disappointed with one thing that they even CGI'd the odm gear scenes. We didn't got a decent odm gear scene in the first part so I thought may be with a better schedule odm gear scenes will be good but mappa said no, may be next ep. Overall It was a 8/10 ep. |
 |
jackoffwanker said: This tweet is from Shuhei Yabuta, director of Vinland Saga S1, also took part of direction in eps 7 Part 1 Final Season from what i remember, i just thought i put something he said here i censored his account name because i'm scared of some harassers potentially lurking around here so... My respect for Hayashi shot up even higher. This is very true and applicable to MAPPA. The way they dealt with AoT as a project shows how little they cared about the quality, but I think staff and directors decided to do something about that and save the day, at least when it comes to this part. (Thank you SO much for censoring their name, you did the right thing) |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
samashi20 said: jackoffwanker said: This tweet is from Shuhei Yabuta, director of Vinland Saga S1, also took part of direction in eps 7 Part 1 Final Season from what i remember, i just thought i put something he said here i censored his account name because i'm scared of some harassers potentially lurking around here so... My respect for Hayashi shot up even higher. This is very true and applicable to MAPPA. The way they dealt with AoT as a project shows how little they cared about the quality, but I think staff and directors decided to do something about that and save the day, at least when it comes to this part. (Thank you SO much for censoring their name, you did the right thing) no problem, anyway, yeah i imagine MAPPA higher-ups don't care about the staff as well but still have reputation to uphold as a studio so maybe they're trying to step up their game for Part 2 (?) and have already assigning additional staff to spread out the workloads in the upcoming episodes (not that i fully understand how production works though lul) the best of luck for everyone involved! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| this Sticky Threads does not work since the Mobile App Feed does not show them dang |
| Osts used in these two videos are better than Whatever mappa did. https://youtu.be/66xbYsmuUmM Sound is kinda weird here but the ost choice is good https://youtu.be/PlHsvsV206s I think the ost used during eren vs Reiner and porco in the recent ep was weak. I didn't felt the hype. I was really hyped for the ep but while watching it I felt nothing. First of all CGI fights doesn't looks great in general but it can look good with proper bgm or with proper fight sequence and both were lacking in this ep. Aot has soo much good ost but why tf mappa keep coming back to the same osts again and again?? People were hyped abt hayashi directing the ep and what happened?? Literally nothing!! I know this is a hot take but S4 P1 ep 1 was overall better directed and was better than this ep.(beast titan was kinda meh tho but still I was hyped while watching that ep) |
| |
| people are still forgetting this fact WIT quit because the production time or schedule is getting so bad than the already bad production time given to them on previous seasons CGI/3DCG is meant to speed up production so that is why MAPPA did that since they have no time to animate titans in 2D @TheFounder131 ye Hayashi maybe weak on OST choices |
deg said: people are still forgetting this fact WIT quit because the production time or schedule is getting so bad than the already bad production time given to them on previous seasons CGI/3DCG is meant to speed up production so that is why MAPPA did that since they have no time to animate titans in 2D ye Hayashi maybe weak on OST choices But Hayashi isn't the sound director (?), Mima Masafumi is actually the sound director. The thing is, he's been in that role since the beginning, but somehow his OST choices are getting worse? Not sure why the OSTs used, more often than not, miss. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
samashi20 said: But Hayashi isn't the sound director (?), Mima Masafumi is actually the sound director. The thing is, he's been in that role since the beginning, but somehow his OST choices are getting worse? Not sure why the OSTs used, more often than not, miss. Actually, from what i heard, the OST placement is chosen by both the episode director and sound director and since Hayashi is the series director he has the final say. Obviously we can't know for sure what is happening behind the scenes, at this point i just hope that the next episodes won't have this issue. |
 |
samashi20 said: But Hayashi isn't the sound director (?), Mima Masafumi is actually the sound director. The thing is, he's been in that role since the beginning, but somehow his OST choices are getting worse? Not sure why the OSTs used, more often than not, miss. yep but as mentioned Hayashi is the series director and episode director too so he has the final say on the OST choice |
| @deg and @Fax001s thank you both for the replies. Yeah, Masafumi (the sound director) has done an amazing job on the first 3 seasons, so this probably means it's not all up to him now. I really hope Hayashi, or whoever's in charge, relies more on him and his choices from now on. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
| Episode 3 music selection is phenomenal. They really went hard on the OSTs and nailed them. I think this is one of the very few episodes where MAPPA raised the impact of the scene higher by the OST chosen. I also think the CGI looks even better than the first two episodes. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
samashi20 said: Episode 3 music selection is phenomenal. They really went hard on the OSTs and nailed them. I think this is one of the very few episodes where MAPPA raised the impact of the scene higher by the OST chosen. I also think the CGI looks even better than the first two episodes. yep agreed the music is finally relevant lol the episode director did awesome than Hayashi this time when it comes to music choices |
deg said: samashi20 said: Episode 3 music selection is phenomenal. They really went hard on the OSTs and nailed them. I think this is one of the very few episodes where MAPPA raised the impact of the scene higher by the OST chosen. I also think the CGI looks even better than the first two episodes. yep agreed the music is finally relevant lol the episode director did awesome than Hayashi this time when it comes to music choices Yeah, this Teruyuki Omine guy saved probably one of the most anticipated episodes from flopping in terms of music. Even his direction is out of this world. Love seeing the core MAPPA directors working on AoT!! |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
| I'm hoping Omine gets a few more episodes this season. |
| As an anime-only, extremely excited to hear that. Declaration of War and Hero are my top 1 episodes of AoT!! xenosys said: SAME! I hope they give him next episode too since manga readers are looking forward to that one too.I'm hoping Omine gets a few more episodes this season. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Apr 3, 2022 |
540 |
by wibugar
»»
May 10, 1:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 9, 2022 |
451 |
by BlueSnow93
»»
May 9, 5:43 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 20, 2022 |
430 |
by phantom346
»»
Apr 18, 5:21 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 13, 2022 |
416 |
by goral
»»
Apr 14, 4:43 AM |
|
» Falco said something in episode 1 of part 1 which I didn't get the reference of_karan_123 - Feb 9, 2022 |
27 |
by manish_2
»»
Mar 28, 7:47 AM |