Nana Komatsu is the greatest character of all time. She is the greatest "stereotypical" "dumb" girly girl in a manga ever.
Yes, she does have the typical shoujo traits of her being needy , clingy, very girly, whatever you assume sereotypical whiny shoujo leads are. and I have to say, I did hate her quite as well, because i thought she is really dumb... but Hachi is anything BUT dumb. and if you don't see this, I am curious as to how much you have read.
What really shows her maturity and responsibility is how she reacted when she was pregnant. If it were any other happy-go-lucky dumb shoujo lead, she would have stayed with Nobu since she "loves him more" and whatnot. But no, Hachi knew staying with Takumi would be the best for the baby regardless of her own feelings on the ordeal.
And honestly, the more I see her progress in the story after being married to takumi, the more I see her as being very in control of her life and trying to make the best of the situation. Sure, she might have been happier with Nobu, but he could not handle the responsibility of being a father and taking care of both hachi and the child. Even though Takumi treats Hachi like shit, and she's not really oblivious to it either, she still stays with him through it all not necessarily because of her feelings but because she knows that it would be bad to break it off with him.
I don't see how you all think Nana is more responsible than Hachi. All nana does in the more recent volumes is wallow in her self-pity, but Hachi has overcome that and puts effort into living her life the best she can. She is also so attune to others feelings to some extent, how she "mothers" shin, and cares deeply for how Nana is feeling,and tries her hardest to make an effort to see Nana when she is really down, which is especially seen in the chapters leading up to Ren's death.
Considering NANA is actually told from Hachi's point of view from the future, you can see very well into her thoughts, and you can see how even though her relationship with Takumi seems to be failing in the future with their two kids, that she still has her life together and is making the best of it.
Hachi is the one of the most "in-control of her life" characters in Nana, and is anything but the dumb stereotypical shoujo lead that she deceivingly starts off as.
And yes, She does start off as your typical shoujo dumb lead, which is why I'm sure many of you dislike her (myself included). She just concerned about boys and romance, but who isnt at her age? But when faced with a life-changing decision with getting married and the responsibility of a child, Hachi does what is right, sure she has a few blunders and acts stupid along the way, but she is anything but stupid in my eyes. |