| Pls AOT S2 will probably end up like SAO S2. |
ChairForceOne said: tsudecimo said: I'm not sure if you are trolling. The point in their statement is that the first season had action as prominent genre, the second season is not going to have a lack of it, thus the expectations of it's followers will not be met. They don't mean that only action shows rank high.. Seriously. The first season of Clannad is comedy and the second season is depressing. Does that also not count? Did SnK touch you somewhere? My point was people are going to be disappointed by the lack of action in the second season of SnK. Not that its a bad thing because the plot can't progress through action alone however that's one of the reason why the manga isn't even in top 50. Most of the casuals in MAL expected SnK to be only about action which is why the recent arc of the manga had a negative reaction since their expectations were not met. The anime will most probably suffer from the same thing. |
F0XFIRE said: Pls AOT S2 will probably end up like SAO S2. Also rated fairly high? Look I'm not saying SnK 2 will be amazing, but lets not pretend the top ten is all action and/or casual related stuff. #2 is a sci fi 3deep5me show and 3 is a slice of life feels anime. |
ChairForceOne said: tsudecimo said: -ignored for good- Wow. Do you always take everything this seriously? Sure. |
 |
F0XFIRE said: Pls AOT S2 will probably end up like SAO S2. Someone will die of AIDS? |
tsudecimo said: ChairForceOne said: Wow. Do you always take everything this seriously? Sure. You need to relax. Not only do you sound really immature, but stressing this much over a website can lead to harmful anxiety attacks. |
Hulohot said: Someone will die of AIDS? idk. I don't think Isayama will sink low enough to use Aids as a plot device. |
ChairForceOne said: tsudecimo said: Sure. You need to relax. Not only do you sound really immature, but stressing this much over a website can lead to harmful anxiety attacks. Sure. |
|
F0XFIRE said: Hulohot said: Someone will die of AIDS? idk. I don't think Isayama will sink low enough to use Aids as a plot device. Armin could probably get aids, if you know what I'm saying. |
ChairForceOne said: But it will have a dramatic shift in tone compared to the first season. One of SnK's main draw were action packed 3D maneuvering gear scenes and the next part apparently slows down and focuses on politics for the most part. Also SnK has lots of haters which will rate low regardless of content, that's why its slipped down the rankings.F0XFIRE said: Pls AOT S2 will probably end up like SAO S2. Also rated fairly high? Look I'm not saying SnK 2 will be amazing, but lets not pretend the top ten is all action and/or casual related stuff. #2 is a sci fi 3deep5me show and 3 is a slice of life feels anime. |
Feaor said: ChairForceOne said: But it will have a dramatic shift in tone compared to the first season. One of SnK's main draw were action packed 3D maneuvering gear scenes and the next part apparently slows down and focuses on politics for the most part. Also SnK has lots of haters which will rate low regardless of content, that's why its slipped down the rankings.Also rated fairly high? Look I'm not saying SnK 2 will be amazing, but lets not pretend the top ten is all action and/or casual related stuff. #2 is a sci fi 3deep5me show and 3 is a slice of life feels anime. By that logic, slowing down the plot and working on building the world might draw in the elitists and appease the low raters, balancing things out and raising the overall rating. Like how After Story taking a serious tone calmed the butthurt moe haters who low rated Clannad. I'm just saying you never know. |
| ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. |
Soul-Master said: ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. But After Story is in the top 10 regardless. I'm not even saying SnK 2 will be a good series. It just might be in the top 10. You never know. |
Journey_95 said: Assuming your opinion of it means anything. It's still not at its climax and there's the 1/5 rule. IntroverTurtle said: Well the next Gintama season will no doubt be #1 at least for a day. But One Piece is the one that deserves it and actually has a chance to reach it. the manga? sure but the anime? fuck no its already rated too high |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
ChairForceOne said: Feaor said: But it will have a dramatic shift in tone compared to the first season. One of SnK's main draw were action packed 3D maneuvering gear scenes and the next part apparently slows down and focuses on politics for the most part. Also SnK has lots of haters which will rate low regardless of content, that's why its slipped down the rankings. By that logic, slowing down the plot and working on building the world might draw in the elitists and appease the low raters, balancing things out and raising the overall rating. Like how After Story taking a serious tone calmed the butthurt moe haters who low rated Clannad. I'm just saying you never know. "My main problem with the show is simply this: The first half of After Story is guilty of going down the worst possible road that a shoujo anime can go down: the dreaded road of "emotion porn", and some of it is absolutely unbearable. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the term, "emotion porn" refers any story/storyarc in a form of media that is incredibly shallow and uses gratuitous amounts of melodrama in order to get a cheap cry out of it's audience. "Emotion Porn" is directed at the emotionally immature and at those who are desperate for a cry, and unfortunately, After Story's first half is jam packed with it." |
Casval_onii-san said: ChairForceOne said: By that logic, slowing down the plot and working on building the world might draw in the elitists and appease the low raters, balancing things out and raising the overall rating. Like how After Story taking a serious tone calmed the butthurt moe haters who low rated Clannad. I'm just saying you never know. "My main problem with the show is simply this: The first half of After Story is guilty of going down the worst possible road that a shoujo anime can go down: the dreaded road of "emotion porn", and some of it is absolutely unbearable. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the term, "emotion porn" refers any story/storyarc in a form of media that is incredibly shallow and uses gratuitous amounts of melodrama in order to get a cheap cry out of it's audience. "Emotion Porn" is directed at the emotionally immature and at those who are desperate for a cry, and unfortunately, After Story's first half is jam packed with it." Still in the top 5. |
| If One Piece keeps the 1 chapter = 1 episode formula for the next 10 years or however long it's going to take before it's over, then no the anime is definitely not going to reach #1. I see more and more people getting fed up with the pacing already. The manga though, yeah probably |
  |
Soul-Master said: ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. Oh dear God, elitists truly are the world's evil. The only ones who downvote shows purposely and even create alts for that are obsessed morons not elitists. |
 |
Journey_95 said: Its score isn't really falling so not as much people must be thinking the same as you or it's not affecting the score yet, either way.IntroverTurtle said: Assuming your opinion of it means anything. It's still not at its climax and there's the 1/5 rule. 1/5 rule? and thankfully I'm not the only one more and more people are getting pissed with the adaption and rightfully so so I doubt it will ever be #1 the manga on the other hand is great and if Oda maintains the quality it will probably be a masterpiece at the end so it should definitely be #1 Only scores where the person has watched at least 1/5 of the completed series are counted. So as soon as it ends a lot of the people who dropped its scores will not count. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| On the other hand One Piece manga could possibly become #1 after it ends. |
Hulohot said: On the other hand One PIece manga could possibly become #1 after it ends. It will never end though. |
F0XFIRE said: Hulohot said: On the other hand One PIece manga could possibly become #1 after it ends. It will never end though. If the author dies it will. |
Soul-Master said: ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. Explain why FMA:B is #1 even though it's incredibly popular? Elitists rate down anime that are shit. |
| the 1/5 rule goes both ways, not just for the people who rated it low and dropped. The anime will most likely be at least 1200 eps, which means anybody who watched less than 240 eps, won't have their score counted, ergo the old users who stopped using their account, their scores won't count. By the time it finishes, I will be surprised if MAL is still there to begin with. but mal scores are srs bz |
|
ChairForceOne said: If the author dies it will. No then it will be unfinished. Oda won't die anyway. The Japanese will transfer his mind into a robot and have him make One Piece forever. |
| HxH |
 |
Casval_onii-san said: Soul-Master said: ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. Explain why FMA:B is #1 even though it's incredibly popular? Elitists rate down anime that are shit. that shitick tho SnK is getting lower, not because of 'elitists' it has it's fair share of normal watchers who hate it, or people that didn't think it was great and was overhyped. |
|
F0XFIRE said: Ignorance, joking, or both?Hulohot said: On the other hand One PIece manga could possibly become #1 after it ends. It will never end though. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Casval_onii-san said: Soul-Master said: ^Once a show becomes as popular as SnK, elitists will rate it down regardless. There are still elitists that trash talk After Story. Its simply that the fans are much more. Explain why FMA:B is #1 even though it's incredibly popular? Elitists rate down anime that are shit. Because FMA:B is both Edgy, and Shounen. |
| Code Geass R2 has reclaimed its number ten position. Highschool DxD BorN has been lowered to 22. |
AnimeSweden said: Code Geass R2 has reclaimed its number ten position. Highschool DxD BorN has been lowered to 22. It should be lower in my opinion. |
ChairForceOne said: Casval_onii-san said: Explain why FMA:B is #1 even though it's incredibly popular? Elitists rate down anime that are shit. Because FMA:B is both Edgy, and Shounen. |
|
| I doubt they will complete the One Piece anime. The anime industry will be shaken up soon as technology begins to progress. |
IntroverTurtle said: Ignorance, joking, or both? Both. I haven't even read or watched One Piece. |
AnimeSweden said: Code Geass R2 has reclaimed its number ten position. Highschool DxD BorN has been lowered to 22. How is this relevant here? I think you mixed up the tabs. |
|
robis798 said: Meh who cares. We're talking about anime rankings and I thought it was relevant enough.AnimeSweden said: Code Geass R2 has reclaimed its number ten position. Highschool DxD BorN has been lowered to 22. How is this relevant here? I think you mixed up the tabs. |
F0XFIRE said: Figured, thanks for being honest.IntroverTurtle said: Ignorance, joking, or both? Both. I haven't even read or watched One Piece. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
IntroverTurtle said: F0XFIRE said: Figured, thanks for being honest.Both. I haven't even read or watched One Piece. You are taking this too seriously. Calm down man. |
| I haven't looked at the top list in a while, HXH2011 #3? Hmm I might check that out sooner than later, perhaps after beck. As for the next top anime to beat FMA, No idea but it guess I thought Snk would be it lol. |
 Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
ChairForceOne said: Casval_onii-san said: Explain why FMA:B is #1 even though it's incredibly popular? Elitists rate down anime that are shit. Because FMA:B is both Edgy, and Shounen. SnK is also edgy and shounen. |
Casval_onii-san said: ChairForceOne said: Because FMA:B is both Edgy, and Shounen. SnK is also edgy and shounen. While it is edgy, it lacks the pure unfiltered edge of FMA:B's victorian imagery and magic. |
| SnK is way more edgy than FMA, its got way more gore and suffering. |
Feaor said: SnK is way more edgy than FMA, its got way more gore and suffering. There's more to edge than gore and suffering. Theres also victorian/renaissance artwork, monsters, pesudo horror and darkness. |
| I don't see any series topping fmab anytime soon. Not even gintama as people are saying will top fmab. We will probably die before seeing anything topping it. |
| I genuinely think Gintama 2015 will suck. Binan Koukou is absolutely terrible. The man has lost his touch. |
More topics from this board
» Is watching a show for the cute girl weird?fallout45 - 12 hours ago |
21 |
by Orokanatenshi
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» I really wish that more animes had re-capsAtmogenic - 15 minutes ago |
7 |
by Atmogenic
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» What anime brought you to watch more anime? :)Rinrinka - 51 minutes ago |
11 |
by MasterTasuke
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » do you want more emotional or more intelligent anime?deg - 5 hours ago |
24 |
by APolygons2
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» what is battle shonen?deg - 4 hours ago |
21 |
by PlasticRobot
»»
14 minutes ago |