Forum Settings
Forums
New
Apr 6, 2008 7:51 AM
#1
Offline
Jan 2008
5
Hey guys,

So I watched this anime, loved it, and have now purchased Dumas' original novel. Can anyone tells me how it shapes up to the anime before I start reading?

Of course there wont be any of the hauntingly beautiful artwork, which is a shame :(
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members
Apr 6, 2008 4:11 PM
#2

Offline
Mar 2008
1175
well, its not too similar. the basic, BASIC story is the same, but the novel is about 80 times more intricate and things, especially towards the end, occur quite differently in the book.
Apr 7, 2008 7:27 AM
#3
Offline
Sep 2007
13
For the first half or so of the show, it's pretty similar. After episode 18, though, the series takes a major divergence from the book. And they tend to rework some of the sideplots and give some characters more screentime than they got in the novel.
Apr 11, 2008 9:02 AM
#4

Offline
Oct 2007
396
Venneh said:
For the first half or so of the show, it's pretty similar. After episode 18, though, the series takes a major divergence from the book. And they tend to rework some of the sideplots and give some characters more screentime than they got in the novel.


Most importantly Albert, who's more of a sidekick in the novel.
Apr 12, 2008 4:54 PM
#5
Offline
Apr 2008
2
Another difference is that in the novel the Count portrays himself more as a messenger from God. Where as, in the anime, he is given a darker tone and is portrayed more as someone who has sold his soul to the Devil.

Of course, there are also many differences as to how certain character's stories are told (like Andrea Cavalcanti).
Apr 21, 2008 5:51 AM
#6

Offline
Apr 2008
276
Actually, I did have to read this book in my school (I'm french so...) and if Maeda dit not respect all the aspect of the novel, he respected Dumas'work.
The main character in the novel is the count whereas Albertmade quick apparitions. And of course, the action doesn't take place in the future.

To my mind, the vengence itself and the darkness of the book are still there. Maeda provides a blazing, but true adaptation.

"Mesdames, messieurs, bonsoir."
May 20, 2008 12:02 PM
#7
Offline
Dec 2007
5308
Yep I'm French too and I believe it's one if not the best adaptation of Dumas's work (even if really different) and a masterpiece of modern animation. Well I love Maeda so I can't say I'm very objective ;)

In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same.
May 21, 2008 8:28 AM
#8
Offline
Jan 2008
5
Excellent. I'm almost a third of the way through the novel and am enjoying it immensely.

It's very interesting observing how the story and portrayal of the characters was changed between the novel and the anime.
Jul 30, 2008 11:39 AM
#9
Offline
Jun 2008
12
I´ve read the book twice before watching the anime and I personally liked the reinterpretation of the characters. Of course the plot keeps a lot from the novel but the anime takes it to a completely different direction (That´s what makes the anime so good =D).

They are very similar at the beginning but in the end two different masterpieces.
Aug 24, 2008 10:06 AM

Offline
Jun 2007
2253
My Gankutsuou review from a long time ago covers this (it's on MAL).

The main difference between the novel and the anime is Edmond. In the book he believes he's doing Gods good work and doing what is right by getting revenge against those who stole everything from him, while in the anime Edmond basically gave his soul to the devil in order to get his revenge. This change of character is why the endings are different and the plot diverged completely with the events of episode 18.

Gankutsuou was never what you'd call a faithful adaptation even up to 18. For example, Franz and Eugenie's characters were changed A LOT, with the latter being changed from a lesbian into a straight woman so she could have a relationship with Albert and Franz being changed into a homosexual so that he could be closer to Albert than he was in the novel.

You do see a lot you'd recognize if you watched the anime before reading the novel but the majority of the content wasn't used or was altered in the anime.

Aug 24, 2008 9:54 PM

Offline
Jul 2007
961
I wanna see the novel O.O
Aug 25, 2008 8:06 AM
Offline
Jan 2008
5
I finished reading the novel a month or so ago, but just noticed this topic was still receiving comments. Thank you all.

I was amazed at how much was changed, as Aionic said. Unfortunately my edition was abridged, and so curiously some things that were portrayed in the anime were absent from my text!

The most notable omission was that of the entire situation with the Cavalcantis, but also nothing was said of Eugenie, so I assumed she stayed with Albert as in the anime until I saw Aionic's post.

Brilliant story though.
Aug 25, 2008 8:21 AM

Offline
Jun 2007
2253
If I recall, Eugenie fled the country with her girlfriend towards the end of the novel when her father got into all sorts of trouble.

The Andrea Cavalcanti side-story was given a lot more time in the novel, Edmond even going to the trouble of paying an Italian noble with money troubles (iirc) to act as his father and paying Andrea to act as his son. Andrea's story was also tied in with the Bertuccio, their connection being that when Bertuccio tried to kill Villefort in order to avenge his brother he noticed Villefort had buried a child, dug him up and tried to raise him as his own with his wife. There was also a comical part towards the end of the novel where, whilst trying to escape from the police, Andrea fell down a chimney and landed in the room where Eugenie and her girlfriend happened to be in bed together.

It's well worth getting the full story since it sounds like you missed out on a lot. I have the 1250 page Penguin Classics version, which includes the author spending a few pages telling the reader about Dumas and a lot of pages towards the end that explain what certain words and/or phrases mean.
Feb 5, 2009 7:00 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
413
The book and the anime go hand and hand in a LOT of ways...but yet they are NOT the same in MANY ways and i suggest both reading the book and watching the anime...all in all the anime was a VERY GOOD interpretation of the book...:)


Oct 25, 2009 8:40 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
3
After I watched the anime I had to read the book, which I'm currently halfway through (which doesnt mean much since it's a pp. 1400+ book). However, the novel is fantastic and so far it's a lot closer to the anime than I would have expected. It's so much more in-depth so there's obviously some stuff left out of the anime, but overall it is not disappointing in the least. Anyone who's a fan of the anime and likes to read should definitely do it. Also, if you're more interested in the main character, reading the book is a must since the anime only starts at the halfway point of the book. The first half is all about how the count got to where he is when the anime starts--like i said: fantastic!
Sep 9, 2011 2:03 PM
Offline
Sep 2011
48
This is one of my favorite adaptions. The original book is basically the same thing but it has a different ending. Some characters and their plotlines are changed in the anime. Other than those few changes it's pretty much the same.
Sep 15, 2011 6:53 AM

Offline
Jun 2007
2253
The best thing about Gankutsuou's direction is that it left Edmond's character shrouded in mystery. By only spending a few minutes showing how he was betrayed, and having Faria's character be replaced by Gankutsuou, it made reading the first 300 or so pages amazing beyond words. I ended Gankutsuou by 10/10ing, but only then - when I started the novel - did I get to see and understand the true Edmond Dantes. Reading the novel compliments the anime in the best way possible.

For example, Vampa's character isn't explored in any detail in the anime. This is understandable because his backstory wasn't needed and would've been one of the first things cut to get the anime content to fit into 24 episodes. But reading about a largely insignificant character in the novel is a part I remember most fondly because of Dumas' ability to convey so much feelings with so few words; almost as if it was effortless.

If you're interested, here's the part I'm referring to, C&Ped:

Luigi Vampa's Backstory:
Reply Disabled for Non-Club Members

More topics from this board

» Who was your fav, char and why?

sweetarisan - Mar 7, 2008

39 by HayateGekkou »»
Oct 5, 2015 9:56 PM

» Best episode?

crazekat - May 26, 2008

11 by JuiciaDeGardiaan »»
Nov 24, 2012 2:09 AM

» Do you know something about a novel Gankutsuou, based on the anime?

alav5112021 - Apr 26, 2009

4 by AironicallyHuman »»
Sep 15, 2011 7:02 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login